Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

LEO checking guns at the range

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #61
    Sniper3142
    Veteran Member
    • May 2004
    • 2579

    Originally posted by grammaton76
    Wouldn't SEEING (not even having to touch) a featured AR without a bullet button in the hands of someone who appears to be too young to have acquired it in 2000 constitute Reasonable Articulable Suspicion for a violation of AW law anyway?

    My understanding is that once they have RAS, escalating to detention is well within their rights.
    No it wouldn't (in my humble Non-LEO opinion).

    The age of the person isn't PC or RS of a crime or illegal activity. They could be active military and have a MAWP.

    And regarding these "searches" or "checks"...
    I have no problem with anyone LOOKING and my property. However, anyone trying to touch my property without my permission would be well advised to ASK first.
    Internet Talk is Cheap

    Man Up, Show Up, or Shut the @#$! Up.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C74HgbjSCLM

    Comment

    • #62
      SVT-40
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Jan 2008
      • 12918

      Both of your examples are related to incidents related to "searches" of a home (apartment). Far different situation than a object in plain view in a public place.

      You really need to study the difference between probable cause and reasonable suspicion.

      If a LEO is legally present in a location and sees an object which he reasonably believes to be illegal he can make detentions and investigate to determine if a crime is occurring.


      So a LEO who was at a public range and saw what he reasonable believed to be a illegal weapon he could detain the possessor of the firearm and investigate to determine if in fact a crime was occurring.

      The LEO does not have to absolutely know the firearm is illegal. All that is required is that he has a reasonable suspicion a crime is occurring.

      The same is true with many vehicle stops.

      Take the violation of a vehicle which is modified so that it's to low . Meaning some part of the vehicle is lower that the lowest portion of the rims (read 24008 CVC).

      Reasonable suspicion allows an officer who sees a vehicle on the street which appears to be to low to stop said vehicle and detain the driver to investigate if in fact the vehicle is to low.

      The officer does not need to absolutely know the vehicle is to low. All he needs is a reasonable suspicion that the vehicle is to low.

      There could be many situations where a reasonable LEO could believe a firearm is in a illegal configuration based on appearance alone.

      One example is a so called "10-30" magazine. If a LEO saw a firearm which was equipped with a "bullet button" type device and a so called "10-30" mag. He could reasonable believe that a crime was occurring because the "10-30" magazine reasonably appeared to be a true 30 round mag.

      We all know it's currently against the law to use a over 10 round mag in "bullet button" required firearms.

      So do many LEO's.

      This knowledge would make it reasonable for the LEO to believe a crime was occurring and make a detention to conduct a investigation..
      Last edited by SVT-40; 08-18-2011, 12:09 PM.
      Poke'm with a stick!


      Originally posted by fiddletown
      What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

      Comment

      • #63
        SVT-40
        I need a LIFE!!
        • Jan 2008
        • 12918

        Originally posted by Sniper3142
        No it wouldn't (in my humble Non-LEO opinion).

        The age of the person isn't PC or RS of a crime or illegal activity. They could be active military and have a MAWP.

        And regarding these "searches" or "checks"...
        I have no problem with anyone LOOKING and my property. However, anyone trying to touch my property without my permission would be well advised to ASK first.
        Here is a great example of thinking from the wrong angle.

        The standard for "reasonable" in searches is the "reasonable officer standard".

        It's all about what a reasonable officer believed at the time of the incident. Not what was discovered later.

        So if a officer saw what he reasonably believed was a criminal violation he can make detentions and conduct inspections or searches to determine if in fact a crime is occurring.

        So age could be a factor in a situation which could add to a officers suspicion that a crime is occurring.
        Last edited by SVT-40; 08-18-2011, 12:04 PM.
        Poke'm with a stick!


        Originally posted by fiddletown
        What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

        Comment

        • #64
          retired
          Administrator
          CGN Contributor - Lifetime
          • Sep 2007
          • 9413

          Originally posted by CSACANNONEER
          Unconsitutional or not is not the issue. The mere fact that an exception (which clearly applies here) is written right into the law is enough for even the dumbest attorney to understand that this law simply does not apply in this case period.

