Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Problems if going below "Starting Load" levels?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    drdarrin@sbcglobal.net
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2011
    • 2219

    Originally posted by gemini1
    Can you stuff the case with paper or cotton to let the powder to cover the bottom/flash hole area?
    People do with satisfactory results. However, OP is shooting IDPA and I'd imagine that requires quite a few rounds. If so that would be a real PITA.
    NRA Life Member
    GOA Life Member
    USMC '71 - '78

    "I am only one; but still I am one. I cannot do everything; but still I can do something; and because I cannot do everything, I will not refuse to do the something that I can do."
    Edward Everett Hale

    Comment

    • #17
      Gryff
      I need a LIFE!!
      • May 2006
      • 12693

      Originally posted by drdarrin@sbcglobal.net
      People do with satisfactory results. However, OP is shooting IDPA and I'd imagine that requires quite a few rounds. If so that would be a real PITA.
      Very true. I'll be loading 500+ rounds at a time.
      My friends and family disavow all knowledge of my existence, let alone my opinions.

      Comment

      • #18
        rsrocket1
        Veteran Member
        • Feb 2010
        • 2774

        Why don't you try Red Dot, Clays, Titewad, AA#2 or Clay Dot?

        Oh yeah, because you said you were limited to Titegroup ONLY!

        First of all, did you chrony the 3.2g load? The test barrels used by those collecting data are probably not the same setup as what's in your gun with the gap between the cylinder and barrel, not the same length and not at the same temperature. That could easily account for a 10% difference (80 fps).

        When working down a load, you shoot and down load until you reach your goal or stick a bullet. Believe me, you will not stick a bullet with 3.0g Titegroup. The worst that will happen is inconsistent velocities depending on whether you tilt the gun up before each shot or tilt it down between each shot. Titegroup is easy enough to ignite that you won't end up with a squib and unlit flakes spewing out of the barrel.

        Quickload says 3.3g Titegroup will shoot 814 fps out of a 6" barrel. Do you have a 6" barrel?
        If you have a 4" barrel, the MV is closer to 740 fps. If your entry into the competition is based on MV and you assume your load is above minimum and you don't meet it, not only do you go home, you also have to disassemble a lot of rounds.

        Test your loads with barrel tilted up first, down first and shaken up. Do this before loading 500+ rounds at a time or you may be pulling 500+ rounds.

        Comment

        • #19
          CK_32
          I need a LIFE!!
          • Sep 2010
          • 14369

          Possible squib.

          But more common probably just poor results or FPS/Pressures.


          Maybe invest in some factory ammo and eat the extra bill if this is for a comp. I feel like a under powered load is just a waste of supplies and time.
          For Sale: AR500 Lvl III+ ASC Armor

          What's Your Caliber??


          My Youtube channel

          Comment

          • #20
            Gryff
            I need a LIFE!!
            • May 2006
            • 12693

            Originally posted by rsrocket1
            First of all, did you chrony the 3.2g load? The test barrels used by those collecting data are probably not the same setup as what's in your gun with the gap between the cylinder and barrel, not the same length and not at the same temperature. That could easily account for a 10% difference (80 fps).
            I was thinking about this. Looking at the Hodgdon page, I found that they tested with a 7.7" barrel (although I don't know if this is a pressure barrel or an actual revolver). So I figure that velocities out of a 4" S&W 686 are going to come in significantly below their posted velocities. That made me realize right away (but after I started this thread) that their Starting Load is probably going to be close (or even below) what I need.

            Originally posted by rsrocket1
            When working down a load, you shoot and down load until you reach your goal or stick a bullet. Believe me, you will not stick a bullet with 3.0g Titegroup. The worst that will happen is inconsistent velocities depending on whether you tilt the gun up before each shot or tilt it down between each shot. Titegroup is easy enough to ignite that you won't end up with a squib and unlit flakes spewing out of the barrel.
            My concern is if there was a physical danger with going beneath the posted Starting Load. Going above the Max Load is obvious about the dangers, but I don't know what I don't know about reloading yet. So I thought I would ask before I tried it.

            Originally posted by rsrocket1
            Do this before loading 500+ rounds at a time or you may be pulling 500+ rounds.
            Definitely. I'm loading 6 rounds of each powder level, broken into 1/10th grain increments. I'll chrono them all next week, but now I'm thinking that I need to try all the way up to 3.7 grains rather than worrying about the lower end of the scale.

            Once I have the load worked out and proven in competition, then I'll do 500-round loading runs. Until then, I will load only what I need for each match.
            Last edited by Gryff; 10-21-2013, 12:39 PM.
            My friends and family disavow all knowledge of my existence, let alone my opinions.

            Comment

            • #21
              Gryff
              I need a LIFE!!
              • May 2006
              • 12693

              Originally posted by CK_32
              Maybe invest in some factory ammo and eat the extra bill if this is for a comp. I feel like a under powered load is just a waste of supplies and time.
              That's actually the problem. I'm finding that most factory .38 Special doesn't make the pathetic 105,000 power factor (bullet weight x velocity) required by IDPA. I shot a big match recently, and was discouraged to find that my American Eagle 130gr. .38 Special only made 97,000 power factor (747fps) over the chrono. This replicated my personal findings, and I also found similar results from other factory .38.

              Pretty pathetic velocity levels, and makes me wonder if the ammo manufacturers are cutting powder levels to save on materials, but that is another discussion. For now, I don't want to have to pay for +P defensive loads to shoot in competition, so I am loading up my own before I shoot another big match in November.
              My friends and family disavow all knowledge of my existence, let alone my opinions.

