Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

El Monte PD

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #76
    Sam1
    Senior Member
    • May 2008
    • 766

    what more details do we need to know? there's a video!

    good thing he got a kick in the face but he surrendered peacefully and didn't deserve it like that

    Comment

    • #77
      MP301
      Veteran Member
      • Oct 2008
      • 4168

      Arg

      Ill try again...

      Originally posted by Erik S. Klein
      --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      Thats great Erik, but first you really need to know what "bahaving properly" is under those conditions.

      I do, and it's no different for police than it is for civilians.

      No. You dont know. Civilians are usually not in danger of being killed, (running on pure adrenaline) if they dont act/react properly.

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      My previous post still stands and it looks like SVT addressed your reply prior to me getting the chance. Its accurate as well.


      I disagree.

      You have that right

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      The first thing you must rememeber is unless you have first hand experience in this type of work, had training with this type of work, you are basing your opinions on flawed information, based on what YOU believe.


      Nonsense.

      No. Its not

      I can tell if a brick wall is built like crap and I can call out the bricklayer for being incompetent.

      Cay you? What if it wasnt incompetence and there is some other reason for the poor quality (materials, etc.)? You would need to be experienced in that field to know the difference.

      The same is true of a bad firefighter, bad teacher, bad plumber or whatever.

      See above

      I don't have to do any of those jobs to recognize when they are being done poorly.

      Police work isn't magic. That isn't to say that there aren't special skills, etc. but that whole "if you aren't in the trenches" argument is bunk.

      Again, without first hand knowledge and training in those fields, you may guess right on the circumstances some of the time, but you could not know and should not pretend to know all of the possibilities. And police work isnt magic, but it IS a specialized skill that you need training for and then need to work with a training officer before you make your own decisions

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      Sure, some of the abuse cases are obvious to all - like cops repeated hitting an unarmed and handcuffed BG for 20 minutes. That's a no brainer. But situations like this are a lot more complicated.


      I'll agree that there are degrees of abuse and that this was very low on the scale, but it was still uncalled for and, as such, abuse.

      That is your opinion and your making that opinion based on what you believe...and again, your not basing that belief on training, experience or first hand knowledge. Sure, there are different degrees of abuse, but there are also different degrees in taking action to protect yourself that are not abuse

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      Did you know that the officer is not breaking the law if he acted on his beliefs, based on the information he had at the time?

      That depends. The problem is that those beliefs often develop after the fact and with the help of police council, etc.

      Yes, that is possible and im sure it happens. It doesnt automatically make it so, just because its a possibility, now does it?

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      Thats why when a cop shoots someone who has a toy gun, he is within his rights going on what he believed at the time, based on available infomation at the time.


      True, if it makes sense. Sometimes the toy gun argument doesn't work. If a teenager in a hoodie on a dark night appears to be threatening a cop with the toy gun that's one thing. If a six year old is waving a bright orange one around on his front lawn while yelling "bang bang" that's quite another.

      Your stating the obvious. I was making a general statement, not trying to blanket the ok to shoot people with obviously fake guns. I have never heard of a police shooting where the toy gun was obviously not a gun.

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      When I first saw the video I had the same reaction as you did. On its face, it didnt look right. Then you look at it again and start paying attention to the details and you see it a whole new story.

      I have and still didn't see anything to justify the kick. I understand what's been written about the perp's potential to make a move on the cop, etc. but the fact remains that he did not make a threatening move.

      Of course you dont or we would not be in this debate. Doesnt mean its not true.

      That's like shooting someone who has a gun in their holster because they had the potential to draw and fire.

      No its not. You make the false assumption that a cop should wait until the guy actually points the gun. The reality is that the BG gets shot when he reaches for the gun.

      In reality until there is an aggressive act the reaction to it is uncalled for.

      No. Thats not the reality. If the guy had not turned his head back toward the officer, then I might agree. But cops are trained to react at the first sign of trouble, not after its too late. If the cop would have shot the guy for turning his head, then I would agree with you. But it appears to me he did the only thing he was able to do to stop a potential (and stupid) move on the part of the BG. He was by himself, just finished a dead run and could not take his gun off the suspect. Whats left?

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      Example, Anyone who thinks that the BART cop, maliciously and purposefullyshot the handcuffed guy in the back in front of all those witnesses is a complete idiot or very ignorant. That was either bad training or an unintential brain fart - or both. But not murder.

