Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Timney vs. Triggertech / Opinions?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    yacko
    Senior Member
    • Mar 2019
    • 631

    Originally posted by FourT6and2
    If I were forced to choose between those exact two... I'd choose a TriggerTech Diamond.

    That said, I have one issue with the Diamond. It has zero over-travel. The trigger breaks and your finger hits a wall. I don't like that because I think dwell time matters. And if you hit that wall before the bullet has left the barrel, it can cause problems. So I actually prefer to have some mild over-travel or "creep" after the trigger breaks.

    I've had a few Timney triggers, Jewell, Bix-n-Andy, and TriggerTech. I prefer the Jewell. I've been using 'em for about 7-8 years without any issues.

    I would like to try the newer Bix-n-Andy Tac Sport Pro though.
    Problem with a lot of those triggers, is they cant handle dust and dirt.

    at windy ranges with a lot of sand and dirt, jewells are the first to lock up.

    It can happen to any of the brands you listed. But is less likely to happen with the triggertech because of the roller in it.

    I think that is the main reason why PRS and NRL shooters went to them so quickly. Ive seen matches where 3 or 4 triggers went down in the span of a 2 day match.

    Comment

    • #17
      sigstroker
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Jan 2009
      • 19993

      I thought Triggertechs were sealed. That was something that I've seen mentioned by PRS people.

      Comment

      • #18
        FourT6and2
        Senior Member
        • Dec 2012
        • 1928

        Originally posted by yacko
        Problem with a lot of those triggers, is they cant handle dust and dirt.

        at windy ranges with a lot of sand and dirt, jewells are the first to lock up.

        It can happen to any of the brands you listed. But is less likely to happen with the triggertech because of the roller in it.

        I think that is the main reason why PRS and NRL shooters went to them so quickly. Ive seen matches where 3 or 4 triggers went down in the span of a 2 day match.
        I know it can happen. But I've never personally experienced it. I guess I don't shoot in extreme conditions. If I knew I needed a rig that could handle that kind of abuse, I would have a "beater" rifle with a good barrel and the rest of the components (stock/chassis, action, trigger, bottom metal, etc.) would be chosen for reliability instead of accuracy/precision. TriggerTech is probably more reliable than Jewell. I love how the TT breaks. But I wish you could dial in some over travel (which you can't). Bix-n-Andy can I think. Might be a good alternative.
        Last edited by FourT6and2; 09-14-2022, 6:55 PM.

        Comment

        • #19
          yacko
          Senior Member
          • Mar 2019
          • 631

          Originally posted by FourT6and2
          I know it can happen. But I've never personally experienced it. I guess I don't shoot in extreme conditions. If I knew I needed a rig that could handle that kind of abuse, I would have a "beater" rifle with a good barrel and the rest of the components (stock/chassis, action, trigger, bottom metal, etc.) would be chosen for reliability instead of accuracy/precision. TriggerTech is probably more reliable than Jewell. I love how the TT breaks. But I wish you could dial in some over travel (which you can't). Bix-n-Andy can I think. Might be a good alternative.
          mmmmmmkay.........

          So you spend a couple hundred on entry fees, several hundred on travel and hotel/food. Couple hundred on ammo

          Go to a match for PRS or NRL and take a beater rifle with you. Not your $6k-10k purpose built comp gun.... that can handle the dust and dirt if you dont run a jewell or other 'sensitive to dirt' trigger.

          Makes sense.... if your purpose built comp gun is actually just a safe queen. and dont shoot it in competition.

          Look at your other thread. the 6.5cm thread. The target pics from 'thegiff'- that rifle is being built up as a prs/nrl rifle- it's a JJRock action (cheaper than many) with a Bartlein 6.5 cm barrel in a chassis. Dont know what trigger or scope he put on it though. Still.. about $5k+ depending on the scope/mount/chassis/trigger.
          Last edited by yacko; 09-15-2022, 5:58 PM.