          Glad you called and got information about the range being subject to searches. Having never been there, I don't know if the ranges patrons sign away their personal rights not to be search or if the searches you are speaking of are just for the range and it's personal property. I totally agree that Federal LEOs have the right to be there and to enforce both state and local laws. However, I still don't see anything in writting giving them the legal authority to randomly search anyone's personal property. So, if they are going to enforce the law, the either have the legal authority to do these searches or, they should be arresting themselves. All anyone here is asking is for someone to cite why, if indeed they do, have the legal authority to do what they are doing. All you have done is spouted some babble and shown everone here how a good sheeple acts.
          Knock off the personal attack.
          retired


          BTW, I didn't mean to attack you because you are a former LEO. Based on your posts (about non existent laws) in this thread, I had no idea that you had any legal training
          It is a still a personal attack and it doesn't make a difference whether he was a former leo or not; it is a personal attack against another member and not permitted, so don't do it anymore.
          Last edited by retired; 08-18-2011, 12:53 AM.

          Comment

          • #65
            retired
            Administrator
            CGN Contributor - Lifetime
            • Sep 2007
            • 9413

            IIRC, there was a comment about turning a rifle over so the mag release button or BB wasn't visible. As applies to the Range staff only, that isn't going to work during a line break.

            I have been going to Lytle Creek for 10yrs. and during the line break and before anyone is permitted to go down range to check or replace their targets, the range staff will inspect every firearm on the tables to ensure they are not loaded. When they call a cease fire, they want the firearms in a position where the actions are open if a rifle or semi auto pistol and and the cylinder open so they can verify the weapon is devoid of ammo; a simple safety precaution.

            Turning it over or putting a blanket over it doesn't work, it will be checked for safety reasons.

            That was what the range staff used to to do that for and when doing so, no one went down range until all ROs gave the clear from their area. I am glad they do, because I've been there when ammo has been found in the chamber of a firearm.

            I've also been there when a new employee did not do a good check on a mosin nagant. After checking and passing that father and son weapons (both adults), the father and son decided to leave and took their rifles back to their truck while people were down line (against the rules). As the father put his rifle in the bed of his truck (next to mine), it fired (since his finger was on the trigger) and the round went into the front seat, narrowly missing his wife. Most of us had our ear protection off at the time.

            That should answer the questions as to why the Range staff are, or at least were checking all firearms during the cease fire and before allowing people downrange. I haven't been there since early this year and I would agree strongly that allowing people downrange while leos are putting hands on weapons should not be permitted due to the possible danger involved.

            As far as any applicable case law to the OP's question, I will refrain from being involved in that as I've been gone from le long enough to not be up on case law in that area.

            My sole purpose with this post was to advise everyone who was curious as to why the ROs have always examined the firearms during the cease fire. They also will not permit anyone to touch ammo, mags or clips and everyone must be off of the sidewalk area by the benches. All for safety reasons.

            Comment

            • #66
              Matt C
              Calguns Addict
              • Feb 2006
              • 7128

              Originally posted by SVT-40
              Both of your examples are related to incidents related to "searches" of a home (apartment). Far different situation than a object in plain view in a public place.
              You may not have a clear understanding of how case law works. Neither case can be distinguished by the mere fact that a dwelling was not involved as the primary authority itself specifically states that the entering of the dwelling was a separate "search", which was lawful based on the intent of the the LEO, but that the moving of the item was a second "search", which falls under the purview of the 4th amendment and absent some other exemption required a warrant; certainly it did not base the holding on the specific factor of a dwelling in either case. This is settled law, ignore it at your own peril. In fact considering that you have been provided the legal references here to correct your misconception, this could be used against you in court and weaken your personal immunity.

              Originally posted by SVT-40
              Here is a great example of thinking from the wrong angle.

              The standard for "reasonable" in searches is the "reasonable officer standard".

              It's all about what a reasonable officer believed at the time of the incident. Not what was discovered later.

              So if a officer saw what he believed to reasonable believed was a criminal violation he can make detentions and conduct inspections or searches to determine if in fact a crime is occurring.
              Totally agree, that is called good police work. Note that a misconception of the FACTS and a misconception of the LAW, are very different things.

              Originally posted by retired
              I haven't been there since early this year and I would agree strongly that allowing people downrange while leos are putting hands on weapons should not be permitted due to the possible danger involved.
              Yes, if they see something they really need to investigate there is no good reason not to wait until the range is clear before they go messing with what could be a loaded gun.
              Last edited by Matt C; 08-18-2011, 2:10 AM.
              I do not provide legal services or practice law (yet).

              The troublemaker formerly known as Blackwater OPS.

