357 SIG

[Napalm Bulldog]

Is this the best the armchair commando brigade can come up with... Sheesh

You sure like to throw insults around. I get it, If we dont agree or think like you than we are not as cool as you are. Well Ill pass on learning the secret hand shake to be a part of your club.

Socrates said to shield a fool from his foolishness is to fill the world full of fools. I can concur with this, But in the case of our discussion it is mute. Do to the fact that there are studies that are both for and against the .357 sig.

Also I wont be calling anyone names because they dont think like me. Atleast they are thinking.

[Jorge]

ST5MF,

With all due respect, you have yet to counter any of the facts and tests posted regarding the .357 SIG other than posting "you are wrong." In fact, in seems as if you have a personal type hate for this round which is pretty bizarre considering it's just cartridge.

[kemasa]

It is a religious issue and when a leader of the person's cult says something, you do not question it and instead you claim all the rest are stupid kool-aid drinkers (as if that will discount all that they have to say). Other tests and information will not cause the faithful to deny their faith, facts do not matter.

Perhaps we, as a society, have learned things over time, so perhaps a newer round might be better or perhaps have a wider range available as to what it can do. Some, cling to what they know and no matter what others say they will stick to old designs.

Then again, time and time again it has been shown that many are closed minded, the world is flat and nothing will convince them otherwise. Even if they are correct, their attacks of kool-aid comments will result in people not listening to them, especially when they refuse to respond to other tests and opinions. Yelling (all caps) makes them think that people will listen to them too.

[ST5MF]

ST5MF,

With all due respect, you have yet to counter any of the facts and tests posted regarding the .357 SIG other than posting "you are wrong." In fact, in seems as if you have a personal type hate for this round which is pretty bizarre considering it's just cartridge.

Which is exactly my point "IT IS JUST A CARTRIDGE" and nothing more than that.

"The Brigade" seems to want to portray it as more. It is NOT. It is just another cartridge PERIOD.

[kemasa]

Ok, so a .22LR is just a cartridge and nothing more than that, so it is the same as a .50BMG, as that is also just a cartridge and nothing more than that.

[ST5MF]

Ok, so a .22LR is just a cartridge and nothing more than that, so it is the same as a .50BMG, as that is also just a cartridge and nothing more than that.

You have a .50BMG PISTOL

Magazine fed too, no doubt.

Any more stupid comments from the peanut gallery armchair commando/my cartridge is better than yours brigade?

[Napalm Bulldog]

You have a .50BMG PISTOL

Magazine fed too, no doubt.

Any more stupid comments from the peanut gallery armchair commando/my cartridge is better than yours brigade?

I think someone needs a warm cup of milk and a nap to cool off.

[locosway]

Just buy a 10mm and be done with this whole thread.

[Napalm Bulldog]

Just buy a 10mm and be done with this whole thread.

Thats my next Handgun.

[kemasa]

You have a .50BMG PISTOL

Magazine fed too, no doubt.

Any more stupid comments from the peanut gallery armchair commando/my cartridge is better than yours brigade?

There are .50 BMG pistols btw. I guess that just goes to show that you tend to speak before thinking :-).

http://airbornecombatengineer.typepad.com/airborne_combat_engineer/2005/01/the_maadi_griff.html#comment-108195942

http://airbornecombatengineer.typepad.com/airborne_combat_engineer/2005/01/the_thunder_50_.html

Your last comment is part of the problem that you have. You need to look in the mirror and take a long hard look. You seem to think that personal attacks will make you look good, but instead it makes you look quite the opposite. Quite clearly, you are unable to provide reasonable, rational responses to the questions put forth to you, so you have to resort to childish responses in order to try to defend your position.

So, you said "it is just a cartridge" and I pointed out that is a silly comment to make, so you have to call me response stupid. That only proves my point.

[Dr. Peter Venkman]

JDoe wins.

[ST5MF]

JDoe wins.

He must be your boyfriend.

[ST5MF]

There are .50 BMG pistols btw. I guess that just goes to show that you tend to speak before thinking :-).

http://airbornecombatengineer.typepad.com/airborne_combat_engineer/2005/01/the_maadi_griff.html#comment-108195942

http://airbornecombatengineer.typepad.com/airborne_combat_engineer/2005/01/the_thunder_50_.html

Your last comment is part of the problem that you have. You need to look in the mirror and take a long hard look. You seem to think that personal attacks will make you look good, but instead it makes you look quite the opposite. Quite clearly, you are unable to provide reasonable, rational responses to the questions put forth to you, so you have to resort to childish responses in order to try to defend your position.

So, you said "it is just a cartridge" and I pointed out that is a silly comment to make, so you have to call me response stupid. That only proves my point.

I gave Dr.Roberts data as well as his commentary. But that was not enough for any of the armchair commando brigade that "cling" to the idealology that 357SIG is any different than the more popular cartridges of 9MM, .40, or .45. You may think you know more than one of the most respected ballistic scientist in the world. Truth is you don't. So be it. You threw in the idoitic .50BMG comment. The brigade can continue to poision themselves with KOOL-AID all they like. It matters not. Spew the FUD that the 357SIG is some "SUPER CARTRIDGE" all you like. A fool and his money are soon departed it seems.

BTW I could care less how I look to a bunch of clowns living in some fanasty world were their guns and ammo trump all else. As if toting a 357SIG is some kind of EDGE. How misguided can people on gun forums be? Quoting gun rags as and posts on AR15.COM as scientific data. Just laughable. This whole thread is a wash with 357SIG FUD.

[Napalm Bulldog]

I gave Dr.Roberts data as well as his commentary. But that was not enough for any of the armchair commando brigade that "cling" to the idealology that 357SIG is any different than the more popular cartridges of 9MM, .40, or .45. You may think you know more than one of the most respected ballistic scientist in the world. Truth is you don't. So be it. You threw in the idoitic .50BMG comment. The brigade can continue to poision themselves with KOOL-AID all they like. It matters not. Spew the FUD that the 357SIG is some "SUPER CARTRIDGE" all you like. A fool and his money are soon departed it seems.

BTW I could care less how I look to a bunch of clowns living in some fanasty world were their guns and ammo trump all else. As if toting a 357SIG is some kind of EDGE. How misguided can people on gun forums be? Quoting gun rags as and posts on AR15.COM as scientific data. Just laughable. This whole thread is a wash with 357SIG FUD.

I think your mad because secretly you wish you could own a .357 Sig. Also help me out what is Fanasty! It must mean a nasty fantasy! I knew it your in love with the .357 Sig. Admit it! What we have here is another closet convert. Come out it's ok!

[ST5MF]

I think your mad because secretly you wish you could own a .357 Sig. Also help me out what is Fanasty! It must mean a nasty fantasy! I knew it your in love with the .357 Sig. Admit it! What we have here is another closet convert. Come out it's ok!

I have a 357SIG. Never use it. Just sits in my safe. As does my .40SW.
Neither do anything a 9MM won't do; and YOU buy all my 9MM.

Nice try though.

You armchair commandos are horrible at trolling.