          Comment

          • #20
            jimmykan
            Veteran Member
            • Jan 2008
            • 3105

            Originally posted by NYT
            trigger tech all day. there is a reason they dominate in popularity in prs matches.
            Because shooters just copy each other, especially whatever the top 10 guys are running, even if that particular piece of kit or technique has little to nothing to do with the success.

            For example: slapping of the trigger and free recoiling the rifle are popular PRS things to do now.

            Comment

            • #21
              sigstroker
              I need a LIFE!!
              • Jan 2009
              • 19993

              Slapping a 1 pound trigger isn't exactly going to throw it off target. IPSC guys have been slapping triggers for decades. I took a class from an IPSC world champion circa 1993 where he taught us to slap the trigger.

              I've also read article on PRS gear bags, and more than one included a spare trigger. Triggers go down enough that people pack spares.

              Comment

              • #22
                FourT6and2
                Senior Member
                • Dec 2012
                • 1928

                Originally posted by yacko
                mmmmmmkay.........

                So you spend a couple hundred on entry fees, several hundred on travel and hotel/food. Couple hundred on ammo

                Go to a match for PRS or NRL and take a beater rifle with you. Not your $6k-10k purpose built comp gun.... that can handle the dust and dirt if you dont run a jewell or other 'sensitive to dirt' trigger.

                Makes sense.... if your purpose built comp gun is actually just a safe queen. and dont shoot it in competition.

                Look at your other thread. the 6.5cm thread. The target pics from 'thegiff'- that rifle is being built up as a prs/nrl rifle- it's a JJRock action (cheaper than many) with a Bartlein 6.5 cm barrel in a chassis. Dont know what trigger or scope he put on it though. Still.. about $5k+ depending on the scope/mount/chassis/trigger.
                When I say "beater" I don't mean cheap.

                Comment

                • #23
                  thegiff
                  Member
                  • Aug 2008
                  • 364

                  I take a spare trigger with me, saved me at a match. My brand new Timney Calvin Elite went down at its first match, couldn’t be revived, jumped to my Huber. I keep a trigger, punch and extra pins in my pack at 2 day matches, I’ve seen maybe a dozen triggers go down with Jewels being the most prevalent, then stock Remington turned down too low, then the Calvin Elite. Usually can be brought back with a good spray clean, which I carry if I’m not flying. NRL has a support trailer with spare everything.
                  So Cal Precision Rifle Team, NRA Life, WEGC Precision Bolt Rifle Director, NRL Member, Bolt Action Rifle Groupie, NRA Pistol Distinguished Expert

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    thegiff
                    Member
                    • Aug 2008
                    • 364

                    The reason comp shooters went to Triggertech is because they adjust well, feel right, and are relatively dirt tolerant.

                    Hubers are non-adjustable and would be much more popular if they were.

                    Jewells feel great and are properly adjustable but go down all the time in dirty conditions. Against the Triggertech, I’d say the Triggertech feels better.

                    Calvin Elite has a similar design to the Jewell therefore similar lack of tolerance to dirt therefore if you can get same or better feel and more dirt tolerance you will get a Triggertech.

                    Cost is secondary to performance and reliability. A match cost about $1k to attend or more if you are by yourself. Those who want to win will do anything to gain an edge, equipment is part, practice is most. We want to depend on the equipment to focus on skill.

                    I don’t have a beater rifle, or beater components. My equipment just evolves over time as I upgrade and interests change, experiment and learn new things, work with match certs and the circle of people around me and various deals and trades. Hence the combo of rifles and components I have now.
                    So Cal Precision Rifle Team, NRA Life, WEGC Precision Bolt Rifle Director, NRL Member, Bolt Action Rifle Groupie, NRA Pistol Distinguished Expert

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      FourT6and2
                      Senior Member
                      • Dec 2012
                      • 1928

                      Originally posted by thegiff
                      The reason comp shooters went to Triggertech is because they adjust well, feel right, and are relatively dirt tolerant.

