Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Problems if going below "Starting Load" levels?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Gryff
    I need a LIFE!!
    • May 2006
    • 12693

    Problems if going below "Starting Load" levels?

    I'm trying to put together a .38 Special load for IDPA competition, but all I have is Titegroup powder.

    I'm using Bear Creek bullets, and the Starting Load data Hodgdon's provides for Titegroup with 158gr. lead bullets is:

    3.2 grains for 815fps at 11,500 CUP

    The problem is that my target velocity is 730fps. So, my question is what happens if I use less powder than Hodgdon's recommends as a Starting Load (such as 3.0 grains instead of 3.2)?

    For reference, Hodgdon's states a 3.8 grain max load (15,400 CUP)
    My friends and family disavow all knowledge of my existence, let alone my opinions.
  • #2
    drdarrin@sbcglobal.net
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2011
    • 2219

    You may end up with insufficient pressure to expand the brass and have it seal the chamber from blow back. You typically see that on your brass as burn marks on the outside.

    You could also end up with erratic pressures if there is insufficient powder to prevent flashover. This may be a clumsy explanation but imagine the primer igniting a compressed load. The powder begins burning at one end and continues to burn until all of it is burned. In more or less a linear fashion. Now imagine there is only enough powder to cover the bottom of the cartridge as it lies horizontal and the flash hole is not covered. When the primer fires, it ignites a much higher percentage of the powder causing pressures to rise faster and the remaining powder to burn faster.

    You could also end up with a bullet stuck in the barrel. A very frustrating experience I'm told.

    I would only go below the minimum load data in a book with great caution; the same caution you should use if you choose to exceed their recommendations. Reloading books tend to be a little conservative because of liability issues.
    NRA Life Member
    GOA Life Member
    USMC '71 - '78

    "I am only one; but still I am one. I cannot do everything; but still I can do something; and because I cannot do everything, I will not refuse to do the something that I can do."
    Edward Everett Hale

    Comment

    • #3
      G-forceJunkie
      Calguns Addict
      • Jul 2010
      • 6530

      For such light loads, I really suggest you look into Hodgdon Trailboss. Big cases with small amounts of power are asking for trouble. Trailboss is super bulky and made for light loads in big cases.

      Comment

      • #4
        Eljay
        Veteran Member
        • Oct 2005
        • 4985

        You might check out this thread: http://www.brianenos.com/forums/inde...owtopic=117198

        Comment

        • #5
          Bastard
          • Jul 2009
          • 2209

          are you going off of book data for FPS or have you actually loaded min & shot over a chrono?

          Comment

          • #6
            Gryff
            I need a LIFE!!
            • May 2006
            • 12693

            Originally posted by drdarrin@sbcglobal.net
            You could also end up with erratic pressures if there is insufficient powder to prevent flashover. This may be a clumsy explanation but imagine the primer igniting a compressed load. The powder begins burning at one end and continues to burn until all of it is burned. In more or less a linear fashion. Now imagine there is only enough powder to cover the bottom of the cartridge as it lies horizontal and the flash hole is not covered. When the primer fires, it ignites a much higher percentage of the powder causing pressures to rise faster and the remaining powder to burn faster.
            That would explain a lot. Thanks for the illustration.

            Originally posted by G-forceJunkie
            For such light loads, I really suggest you look into Hodgdon Trailboss. Big cases with small amounts of power are asking for trouble. Trailboss is super bulky and made for light loads in big cases.
            As I said, all I have is Titegroup.

            Originally posted by Bastard
            are you going off of book data for FPS or have you actually loaded min & shot over a chrono?
            Data is from Hodgdon's website. I'm trying to determine a range of loads that I will take up to the range and chrono myself to get real-world results. I just didn't know what were the negative issues with going too low.
            My friends and family disavow all knowledge of my existence, let alone my opinions.

            Comment

            • #7
              tiller
              Senior Member
              • Jun 2011
              • 794

              Originally posted by G-forceJunkie
              For such light loads, I really suggest you look into Hodgdon Trailboss. Big cases with small amounts of power are asking for trouble. Trailboss is super bulky and made for light loads in big cases.
              Hodgdon trail boss?? IMR makes trail boss
              .223 & .308 brass processing

              Comment

              • #8
                SoCal326
                Senior Member
                • Oct 2011
                • 1098

                I was doing some load devolupment in .243 Win a while back and shooting over a chrono. I found that my hottest loads were the ones with the least powder in them. The above explination accounts for my results. Not sure if people see the same thing in pistol though

                Comment

                • #9
                  checkenbach
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 2008
                  • 1469

