Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

close

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #46
    9Cal_OC
    Calguns Addict
    • Apr 2019
    • 6706



    I’m curious now which is it.
    Freedom isn't free...

    sigpic

    iTrader

    Comment

    • #47
      SkyHawk
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Sep 2012
      • 23532

      Originally posted by morrcarr67
      I'm not going to re-post the code, you can go back and rip it apart if you like.

      The code is written for a CA licensed gun dealer/gunsmith in mind.
      Yes it is, but it does not say that a dealer cannot subcontract out part of the work to another FFL, which would be very common. One guy does the mods or repairs, another guy does the engraving, another guy applies the finish, comes back to the first guy for final fitting assembly, testing.

      After all that is done, the original owner can still come back to the place where he tendered it for service or customization and leave with it without 4473 or DROS.

      The code was also written to cover that scenario which is why nowhere does it say the gun must remain at the original licensed premise the whole time. If they intended that to be the case, they would have written it that way.

      ATF even has guidance on this topic, reminding FFLs who sub out work that everyone needs to log the gun in/out of bound books, and this is one reason why some FFLs keep separate bound books for such intra-FFL exchanges
      Last edited by SkyHawk; 09-20-2022, 2:39 PM.
      Click here for my iTrader Feedback thread: https://www.calguns.net/forum/market...r-feedback-100

      Comment

      • #48
        morrcarr67
        I need a LIFE!!
        • Jul 2010
        • 15074

        Originally posted by SkyHawk
        Yes it is, but it does not say that a dealer cannot subcontract out part of the work to another FFL, which would be very common. One guy does the mods or repairs, another guy does the engraving, another guy applies the finish, comes back to the first guy for final fitting assembly, testing.

        After all that is done, the original owner can still come back to the place where he tendered it for service or customization and leave with it without 4473 or DROS.

        The code was also written to cover that scenario which is why nowhere does it say the gun must remain at the original licensed premise the whole time. If they intended that to be the case, they would have written it that way.

        ATF even has guidance on this topic, reminding FFLs who sub out work that everyone needs to log the gun in/out of bound books, and this is one reason why some FFLs keep separate bound books for such intra-FFL exchanges
        That's interesting that they could do that with ATF's blessing.

        It's akin to a truck driver running two logs. All kinds of misrepresentation can happen.

        But that would be a way to get around the original A&D record.

        If I held a license that the ATF could regularly give a surprise inspection there's absolutely no way I would do that. Even with their blessings. How many time in recent memory have they gone back on what they said was OK?
        Yes you can have 2 C&R 03 FFL's; 1 in California and 1 in a different state.

        Originally posted by Erion929

        Comment

        • #49
          morrcarr67
          I need a LIFE!!
          • Jul 2010
          • 15074

          Originally posted by dskell
          I agree with you on everything except for the bolded sections in the quote above.

          The code does not state that you must be a gunsmith. If the firearm is delivered to the licensee (could be a gunsmith, but doesn't have to be) for the purposes of the service or repair of that firearm, then it may be returned to that owner upon completion of the work.

          Additionally, the code does not state that the exemption only applies when the work is completed by the licensee that the firearm is delivered to. It can be, but this is not a requirement.

          The law does not state either of these things anywhere. That proves the contrary of what you are saying. I am merely going off of what the law says.

          Some anecdotal evidence: my business has processed repairs on off-roster firearms belonging to non-exempt individuals exactly as outlined above. Records of these transactions have been reviewed in subsequent DOJ audits and have not caused issue. The company I work for, nor myself are licensed gunsmiths.
          But the only way to get around the original A&D entry is to do what Skyhawk says above.

          Just the opinion of one Federally licensed person (not a dealer), I think that is a very bad way to do business. But apparently there are some that are willing to take that risk.

          Though with the new fine schedule that the CA DOJ is pushing I wonder how many will still be willing going forward.
          Yes you can have 2 C&R 03 FFL's; 1 in California and 1 in a different state.

          Originally posted by Erion929

          Comment

          • #50
            SkyHawk
            I need a LIFE!!
            • Sep 2012
            • 23532

            Originally posted by morrcarr67
            That's interesting that they could do that with ATF's blessing.

            It's akin to a truck driver running two logs. All kinds of misrepresentation can happen.

            But that would be a way to get around the original A&D record.

            If I held a license that the ATF could regularly give a surprise inspection there's absolutely no way I would do that. Even with their blessings. How many time in recent memory have they gone back on what they said was OK?
            They do not do it in an attempt to hide anything, they do it to stay organized. Especially when keeping track of guns going in and out for service. There is nothing unusual about it at all. All the books are made available whenever they are asked to produce them.



            May a licensee keep more than one "bound book" at the same time?[/B]

            Yes. A licensee is not limited to using only one “bound book.” It may be convenient for a licensee to account for different brands or types of firearms, or business activities (e.g., retail, pawn, or gunsmith inventories), in separate “bound books.”
            It is also the guidance that NSSF gives to dealers - and so a lot of dealers do it this way
            Every retailer must keep complete and accurate A&D records for all firearms taken in for repair, whether for cleaning or return to the manufacturer.


            The aim of this article is to help every retailer keep complete and accurate A&D records for all firearms taken in for repair, whether it be just for cleaning or for return to the manufacturer for repair or replacement, and everything in between.

            First, keep a separate A&D book for your repairs. It’s much easier that way.

            and

            Between the receipt of the firearm for repair and the return of the repaired firearm to whoever picks it up, several things can happen. Most commonly, the firearm can be sent out to another licensed FFL/gunsmith for repair, or it can be sent back to the manufacturer for repair.
            It is very common for FFLs to take in guns for service that they do not intend to service themselves.

