Peņa v. Cid (Handgun Roster) **CERT DENIED 6-15-2020**

[taperxz]

While Pena is being re-examined by the lower court, will there be a window to buy off roster stuff or the law is upheld until there is a decision?

Did i miss something? Or isn't Pena sitting in the SCOTUS pocket right now? Where or who said Pena was in any lower court to be re-examined?

[tehDiceman]

I've seen people talk about a roster freedom week. Even if the roster was suspended we would still have one in thirty and a 10 day wait. As with freedom week we all knew it wouldn't last long. I suspect at best you would get one purchase during such a period. So it isn't something you should be saving a ton of cash for it making a long list.

So just keep an eye on your one purchase. I know it feels like a wasted opportunity but I think my roster freedom week purchase would be a Ruger MK IV given the poor choices of 22lr pistols on the roster.

This will also depend on what is in stock. IIRC, a shop "can't" start a DROS without the firearm in hand. I think Turners got busted for this where they'd start the DROS while the firearm was in warehouse and then they had 10 days to get it to the local store for pickup. DOJ said no.

Fact check this info though, it may not be 100% accurate.

Either way, I wouldn't hold my breath for an off roster freedom week, it just doesn't seem plausible. I want to be wrong though, I'd love to get my hands on a Glock 45 for something resembling MSRP.

[kemasa]

I've seen people talk about a roster freedom week. Even if the roster was suspended we would still have one in thirty and a 10 day wait. As with freedom week we all knew it wouldn't last long. I suspect at best you would get one purchase during such a period. So it isn't something you should be saving a ton of cash for it making a long list.

So just keep an eye on your one purchase. I know it feels like a wasted opportunity but I think my roster freedom week purchase would be a Ruger MK IV given the poor choices of 22lr pistols on the roster.

If you have a C&R FFL and CA DOJ COE, then you are exempt from the 1 in 30 even for modern firearms, so in that case you could buy all that you can afford.

[Kraken]

Did i miss something? Or isn't Pena sitting in the SCOTUS pocket right now? Where or who said Pena was in any lower court to be re-examined?

This.

What are you people talking about?

[AdamVIP]

This will also depend on what is in stock. IIRC, a shop "can't" start a DROS without the firearm in hand. I think Turners got busted for this where they'd start the DROS while the firearm was in warehouse and then they had 10 days to get it to the local store for pickup. DOJ said no.

Fact check this info though, it may not be 100% accurate.

Either way, I wouldn't hold my breath for an off roster freedom week, it just doesn't seem plausible. I want to be wrong though, I'd love to get my hands on a Glock 45 for something resembling MSRP.

S&W Model 41s are still roster exempt under the olympic exemption and a great choice for a nice 22lr. I would use a freedom week for a nice target 9mm/45acp or even a CCW option. Maybe a sig P210 or P365. A nice 9mm 1911 would be cool too.

[mit31]

It's a misunderstanding. Wireless said:

"I think Pena will be sent back to the lower courts. It will be the new baseline for wasn’t acceptable. NY case will reaffirm history and tradition test equivalent to true intermediate scrutiny. AWB and carry will continue to be litigated because true scrutiny standards won’t be adopted by SCOTUS."

Cire Raeb was just rolling with Wireless' opinion when he asked:

"While Pena is being re-examined by the lower court, will there be a window to buy off roster stuff or the law is upheld until there is a decision?"

No one has said Pena is CURRENTLY with lower courts. Just that it might end up there.

This.

What are you people talking about?

[taperxz]

No, it will either be denied cert or granted. The only other possibility is reverse and remand if NY is heard and in favor of gun rights.

[Offwidth]

No, it will either be denied cert or granted. The only other possibility is reverse and remand if NY is heard and in favor of gun rights.

Any other way to dispose of it remains on a table. SCOTUS can do whatever they want.

[aBrowningfan]

Any other way to dispose of it remains on a table. SCOTUS can do whatever they want.

Yeah, like the present suspended animation condition. The petition hasn't been denied, nor has it been granted.

[taperxz]

Yeah, like the present suspended animation condition. The petition hasn't been denied, nor has it been granted.

[aBrowningfan]

How is it useful? The roster remains in full force and effect.

Justice delayed is justice denied.

[taperxz]

How is it useful? The roster remains in full force and effect.

Justice delayed is justice denied.

Ya, and the courts work at internet speed.

It didn't get denied for a reason. NY may predicate what happens to Pena. How do you not get this?

[bruss01]

How is it useful? The roster remains in full force and effect.

Justice delayed is justice denied.

I get the impatience but come on... really?

Things of lasting value have to be planned and executed to spec, otherwise they fall apart again at the least challenge or simply crumble with age.

[Paladin]

[Calier]

So what's happening with this case? Are we basically waiting for SCOTUS to say whether or not they will be hearing it?