                      Hubers are non-adjustable and would be much more popular if they were.

                      Jewells feel great and are properly adjustable but go down all the time in dirty conditions. Against the Triggertech, I’d say the Triggertech feels better.

                      Calvin Elite has a similar design to the Jewell therefore similar lack of tolerance to dirt therefore if you can get same or better feel and more dirt tolerance you will get a Triggertech.

                      Cost is secondary to performance and reliability. A match cost about $1k to attend or more if you are by yourself. Those who want to win will do anything to gain an edge, equipment is part, practice is most. We want to depend on the equipment to focus on skill.

                      I don’t have a beater rifle, or beater components. My equipment just evolves over time as I upgrade and interests change, experiment and learn new things, work with match certs and the circle of people around me and various deals and trades. Hence the combo of rifles and components I have now.
                      I just have different priorities. Reliability in adverse conditions is a secondary or even tertiary criteria for me. I do love the feel of the TT Diamond. Just wish it had over-travel adjustability. I would ditch Jewell and switch if it did because precision/accuracy is my number one goal. Sure, I can hit a plate no problem with the TT. But I also like tight groups and Jewell gets me there better than TT.

                      Any experience with the Bix n Andy Tac Sport Pro?
                      Last edited by FourT6and2; 09-16-2022, 10:36 AM.

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        thegiff
                        Member
                        • Aug 2008
                        • 364

                        I haven't come across one so far, though I hear they are really nice. I personally don't like overtravel, it throws my shots off by making the rifle jump a bit.
                        So Cal Precision Rifle Team, NRA Life, WEGC Precision Bolt Rifle Director, NRL Member, Bolt Action Rifle Groupie, NRA Pistol Distinguished Expert

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          yacko
                          Senior Member
                          • Mar 2019
                          • 631

                          Originally posted by FourT6and2
                          I just have different priorities. Reliability in adverse conditions is a secondary or even tertiary criteria for me. I do love the feel of the TT Diamond. Just wish it had over-travel adjustability. I would ditch Jewell and switch if it did because precision/accuracy is my number one goal. Sure, I can hit a plate no problem with the TT. But I also like tight groups and Jewell gets me there better than TT.

                          Any experience with the Bix n Andy Tac Sport Pro?
                          And thats why we have a communication problem.

                          Is reliablitlity secondary or tertiary to your home protection firearms?

                          You say 'take a beater rifle to a match'

                          I say this is the match and I take my Comp rifle to the match.

                          My comp rifle has to deal with the wind and sand and dust and the muzzle brakes throwing up more dust and it HAS TO WORK. Reliability is absolutely required.. Accuracy is now tied with reliability under harsh conditions.

                          Sounds to me, your comp gun is BR- On a nice windless day- the sun is shining just right- no shadows.... my butt is perfectly seated in the chair, the air temp/humidity are just perfect for shooting tiny bugholes.

                          go put that thing prone in the dirt with people on both sides of you shooting with brakes spittting dirt on your panda action. A couple blasts in the dirt from brakes- you wont even be able to close that action.

                          Point is... built for a PURPOSE- You seem to be built for BR with everything perfect and clean.

                          We shoot in the dirt and the sand and the rain- It has to function first- accuracy is good- but a fouled trigger or an action that wont close because a little dirt doesnt work here.

                          Different builds- different purposes.

                          You will want to brag about your tiny groups on a great day.

                          I will not have as good of groups as you- but I can do it any day. Including dust/dirt/rain or shine. Different build- different purpose. Yes I shot a 2 day match in the rain- at least when it rained the sand got wet and didnt get kicked up into the trigger/action from the crazy winds before the rain.

                          Different game- different equipment- different expectations.

                          But- if you are just a range queen nice weather shooter on a bench with no dust/dirt/sand- a jewell work just fine for you.

                          So if you are a BR guy- ask Lynn about the best triggers for that game.

