Full size .45 1911 - Ladies, make some suggestions

[pterrell]

I'm a Sig fan myself although I've given serious thought to a Wilson Combat or a Colt (that I'll actually shoot).

[3RDGEARGRNDRR]

Hi Ladies, I'm looking to pick up an uber small 1911 style pistol for my wife for off body carry.
She likes the look of the Purple Pearl Sig P238, and partly expects me to purchase that,




I'm considering just surprising her with a Kimber Sapphire Carry instead, in 9mm,
although she hasnt shot a lot of 9mm, she shoots 38spl regularly.



What is the consensus of the crowd on this one?
Should I not override the wife's previous opinion?

[Tragic Image]

I watched a P238 malfunction all weekend long at a 2 day class this past Saturday and Sunday.

[BonnieB]

Generally, it's a better idea to let a woman select and buy her own gun, after renting/borrowing/shooting, to confirm fit. Don't buy a gun for your S/O unless she has already confirmed her choice. Specifically, do not buy her a different gun than the one she wants. Really.

[3RDGEARGRNDRR]

Thanks Bonnie. I kind of figured as much.
And i have a p238 that has been flawless so far. It has mag problems but the latest mags run fine

[Steyrlp10]

Well said Bonnie. There's nothing worse than having something crammed at you without a vote, not to mention the cost of the product that you don't like!

[A-J]

This thread is posted in the Women's Forum. If you OT fans are tempted to pile on, don't bother. We don't like it and we push back. However, constructive comments are always welcome.

This thread is for the women who shoot .45 1911's particularly.

Ladies,

I'm considering a .45 1911 for my next purchase. I kinda got a bug for this and the clock is ticking on our chances for off-roster SSE guns.

I shoot .40 polymer subcompacts routinely, and am ready for the next step. I'm thinking full size, all metal 1911, because I already have plenty of small light guns.

The sexiness of the Desert Eagle appeals to me. The Ruger SR appeals to me esthetically. I always like Colts. I kinda like the Sig 220, assuming I can get one.

So, what do you women shoot, in .45? My requirements involve accuracy, reliability, un-fussiness about ammo. I'm not interested in a revolver. I think I'd like a wood grip, and I never expect to carry this one unless the apocalypse strike, so 'bigger is better'.

New requirement: replaceable sights, prefer USA made but not an exclusive requirement, not more than $1,000.

Unfortunately, I can't find a .45 in Rainbow, or that would solve the problem in one step.

So, whadya think?

My wife handled multiple 1911s at the range, and the one that "just felt right" to her was the Kimber Custom II. It's her one and only gun and she loves it, doesn't want anything else.

[BonnieB]

The more I pursue this, the more I'm hearing that how the gun feels in your hand is one of the most important factors when a woman (or man) chooses a full size .45 1911. People are telling me, and I believe it, that when you finally pick up the right gun for you, it feels like it's always been there, like well-worn jeans or properly broken-in boots.

This is not to discount performance, quality, price, etc. But it is a new perspective and could make gun selection a whole lot easier for me.

[Snoopy47]

The more I pursue this, the more I'm hearing that how the gun feels in your hand is one of the most important factors when a woman (or man) chooses a full size .45 1911.

I just want to point out that almost any 1911 can be made to feel like any other 1911.

The trigger, grips, manual safety, beaver safety and main spring housing can all be swapped out and make a 1911 feel vastly different from it's original configuration.

The front strap checkering is the only thing that might be un-changeable, and if it lacks it, skate board tape can be added (or not).

I and my lady find a smooth fitting pistol with warm contours doesn't make for a solid grip needed for accuracy and follow up shots.

A $500 1911 can be made to feel a lot like a $1500 one when only holding it with the eyes closed.