              Comment

              • #22
                CK_32
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Sep 2010
                • 14369

                Huh didn't know that. Something I'll have to look into. I've always felt factory plinking ammo in 38/357 was always super light and soft to shoot never thought to realize the FPS was cut with it. Makes sence tho.

                Focus on your numbers then not the grain weight just stay with in listed and you should be fine.

                GL in your next match BTW. Hope you get your load sorted by then.
                For Sale: AR500 Lvl III+ ASC Armor

                What's Your Caliber??


                My Youtube channel

                Comment

                • #23
                  JagerDog
                  I need a LIFE!!
                  • May 2011
                  • 15910

                  Titegroup isn't position dependent. Millions upon millions of suitable performance rounds (including high stakes competition) have been loaded with 2.8g Bullseye. The only thing I'd be cautious of a squib lodged in the barrel.

                  Per Hodgdon:

                  TITEGROUP is a spherical propellant that was designed for accuracy. Because of the unique design, this powder provides flawless ignition with all types of primers including the lead-free versions. Unlike pistol powders of the past, powder position in large cases (45 Colt, 357 Magnum and others) has virtually no effect on velocity and performance. Cowboy Action, Bullseye and Combat Shooters should love this one! TITEGROUP has it all, low charge weight, clean burning, mild muzzle report and superb, uniform ballistics.
                  Last edited by JagerDog; 10-21-2013, 1:28 PM.
                  Palestine is a fake country

                  No Mas Hamas



                  #Blackolivesmatter

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    Swagman00
                    Veteran Member
                    • Apr 2012
                    • 4149

                    Originally posted by G-forceJunkie
                    For such light loads, I really suggest you look into Hodgdon Trailboss. Big cases with small amounts of power are asking for trouble. Trailboss is super bulky and made for light loads in big cases.
                    This x100 (Even though Hodgdon bought out IMR...)

                    Trailboss is unequaled in .38 Special.

                    IMHO, it's unequaled in any revolver round with lead.

                    You'll never DC, you'll never hurt yourself with recoil, and you'll never forget what you're using if you forget to label it (outside of a case of course).

                    The only downside is price, but it's worth every penny.

                    I've filled everything from .32 S&W Long to S&W 500 with the stuff. The result: Small guns shoot like pellet guns, large guns shoot like small guns.
                    Anyway...here's a dearth of reasoning to ponder: http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Guns

                    Originally posted by movie zombie
                    and you guys wonder why women are fed up with bad behavior?!

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      sargenv
                      Veteran Member
                      • Oct 2005
                      • 4620

                      The main problem with Titegroup is the high nitro content.. if you shoot a LOT of it in a hurry, it will heat up your gun faster than just about any other powder.. This doesn't matter so much to the casual target shooter.. but action shooters may burn up to 40 rounds of it in a common long stage and the barrel will be quite hot to the touch after a run with Titegroup.. Other lower nitro powders will not heat the barrel up like it..

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        J-cat
                        Calguns Addict
                        • May 2005
                        • 6626

                        Do not use any fillers over TG.

                        Hodgdon's test barrel is a lot faster than your typical revolver. You should be looking at accuracy first, then velocity.

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          ar15barrels
                          I need a LIFE!!
                          • Jan 2006
                          • 57202

                          Originally posted by rsrocket1
                          The test barrels used by those collecting data are probably not the same setup as what's in your gun with the gap between the cylinder and barrel, not the same length and not at the same temperature.
                          Actually, revolver cartridge test barrels usually have a separate chamber, cylinder gap and a forcing cone to simulate actual firing in a real revolver.
                          They develop load data in similar conditions to how they expect it to be used in the real world.
                          Randall Rausch

                          AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
                          Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
                          Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
                          Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
                          Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            ar15barrels
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • Jan 2006
                            • 57202

                            Originally posted by Gryff
                            all I have is Titegroup powder.
                            Once you buy some trailboss, you won't have the problem of only having titegroup...
                            Randall Rausch

                            AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
                            Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
                            Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
                            Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
                            Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              rsrocket1
                              Veteran Member
                              • Feb 2010
                              • 2774

                              Originally posted by ar15barrels
                              Actually, revolver cartridge test barrels usually have a separate chamber, cylinder gap and a forcing cone to simulate actual firing in a real revolver.
                              They develop load data in similar conditions to how they expect it to be used in the real world.
                              I didn't know that. Thanks for the enlightenment.

                              The thing that bothers me is that many times, the load data do not include the test conditions. Some do and I am grateful, but there can be a noticable difference between the MV from a 6" barrel and a 4" barrel.

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                bruceflinch
                                I need a LIFE!!
                                • Jan 2006
                                • 40180

                                Originally posted by Gryff
                                Very true. I'll be loading 500+ rounds at a time.
                                Once you shoot your test loads, you may find the bottom or near bottom of the starting loads will work. Of the loads for Unique, I'm below Midscale with Bear Creek & my 686-4".

                                Since you are loading up a bunch of test loads, you may find the slowest does not provide the accuracy or recoil you expect. YMMV. IME, the difference in 1/10th grain increments is hardly noticeable in terms of recoil. 3/10th, yes.

                                Good Luck!
                                Actually I only started collecting Milsurps 3 years ago. I think I might own about 24...They're cheaper than guns that will most likely never get the opportunity to kill somebody...

                                I belong to the group that uses firearms, and knows which bathroom to use.

                                Tis better to have Trolled & lost, Than to never have Trolled, at all.

                                Secret Club Member?.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1