Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Please Help--Quick Straw Purchase Question

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    Tripper
    Calguns Addict
    • Jan 2011
    • 7628

    there is nothing against the law about a dad buying a gift for his son
    I'm pretty sure I've seen that in writing somewhere even
    call DOJ and ask them
    I'll bet a dollar they would say its fine
    WTB NAA Belt Buckle
    MILITARY STRETCHER/RADIATION DETECTION KIT

    Comment

    • #17
      Tripper
      Calguns Addict
      • Jan 2011
      • 7628

      wait, is gambling legal
      WTB NAA Belt Buckle
      MILITARY STRETCHER/RADIATION DETECTION KIT

      Comment

      • #18
        SocomM4
        Senior Member
        • Oct 2010
        • 2187

        Originally posted by fiddletown
        I won't argue with that. It makes life difficult, and it's hard to understand. But we're stuck with the law as it is unless we can get things changed.

        Common sense? Anything like Diane Feinstein's common sense gun control? Common sense isn't necessarily all that reliable.
        You sound Like a supporter, you tell me. How is it illegal for a dad to buy his son a pistol as a gift.

        You sure pushy for someone who started your whole argument on "looks like".
        Last edited by SocomM4; 04-20-2012, 11:49 PM.
        Originally posted by TeddyBallgame
        maybe I'm wrong, but, if a $50.00 investment can help me a bit, i'll just have to go a day without the hookers and blow to cover it
        Originally posted by ir0nclash86
        I would wipe it off for the simple fact of not wanting to get sprayed in the face with it during the first few rounds.
        Originally posted by Ride Madone
        It does not matter.An AR is the very best and safest weapon to use for home defence.

        Comment

        • #19
          d4v0s
          Senior Member
          • Aug 2010
          • 1661

          Originally posted by maidendeth13
          Can I have my dad purchase this for me, wait his 10 days pick up the gun, and then transfer it between him and myself next time he visits me up here?
          NOT A STRAW PURCHASE! As long as its transferred legally this would not be a straw purchase in any way shape or form.
          Originally posted by Franklincollector
          It was administered with a toothpick and placed on a street taco.

          Comment

          • #20
            fiddletown
            Veteran Member
            • Jun 2007
            • 4928

            Originally posted by SocomM4
            You sound Like a supporter, you tell me. How is it illegal for a dad to buy his son a pistol as a gift.
            Your common sense tell you that? Anyway, since I've concluded that your opinion is worthless, I'm not concerned about your insult.

            Originally posted by SocomM4
            ...How is it illegal for a dad to buy his son a pistol as a gift.
            As I've stated several times, buying a gun as a gift is legal. What you don't understand is how to distinguish between buying a gift, in which case the giver is the actual purchaser, and which is legal, and buying gun on someone's behalf, in which case the buyer is not the actual purchaser, and which is not legal.

            If dad buys son the gun with his own money, that looks like a gift. If son arranges with dad to buy the gun for him and either puts up the money or reimburses dad, that no longer looks like a gift, because a gift, by definition, is (merriam-webster.com):
            ...something voluntarily transferred by one person to another without compensation...

            Originally posted by d4v0s
            NOT A STRAW PURCHASE! As long as its transferred legally this would not be a straw purchase in any way shape or form.
            Not true at all. See post 3 for what the ATF says about it.
            "It is long been a principle of ours that one is no more armed because he has possession of a firearm than he is a musician because he owns a piano. There is no point in having a gun if you are not capable of using it skillfully." -- Jeff Cooper

            Comment

            • #21
              DJ Skillz
              Senior Member
              • Mar 2008
              • 1255

              Dad bought a handgun. Dad decided he didn't like said handgun. Dad transfers said handgun to son. I see no problem here.

              Comment

              • #22
                d4v0s
                Senior Member
                • Aug 2010
                • 1661

                Originally posted by fiddletown
                Not true at all. See post 3 for what the ATF says about it.
                Saw the post, does not in anyway relate to this issue.

                Here is another fun one for you. Your dad can simply send in a change of ownership (like $15 bucks) and transfer the gun up or down the family tree. So grandpa to dad, dad to son, son to his sons and up the chain as well.

                Buying a gun legally, then selling it legally is not a straw purchase.

                you may be a lawyer, but I stayed at a holiday inn express last night
                Originally posted by Franklincollector
                It was administered with a toothpick and placed on a street taco.

                Comment

                • #23
                  Quiet
                  retired Goon
                  • Mar 2007
                  • 30242

                  Originally posted by fiddletown
                  Your common sense tell you that? Anyway, since I've concluded that your opinion is worthless, I'm not concerned about your insult.

                  As I've stated several times, buying a gun as a gift is legal. What you don't understand is how to distinguish between buying a gift, in which case the giver is the actual purchaser, and which is legal, and buying gun on someone's behalf, in which case the buyer is not the actual purchaser, and which is not legal.

                  If dad buys son the gun with his own money, that looks like a gift. If son arranges with dad to buy the gun for him and either puts up the money or reimburses dad, that no longer looks like a gift, because a gift, by definition, is (merriam-webster.com):
                  Not true at all. See post 3 for what the ATF says about it.



                  Bottom Line:
                  As long as the dad buys the firearm with his own money and gifts the firearm to his son and the son reports the gift transfer to CA DOJ, it's legal.
                  If the son gives his dad money for the firearm or reimburses his dad for the firearm, then it's not legal because it is considered a straw purchase.
                  sigpic

                  "If someone has a gun and is trying to kill you, it would be reasonable to shoot back with your own gun." - Dalai Lama (Seattle Times, 05-15-2001).

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    Ron-Solo
                    In Memoriam
                    • Jan 2009
                    • 8581

                    I have bought several firearms with the specific intent to make them a GIFT to my children. There is nothing illegal about this. Each time they were transferred to my children using the OpLaw/Intrafamilial transfer form and paying DOJ a fee of $19. Each time they received a letter from DOJ indicating the transfer completion.

                    One good year, Santa gave my all three of my kids guns.

                    Daughter got an LC9 and an AR tht way, oldest son got an LCP, Yugo 59/66 and an LC9, youngest son got a Glock 19 and a Ruger MKIII. My gift ideas came about from range trips with them and which guns of mine that they really liked.

                    My three grandkids have all received Crickett rifles and Ruger 10/22's. One of each in pink.

                    It is perfectly legal for dad to buy this gun, then give it to his son as a gift. Both will need a Handgun Safety Certificate.
                    LASD Retired
                    1978-2011

                    NRA Life Member
                    CRPA Life Member
                    NRA Rifle Instructor
                    NRA Shotgun Instructor
                    NRA Range Safety Officer
                    DOJ Certified Instructor

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      fiddletown
                      Veteran Member
                      • Jun 2007
                      • 4928

                      Originally posted by d4v0s
                      Saw the post, does not in anyway relate to this issue....
                      It does, but I guess you just can't understand it.

                      Originally posted by d4v0s
                      ...Here is another fun one for you. Your dad can simply send in a change of ownership (like $15 bucks) and transfer the gun up or down the family tree. So grandpa to dad, dad to son, son to his sons and up the chain as well....
                      That's all fine as a matter of state law, but it doesn't address the federal law issue that arises when the 4473 is filled out for the initial acquisition.

                      Originally posted by d4v0s
                      ...Buying a gun legally, then selling it legally is not a straw purchase...
                      No, but falsely claiming on the 4473 to be the actual buyer is not buying a gun legally. It's an illegal straw purchase.

                      A gift is perfectly legal. What's illegal is to buy a gun on behalf of someone else, as his agent or proxy. Whether or not one has engaged in the illegal transaction will be a question of fact and depend on all the exact circumstances.

