Which XDS and why?

[theneko]

I have had no issues with my pre- or post-recall XDS9 or XDS45. Both have seen 700+ rounds. I liked the trigger better before I sent them in but it has improved with use.
I had the 45 first and honestly I think I like it better than the 9 but it depends on you. I dont like shooting with the extended mags so capacity is an issue. Recoil is stout on the 45 but I found Barnes TAC-XPD ammo to be very soft. The 45 seems much more accurate than the 9 for me but maybe that is just the way I shoot. The XDS fits my hand much better than the Shield (which I also found to be less accurate in my hands).

[stryper]

The best advice I can give is to try them both. Since this is going to be your CCW firearm, you have to make sure you're comfortable with it. Weight wise and functionality.

I own/owned both models and calibers. I didn't care for the Shields, they just didn't feel right. I own a XD-s in .45 and 9mm. The XD-s 9 is actually a little heavier than the .45 model because of the barrel thickness and the extra ammo.
I carry the XD-s 45 because I've always been partial to and the capabilities of the .45acp round. The XD-s 9 was bought for my wife. As for the "kick" of the XD-s 45, the best sub-compact 45 I've shot. My daughter loved my XD-s 45 and now owns one. As for the trigger, any sub-compact polymer pistol can use a trigger upgrade but I've become accustomed to my factory one and like it best out of all the other sub-compact pistols I've shot. I have never had a problem with my XD-s 45 or 9 and can't say enough good things about them.

[Dannicus]

I may be odd for feeling this way, but I prefer the heavier thud of the .45 over the snappy feeling of the 9mm.

That's why I went with the .45.

I shoot it just as well and both require a really firm grip to keep the muzzle down for follow up shots. Accuracy is fantastic for me in both 9 and 45. I attribute that to the trigger and the great sights. Never tried the 40. Don't want to.

Mine has been reliable before and after the recall. It did have that issue with being able to push the slide out of battery and having it stay there. That cleared up after a couple hundred rounds.

I stick with 230 grains to maintain whatever penetration the short barrel can muster.

[javaduke]

Just jailed my XDs 9mm yesterday. I was looking for a concealable 9mm and it was a tough decision between LC9, M&P Shield and XDs. Surprisingly M&P had a VERY gritty trigger and felt a bit heavier than the XDs. LC9 trigger was nice but way too long (I have small hands). So XDs was the best of them all. A nice crisp trigger, and those extra two rounds seem like an advantage. Just my 2c.

[jims1001]

I went to my LGS this afternoon to dros my M&P pro. I had the sales to pull out the XDs and let me handle it. The grip is ok but not great due to my big fat hand. The trigger is a little heavy but still manageable. When I asked for to handle the Shield, the sales told me I won't like it for sure.

[tal3nt]

Just jailed my XDs 9mm yesterday. I was looking for a concealable 9mm and it was a tough decision between LC9, M&P Shield and XDs. Surprisingly M&P had a VERY gritty trigger and felt a bit heavier than the XDs. LC9 trigger was nice but way too long (I have small hands). So XDs was the best of them all. A nice crisp trigger, and those extra two rounds seem like an advantage. Just my 2c.

Out of those, I'd say you made the right choice

[BoJackUSMC]

Wait until Glock comes out with their own single stack 9mm.. Cant wait.

[River Bound]

Appreciate all the good input. Thanks everyone.

[TemeC]

where are you guys finding the XDs? my lgs says its not on the roster?

[CpuFixrMan]

Depending on the LGS they can do a SSE (single shot exemption). For example, Tracy Rifle and Pistol in Tracy, CA will do it.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk