Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

El Monte PD

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #46
    Erik S. Klein
    Member
    • May 2009
    • 202

    Originally posted by masameet
    Believe me, I have witnessed police abuse in action, and that kick pales in comparison.
    Agreed.

    But the kick was still abuse regardless of how much we want the guy eating boot to be abused.

    The police can't be allowed to treat the public like that and the department can't be allowed to make lame-*** excuses for miscreant cops.

    All that does is erode the public trust without which the police can't be effective.
    Erik
    NRA Life Member
    Sig fan.

    Comment

    • #47
      SVT-40
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Jan 2008
      • 12918

      Some of you judge so quickly. It would be interesting to see you do the job. Once again it's easy to sit back behind your computer and Play judge. Try and get out there and do the job.

      Maybe then you would learn just how quickly your life can end if you do not quickly take command of a deadly situation such as this was.

      It's really just pathetic for you to pass judgment with out any expertise or law enforcement experience.

      Thank god the judgment will be based on what a "reasonable officer would do" when confronted with the situation with very little time to decide what is "right".

      The parolee was not "abused" he received one kick, after obviously disobeying the officers commands. End of story.
      Poke'm with a stick!


      Originally posted by fiddletown
      What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

      Comment

      • #48
        CaliTheKid
        Senior Member
        • Oct 2005
        • 546

        Originally posted by Erik S. Klein

        If I kicked someone like that I'd be arrested for assault.
        No you wouldn't.

        Comment

        • #49
          fairfaxjim
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2006
          • 2146

          Originally posted by SkyStorm82
          I long for the day, that every non-LEO citizen truly understands the evil that gangsters are, and either take care of the problem themselves and/or demand the government do what really needs to be done.
          And when they do, you damn well better pray that some cop on the street doesn't judge/jury/executioner you or someone in your family as a "gangster" (black, mexican, drug dealer, gun owner, or any other politically incorrect person for that day) There is a reason that we have separate enforcement and judgement systems in this country.

          Originally posted by CaliTheKid
          Originally posted by Erik S. Klein
          If I kicked someone like that I'd be arrested for assault.
          No you wouldn't.
          Ok, can I kick YOU like that?
          "As soon as we burn 'em," Chinn said, "more come in."
          Ignatius Chinn, a FORMER veteran firearms agent.
          CONTRA COSTA TIMES 03/04/2008

          "please guys please no ridiculous offers....Im a girl, not an idiot" Mistisa242

          Comment

          • #50
            CaliTheKid
            Senior Member
            • Oct 2005
            • 546

            Blah blah blah. You missed the point completely.
            Last edited by CaliTheKid; 05-20-2009, 12:43 AM.

            Comment

            • #51
              MP301
              Veteran Member
              • Oct 2008
              • 4168

              Originally posted by fairfaxjim
              And when they do, you damn well better pray that some cop on the street doesn't judge/jury/executioner you or someone in your family as a "gangster" (black, mexican, drug dealer, gun owner, or any other politically incorrect person for that day) There is a reason that we have separate enforcement and judgement systems in this country.



              Ok, can I kick YOU like that?
              You can kick me like that. But you will only do it once....then.....


              But anyway...


              There are obviously two sides to this coin. On the one hand, we have rules that have to work for everbody across the board. Someones status or race or whatever should not apply. We obviously cant have different rules for different groups and where would you draw the line?
              So, how you need to deal with someone is not by who or what he is, but by what he does.

              Does the BG get his a** handed to him because he is guilty of contempt of cop by making you chase him? No

              But what I see here from the available information is a dangerous situation where after a high speed chase and a lot of adrenaline, a BG's failure to follow a lawfull order which could result in injury to the lone officer.

              SVT-40's post is accurate and well written. It makes far more sense then the idea that this officer just kicked him for punishment. If the BG was laying on the ground with his head turned way and did not move, then the abuse claim might be in order. If the officer had kicked him more then once, then the abuse claim might fly. If the assisting officer had hit the BG after his hand was pulled from underneath him, then crying abuse is a possibility too. But as you can see from the video, none of that applies here.

              What was said about parolee's training to defeat LE's while being taken in custody is very accurate. I saw a video taken by prison guards while I was in the academy that showed these mullets in a practice session doing just that. Half a dozen were standing around playing students, two were playing the cop role and one was showing the others how to push off the wall (the old method of searching and cuffing BG's ), slash both cops with a knife and take off at a dead run before they reacted.

              Nothing is ever clear, cut and dried.
              Last edited by MP301; 05-20-2009, 4:01 AM.
              Any Questions about Front Sight memberships or specific information about attending, Feel Free to send me a PM!

              Comment

              • #52
                geeknow
                Lifetime Contributor #1
                CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                • Aug 2007
                • 3144

                Originally posted by SVT-40
                Most of you posting here are condemning the Ofc. for his kick even though you have NO IDEA about the training and experience this officer has.

                The standard for what is lawful or not is "What would a reasonable OFFICER" do in the situation. Thank god it's not what every untrained amateur would do.

                Now lets really look at the video. You see the suspect run into a back yard and then stop near a wall. He raises his hands over his head. It appears he is following the commands of the officer as he lays down and places his arms above his head. At that exact second the suspects is facing away from the officer because the officer is ordering him to do so. ( common training) Just a second later you see the suspect turn his head toward the officer. This would be in direct disobedience to the officers commands. It appears the officer was alone at that time and the suspect may have been attempting to locate him so he could begin a ground attack .

                As the officer was already committed to approaching the suspect he used a distraction kick to keep the suspect off guard. It worked and the suspect turned his head away and the officer engaged the suspects left arm. At that time the suspect places his right are under his body, why? to reach for a weapon? At that time neither officer knew if the suspect was armed or not.

                The second officer arrives and seeing the suspect with his right arm under his body delivers a distraction blow to the suspects torso, then grabs the suspects right arm and forces it behind his back. Handcuffs are applied and the confrontation is over.

                What most all you non LEO types are ignorant of is the FACT that prison inmates train constantly to disarm officers and practice many type attacks including attacks on officers from the prone position. The main need for the suspect to initiate a attack is to accurately locate the officers legs.

                That is why during all confrontations where you "prone out a suspect" you ALWAYS have them face away from you.

                This suspect did at first face away from the officer, however just before the officer engaged him the suspect turned his head toward the officer. Why did he do this??

                He is obviously a hard corps gang member and parolee. So he may have intended to try and use a tripping technique on the officer who at the time of the kick was alone.

                As far as I can see the officer was absolutely justified in delivering ONE kick to the suspect. The kick resulted in the suspect turning away from the officer, and confused the suspect allowing the officer to SAFELY engage the suspect. The second officer was also justified in the ONE blow he delivered, as the suspect had moved his right hand under his body near his waistband (the most common area to hide a weapon).

                Don't jump to conclusions when you have no idea how officers are trained and the threats which they are faced with. These Parolees are animals and have no compunction in harming or killing you or an officer if it means them staying out of custody.

                Judge this suspects level of violence based on his driving. He had no concern for anyone on the street.

                I disagree with you 100%. How can you simply justify the actions of this officer without the benefit of any of the "facts" while simultaneously chiding those critical of this officer of the same?

                Could it be that you really believe that LEO's are somehow better than those they choose to serve? Cant say for sure, but it sure sounds like it...

                Regardless of what led up to the bad guy (yes, he is a bad guy I believe) going prone, once he was there the need to kick him in the head left, plain and simple.

                To state that being kicked in the head savagely like that was justified by nothing more than turning his head...? wtf? that is human nature dude. would you seriously have any of us believe that it is anything other than natural to look at the person you are running from given the circumstances?

                No, you will not convince me of that....

                This, to me (you know, a citizen and a voter...) shows yet another example of a police department running roughshod over the same laws and principles that they swore to uphold. Shameful...