                      Originally posted by d4v0s
                      ...you may be a lawyer, but I stayed at a holiday inn express last night
                      Yes I'm a lawyer. But you've just proved that you won't learning anything about the law staying at a Holiday Inn.

                      Originally posted by Quiet
                      ....Bottom Line:
                      As long as the dad buys the firearm with his own money and gifts the firearm to his son and the son reports the gift transfer to CA DOJ, it's legal.
                      If the son gives his dad money for the firearm or reimburses his dad for the firearm, then it's not legal because it is considered a straw purchase.
                      Agreed. That is the bottom line.

                      Originally posted by Ron-Solo
                      ...It is perfectly legal for dad to buy this gun, then give it to his son as a gift. Both will need a Handgun Safety Certificate.
                      I agree completely. The issue is distinguishing between a bona fide gift, which is legal, and buying the gun on someone's behalf, as his agent or proxy, which is not legal.

                      If X arranges with Y to buy a gun for him [X] and either puts up the money or reimburses Y, X and Y will probably not be believed by a federal prosecutor/grand jury/judge/jury if they claim the gun was gift, because a gift, by definition, is (merriam-webster.com):
                      ...something voluntarily transferred by one person to another without compensation...
                      "It is long been a principle of ours that one is no more armed because he has possession of a firearm than he is a musician because he owns a piano. There is no point in having a gun if you are not capable of using it skillfully." -- Jeff Cooper

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        SocomM4
                        Senior Member
                        • Oct 2010
                        • 2187

                        Originally posted by fiddletown
                        Your common sense tell you that? Anyway, since I've concluded that your opinion is worthless, I'm not concerned about your insult.

                        As I've stated several times, buying a gun as a gift is legal. What you don't understand is how to distinguish between buying a gift, in which case the giver is the actual purchaser, and which is legal, and buying gun on someone's behalf, in which case the buyer is not the actual purchaser, and which is not legal.

                        If dad buys son the gun with his own money, that looks like a gift. If son arranges with dad to buy the gun for him and either puts up the money or reimburses dad, that no longer looks like a gift, because a gift, by definition, is (merriam-webster.com):
                        Not true at all. See post 3 for what the ATF says about it.
                        When did I say I didnt know the diff?? Are you high? What I said was a gift is legal , same thing everyone else has said, you included. So who are you running your fingers at dude ? Who are you ?See post 8 . Your beating a dead horse . I'm aware if he repays it's not legal under the letter of the law. Got it. Had it.
                        Last edited by SocomM4; 04-21-2012, 1:02 AM.
                        Originally posted by TeddyBallgame
                        maybe I'm wrong, but, if a $50.00 investment can help me a bit, i'll just have to go a day without the hookers and blow to cover it
                        Originally posted by ir0nclash86
                        I would wipe it off for the simple fact of not wanting to get sprayed in the face with it during the first few rounds.
                        Originally posted by Ride Madone
                        It does not matter.An AR is the very best and safest weapon to use for home defence.

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          Librarian
                          Admin and Poltergeist
                          CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                          • Oct 2005
                          • 44697

                          This is at least the second thread where people are getting bent out of shape over a discussion of 'straw purchase'.

                          First item: this is Federal law we are talking about. Please stop trying to apply ordinary logic to the situation - it works no better than trying that with California law. These BATF things are all malum prohibitum, 'bad because we say so', and it is impossible to reason to the conclusion that one of these acts might be illegal.

                          Second item: the issue is lying on the Federal paperwork, the 4473, about who is actually the purchaser.

                          Here's how that works.

                          You can buy me a gift.

                          You fill out the paperwork, and properly identify yourself as the buyer. You take your money, buy the gun, and later transfer the gun to me, following all applicable state and Federal laws. Happy Birthday, Merry Christmas!

                          That's all fine.

                          However, if I give you the money, and say to you 'please buy gun X for me', I am the buyer, not you.

