Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

1911 vs everything else?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • XDm .40
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2011
    • 629

    1911 vs everything else?

    So at some point in the nearish future I am going to need to buy a sidearm and I would like some pros and cons about the 1911, and how it stacks up to other semis if it was your only sidearm.

    I would like 40 or 45 cal, something smooth to shoot for practice, and reliable enough for a combat situation. Im not planning to fight zombies, yet, but more so be ready for a home invasion. My back yard is on a major road and I don't trust people.

    My spending range would be around 4-700. Let's hear it!
    "I came to confess... I was the second shooter on the grassy gnoll!"
  • #2
    Capybara
    CGSSA Coordinator
    CGN Contributor
    • Feb 2012
    • 15780

    The 1911 is a classic and many shooters feel that it is ultimate handgun. If you look at when it was invented, all of the great combat shooters who have contributed to it becoming so popular, it is hard to go wrong with one. I bought my first 1911 15 years ago. I am not a hardcore shooter but I have a soft spot for the classic arms that "saved the world" and by any measure, the 1911 and the M1 Garand did save the world.

    Not sure if you have shot a .45 ACP, but smooth is not the term that comes to mind as far as when I shoot mine. It has some blast and some kick to it, I can shoot my little Ruger 9mm more smoothly than my 1911 but I have a lot more fun shooting my 1911 ;-)

    As far as reliability, I don't think anyone would deny that the 1911 is incredibly reliable and solid for combat, it has been proven in war for around 100 years? For $400.00 to $700.00, you would want to spend the $700.00 and get either an inexpensive new one or a nice lightly used SA 1911-A1 or something like that. My gunsmith just bought the Philippines made RIA 1911 and he loves it and says it is built very solidly and shoots great. So there are new 1911s in your price range that are getting pretty solid reviews and building a rep. Is a $3,000.00 Les Baer or Kimber custom better? Sure, you get what you pay for but generally, even the lower end 1911s benefit from a great, classic and strong design.

    Have you shot a 1911 before? What did you think? I think the 1911 is the Ford vs. Chevy argument with handguns. The 1911 is the Ford and the Glock/XD and every other DA poly pistol is the Chevy. Both are solid, both are reliable but they are very different. I like them both, but if I could only have one, it would be my 1911-A1.

    Dan
    NRA Certified Metallic Cartridge Reloading Instructor, Shotgun Instructor and Range Safety Officer

    sigpic

    Comment

    • #3
      Bug Splat
      Calguns Addict
      • Dec 2007
      • 6561

      Love the feel of a 1911 and they look just drop dead sexy. They are reliable for the most part but are complicated by todays standards. Shoots the hard hitting 45 but you only get 7-8 in the mag, again today's standards are a bit higher. Aftermarket parts are somewhat cheap and plentiful. You can build it up any way you like. Trigger can be very nice but you have to carry cocked and locked. I personally don't like this method and prefer double actions for defense. Neither is a plus or minus, just what you feel comfortable with.

      Again I love the 1911 but there are probably better choices for zombies and home invasions.

      Comment

      • #4
        wjc
        I need a LIFE!!
        • Dec 2009
        • 10887

        I was about to hit you with the commandments according to John Browning but I'll leave it at this.

        The 1911 is a battle tested, well engineered pistol that is still popular with todays military.

        I have one...you should too.
        sigpic

        NRA Benefactor Member
        NRA Golden Eagle
        SAF Life Member
        CGN Contributor

        Comment

        • #5
          PandaLuv
          Senior Member
          • Jan 2011
          • 641

          For your price range and purpose, I would go with glock 21, XD45, FNP45 or MP45.



          1911s are nice, but most of them are kinda pricey, ergonomically they're outdated, but they're reliable as all hell and have the best stock trigger for around 1K range. I personally love them, but I would pick other guns for HD in .40SW and .45ACP.
          Молон Лабе
          I'd rather be carried by 6 than judged by 12

          Comment

          • #6
            Freq18Hz
            Senior Member
            • Apr 2011
            • 1243

            Originally posted by XDm .40
            So at some point in the nearish future I am going to need to buy a sidearm and I would like some pros and cons about the 1911, and how it stacks up to other semis if it was your only sidearm.

            I would like 40 or 45 cal, something smooth to shoot for practice, and reliable enough for a combat situation. Im not planning to fight zombies, yet, but more so be ready for a home invasion. My back yard is on a major road and I don't trust people.

            My spending range would be around 4-700. Let's hear it!
            #1 for home defense get a shotgun
            #2 if you mudt get a handgun for HD, get a .45 or a .357

            .45 is better if you live close to neighbors.