                My prediction is this.....

                Nothing will come of this. Never does. The slick lawyers, spokes-holes, and the like will spin this away like they do everything else.

                But dont pretend the problem doesnt exist...It does.

                If you want to believe that kicking a guy in the head today because of what he did yesterday makes things right, then go on with your bad self...

                You have to live with yourself, not me...

                As I type this, know that I live across the street from a member of that same department.

                Know also, that I, my family, and everyone else on our street avoids him like the plague....

                He has shown himself to each of us to be crooked, a liar, armed with a badge and a gun, and someone to be feared, not trusted...

                That, sir, is the reputation that the El Monte PD has earned for itself in the community THEY serve.

                Comment

                • #53
                  Ron-Solo
                  In Memoriam
                  • Jan 2009
                  • 8581

                  Originally posted by Erik S. Klein
                  And they'll lie through their teeth to protect their fellow officers.
                  Another common misconception by the un-informed, who have obtained the majority of their law enforcement expertise from watching Hawaii Five-O to Law & Order to CSI.
                  LASD Retired
                  1978-2011

                  NRA Life Member
                  CRPA Life Member
                  NRA Rifle Instructor
                  NRA Shotgun Instructor
                  NRA Range Safety Officer
                  DOJ Certified Instructor

                  Comment

                  • #54
                    Ron-Solo
                    In Memoriam
                    • Jan 2009
                    • 8581

                    Originally posted by masameet
                    A "distraction blow" sounds pretty legitimate to me.

                    lol

                    [/url]
                    I doubt there are many Departments that teach this technique. He's gonna need to be able to back it up. It wouldn't fly with LASD. Any headstrike requires an IAB roll-out and you pretty much have to be able to justify deadly force before you can use an impact weapon (or boot) to the head.

                    Don't know what El Monte's policy is on this matter or what academy the officer went to. If he went to LASD's academy, it will be harder to sell, since it isn't taught there. If he went to Rio Hondo, who knows?
                    LASD Retired
                    1978-2011

                    NRA Life Member
                    CRPA Life Member
                    NRA Rifle Instructor
                    NRA Shotgun Instructor
                    NRA Range Safety Officer
                    DOJ Certified Instructor

                    Comment

                    • #55
                      ilbob
                      Senior Member
                      • Jul 2008
                      • 1777

                      Originally posted by Erik S. Klein
                      And they'll lie through their teeth to protect their fellow officers.
                      I suspect any lies will not come from IA, but to them.

                      There might be less interest in investigating certain aspects of the case, but direct lying by IA is not as likely as you might think.

                      My guess is everyone involved has had plenty of time to get their stories straight before IA does much of anything.

                      It might even turn out it was not a recreational thing but a legitimate response to something the guy laying on the ground did.

                      No one here will ever know for sure though. Just the way these things play out.
                      bob

                      Disclaimers: I am not a lawyer, cop, soldier, gunsmith, politician, plumber, electrician, or a professional practitioner of many of the other things I comment on in this forum.

                      Comment

                      • #56
                        masameet
                        Veteran Member
                        • Jun 2008
                        • 4487

                        Originally posted by Ron-Solo
                        I doubt there are many Departments that teach this technique. He's gonna need to be able to back it up. It wouldn't fly with LASD. Any headstrike requires an IAB roll-out and you pretty much have to be able to justify deadly force before you can use an impact weapon (or boot) to the head.

                        Don't know what El Monte's policy is on this matter or what academy the officer went to. If he went to LASD's academy, it will be harder to sell, since it isn't taught there. If he went to Rio Hondo, who knows?
                        I guess I should have put in "[sarcasm]pretty legitimate[/sarcasm]" instead of "lol," so as not to give the impression that the kick IMO was good or legit. (Still you have to admit that the POA lawyer came up with a very creative justification. lol)

                        Was the kick necessary?