                          If I give you the money, you are not buying the gun, I am. It does not matter that you are the one who goes to the store and fills out the paperwork, any more than if I give you money for beer and a pizza, and it doesn't matter if I give you the money before or after the purchase.

                          The act of transferring valuable consideration for a good is a commercial transaction, and anyone can do that on behalf of anyone else (though not always legally); the question that concerns BATF is who pays and who receives the benefit - THAT's the buyer.

                          Most of the time the person engaging in the transaction and who supplies the money and who benefits from the newly acquired good is the same person - but it could be as many as three - financier, purchase-processor, beneficiary (e.g. 'Son, here is $5 - go buy your mother a card for Mother's day': father is financier, son is purchase-processor, mother is beneficiary)

                          My money, I'm the buyer. Your money, you're the buyer.

                          If you would mark the 4473 that you are not the actual buyer, the FFL will cancel the sale.

                          If you would mark the 4473 and say you are the actual buyer, and in fact you would be using my money, or you would expect to be reimbursed by me for that purchase, and the gun is eventually going to me or someone not you, you would have lied - and that's the crime.

                          The BATF via the 4473 expects, and enforces, that all three possible roles (again, financier, purchase-processor, beneficiary) are one and the same person. When more than one person fills these roles, BATF calls it a straw purchase.
                          Last edited by Librarian; 04-21-2012, 2:30 AM.
                          ARCHIVED Calguns Foundation Wiki here: http://web.archive.org/web/201908310...itle=Main_Page

                          Frozen in 2015, it is falling out of date and I can no longer edit the content. But much of it is still good!

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            KrazL
                            Junior Member
                            • Apr 2012
                            • 32

                            Sorry to bulge in your thread post, but I have a somewhat similar question about the "straw purchase".
                            - If my brother buys a stripped lower, and I (18), not being old enough to purchase one, build a long rifle around it (living in the same house blah blah), would the rifle still be considered his?
                            > If so, is it possible for him to 'gift' or transfer it to me?(with the required paperwork(if there is any)), or is sibling to sibling illegal? If it IS legal, how much would paperwork cost?

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              Quiet
                              retired Goon
                              • Mar 2007
                              • 30242

                              Originally posted by KrazL
                              Sorry to bulge in your thread post, but I have a somewhat similar question about the "straw purchase".
                              - If my brother buys a stripped lower, and I (18), not being old enough to purchase one, build a long rifle around it (living in the same house blah blah), would the rifle still be considered his?
                              > If so, is it possible for him to 'gift' or transfer it to me?(with the required paperwork(if there is any)), or is sibling to sibling illegal? If it IS legal, how much would paperwork cost?
                              If you built the reciever into a rifle, your brother is still the owner.

                              Intra-familial gift only works vertically (grandparent - parent -child - grandchild).
                              So, your brother can not gift the firearm by just giving it to you.
                              In order to be a legal transfer, your brother & you must PPT it (transfered through a CA FFL dealer).
                              However, Federal laws prohibits a FFL dealer in transfering a firearm that is not a rifle or shotgun to a person under the age of 21.

                              What this all means...
                              Your brother using his own money can purchase a receiver.
                              He then uses his own money to buy parts, builds the reciever into a rifle.
                              After it's built into a rifle, you & your brother goto a CA FFL dealer and PPT it (you do 4473/DROS + 10 day wait).
                              At no time can you pay for it or reimburse him for the firearm, he must pay for it using his own money.
                              sigpic

                              "If someone has a gun and is trying to kill you, it would be reasonable to shoot back with your own gun." - Dalai Lama (Seattle Times, 05-15-2001).

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                roushstage2
                                Veteran Member
                                • Aug 2011
                                • 2782

                                1. Yes, unless you do a PPT.
                                2. Family transfers work between parent and child or grandparent and grandchild. It doesn't work laterally (wife and husband, brother and sister).

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1