IMO, the Sig is a better engineered 1911. Holding it just feels sooo good. The Springfield is a great all-around 1911. As for recoil, I have found the Springfield is slightly better managing the energy then a Sig (that's with using the same grips on each pistol).
It comes down with what YOU are most comfortable with. DOn't drive yourself nuts which to purchase. Flip a coin as no matter which pistol you buy, you'll have a smile on your face.
It comes down with what YOU are most comfortable with. DOn't drive yourself nuts which to purchase. Flip a coin as no matter which pistol you buy, you'll have a smile on your face.

Comment