I only own one Tops knife I bought it years ago. It was kind of an odd ball do it all knife called the Surv Tac 7. This was before I knew what I wanted in a medium sized knife.
I was very pleased with the quality of the knife. The steel is excellent, sharp as can be. But the design, while serviceable, is not something you would want to use a lot. And that is where Tops sometimes falls down. The designs are almost always imperfect and sometimes just plain goofy.
More recently I think Tops has some better designs. Tops BOB seems like a decent knife, the Brakimo, and Tahoma Field Knife (except the swedge is unnecessary, as are the notches they put on top. There are some others. With Tops if you find a design you like it will probably serve you well. Very good 1095 heat treatment.
Bark River, on the other hand seems to be putting out some excellent knives lately. I especially like the Bravo line (I have a Bravo 1.25 in 3V. 5" blade thick spine). I really like the performance of the full convex grinds. I prefer convex because it is easy to sharpen with a strop and I don't have to pull out my Apex or Japanese sharpening stones. Since 3V holds an edge beautifully stropping is all you have to do unless you damage it.
I'll be buying another Bark River in 3V pretty soon.
I was very pleased with the quality of the knife. The steel is excellent, sharp as can be. But the design, while serviceable, is not something you would want to use a lot. And that is where Tops sometimes falls down. The designs are almost always imperfect and sometimes just plain goofy.
More recently I think Tops has some better designs. Tops BOB seems like a decent knife, the Brakimo, and Tahoma Field Knife (except the swedge is unnecessary, as are the notches they put on top. There are some others. With Tops if you find a design you like it will probably serve you well. Very good 1095 heat treatment.
Bark River, on the other hand seems to be putting out some excellent knives lately. I especially like the Bravo line (I have a Bravo 1.25 in 3V. 5" blade thick spine). I really like the performance of the full convex grinds. I prefer convex because it is easy to sharpen with a strop and I don't have to pull out my Apex or Japanese sharpening stones. Since 3V holds an edge beautifully stropping is all you have to do unless you damage it.
I'll be buying another Bark River in 3V pretty soon.
Comment