            I believe the CA law regarding return to owner was written to mimic and coexist with federal law and common industry practices.
            Last edited by SkyHawk; 09-20-2022, 4:57 PM.
            Click here for my iTrader Feedback thread: https://www.calguns.net/forum/market...r-feedback-100

            Comment

            • #51
              rareair
              Senior Member
              • Jul 2010
              • 1898

              OP is having a dilemma of using a FFL to ship his firearm to SIG for inspection? Why not use his employer?

              Originally posted by dskell
              He is not. Below is the PC that provides an exemption for delivery of an off-roster firearm to an otherwise non-exempt person when it has been sent for repair.

              I am employed by a large FFL dealer, and have been for the past twelve years (not to say working for an FFL means you know the law LOL). In my experience, and based on the law, this is how things work.

              As I stated earlier, the same SN being returned to the owner who brought the firearm in does not require a DROS.

              Penal Code 32110
              Article 4 (commencing with Section 31900) and Article 5 (commencing with Section 32000) shall not apply to any of the following:
              (d) The delivery of a pistol, revolver, or other firearm capable of being concealed upon the person to a person licensed pursuant to Sections 26700 to 26915, inclusive, for the purposes of the service or repair of that firearm.
              (e) The return of a pistol, revolver, or other firearm capable of being concealed upon the person by a person licensed pursuant to Sections 26700 to 26915, inclusive, to its owner where that firearm was initially delivered in the circumstances set forth in subdivision (a), (d), (f), or (i).
              MagPul MPLA
              POF-USA P415-18-11T-223
              TROY M7A1
              & a bunch of SIG pistols and rifles

              **WTB P227 TacOps**

              Comment

              • #52
                dskell
                Senior Member
                • May 2009
                • 825

                Originally posted by rareair
                OP is having a dilemma of using a FFL to ship his firearm to SIG for inspection? Why not use his employer?
                If I were to go the route of sending the gun in, I would absolutely go through work.

                The primary question to begin with was if anyone had found a solution to back plate coming out of place, without having to send the gun back in because I'd rather not. Then we got off the rails about sending off-roster guns in lol.

                Comment

                • #53
                  dskell
                  Senior Member
                  • May 2009
                  • 825

                  Originally posted by morrcarr67
                  But the only way to get around the original A&D entry is to do what Skyhawk says above.

                  Just the opinion of one Federally licensed person (not a dealer), I think that is a very bad way to do business. But apparently there are some that are willing to take that risk.

                  Though with the new fine schedule that the CA DOJ is pushing I wonder how many will still be willing going forward.
                  There isn't anything to "get around", state law provides an exemption specifically for this purpose.

                  I presume you are an 03 FFL holder based on your signature. BATFE could care less if a firearm is brought onto a dealers books from a customer, sent in to an MFG for repair, and then returned to the original purchaser once the repairs had been made.

                  No laws are being broken doing this, so no fees would be warranted.

                  Feel like I'm beating a dead horse at this point. I understand that some dealers may not want to complete this transaction. I am not advocating that they do, and I'm not advocating that consumers go through a dealer for this purpose. Just responding to your statement that it could not legally be done. It can be.

                  WHEW.

                  Called Sig today and spoke to a different rep. Explained the issue with the gun and he immediately asked when the firearm was made. Didn't ask if I purchased it used etc. Once I told him the est date of MFG, he got a new end plate on the way to me at no charge.

                  I asked about having a new striker assembly sent, but he stated that the end plate should fix the issue as thed esign was changed to address that problem. I'm interested to compare new vs. old when it gets here.
                  Last edited by dskell; 09-20-2022, 8:09 PM.

                  Comment

                  • #54
                    SkyHawk
                    I need a LIFE!!
                    • Sep 2012
                    • 23532

                    Please let us know your observations with the new back plate, thanks!
                    Click here for my iTrader Feedback thread: https://www.calguns.net/forum/market...r-feedback-100

                    Comment

                    • #55
                      Barang
                      CGN Contributor
                      • Aug 2013
                      • 13608

                      tagging for the outcome with new plate installed.

                      Comment

                      • #56
                        Palmaris
                        Calguns Addict
                        • Mar 2009
                        • 6579

                        Originally posted by dskell
                        There isn't anything to "get around", state law provides an exemption specifically for this purpose.

                        I presume you are an 03 FFL holder based on your signature. BATFE could care less if a firearm is brought onto a dealers books from a customer, sent in to an MFG for repair, and then returned to the original purchaser once the repairs had been made.

                        No laws are being broken doing this, so no fees would be warranted.

                        Feel like I'm beating a dead horse at this point. I understand that some dealers may not want to complete this transaction. I am not advocating that they do, and I'm not advocating that consumers go through a dealer for this purpose. Just responding to your statement that it could not legally be done. It can be.

                        WHEW.

                        Called Sig today and spoke to a different rep. Explained the issue with the gun and he immediately asked when the firearm was made. Didn't ask if I purchased it used etc. Once I told him the est date of MFG, he got a new end plate on the way to me at no charge.

                        I asked about having a new striker assembly sent, but he stated that the end plate should fix the issue as thed esign was changed to address that problem. I'm interested to compare new vs. old when it gets here.
                        what is your gun DOM? mine is 23 Jan 2020. Still old design striker sleeve.
                        sd_shooter:
                        CGN couch patriots: "We the people!"

                        In real life: No one

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        UA-8071174-1