                          He knows his stuff. No joke- he is the resident expert. I hold him in high regard. He also knows those triggers and actions dont play nice in the dirt.
                          Last edited by yacko; 09-16-2022, 8:18 PM.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            LynnJr
                            Calguns Addict
                            • Jan 2013
                            • 7959

                            OP
                            Since your after a hunting and general purpose target trigger try the various options out and get what you like.
                            I own jewells bix&andy flavio fare shilen timney sss rifle basix canjar kepplinger anschutz calfee and kenyon triggers and i wouldnt put a 2 stage trigger on any gun i own.
                            That said if i was shooting in a competition environment that demanded a 2 stage trigger i would own several and use them.
                            Tomorrow i will be hunting with a timney and monday i will be hunting with a jewell.
                            If your ever in norcal get in touch and you can try them out before you buy one.
                            We shoot gongs out to 3700 yards each month and in the last 8 years we have never had a trigger of any manufacturer fail on the line and we lay in the dirt with big boomers.
                            Lynn Dragoman, Jr.
                            Southwest Regional Director
                            Unlimited Range Shooters Association (URSA)
                            www.unlimitedrange.org
                            Not a commercial business.
                            URSA - Competition starts at 2000 yards!

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              FourT6and2
                              Senior Member
                              • Dec 2012
                              • 1928

                              Originally posted by yacko
                              And thats why we have a communication problem.

                              Is reliablitlity secondary or tertiary to your home protection firearms?

                              You say 'take a beater rifle to a match'

                              I say this is the match and I take my Comp rifle to the match.

                              My comp rifle has to deal with the wind and sand and dust and the muzzle brakes throwing up more dust and it HAS TO WORK. Reliability is absolutely required.. Accuracy is now tied with reliability under harsh conditions.

                              Sounds to me, your comp gun is BR- On a nice windless day- the sun is shining just right- no shadows.... my butt is perfectly seated in the chair, the air temp/humidity are just perfect for shooting tiny bugholes.

                              go put that thing prone in the dirt with people on both sides of you shooting with brakes spittting dirt on your panda action. A couple blasts in the dirt from brakes- you wont even be able to close that action.

                              Point is... built for a PURPOSE- You seem to be built for BR with everything perfect and clean.

                              We shoot in the dirt and the sand and the rain- It has to function first- accuracy is good- but a fouled trigger or an action that wont close because a little dirt doesnt work here.

                              Different builds- different purposes.

                              You will want to brag about your tiny groups on a great day.

                              I will not have as good of groups as you- but I can do it any day. Including dust/dirt/rain or shine. Different build- different purpose. Yes I shot a 2 day match in the rain- at least when it rained the sand got wet and didnt get kicked up into the trigger/action from the crazy winds before the rain.

                              Different game- different equipment- different expectations.

                              But- if you are just a range queen nice weather shooter on a bench with no dust/dirt/sand- a jewell work just fine for you.

                              So if you are a BR guy- ask Lynn about the best triggers for that game.

                              He knows his stuff. No joke- he is the resident expert. I hold him in high regard. He also knows those triggers and actions dont play nice in the dirt.
                              Sure thing

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                thegiff
                                Member
                                • Aug 2008
                                • 364

                                Agree with Yacko’s comments, different triggers for different disciplines. I’ve been to a match where it rained every day for three days and you got muddy and wet on 1 out of 4 stages or so and blew dirt and mud around with muzzle blast. Had a couple triggers go down on our squad and I had the cleaning tools and equipment to bring them back.

                                Another match in New Mexico where it was really sandy and windy. Blowing sand would come up constantly. I kept my rifle in a soft case except when shooting, none of my squad mates followed my lead, even on the second day. Didn’t even wrap or cover their rifles. Had multiple triggers go down and even bolts not cycle or rounds not chamber just in my squad. Idiotic in my view but whatever.
                                So Cal Precision Rifle Team, NRA Life, WEGC Precision Bolt Rifle Director, NRL Member, Bolt Action Rifle Groupie, NRA Pistol Distinguished Expert

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1