                  I used 3.5 grains of Titegroup with Missouri Bullet Co. 158 grn LRN and got 130 power factor out of a 686 SSR, I also tried 3.0 grains of Titegroup with Extreme 158 grn RNFP copper plated bullets and got 95 power factor, again out of my 686 SSR. I used 3.2 grains of American Select with Missouri Bullet Co. 158 grn LRN to get 123 power factor, then finally settled for 3.5 grains of TrailBoss to get 120 power factor with Berry's 158 grain RN copper plated. Missouri Bullet Co. cast bullets leaded up my 686 SSR quite badly, possibly from hard bullets( I was #11 and # 15 Cowboy bullets), or the newer style EDM rifling. i switched to copper plated and have had no issues.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    gemini1
                    Senior Member
                    • Nov 2008
                    • 2230

                    Originally posted by drdarrin@sbcglobal.net
                    You may end up with insufficient pressure to expand the brass and have it seal the chamber from blow back. You typically see that on your brass as burn marks on the outside.

                    You could also end up with erratic pressures if there is insufficient powder to prevent flashover. This may be a clumsy explanation but imagine the primer igniting a compressed load. The powder begins burning at one end and continues to burn until all of it is burned. In more or less a linear fashion. Now imagine there is only enough powder to cover the bottom of the cartridge as it lies horizontal and the flash hole is not covered. When the primer fires, it ignites a much higher percentage of the powder causing pressures to rise faster and the remaining powder to burn faster.

                    You could also end up with a bullet stuck in the barrel. A very frustrating experience I'm told.

                    I would only go below the minimum load data in a book with great caution; the same caution you should use if you choose to exceed their recommendations. Reloading books tend to be a little conservative because of liability issues.
                    Can you stuff the case with paper or cotton to let the powder to cover the bottom/flash hole area?

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Bastard
                      • Jul 2009
                      • 2209

                      Originally posted by checkenbach
                      I used 3.5 grains of Titegroup with Missouri Bullet Co. 158 grn LRN and got 130 power factor out of a 686 SSR, I also tried 3.0 grains of Titegroup with Extreme 158 grn RNFP copper plated bullets and got 95 power factor, again out of my 686 SSR. I used 3.2 grains of American Select with Missouri Bullet Co. 158 grn LRN to get 123 power factor, then finally settled for 3.5 grains of TrailBoss to get 120 power factor with Berry's 158 grain RN copper plated. Missouri Bullet Co. cast bullets leaded up my 686 SSR quite badly, possibly from hard bullets( I was #11 and # 15 Cowboy bullets), or the newer style EDM rifling. i switched to copper plated and have had no issues.

                      if I had to venture a guess; it was not the hard cast leading your barrel as much as it the "custom barrel" on the SSR. I am basing this guess on the fact that that all the MBC that you listed were .358 and the Berrys were .357.... but that would just be a guess, that you didn't ask for.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        stilly
                        I need a LIFE!!
                        • Jul 2009
                        • 10685

                        Originally posted by drdarrin@sbcglobal.net
                        You may end up with insufficient pressure to expand the brass and have it seal the chamber from blow back. You typically see that on your brass as burn marks on the outside.
                        ...
                        I tried like 4gr or something like that of Lil Gun in 44 mag. It scorched the hell outta all mah brass. I did not like it, now I need to revisit it though to add more of it to the load.
                        7 Billion people on the planet. They aint ALL gonna astronauts. Some will get hit by trains...

                        Need GOOD SS pins to clean your brass? Try the new and improved model...



                        And remember- 99.9% of the lawyers ruin it for the other .1%...

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          G-forceJunkie
                          Calguns Addict
                          • Jul 2010
                          • 6530

                          Originally posted by tiller
                          Hodgdon trail boss?? IMR makes trail boss
                          Sorta. Hodgdon owns IMR. All the load data put out for Trailboss is put out by Hodgdon and on the Hodgdon website. But the label on the bottle does say IMR so you are correct there.

                          Originally posted by Gryff
                          .



                          As I said, all I have is Titegroup.
                          So, you have the wrong powder for the job according to the data and your desired effects. What suggestion are you looking for that can change that? Nothing other than using a different powder, that is all I suggested.
                          Last edited by G-forceJunkie; 10-21-2013, 1:00 AM.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            ar15barrels
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • Jan 2006
                            • 57199

                            Originally posted by G-forceJunkie
                            So, you have the wrong powder for the job according to the data and your desired effects. What suggestion are you looking for that can change that? Nothing other than using a different powder, that is all I suggested.
                            Wave your magic wand and change the bulk density of his titegroup by a factor of 4x.
                            Randall Rausch

                            AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
                            Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
                            Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
                            Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
                            Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              Germz
                              Vendor/Retailer
                              • Apr 2013
                              • 4691

                              try filling the rest of the case with cotton...or flour.


                              don't do that. its a joke.
                              Retired Account

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1