      Murder in the second degree, for sure.

      No its not. That takes intent. Again, in front of all those witnesses, you believe that he had intent?

      First degree (malicious and purposeful) - Not likely, but possible.

      An even further stretch. You actually think that incident was premeditated?

      I'd argue that the guy became guilty of first degree when he strapped on his sidearm that morning. He had to have known how utterly stupid and incompetent he was, after all.

      No again. First off, maybe you dont know this, but incompetent people dont actually know they incompetent! And we know he wasnt incompetent because he most likely wouldnt have been hired in the first place and at the very least he would have never passed probation. It is a big mistake, IMHO, to give officers weapons that are too similar to thier firearm, because under stress, it is possible (this isnt the first time this has happened) to momentarily confuse the two while multitasking - like taking sojmeone into custody while watching your back with a couple dozen people taunting you! And you sure dont wear the thing on the same side as your gun either!

      Quote:
      Originally Posted by MP301
      Food for thought...

      Agreed.

      I'm not against giving cops the benefit of the doubt. Many times I'm more than willing. I've seen/read about the police involved in bad shoots that were, in fact, justified by the circumstances.

      You are obviously against giving them the benefit of the doubt - otherwise, you wouldnt be so convinced that this cop is guilty of abuse until all the facts were in.

      Then there are the many, many examples of them simply screwing up (like the BART situation) and the rest of the gang jump in line to defend the bad cops.

      No. for reasons previously stated, the BART incident is a bad example. Furthermore, what your saying is that since some were guilty of abuse, they are all automatically guilty in your eyes.

      The Cau Thi Bich made Tran incident is another example, as is the Elio Carrion incident.

      Not familiar and its irrelavant to this discussion

      Every time a cop does this and gets away with it (the BART shooter will, I'm sure - either way he wasn't arrested on the spot) the public's trust in the police is justifiably eroded.

      Yeah, assuming all the cops are guilty sure will screw up trust. Hey, lets go riot and break things and steal things!

      Why would you trust the police if they might shoot, kick, pistol whip, club or otherwise abuse you for no apparent reason and when you have no recourse? Even with video they're almost certain to get away with it and it's all but assured that you'll be harassed for just pursuing the matter.

      I can see that you had your mind made up before the incident happened. Predisposed is the term.

      Why would you cooperate with a force like that?

      Predisposed. There are bad cops, but its a small percetage. Your saying because of this, the whole dept is bad.

      Why call 911 when you know you're taking that kind of a chance?

      I dont think the guy on the video called anyone.

      Your mind is made up and its obvious you will view law enforcement in a negative light...always think guilty until proven innocent...if even then.

      Im done. Ive wasted too much time debating this already. Im sorry that you feel the way you do. I dunno, maybe you had a bad experience and thats causing you to blanket all cops with that view.

      Any Questions about Front Sight memberships or specific information about attending, Feel Free to send me a PM!

      Comment

      • #78
        yzErnie
        CGN/CGSSA Contributor - Lifetime
        CGN Contributor - Lifetime
        • Mar 2007
        • 6310

        I'm afraid we can talk, explain and justify to Erik S. Klein until time stops and nothing will change his opinion on the matter. He is focused on his opinion and nothing we could say will change his mind. I say we stop feeding the troll in this forum and he will go away.
        The satisfaction of a job well done is to be the one who has done it

        Originally posted by RazoE
        I don't feel a thing when some cop gets ghosted.

        Comment

        • #79
          Erik S. Klein
          Member
          • May 2009
          • 202

          Originally posted by SVT-40
          The officer, dealing with the situation he was confronted with at the time decided to issue one kick to the suspect. Nothing else. He will be judged like any other officer who uses force. The question will revolve around only one issue. that question is.

          Did he act "reasonably" considering ALL the factors related to the incident including what he was thinking at the time of the kick. That's it.

          "Reasonably" means would an officer given the same situation thinking the way this officer was thinking act in a similar way. If the answer is yes, then the force was reasonable. If the force is judged unreasonable he will be disciplined.
          And the only problem I have with that is the use of "officer" where "person" should be used.

          The police are not "special" and do not have, nor do they deserve, special rules.

          Originally posted by SVT-40
          You are not qualified to judge the officer. You can have an opinion. But to actually judge someones actions you must have some knowledge of the job he does and the situation he was involved with.
          Incorrect. I can have an opinion and judge the officer without actually being a cop myself.

