Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

close

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #31
    Palmaris
    Calguns Addict
    • Mar 2009
    • 6578

    Originally posted by static2126
    Op.if you don't get tbis sorted to your satisfaction I may be able to be talked into selling a full p365 complete slide for 255
    OP, do not loose this opportunity. This is stand up guy from my personal experience. He will treat you his own brother.
    sd_shooter:
    CGN couch patriots: "We the people!"

    In real life: No one

    Comment

    • #32
      jonc
      Calguns Addict
      • Aug 2009
      • 6408

      Comment

      • #33
        TrailerparkTrash
        Veteran Member
        • Oct 2005
        • 4249

        Solution: Glock. Easy.
        sigpic

        It`s funny to me to see how angry an atheist is over a God they don`t believe in.` -Jack Hibbs

        -ΙΧΘΥΣ <><

        Comment

        • #34
          morrcarr67
          I need a LIFE!!
          • Jul 2010
          • 15074

          Originally posted by dskell
          That is incorrect for a firearm that is brought in for repair. As long as the same serial number is returned, it would not need to be DROS'ed and thus, the roster is irrelevant. If they replaced the firearm with a new SN, I would be SOL at that point.
          Originally posted by Quiet
          As long as the serial number remains the same, the handguns qualifies for an exemption that allows it to be returned to the registered owner that submitted it for service/repairs. [PC 32110(e)]


          Penal Code 32110
          Article 4 (commencing with Section 31900) and Article 5 (commencing with Section 32000) shall not apply to any of the following:
          (d) The delivery of a pistol, revolver, or other firearm capable of being concealed upon the person to a person licensed pursuant to Sections 26700 to 26915, inclusive, for the purposes of the service or repair of that firearm.
          (e) The return of a pistol, revolver, or other firearm capable of being concealed upon the person by a person licensed pursuant to Sections 26700 to 26915, inclusive, to its owner where that firearm was initially delivered in the circumstances set forth in subdivision (a), (d), (f), or (i).
          As far as I know that PC is set up for a dealer themselves to do work on an off roster handgun and return it to the owner.

          Does it allow for a dealer to return an off roster firearm to a non-exempt person that they did not do the work on?

          If a dealer "takes in a firearm for shipment", the proper way to do so would be to log said firearm into their bound book. When they ship said firearm to a FFL holder they then log it out of their bound book. Same thing in reverse, when they receive the firearm back from the FFL they shipped it to they must now log it into their bound book.

          The shipping to another dealer/manufacture/gunsmith and getting it shipped back in changes what has happened and the reason the CA dealer took the firearm into their inventory. They did not take it in for service or repair, they took it into inventory for the sole purpose of shipping it to another FFL holder.

          Does this exemption allow a CA dealer to receive an off roster firearm from another FFL, log it into their bound book and deliver it to a non-exempt person?
          Yes you can have 2 C&R 03 FFL's; 1 in California and 1 in a different state.

          Originally posted by Erion929

          Comment

          • #35
            dskell
            Senior Member
            • May 2009
            • 825

            Originally posted by morrcarr67
            As far as I know that PC is set up for a dealer themselves to do work on an off roster handgun and return it to the owner.

            Does it allow for a dealer to return an off roster firearm to a non-exempt person that they did not do the work on?

            If a dealer "takes in a firearm for shipment", the proper way to do so would be to log said firearm into their bound book. When they ship said firearm to a FFL holder they then log it out of their bound book. Same thing in reverse, when they receive the firearm back from the FFL they shipped it to they must now log it into their bound book.

            The shipping to another dealer/manufacture/gunsmith and getting it shipped back in changes what has happened and the reason the CA dealer took the firearm into their inventory. They did not take it in for service or repair, they took it into inventory for the sole purpose of shipping it to another FFL holder.

            Does this exemption allow a CA dealer to receive an off roster firearm from another FFL, log it into their bound book and deliver it to a non-exempt person?
            Do you have a source for that info?

            Yes, it does allow for a dealer to return an off-roster firearm to a non-exempt person without having been the FFL that did the service.

            You are correct about the process; bringing it in to the A&D, taking it out of the A&D when it has been shipped. However, this does not change the status of the firearm relative to the exemption listed above. The firearm is being shipped, but it was brought in for repair and is listed as such.

            As stated in the PC, this exemption only allows for a dealer to receive an off-roster firearm from another FFL and deliver it to a non-exempt person for the purposes of repair or service.

            Comment

            • #36
              dskell
              Senior Member
              • May 2009
              • 825

              Originally posted by TrailerparkTrash
              Solution: Glock. Easy.
              LOL. I have reacquainted myself with my trusty G19.

              Comment

              • #37
                Palmaris
                Calguns Addict
                • Mar 2009
                • 6578

                When we are saying dealer-are we talking about Sig dealer or FFL in general?
                sd_shooter:
                CGN couch patriots: "We the people!"

                In real life: No one

                Comment

                • #38
                  Palmaris
                  Calguns Addict
                  • Mar 2009
                  • 6578

                  That striking assembly just $59. We can keep spare as consumable. Like we keep spare bolt for AR15 kind of rifles.
                  sd_shooter:
                  CGN couch patriots: "We the people!"