            -Freq

            Comment

            • #7
              XDm .40
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2011
              • 629

              I've never shot a 1911 or even a 45 caliber pistol. The shotgun is in the safe but my thing is if I had to chase someone a pistol would be a great choice. I appreciate the info.
              "I came to confess... I was the second shooter on the grassy gnoll!"

              Comment

              • #8
                scotty99
                Senior Member
                • Dec 2009
                • 1184

                +1 on the Glock/XD/M&P suggestion. In your price range, you will be at the bottom of the 1911 market, but $500 will get you any of the above. I have a customized 1911 in the safe in the garage that was $1500 20 years ago, but the XD45 lives under the bed. As long as your hand fits around the grip of the .45s, go that route. The only advantage to the .40 is mag capacity and here in Cali our betters up north have negated that issue.

                Comment

                • #9
                  Massan
                  Senior Member
                  • Jul 2010
                  • 1042

                  Originally posted by PandaLuv
                  1911s are nice, but most of them are kinda pricey, ergonomically they're outdated, but they're reliable as all hell and have the best stock trigger for around 1K range. I personally love them, but I would pick other guns for HD in .40SW and .45ACP.
                  Dunno about reliability, short the "milspec" ones with loose tolerances all the other "higher" end 1911s usually have quirks with them and need some minor gunsmithing.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    dbbspider
                    Member
                    • Nov 2008
                    • 334

                    Any pistol that is reliable and u shoot well would qualify for HD. 38 spl, 9mm, 357, 40 and 45 are all good. Its all about shot placement. 1911 come in 38 super, 9mm, and 45 for the most part. They are difficult to find in 40 and u dont need the 10mm. polymer pistols like Glock are battle tested and will do the job just as good as a 1911. Try shooting as many brands and styles as you can, and choose the one that u shoot best. It really comes down to preference

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      wash
                      Calguns Addict
                      • Aug 2007
                      • 9011

                      There are some bargains available in 1911s if you look hard enough.

                      In your price range, look at used guns. For reliability, you should start with a quality frame, forged steel not cast and properly machined (not all are). Make sure the barrel is throated properly, the ejector is intact and the extractor has proper tension. Barrel lug engagement and slide clearance are important too.

                      If you buy used, probably change the recoil spring to avoid battering the frame and make sure both of the safeties work too.

                      I know several people who have bought very nice reliable 1911s that just happen to be put together with quality parts that don't "match" but the parts all fit and work together.

                      There are some bad mis-matched 1911s out there too so you do have to know what you are looking for.
                      sigpic
                      Originally posted by oaklander
                      Dear Kevin,

                      You suck!!! Your are wrong!!! Stop it!!!
                      Proud CGF and CGN donor. SAF life member. Former CRPA member. Gpal beta tester (it didn't work). NRA member.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Chrushev
                        Member
                        • Feb 2012
                        • 124

                        Originally posted by XDm .40
                        I've never shot a 1911 or even a 45 caliber pistol. The shotgun is in the safe but my thing is if I had to chase someone a pistol would be a great choice. I appreciate the info.
                        I believe that if you are chasing someone (even someone that almost killed you a second ago) and shoot them... you are basically guaranteed to go to jail as it will be considered Murder... unfortunately

                        I think if someone had intent of killing you you have every right to hurt them back, even if they are running away.. because they may come back.
                        Own: GSG 1911CA (2nd Gen), Beretta 92FS
                        Guides: Make GSG1911 run smooth as butter with any ammo guide HERE

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          Nynvolt
                          Member
                          • Oct 2009
                          • 297

                          More moving parts equals more chances to fail. They are expensive comparably and pretty guns. I wouldn't mind having one but it wouldn't be my nightstand gun. Just my personal opinion.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            lordres
                            Senior Member
                            • Mar 2011
                            • 500

                            You probably don't want to do any chasing with any gun in this state.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              AeroEngi
                              Veteran Member
                              • Oct 2010
                              • 2887

                              First of all, I'd like to thank Capybara for an excellent post.

                              That said, I believe that every handgun enthusiast should have at least one 1911. My first handgun was a Sig P220R and i love that thing. It has been one of the most reliable pistols I've ever fired but for some reason, I cherish my 1911 to another level. Maybe its the history behind the gun or maybe its because its THE most accurate handgun I've ever fired. Even though my 1911 had some issues out of the box, I would now trust my life to that thing.

                              All I can tell you is you can't go wrong with a 1911.

                              Good luck in your decision.

                              Sent from my Asus Transformer using Tapatalk.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1