Weaver or Isosceles?

[9mmepiphany]

I'm not sure which study you read, but the one's I've been exposed to in classes, in-service training and periodicals have shown that under stress, most folks will go into a version of the Isosceles.

These studies were conducted in academies with recruits before they received firearms training to avoid contamination or influence.

I'm not, by any means, saying that the Weaver philosophy doesn't have a place in defensive shooting. It is especially useful when the shooter won't continue to train to maintain/improve their skills, it is also easier to teach

[Ricky-Ray]

Who cares what stances other people are shooting. Shoot how you are most comfortable and able to get rounds downrange accurately with.

[9mmepiphany]

It doesn't make a difference to most folks, because they'll never reach a level of skill where it starts to make a difference.

For folks just starting who don't have a preference, why not start with a more optimized path to putting shots quickly and accurately on target.

For folks trying to improve in that same goal, it is worth the effort, unless you have a physical limitation, to change over and also to use a thumb forwards grip

[penguin0123]

I'm not sure which study you read, but the one's I've been exposed to in classes, in-service training and periodicals have shown that under stress, most folks will go into a version of the Isosceles

I must have recalled wrong.

[neouser]

I use my dominant/strong hand.

I guess I should practice weak hand shooting as well...

[rix]

Proper sight alignment/sight picture,trigger press and proper grip. Stance means nothing.

[Jet Setter]

Use whatever stance works for you...
I use modified isosceles stand.

+1. Not everything is cookie cutter. Mmmmm cookies...

[teflondog]

For slow target shooting, I prefer a modified Weaver stance since I'm more accurate with it and I don't get tired as fast.

For fast point shooting, I prefer Isosceles. I acquire the front sight faster with an Isosceles stance but my shoulders get tired if I hold the stance for too long.

[9mmepiphany]

I acquire the front sight faster with an Isosceles stance but my shoulders get tired if I hold the stance for too long.

I'll bet you're rolling your shoulders forward/up and lowering your head.

Try shooting with your shoulders more relaxed and your head more upright, like this:

[DRAB_81]

For slow target shooting, I prefer a modified Weaver stance since I'm more accurate with it and I don't get tired as fast.

For fast point shooting, I prefer Isosceles. I acquire the front sight faster with an Isosceles stance but my shoulders get tired if I hold the stance for too long.

How long are you standing static in the same position during rapid fire drills? For rapid fire/point shooting, I wouldn't think you'd be firing enough rounds consecutively or stand still long enough to get tired. Atleast that hasn't been something I've experienced so far through classes, USPSA matches & general practice, and I use a modified stance that tips more toward isosceles.

[rsmorgan]

Weaver works better for me for static shooting but I practice and use both since the realities of combat require flexibility of action. In a confrontational situation, the natural reaction is to face the enemy, which is basically the Isosceles stance. Combat reality is you will probably need to shoot from whatever position you are in, which may include such "dignified options" as shooting while falling, etc.

[9mmepiphany]

which may include such "dignified options" as shooting while falling, etc.

It could be hard to practice this more than once

[teflondog]

I'll bet you're rolling your shoulders forward/up and lowering your head.

Try shooting with your shoulders more relaxed and your head more upright, like this:

I realize I just need more practice. I don't get tired when I make a conscious effort to stay relaxed. It's under time pressure when I tense up.

How long are you standing static in the same position during rapid fire drills? For rapid fire/point shooting, I wouldn't think you'd be firing enough rounds consecutively or stand still long enough to get tired. Atleast that hasn't been something I've experienced so far through classes, USPSA matches & general practice, and I use a modified stance that tips more toward isosceles.

My problem is that I instinctively flex my traps and shoulders while trying to maintain a firm grip during shooting. I use the push-pull method to control recoil. It's definitely a training issue that I need to work on.

[9mmepiphany]

I use the push-pull method to control recoil. It's definitely a training issue that I need to work on.

If you didn't do that, you'd be able to shoot a lot faster without losing any accuracy. You'd also transition faster between targets and feel less tired afterwards

[CnCFunFactory]

Isosceles, unless I'm trying to recreate a scene from the TV show Miami Vice.