IMO with your budget, I wouldnt purchase a new 1911 for HD . There are so many better alternatives out there. Increase that budget to 1000ish + with good mags and now were talking.
Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1911 vs everything else?
Collapse
X
-
-
I agree with people saying in that price range you should be looking into a polymer wonder gun. A 1911 IMO needs to be built properly to be a bet your life reliable sidearm I don't think you always get that with a new $700 dollar 1911 in that price range your looking at RIA or SA Mil-Spec unless your looking at used.
Anyways the only problem I have with the GI as a HD sidearm is it doesn't come with dovetail cuts so adding NS will cost much more. Also since this sounds like your first HG I would look into getting a 9mm since you'll be able to practice cheaper and hitting what you aim at matters more than caliber selection. Maybe you heard only a .40 or .45 will do the job well that's just not true especially not today with modern defensive ammunition.
Besides that IMO a 1911 is not a good beginner weapon especially if you don't have some kind of support by a more knowledgeable person next to you. To me beginners buying cheap 1911's or AR's are more often than not put off by the platforms. Since they inevitably run into problems from cheap parts and shoddy craftsmanship and don't posses the working knowledge to diagnose or repair problems that commonly arise.Comment
-
The problem is these two conflicting desires
...coupled with
...likely makes the 1911 a poor choice for a first primary handgun. You don't really have the knowledge to wisely select a used gun for more than a range toy.I've never shot a 1911 or even a 45 caliber pistol
One of the polymer pistols in 9mm would be a good way to start in that price range...it takes a lot of practice to get proficient with a handgun...because the journey is the worthier part...The Shepherd's TaleComment
-
Comment
-
Yes, I do. The only reason why I have a 1911 in a 10mm is because the Glock 20 looks like ***.Any pistol that is reliable and u shoot well would qualify for HD. 38 spl, 9mm, 357, 40 and 45 are all good. Its all about shot placement. 1911 come in 38 super, 9mm, and 45 for the most part. They are difficult to find in 40 and u dont need the 10mm. polymer pistols like Glock are battle tested and will do the job just as good as a 1911. Try shooting as many brands and styles as you can, and choose the one that u shoot best. It really comes down to preference
I still plan to get a G20SF though.
Comment
-

Comment
-
-
The 1911 is a combat weapon, plain and simple. One can bludgeon to death an adversary
with one when it runs dry.
The chap who said that a 1911 is not a good choice for a first primary handgun I can only say, "Boulderdash!""I kill things for a living, don't make yourself one of them"Comment
-
Sorry man but I'm gonna have to disagree with you on that.For your price range and purpose, I would go with glock 21, XD45, FNP45 or MP45.
1911s are nice, but most of them are kinda pricey, ergonomically they're outdated, but they're reliable as all hell and have the best stock trigger for around 1K range. I personally love them, but I would pick other guns for HD in .40SW and .45ACP.
The grip angle is IMO perfect, the front strap and MSH checkering helps you grip the gun a lot better while being comfortable and the controls are all exactly where they need to be.Comment
-
The 1911 is a good choice for someone entering the world of handguns. If you can take one of those apart, maintain it, and learn how it works, all other pistols in today's age will be a cakewalk. The sharper your learning curve in the beginning, the less you'll be forced to learn later. If you're really interested in firearms and feel as though you're going to continue on with them, I'd recommend a Para Ordinance 1911 GI. They're roughly the same cost as some of the polymer pistols mentioned on here and just as reliable.
Here's the model from their website just so you can view the specs. I've heard nothing but good things from them.Comment
-
Pros and cons as requested:
Pros-
Very nice looking and feeling gun of a classic design
accurate
great trigger
hammer
manual safety
grip safey
Parts and upgrades readily available
Knowledge and support readily available
time proven classic battle pistol
Cons-
Heavy (this is a pro for me, but can be considered one of its downsides)
expensive (relative)
slightly more complicated take down procedure
If you chose to buy a 1911 for home defense in the $400-$700 range, I would recommend the following: either buy a used one that you know has worked well and been proven or buy a new RIA. I say this for a couple reasons. One is that you won't find many new options, and RIA has proven to be a solid performing budget 1911. Buying a used 1911 has significant risks (especially in this price range). The previous owner may have had trouble with it feeding properly, may have sent it back multiple times and is fed up with it, etc. If you don't know the ins and outs of a 1911, buying one used can lead to a whole host of headaches (ask me how I know, or search for threads that I have started!) But if you buy a new RIA (I don't know of any other brands that fall in to this price range new), they will back their product with good customer service. In either case, once you buy the pistol, shoot the heck out of it and prove it to yourself that it is worthy of protecting your life. While 1911 pistols have the reputation for being battle proven, they also have a reputation for being picky when it comes to magazines and ammo.
If I had $4-700 to spend on a .45acp home defense gun (assuming you are new to handguns and this will be your one and only handgun), I would be looking at the aforementioned polymer selection (S&W, Glock, XD) or a used Sig p220.
Comment
-
I don't own a 1911 but I've heard that most of them have problems with JHP rounds. If this is true it could pose problems for HD. Any one have any experience with this?Welcome to OT, where hypocrisy is King, outrage is Queen and the Kingdom is on the shores of the Denial River.
__________________Comment
-
There is nothing wrong with having a 1911 as your first handgun. Just spend some time on learning the functions and takedown process. It is like me telling you to ride a bike and not drive a car. It might have a slightly higher learning curve than a modern polymer handgun, but it is still easy enough for beginners. Don't get intimidate or discourage by people telling you it is too complicated. Field strip one and you'll see what I mean. Just a few more steps than a modern handguns.
If you intend to use it as a home defense gun, please take it to the range and put a few hundred rounds through it to make sure it is reliable. For me, I put 1,000 rounds before I put it in my nightstand.Comment
-
My SA 1911 TRP has fed JHP just as reliably as it has fed FMJ. After about 1500 rounds, it has failed to return to battery only a handful of times and that's because I wasn't initially lubing it correctly and the extractor was out of spec (too short). The last 750-800 rounds have been completely flawless with JHP and FMJ.Comment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,986
Posts: 25,178,192
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,382
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 40177 users online. 100 members and 40077 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.

Comment