                  In real life: No one

                  Comment

                  • #39
                    Kabitz
                    Member
                    • Oct 2015
                    • 206

                    Originally posted by dskell
                    That is incorrect for a firearm that is brought in for repair. As long as the same serial number is returned, it would not need to be DROS'ed and thus, the roster is irrelevant. If they replaced the firearm with a new SN, I would be SOL at that point.
                    THIS !
                    John 3:16

                    Comment

                    • #40
                      morrcarr67
                      I need a LIFE!!
                      • Jul 2010
                      • 15074

                      Originally posted by dskell
                      Do you have a source for that info?

                      Yes, it does allow for a dealer to return an off-roster firearm to a non-exempt person without having been the FFL that did the service.
                      My source is the the PC.
                      Yes you can have 2 C&R 03 FFL's; 1 in California and 1 in a different state.

                      Originally posted by Erion929

                      Comment

                      • #41
                        dskell
                        Senior Member
                        • May 2009
                        • 825

                        Originally posted by morrcarr67
                        My source is the the PC.
                        Where in the PC does it state that the repairs must be completed by the FFL that the firearm is brought to? Maybe you're seeing something I'm not.

                        Comment

                        • #42
                          SkyHawk
                          I need a LIFE!!
                          • Sep 2012
                          • 23532

                          I believe the PC allows a FFL to ship and receive on behalf of a customer for purposes of repair and return the gun to them without a DROS.

                          The problem is many FFLs do not see it that way. And for all we know (and it would hardly be a surprise), there are DOJ reps who tell them they cannot. That is why we frequently advise to never involve an FFL especially if it is off roster.

                          With the screws being turned by UPS and Fedex now, we may need a come to Jesus on the topic - perhaps in the form of guidance to dealers from 2A advocacy groups.
                          Last edited by SkyHawk; 09-20-2022, 10:39 AM.
                          Click here for my iTrader Feedback thread: https://www.calguns.net/forum/market...r-feedback-100

                          Comment

                          • #43
                            morrcarr67
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • Jul 2010
                            • 15074

                            Originally posted by dskell
                            Where in the PC does it state that the repairs must be completed by the FFL that the firearm is brought to? Maybe you're seeing something I'm not.
                            Originally posted by SkyHawk
                            I believe the PC allows a FFL to ship and receive on behalf of a customer for purposes of repair and return the gun to them without a DROS.

                            The problem is many FFLs do not see it that way. And for all we know (and it would hardly be a surprise), there are DOJ reps who tell them they cannot. That is why we frequently advise to never involve an FFL especially if it is off roster.

                            With the screws being turned by UPS and Fedex now, we may need a come to Jesus on the topic - perhaps in the form of guidance to dealers from 2A advocacy groups.
                            I'm not going to re-post the code, you can go back and rip it apart if you like.

                            The code is written for a CA licensed gun dealer/gunsmith in mind.

                            The code is written that said CA dealer/gunsmith may take in handguns for service or repair and that the CA Safe Handgun roster does not apply to the return of said handgun.

                            This I think we can all agree on. Right?

                            It's the part about the shipping that is getting you guys hung up on.

                            As I mentioned before, when ever a Federally licensed gun dealer/gunsmith/pawnbroker/manufacture takes in a firearm they have to "log it into their 'Acquisition and Disposition' book".

                            I'm pretty sure that we can all agree on this too. Right?

                            Now let's follow the A&D book.

                            Example One:

                            Ocean Bob brings in his off roster handgun to Skyhawk's LGS.

                            Skyhawk will log this handgun into his A&D book.

                            Someone who works at Skyhawk's LGS does all the work to Ocean Bob's handgun there at their location.

                            Skayhawk calls Ocean Bob and tells him all the work is done and he can now come and get his handgun.

                            Ocean Bob shows up at Skyhawk's LGS and picks up his off roster handgun.

                            Skyhawk will now enter into his A&D book that he returned the handgun to Ocean Bob.

                            Acquisition = Ocean Bob - Disposition = Ocean Bob

                            I think it fair to say that nobody has any problem with example one. Right?

                            Now let's move on to example two, the shipping.

                            Ocean Bob brings in his off roster handgun and ask Skyhawk's LGS to ship their gun to Super Gunsmith in any other state USA to get some work done to it.

                            So again let's follow the A&D book:

                            Ocean Bob brings in the handgun, Skyhawk logs it into his A&D book. Skyhawk packs and ships the handgun to Super Gunsmith, he now logs it out of his A&D book to Super Gunsmith. This now closes that line in the A&D book and nothing more can be done to it.

                            Acquisition = Ocean Bob - Disposition = Super Gunsmith

                            4 weeks later Super Gunsmith ships the handgun back to Skyhawk's LGS. At this time Skyhawk logs this "NEW" "Acquisition" in to his A&D book showing that he just "acquired" it from Super Gunsmith.

                            This is where the issue comes into play.

                            Skyhawk's LGS didn't do the work but instead sent it out. When it comes back to Skyhawk's LGS it's a completely new acquisition in his A&D book.

                            How is he going to process that?