          Sorry, that's just reality.

          Originally posted by SVT-40
          Keep the rest to your self.
          I am under no obligation to do so.

          Originally posted by SVT-40
          Besides even police officers have rights. We too are considered innocent until PROVEN guilty.
          Absolutely. The same rights as everyone else. No more, no less.

          Originally posted by SVT-40
          So show the officer the same respect you would demand if you were accused of wrongdoing.
          I am.

          Of course there is a video. It's hard to make that say something other than what it says.

          Originally posted by SVT-40
          Oh, one other thing the Bart cop. He definitely messed up in the heat of the incident he confused the taser with his duty pistol. But murder?? no way, you need to educate yourself. There was no malice no intent.
          There was absolutely malice and intent sufficient for 2nd degree murder under CA law: "a killing caused by dangerous conduct and the offender's obvious lack of concern for human life."

          There was no reason to draw either a taser or firearm more or less fire one. That fits both qualifiers above - dangerous conduct and a lack of concern for human life.

          And if you really think that the moron confused his taser with his duty weapon then I'm back on first degree murder - strapping on a sidearm when you're that stupid is premeditated murder.

          Originally posted by SVT-40
          I'm sure at some point in the future he will plead guilty to voluntary manslaughter. He will do some time and fade away.
          And I'm sure that the plea will be offered in such a way that he gets far more lenient treatment than any civilian ever would.

          Originally posted by SVT-40
          A shame for all involved. A life lost and a career ruined.
          A man is shot and killed by an idiot cop and it's "a shame?"
          Erik
          NRA Life Member
          Sig fan.

          Comment

          • #80
            Dr. Peter Venkman
            Veteran Member
            • Oct 2006
            • 4899

            Originally posted by Gio
            He is still a Human Being Regardless of how you feel about him
            What is so special about human beings? The gangbanger is a dirtbag and the kick to the head is the most punishment that guy has seen in his "career" gangbanger life.
            sigpic
            "America is not at war. The Marine Corps is at war; America is at the mall."
            Originally posted by berto
            You're right. There's no possible way that CGN members marching alongside the Pink Pistols in the SF Pride Parade can do anything to dispel the stereotype that gun owners are conservative bigots clinging to their guns and bibles. Not a single person in the crowd is rational or reachable because the parade's for gay folks and it's in SF.

            Comment

            • #81
              Erik S. Klein
              Member
              • May 2009
              • 202

              Originally posted by MP301
              No. You dont know. Civilians are usually not in danger of being killed, (running on pure adrenaline) if they dont act/react properly.
              That's not the point. The point is that a civilian in the same exact situation - one who could be considered in the same danger - wouldn't have the same options.

              Originally posted by MP301
              Cay you? What if it wasnt incompetence and there is some other reason for the poor quality (materials, etc.)? You would need to be experienced in that field to know the difference.
              I'd need some experience with the field, but I wouldn't need to be a master bricklayer to figure it out.

              Originally posted by MP301
              Again, without first hand knowledge and training in those fields, you may guess right on the circumstances some of the time, but you could not know and should not pretend to know all of the possibilities. And police work isnt magic, but it IS a specialized skill that you need training for and then need to work with a training officer before you make your own decisions
              I agree, mostly, but it's all a matter of degree.

              I may not be able to determine that the mortar used in a brick wall is deficient and may fail in 20 years instead of 30 but if the wall is bowed and the bricks poorly aligned I'll notice quickly.

              This particular incident isn't as subtle as you are making it out to be. It's a clearly crappy brick wall and, like smacking an unconscious man with a billy-club or draping a paraplegic over a wall to frisk him, no excuse can be made.

              Originally posted by MP301
              That is your opinion and your making that opinion based on what you believe...and again, your not basing that belief on training, experience or first hand knowledge. Sure, there are different degrees of abuse, but there are also different degrees in taking action to protect yourself that are not abuse
              No argument.

              This cop should have stood off at a safe distance with his weapon drawn until his backup arrived.

              The kick was not necessary and, therefore, constitutes abuse.

              Originally posted by MP301
              Yes, that is possible and im sure it happens. It doesnt automatically make it so, just because its a possibility, now does it?
              Correct.

              In this case my conclusion is drawn from copious evidence collected over years and years of observation.

              It's not a given, but it sure is likely.

              Originally posted by MP301
              Your stating the obvious. I was making a general statement, not trying to blanket the ok to shoot people with obviously fake guns. I have never heard of a police shooting where the toy gun was obviously not a gun.
              See above. . .
              Originally posted by MP301
              No its not. You make the false assumption that a cop should wait until the guy actually points the gun. The reality is that the BG gets shot when he reaches for the gun.
              No, my assumption is the same. The act of attempting to draw is sufficient. Standing there with your hands up (or lying prone) is not an attempt to draw and can never be confused with it.

              Originally posted by MP301
              No. Thats not the reality. If the guy had not turned his head back toward the officer, then I might agree. But cops are trained to react at the first sign of trouble, not after its too late. If the cop would have shot the guy for turning his head, then I would agree with you. But it appears to me he did the only thing he was able to do to stop a potential (and stupid) move on the part of the BG. He was by himself, just finished a dead run and could not take his gun off the suspect. Whats left?
              I already stated what was left. Stand off at a safe distance until backup arrives.

              The act of looking at someone is not inherently aggressive and it's certainly not a threat no matter how much BS you apply to justify it.

              Again, I understand your claim, I just disagree.

              Originally posted by MP301
              No its not. That takes intent. Again, in front of all those witnesses, you believe that he had intent?
              Not quite. See my post above.

              Originally posted by MP301
              No again. First off, maybe you dont know this, but incompetent people dont actually know they incompetent! And we know he wasnt incompetent because he most likely wouldnt have been hired in the first place and at the very least he would have never passed probation. It is a big mistake, IMHO, to give officers weapons that are too similar to thier firearm, because under stress, it is possible (this isnt the first time this has happened) to momentarily confuse the two while multitasking - like taking sojmeone into custody while watching your back with a couple dozen people taunting you! And you sure dont wear the thing on the same side as your gun either!
              Yes I know that. . . this particular line of argument is hyperbole on my part. I'm just stressing the fact that this cop was a complete and utter idiot which sort-of negates your belief that the department doesn't hire those types. . .
              Originally posted by MP301
              You are obviously against giving them the benefit of the doubt - otherwise, you wouldnt be so convinced that this cop is guilty of abuse until all the facts were in.
              All of the facts are in.
              Originally posted by MP301
              No. for reasons previously stated, the BART incident is a bad example. Furthermore, what your saying is that since some were guilty of abuse, they are all automatically guilty in your eyes.
              That is not at all what I said.

              Originally posted by MP301
              Yeah, assuming all the cops are guilty sure will screw up trust. Hey, lets go riot and break things and steal things!
              Again, that's not what I said.

              Originally posted by MP301
              I can see that you had your mind made up before the incident happened. Predisposed is the term.
              (Deliberately) Wrong again.

              Originally posted by MP301
              Predisposed. There are bad cops, but its a small percetage. Your saying because of this, the whole dept is bad.
              I am saying that the fact that the department doesn't address the small percentage they both encourage that number to get larger and erode the trust of the public.

              Originally posted by MP301
              I dont think the guy on the video called anyone.
              True that.

              Originally posted by MP301
              Your mind is made up and its obvious you will view law enforcement in a negative light...always think guilty until proven innocent...if even then.
              Incorrect again; but feel free to continue misrepresenting my arguments if you think it bolsters yours.

              Meanwhile you're making my point. Cops will, by nature, always give other cops the benefit of the doubt - to the point of making up stupid options like "distraction kicks" for them.
              Erik
              NRA Life Member
              Sig fan.

              Comment

              • #82
                biglou
                Senior Member
                • May 2007
                • 1317

                When I started this thread it was in the form of a question to LEO's. They (FoxNews) had just aired the video for the second time. It was never my intent for anti LE to come on here and make unqualified statements and accusations. Be that as it may, this is what this tread had turned into. I really believe, after read Erik's post that he has some serious mental issues. I am not a Doctor of Mental Health. This is only my opinion based on this comment by Erik: "I'd argue that the guy became guilty of first degree when he strapped on his sidearm that morning. He had to have known how utterly stupid and incompetent he was, after all." This is one of the most outlandish comments I have read in reference to LE. If you are not mental than you are just on this Specialty Forum making stupid comments to get replies from LE for some type of gratification or cheap thrill. SVT-40 gave a good breakdown of the video along with his professional opinion. Mods need to lock this thread.

