Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

El Monte PD

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #91
    masameet
    Veteran Member
    • Jun 2008
    • 4487

    Originally posted by biglou
    When I started this thread it was in the form of a question to LEO's. They (FoxNews) had just aired the video for the second time. It was never my intent for anti LE to come on here and make unqualified statements and accusations. Be that as it may, this is what this tread had turned into. I really believe, after read Erik's post that he has some serious mental issues. I am not a Doctor of Mental Health. This is only my opinion based on this comment by Erik: "I'd argue that the guy became guilty of first degree when he strapped on his sidearm that morning. He had to have known how utterly stupid and incompetent he was, after all." This is one of the most outlandish comments I have read in reference to LE. If you are not mental than you are just on this Specialty Forum making stupid comments to get replies from LE for some type of gratification or cheap thrill. SVT-40 gave a good breakdown of the video along with his professional opinion. Mods need to lock this thread.
    Ugh. Why do people insist on psychobabbleanalyzing other people they have never met and probably never will?

    I think Erik was using hyperbole and speaking as someone who is outraged at injustices, small and large. If LEOs were to poll a broad spectrum of citizens, the consensus regarding this videoed kick would probably fall along the lines of Erik's thinking. Is that unusual? I would say, no, it is not. Is such thinking truly LEO bashing? No, I would say it is not. We Americans are taught from the cradle to love freedom and justice and to speak out against perceived injustices. The American Revolution, the Declaration of Independence, the U.S. Constitution, and various SCOTUS rulings and legislations are our birthright and the foundation on which we stand and enjoy our lives.

    If such thinking offends LEOs, then what can you guys expect? One of yours is found to be performing an extra-legal and extra-training action for all to see forever and that even some LEOs on this forum expressed was wrong. Put it up to scrutiny, have some naysayers, and y'all say "Back off!"

    I pretty much glanced through Erik's replies and they did not seem to be near as flaming as other posters. He offered arguments that were just as sound and reasonable as any LEOs as to why that El Monte cop needed or didn't need to kick a downed suspect while he held a cocked semi-automatic pistol on him.

    Still being argumentative in the forum is counterproductive. It adds no insight.
    x

    "Let those find fault whose wit's so very small,
    They've need to show that they can think at all;
    Errors, like straws, upon the surface flow;
    He who would search for pearls, must dive below." -- John Dryden

    Comment

    • #92
      Fire in the Hole
      Senior Member
      • Oct 2008
      • 1563

      Here's a thought: We pass a law and make it a policy, that if you flee from the police, either on foot on by vehicle, the pursuing officer gets one free hit. It must be limited the the single officer, so no free for alls. No shooting, just a single strike or kick. Dealere's choice. Publish this so that all BG's know it. Now we've eliminated all the arguments.

      Comment

      • #93
        biglou
        Senior Member
        • May 2007
        • 1317

        Call it what you will. Erik still made outlandish comments that have no busines in this forum. To make the assumption that an Officer is guilty of murder when he puts on his duty gun is the stupidest thing I have read here. I don't care what Officer he is referring to. No one knows what's instore for them on any particular day. Maybe we should just figure that all of Erik's posts are hyperbole. I won't comment any further. No reason to give this knucklehead any further credence.

        Comment

        • #94
          masameet
          Veteran Member
          • Jun 2008
          • 4487

          Originally posted by biglou
          ... No one knows what's instore for them on any particular day ....
          So true. Stay safe and come home at the end of the day.
          x

          "Let those find fault whose wit's so very small,
          They've need to show that they can think at all;
          Errors, like straws, upon the surface flow;
          He who would search for pearls, must dive below." -- John Dryden

          Comment

          • #95
            stormy_clothing
            Banned
            • Dec 2008
            • 2809

            Originally posted by SVT-40
            Some of you judge so quickly. It would be interesting to see you do the job. Once again it's easy to sit back behind your computer and Play judge. Try and get out there and do the job.

            Maybe then you would learn just how quickly your life can end if you do not quickly take command of a deadly situation such as this was.

            It's really just pathetic for you to pass judgment with out any expertise or law enforcement experience.

            Thank god the judgment will be based on what a "reasonable officer would do" when confronted with the situation with very little time to decide what is "right".

