Sig vs CZ or similar metal frame gun

[missiontrails]

sig p226 and if you don't go with metal, check out the sig sp2022.

In my book, the 2022 ranks well below the Glock.

[missiontrails]

Non-German Sigs are pretty bad, especially after Cohen came on board. HK's quality is still top-notch, not only that they are still made in Germany where quality actually meant something.

Right... my non-German Navy is a total POS... what was I thinking.

[waddlingweezol]

Right... my non-German Navy is a total POS... what was I thinking.

I can't tell was this sarcastic? Honest question, because I have heard a lot of mixed things about Sig's QC

[missiontrails]

I can't tell was this sarcastic? Honest question, because I have heard a lot of mixed things about Sig's QC

I was being very sarcastic.... not a damn thing wrong with US made Sigs. Fit, finish and performance on all of those I've owned has been fine. For someone to say US ones are "pretty bad" is ludicrous.

[Rsenal7]

As an owner of a Glock and an HK USP .45, I say get the Sig. My reasoning is, I would never buy a fine weapon like an HK and then just throw it around in my truck. That's what Glocks are for, reliability and expendability.

[sffred]

IMHO metal framed pistol I'd personally say CZSP01, or Sigp229 (CZ75 doesn't have a rail, & P226 has to big of a grip circumference)

IMHO in a polymer framed pistol I'd say Glock19, HKUSPC9, VP9, PPQ, and m&p9.

[missiontrails]

Just pick one.....

[QXSOUP]

'nuf said...



I do like HK's. I'd like them a whole hell of a lot more of they were reasonably priced and the mags were a little more available and cheaper.

[BigPimping]

You're kidding right? Glocks are worthy, but not in the same class as the other two.

Serious as a heart attack. The others are super nice. But is there any proof anywhere that they are any more reliable or accurate? More durable or user friendly? HK is a fine brand. It is like Apple though, that you are paying for a brand name and that is fine for those who love bragging rights and designer labels.

[BigPimping]

just skip the bs and get a cz. i have both a sig and a cz, I got the p226 scorpion pretty much because its pure badass, but my cz75b is my truck/fishing/everyday gun. also, i like the different ways you can carry the cz, cocked and locked, da/sa. I have fired about 2000 round thru my sig no malfunctions and about 1500 thru the cz also with no malfunctions. i really like the tight tolerance of the slide to frame fit of the cz, the sig has a little rattle to it if you shake it side to side. also, i really like the heavy all steel frame of the cz, and you have to mention the ergonomics.

I tried a friends Sig226. It was really, really nice........The price however was a bit rich for my tastes. It was extremely well made and felt great.

[customiiguy]

Sig 226ee would be your best bet. Although I have a mk25 I wish it came with the srt

[Barang]

'nuf said...



I do like HK's. I'd like them a whole hell of a lot more of they were reasonably priced and the mags were a little more available and cheaper.

Dang! P239 is what missing from my stable.

[Mayor McRifle]

Why not get the most reliable, best priced, most durable handgun with the most options imaginable? Gaston Glock is waiting to help you out.

Well, he was a genius with curtain rods, but we're talking about handguns here.

[Mayor McRifle]

.... not a damn thing wrong with US made Sigs. Fit, finish and performance on all of those I've owned has been fine. For someone to say US ones are "pretty bad" is ludicrous.

Amen.

[missiontrails]

Serious as a heart attack. The others are super nice. But is there any proof anywhere that they are any more reliable or accurate? More durable or user friendly? HK is a fine brand. It is like Apple though, that you are paying for a brand name and that is fine for those who love bragging rights and designer labels.

Simple fact... part for part, material for material.. HK is a higher quality piece than the Glock, and yes you pay more for that. Accuracy is a null point, both are accurate, but for whatever reason certain people are able to shoot one better than the other. Is the frame of a HK superior to the Glock... hell yes. Are the barrels of the HK's one notch above the Glock... hell yes. Are the parts inside the frame of an HK a notch above s Glock.... hell yes.