                        From the video I would have to agree that no, it wasn't. (And looking at the arresting mug shot, the BG has two raspberries -- one to the left side of his forehead and the other on the right side of his jaw. When I watched the kick being given, my initial reaction was: That's a good way to break somebody's jaw.)

                        And as to the stuff printed by the San Gabriel Valley Times, esp. about the officer's alleged problems within the EPMD, I'd say the kicking officer has at least one less friend in the EMPD.
                        x

                        "Let those find fault whose wit's so very small,
                        They've need to show that they can think at all;
                        Errors, like straws, upon the surface flow;
                        He who would search for pearls, must dive below." -- John Dryden

                        Comment

                        • #57
                          chaseman
                          Junior Member
                          • Apr 2009
                          • 32

                          This has turned into a pretty hot debate. I'm not going to go getting into the it was right it was wrong, justified unjustified for a few reasons. 1) I am not a LEO and I have not been trained to know what to do in a situation like that so its hard for me to say which leads me to the second reason

                          2) I wasnt there so I dont know what his level of compliance was? Up until the point where he laid on the ground it hadn't been very high.

                          With all that said, I do know this, I was always taught that police officers have a very dangerous job so when approached dont ever give them a reason to think you are the bad guy. For example, pull over timely, roll down your window keep your hands where they can be seen etc etc.

                          This guy did not do that he ran, running is an act of desperation. Desperate people = Dangerous people. So there has to be a certain amount of benefit of the doubt to the officer. Are there bad apples, of course. But we gave this guy a badge we made him jump through all the hoops of getting hired (background checks, psychs,physicals etc.) and then trained the hell out of him so he can make these decisions. Am I saying not to question of course not but some of you have already fired this guy and convicted him. That isnt right, innocent until proven guilty especially with our leos and millitary because they are held to a higher standard.

                          This officer was running on the assumption that this was one bad dude, he has to. This idiot risked all their lives and hundreds of innocent bystanders. He must be pretty desperate. anyways i drove that one into the ground.

                          All I know is I dont want a gun stuck in my face and i dont want to be tackled, so Im gonna do what you ask.

                          All I could think was ooooh, you shouldve listened, idiot.

                          one last thing sorry for the mispelllings and lack of punctuation I wrote that whole thing from my phone...while driving haha




                          jk bout the driving

                          Comment

                          • #58
                            SVT-40
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • Jan 2008
                            • 12918

                            geeknow "I disagree with you 100%. How can you simply justify the actions of this officer without the benefit of any of the "facts" while simultaneously chiding those critical of this officer of the same?"

                            Define "facts", plus you seem to be able to say the officer was wrong without ANY facts. The reason I can chide those critical of the officer is those people have never been t in the situation the officer was in. They are ignorant to such situations. Besides I'm not justifying anything. I'm stating my opinion. I have 29 years experience in So Calif law enforcement experience. I've been in similar situations and every one is different. Becaise of my experience I can have a more informed opinion than one who has never been in similar situations.

                            geeknow "Could it be that you really believe that LEO's are somehow better than those they choose to serve? Cant say for sure, but it sure sounds like it..."

                            No, Cops are not as you say "better" than those they serve. This statement alone gives away your own personal dislike for LEO's in general.

                            geeknow"Regardless of what led up to the bad guy (yes, he is a bad guy I believe) going prone, once he was there the need to kick him in the head left, plain and simple."

                            Again you are just wrong. ALL gang members know when being proned out by a LEO after any kind of incident they need to follow the instructions of the LEO EXACTLY!!

                            geeknow "To state that being kicked in the head savagely like that was justified by nothing more than turning his head...? wtf? that is human nature dude. would you seriously have any of us believe that it is anything other than natural to look at the person you are running from given the circumstances?"

                            From my training and experience I know during these contacts the officer will always tell the suspect to look away. You can see the suspect in the video at first look away, then turn his head back and look at the officer. The officer has no way to tell why the suspect turns his head back toward him. Was the suspect trying to locate him to attempt to grab his legs, or some other type of grappling move?The officer has no idea. So he kicks the suspect to keep him off guard. Not a "savage" kick as you state just a kick.