                            His A&D book will now show that he acquired an off roster handgun from an OOS gunsmith and delivered it to a person that is not roster exempt.

                            Acquisition = Super Gunsmith - Disposition = Ocean Bob

                            It's for this reason you can not have a CA dealer ship an off roster handgun to an OOS dealer/manufacture/gunsmith for repair and expect the CA dealer to be able to return your firearm to you.

                            I could be wrong, but no one has posted anything to prove the contrary .
                            Last edited by morrcarr67; 09-20-2022, 1:07 PM.
                            Yes you can have 2 C&R 03 FFL's; 1 in California and 1 in a different state.

                            Originally posted by Erion929

                            Comment

                            • #44
                              dskell
                              Senior Member
                              • May 2009
                              • 825

                              Originally posted by morrcarr67
                              I'm not going to re-post the code, you can go back and rip it apart if you like.

                              The code is written for a CA licensed gun dealer/gunsmith in mind.

                              The code is written that said CA dealer/gunsmith may take in handguns for service or repair and that the CA Safe Handgun roster does not apply to the return of said handgun.


                              This I think we can all agree on. Right?

                              It's the part about the shipping that is getting you guys hung up on.

                              As I mentioned before, when ever a Federally licensed gun dealer/gunsmith/pawnbroker/manufacture takes in a firearm they have to "log it into their 'Acquisition and Disposition' book".

                              I'm pretty sure that we can all agree on this too. Right?

                              Now let's follow the A&D book.

                              Example One:

                              Ocean Bob brings in his off roster handgun to Skyhawk's LGS.

                              Skyhawk will log this handgun into his A&D book.

                              Someone who works at Skyhawk's LGS does all the work to Ocean Bob's handgun there at their location.

                              Skayhawk calls Ocean Bob and tells him all the work is done and he can now come and get his handgun.

                              Ocean Bob shows up at Skyhawk's LGS and picks up his off roster handgun.

                              Skyhawk will now enter into his A&D book that he returned the handgun to Ocean Bob.

                              Acquisition = Ocean Bob - Disposition = Ocean Bob

                              I think it fair to say that nobody has any problem with example one. Right?

                              Now let's move on to example two, the shipping.

                              Ocean Bob brings in his off roster handgun and ask Skyhawk's LGS to ship their gun to Super Gunsmith in any other state USA to get some work done to it.

                              So again let's follow the A&D book:

                              Ocean Bob brings in the handgun, Skyhawk logs it into his A&D book. Skyhawk packs and ships the handgun to Super Gunsmith, he now logs it out of his A&D book to Super Gunsmith. This now closes that line in the A&D book and nothing more can be done to it.

                              Acquisition = Ocean Bob - Disposition = Super Gunsmith

                              4 weeks later Super Gunsmith ships the handgun back to Skyhawk's LGS. At this time Skyhawk logs this "NEW" "Acquisition" in to his A&D book showing that he just "acquired" it from Super Gunsmith.

                              This is where the issue comes into play.

                              Skyhawk's LGS didn't do the work but instead sent it out. When it comes back to Skyhawk's LGS it's a completely new acquisition in his A&D book.

                              How is he going to process that?

                              His A&D book will now show that he acquired an off roster handgun from an OOS gunsmith and delivered it to a person that is not roster exempt.

                              Acquisition = Super Gunsmith - Disposition = Ocean Bob

                              It's for this reason you can not have a CA dealer ship an off roster handgun to an OOS dealer/manufacture/gunsmith for repair and expect the CA dealer to be able to return your firearm to you.

                              I could be wrong, but no one has posted anything to prove the contrary .
                              I agree with you on everything except for the bolded sections in the quote above.

                              The code does not state that you must be a gunsmith. If the firearm is delivered to the licensee (could be a gunsmith, but doesn't have to be) for the purposes of the service or repair of that firearm, then it may be returned to that owner upon completion of the work.

                              Additionally, the code does not state that the exemption only applies when the work is completed by the licensee that the firearm is delivered to. It can be, but this is not a requirement.

                              The law does not state either of these things anywhere. That proves the contrary of what you are saying. I am merely going off of what the law says.

                              Some anecdotal evidence: my business has processed repairs on off-roster firearms belonging to non-exempt individuals exactly as outlined above. Records of these transactions have been reviewed in subsequent DOJ audits and have not caused issue. The company I work for, nor myself are licensed gunsmiths.

                              Comment

                              • #45
                                dskell
                                Senior Member
                                • May 2009
                                • 825

                                Originally posted by SkyHawk
                                I believe the PC allows a FFL to ship and receive on behalf of a customer for purposes of repair and return the gun to them without a DROS.

                                The problem is many FFLs do not see it that way. And for all we know (and it would hardly be a surprise), there are DOJ reps who tell them they cannot. That is why we frequently advise to never involve an FFL especially if it is off roster.

                                With the screws being turned by UPS and Fedex now, we may need a come to Jesus on the topic - perhaps in the form of guidance to dealers from 2A advocacy groups.
                                100% agree. In no way am I advocating that people do this, as I am sure many dealers would not be comfortable returning it to you. Just pointing out that legally speaking, it can be done.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1