                Comment

                • #83
                  CaliTheKid
                  Senior Member
                  • Oct 2005
                  • 546

                  Taken down.
                  Last edited by CaliTheKid; 05-21-2009, 11:05 AM.

                  Comment

                  • #84
                    biglou
                    Senior Member
                    • May 2007
                    • 1317

                    Figures. UC liberal.

                    Comment

                    • #85
                      masameet
                      Veteran Member
                      • Jun 2008
                      • 4487

                      Originally posted by CaliTheKid
                      Judge for yourself if he's qualified.

                      link removed
                      In other online forums posting a member's personal information would be in violation of the Terms of Service.

                      But Calguns seems not to have a TOS so the revelation 'tis moot.

                      Still what current and retired LEO would stand to have his or her personal information posted on an online forum?
                      Last edited by masameet; 05-21-2009, 11:14 AM.
                      x

                      "Let those find fault whose wit's so very small,
                      They've need to show that they can think at all;
                      Errors, like straws, upon the surface flow;
                      He who would search for pearls, must dive below." -- John Dryden

                      Comment

                      • #86
                        CaliTheKid
                        Senior Member
                        • Oct 2005
                        • 546

                        First of all, I wouldn't put my personal information up on the internet for everyone to see nor would I use my real name on public forums. It's called common sense which he has shown very little of to begin with in his posts. It's not like he has tried to have the least bit of an expectation of privacy -- he's made it public.

                        But I'll take it down if it brushes up against some implied TOS.
                        Last edited by CaliTheKid; 05-21-2009, 11:05 AM.

                        Comment

                        • #87
                          Erik S. Klein
                          Member
                          • May 2009
                          • 202

                          Originally posted by biglou
                          When I started this thread it was in the form of a question to LEO's. They (FoxNews) had just aired the video for the second time. It was never my intent for anti LE to come on here and make unqualified statements and accusations. Be that as it may, this is what this tread had turned into. I really believe, after read Erik's post that he has some serious mental issues. I am not a Doctor of Mental Health. This is only my opinion based on this comment by Erik: "I'd argue that the guy became guilty of first degree when he strapped on his sidearm that morning. He had to have known how utterly stupid and incompetent he was, after all." This is one of the most outlandish comments I have read in reference to LE. If you are not mental than you are just on this Specialty Forum making stupid comments to get replies from LE for some type of gratification or cheap thrill. SVT-40 gave a good breakdown of the video along with his professional opinion. Mods need to lock this thread.
                          As I stated above that part was intentional hyperbole - just my way of saying that that particular cop was clearly a moron. . . a point which would be hard to argue.

                          The rest of your ad hominem, well, same back at ya.
                          Erik
                          NRA Life Member
                          Sig fan.

                          Comment

                          • #88
                            masameet
                            Veteran Member
                            • Jun 2008
                            • 4487

                            Originally posted by CaliTheKid
                            First of all, I wouldn't put my personal information up on the internet for everyone to see nor would I use my real name on public forums. It's called common sense which he has shown very little of to begin with in his posts. It's not like he has tried to have the least bit of an expectation of privacy -- he's made it public.

                            But I'll take it down if it brushes up against some implied TOS.


                            I know a few LEOs who have posted their names on the internet. They made that choice for themselves.
                            x

                            "Let those find fault whose wit's so very small,
                            They've need to show that they can think at all;
                            Errors, like straws, upon the surface flow;
                            He who would search for pearls, must dive below." -- John Dryden

                            Comment

                            • #89
                              Erik S. Klein
                              Member
                              • May 2009
                              • 202

                              Originally posted by CaliTheKid
                              First of all, I wouldn't put my personal information up on the internet for everyone to see nor would I use my real name on public forums. It's called common sense which he has shown very little of to begin with in his posts. It's not like he has tried to have the least bit of an expectation of privacy -- he's made it public.

                              But I'll take it down if it brushes up against some implied TOS.
                              True, that. Using my real name (as opposed to being a coward and hiding behind a handle) and posting my real opinions should be a risk, right?

                              But you're right. Trusting y'all wasn't very sensible.
                              Erik
                              NRA Life Member
                              Sig fan.

                              Comment

                              • #90
                                Erik S. Klein
                                Member
                                • May 2009
                                • 202

                                Originally posted by biglou
                                Figures. UC liberal.
                                Not even close. . .
                                Erik
                                NRA Life Member
                                Sig fan.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1