            The parolee was not "abused" he received one kick, after obviously disobeying the officers commands. End of story.
            being a police officer is not the same as being a poster on cal guns there is no discipline or training for posting on a web board.

            as far as I'm concerned the cop should be fired for promoting crime based clothing to begin with.

            There was a time in this country when officers were required to aspire to a level of professionalism and respectability now I see them with shabby dress and Loc sunglasses on riding around low in there seats like thugs.

            They would not tolerate that stuff while in the academy and I think mannerisms like that should be terminable while on the job so that the true pillars of society can fill those positions.

            there is absolutely no question he kicked a man was down and that it wrong no matter where you look in the world that is wrong.

            If he had been at least smart enough to do it behind the scenes to send a message like my grandpa would do as a cop in chicago than at least there would be some sign of self control, there wasn't. Imagine that same person holding a gun.

            And what did it do for anyone, the kid probably brags about it, a cop will face punishment and the public loses more faith.

            to be honest I think it would have been better to shoot the suspect while he was fleeing instead of this.
            Last edited by stormy_clothing; 05-21-2009, 3:35 PM.

            Comment

            • #96
              Jonathan Doe

              Speculation on a very short video clip is not a good thing whether the officer is wrong or not. People should wait until the investigation was over.

              Comment

              • #97
                SVT-40
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Jan 2008
                • 12918

                Eric, we have all read what you have written. Since you fail or are unable to understand some of the points made by myself and others please just post elsewhere. I think we all know how you feel.
                Poke'm with a stick!


                Originally posted by fiddletown
                What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

                Comment

                • #98
                  solanoshooter
                  Member
                  • Oct 2008
                  • 252

                  Originally posted by Erik S. Klein

                  Originally Posted by SVT-40
                  The officer, dealing with the situation he was confronted with at the time decided to issue one kick to the suspect. Nothing else. He will be judged like any other officer who uses force. The question will revolve around only one issue. that question is.

                  Did he act "reasonably" considering ALL the factors related to the incident including what he was thinking at the time of the kick. That's it.

                  "Reasonably" means would an officer given the same situation thinking the way this officer was thinking act in a similar way. If the answer is yes, then the force was reasonable. If the force is judged unreasonable he will be disciplined.




                  And the only problem I have with that is the use of "officer" where "person" should be used.

                  The police are not "special" and do not have, nor do they deserve, special rules.

                  This is just one glaring example of how little you do not know or understand.

                  The law and the courts do believe that peace officers are "special" as you put it. And as such, the law says that when judging whether what an officer has done is reasonable, it MUST be compared to what other OFFICERS would do in similar situations. Not persons.

                  This is because peace officers do have specialized training and experience that the "average person" does not.

                  And we do have special rules and laws that apply just to us.

                  Comment

                  • #99
                    Erik S. Klein
                    Member
                    • May 2009
                    • 202

                    Originally posted by solanoshooter
                    This is just one glaring example of how little you do not know or understand.

                    The law and the courts do believe that peace officers are "special" as you put it. And as such, the law says that when judging whether what an officer has done is reasonable, it MUST be compared to what other OFFICERS would do in similar situations. Not persons.

                    This is because peace officers do have specialized training and experience that the "average person" does not.

                    And we do have special rules and laws that apply just to us.
                    And that, in a nutshell, is the problem.

                    Set yourselves apart from the people and guess what, you're apart from the people. . .
                    Erik
                    NRA Life Member
                    Sig fan.

                    Comment

                    • yzErnie
                      CGN/CGSSA Contributor - Lifetime
                      CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                      • Mar 2007
                      • 6310

                      Originally posted by topgun7
                      Speculation on a very short video clip is not a good thing whether the officer is wrong or not. People should wait until the investigation was over.
                      And there you have it, well said TG7.

                      As I posted earlier in this thread, people of every walk of life, including some in law enforcement, were calling for ex-deputy sheriff Ivory Webb to be hanged at noon in the public square for the shooting of the drunken soldier. He was ultimately aquitted of felony charges by a jury not of his peers but by a jury of 'citizens'. So, I say again, I will withhold public judgement of the El Monte officer until all of the facts are known. IMO, some people who have posted in this thread are simply ignorant to the facts that 'innocent until proven guilty' and due process also pertain to a law enforcement officer.
                      The satisfaction of a job well done is to be the one who has done it

                      Originally posted by RazoE
                      I don't feel a thing when some cop gets ghosted.