                            So you say it's "natural " for a person to look at "person" you are running from.

                            Not if the "person" you are running from is a uniformed LEO who is issuing you commands.



                            geeknow "No, you will not convince me of that....

                            "This, to me (you know, a citizen and a voter...) shows yet another example of a police department running roughshod over the same laws and principles that they swore to uphold. Shameful..."


                            This statement again shows your prejudice against LEO's and law enforcement in general.

                            geeknow "My prediction is this.....

                            Nothing will come of this. Never does. The slick lawyers, spokes-holes, and the like will spin this away like they do everything else."


                            My prediction is the officer will not be found guilty of any wrong doing. because the standard of conduct is as I have said before is. What would a reasonable officer do given the TOTALITY of what the officer in THIS incident was confronted with.


                            geeknow "But dont pretend the problem doesnt exist...It does. "

                            I don't pretend anything. But each incident must be judged on it's own merits without prejudice.

                            geeknow "If you want to believe that kicking a guy in the head today because of what he did yesterday makes things right, then go on with your bad self..."

                            The fellow who received the kick was kicked because of his actions at the time. Not actions the day before or even minutes before.

                            geeknow "You have to live with yourself, not me..."

                            Thank god, because you seem to be able to justify the actions of a street thug, and not be able to reasonably view the actions of the officer from his standpoint. A very myopic and narrow viewpoint.

                            geeknow "As I type this, know that I live across the street from a member of that same department.

                            Know also, that I, my family, and everyone else on our street avoids him like the plague....

                            He has shown himself to each of us to be crooked, a liar, armed with a badge and a gun, and someone to be feared, not trusted...

                            That, sir, is the reputation that the El Monte PD has earned for itself in the community THEY serve."



                            You state your neighbor is "crooked". What crime has he allegedly committed and been convicted of. Or what corrupt act has he been found guilty of?

                            It's easy to make accusations but hard to follow them up with FACTS!!

                            Again you lump ALL El Monte cops into the same bunch. This shows your own prejudice.


                            My standard of judgment is related to what I actually know. Unlike you, who seem to have the supernatural ability to presume all of a particular group as bad or evil. Are there "bad" El Monte cops? Maybe. But to group all of them together as "bad", taints your opinion and makes any of your statements rendered about this particular incident meaningless.

                            Above all remember the officer was presented with a difficult situation and was alone with a dangerous felony suspect. he had a fraction of a second to make his decisions. As in all similar situations you are trained to win, and try to use the minimal force to accomplish the arrest. Could the office have done something else, maybe I don't know I was not there under those conditions.

                            What is a fact is the officers were not hurt, and the suspect was captured without serious injury. A win for all.

                            The use of force in most situations looks "bad" because the viewer is not privy to all the influences at the time of the force is used. Pictures or video alone do not tell the whole tale.
                            Last edited by SVT-40; 05-20-2009, 1:07 PM.
                            Poke'm with a stick!


                            Originally posted by fiddletown
                            What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

                            Comment

                            • #59
                              Erik S. Klein
                              Member
                              • May 2009
                              • 202

                              Originally posted by Ron-Solo
                              Another common misconception by the un-informed, who have obtained the majority of their law enforcement expertise from watching Hawaii Five-O to Law & Order to CSI.
                              Or working with the police and seeing them in action in the real world. . .
                              Erik
                              NRA Life Member
                              Sig fan.

                              Comment

                              • #60
                                Erik S. Klein
                                Member
                                • May 2009
                                • 202

                                Originally posted by ilbob
                                It might even turn out it was not a recreational thing but a legitimate response to something the guy laying on the ground did.
                                Regarless of what really happened the above is the way it will turn out. . . even if the truth has to be bent a bit to get there.
                                Erik
                                NRA Life Member
                                Sig fan.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1