                      Comment

                      • cryptkeeper
                        Member
                        • Nov 2008
                        • 414

                        You guys know this is his clothing line right?

                        Comment

                        • CnCFunFactory
                          Senior Member
                          • Mar 2009
                          • 1084

                          Originally posted by CaliTheKid
                          Distraction Blow!! Case solved.
                          Creative articulation is where it's at, almost anything can be rationalized and explained
                          NUNQUAM NON PARATUS

                          sigpic

                          Comment

                          • Fire in the Hole
                            Senior Member
                            • Oct 2008
                            • 1563

                            Originally posted by Erik S. Klein
                            And that, in a nutshell, is the problem.

                            Set yourselves apart from the people and guess what, you're apart from the people. . .

                            This special status is not something that LE actually affirmatively wished to be brought upon them. Society at large, ie. the Courts, DA's, and Jon Q. Citizen expects and demands that LE behave at a more professional and mature level over the average citizen. This is one reason that when an LEO does screws up and is prosecuted for a crime, they get hammered harder. The judge will even tell them at sentencing that he is holding them to a higher standard of conduct that that of the average citizen.

                            As far as being apart from the people, LE is required to dress differently than the rest of society, typically have shaved faces, short haircuts, no exposed tattoos, speak articulately, not fly off at the handle, reserve personal opinions to themselvs, etc. I guess this necessarily sets LE apart in many ways.

                            John Q. Public has a right to openly affiliate with whatever organization he wants to. And as long as he is not breaking the law, may do so. LE are not allowed to openly belong to the KKK, Black Panthers, Hells Angels, Nortenoz, etc. even on their own time and dime.

                            And BTW the Gov. said at Peace Officer Memorial Day that LE were all in a "Special Class." So that should settle that.

                            Glad I could help you out with this.

                            Comment

                            • compsoftstation
                              Senior Member
                              • Apr 2009
                              • 849

                              I take my stand with the LE. Innocent people could of died in that chase. If that garbage killed a love one or someone you know, I think you'd do more than kicking him in the face.
                              sigpicThe Mind is like a parachute it works best when opened - Frank Zappa
                              E93 M3/ BLACK, WHITE, AND CARBON FIBER COLOR COMBO/ AFE COLD AIR INTAKE/ AFE POWER PULLEY/ ROYAL FULL CATBACK EXHAUST/ ECU FLASH/ H&R COIL OVER/ PREDATOR ORION V2 ANGEL EYE/ VORSTEINER CARBON FIBER GTS HOOD/ VORSTEINER REAR CARBON FIBER GTS DIFFUSER/ VORSTEINER GTS FRONT CARBON FIBER LIP/ VORSTEINER REAR TRUNK SPOILER/ 20" FORGIATO CARBON FIBER WHEELS/ 500+ HP

                              Comment

                              • ilbob
                                Senior Member
                                • Jul 2008
                                • 1777

                                Originally posted by Ron-Solo
                                Another common misconception by the un-informed, who have obtained the majority of their law enforcement expertise from watching Hawaii Five-O to Law & Order to CSI.
                                Its not normally necessary to lie. A properly formed report can be completely truthful while not especially illuminating as to what actually happened.

                                We sometimes forget that cops on TV are near perfect while cops in real life are mostly imperfect human beings who are subject to the same misjudgements that all us of are.

                                I don't see the high-5 as a problem. They might well have done that afterwards, kick or not.

                                Not sure I see the flashlight as an issue either. At that point the situation is such a mess that its hard for me to question what that officer did.

                                The kick is another thing. The guy is on the ground. His hands are away from his body. At that point the pursuit is over. The claim that the proned out guy moving his head gives the cop justification for kicking him in the head is going to be an interesting argument that the PD may well accept. PDs almost always side with their officers, and its not just about the blue line.

                                A civil court may see it differently.

                                In fact, it may be that there was some misconduct but it was not criminal in nature.
                                bob

                                Disclaimers: I am not a lawyer, cop, soldier, gunsmith, politician, plumber, electrician, or a professional practitioner of many of the other things I comment on in this forum.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1