              Comment

              • #67
                sandman21
                Senior Member
                • Apr 2010
                • 1145

                Originally posted by SVT-40
                Both of your examples are related to incidents related to "searches" of a home (apartment). Far different situation than a object in plain view in a public place.
                It does not change anything; the search of the equipment was a separate search from the home, requiring justification for that search.

                Originally posted by SVT-40
                You really need to study the difference between probable cause and reasonable suspicion.
                Nothing you posted changes the fact that AZ v. Hicks requires the LEO to have PC to perform a search/seizure of an object in plain view; RAS has nothing to do with it. If you have another case, I do not know about, I would be happy to read it. However, a rifle positioned so you cant see the BB or covered requires PC to perform a search/seizure.

                Comment

                • #68
                  Ron-Solo
                  In Memoriam
                  • Jan 2009
                  • 8581

                  Sorry Sandman, but you are interpreting these cases incorrectly. Like SVT-40 said, they apply to different types of situations.

                  If I see a rifle that "could" be a prohibited weapon based on my training and experience, I do not need a warrant to examine it further. The courts have held that said inspection is reasonable under the circumstances.

                  Search and seizure is like Legos. You need more than one piece to build anything, it can be missing some pieces or have holes in it, as long as the right pieces are filled in, it will work. It doesn't have to be completely filled in.

                  I have testified in hundreds of 1538.5 motions (Motions to supress the evidence) and have never had evidence supressed by the court.

                  Having "knowledge" obtained from books/reading is not as practical as that obtained from hands on experience on the job. SVT-40, like myself, has plenty of working knowledge.
                  LASD Retired
                  1978-2011

                  NRA Life Member
                  CRPA Life Member
                  NRA Rifle Instructor
                  NRA Shotgun Instructor
                  NRA Range Safety Officer
                  DOJ Certified Instructor

                  Comment

                  • #69
                    GunSafari
                    Member
                    • Apr 2011
                    • 383

                    This I have seen often, checking if weapons are unloaded etc which makes sense since not everyone handles their weapons reasonably around other people. Other then that I have never seen them checking legality of weapons
                    sigpic
                    daniel@gunsafari.com
                    www.GunSafari.com
                    www.facebook.com/GunSafari like us and be the first to hear of the latest deals coming from us
                    Coupon codes: "ontarget" 10% off trijicon, "aimlow" 5% off aimpoint
                    FFL coming May 2012...

                    Comment

                    • #70
                      sandman21
                      Senior Member
                      • Apr 2010
                      • 1145

                      Originally posted by Ron-Solo
                      Sorry Sandman, but you are interpreting these cases incorrectly. Like SVT-40 said, they apply to different types of situations.

                      If I see a rifle that "could" be a prohibited weapon based on my training and experience, I do not need a warrant to examine it further. The courts have held that said inspection is reasonable under the circumstances.
                      Which case am I interpreting incorrectly? Are you suggesting that RAS is all that is needed to seize an item thought to be contraband? Which case is that?


                      Originally posted by Ron-Solo
                      Search and seizure is like Legos. You need more than one piece to build anything, it can be missing some pieces or have holes in it, as long as the right pieces are filled in, it will work. It doesn't have to be completely filled in.

                      I have testified in hundreds of 1538.5 motions (Motions to supress the evidence) and have never had evidence supressed by the court.

                      Having "knowledge" obtained from books/reading is not as practical as that obtained from hands on experience on the job. SVT-40, like myself, has plenty of working knowledge.

                      Comment

                      • #71
                        bigfrank
                        Member
                        • Oct 2009
                        • 190

                        Originally posted by TrailerparkTrash
                        Yes, you're on U.S. Forestry land up at Lytle Creek. If you want to shoot on their land, you have to follow and abide by their rules. Plain and simple.

                        Now, I suppose that if you refuese to show them your gun, they'd without a doubt kick you off the range. If you have a legal firearm, you have nothing to worry about, except of a slight inconvenience of your time.

                        That being said, it makes me angry that they are checking guys out on the range, when they should be out checking for marijuana grows and the illegals with their AK's plowing the fields out on OUR forest public land.
                        It's not "THEIR" land, it's ours.
                        State of Jefferson Firearms Training
                        NRA Certified Instruction
                        Personal Protection
                        Pistol
                        CRSO
                        Utah Certified Instructor
                        Ca. and Utah CCW classes

                        Comment

                        • #72
                          Ron-Solo
                          In Memoriam
                          • Jan 2009
                          • 8581

                          "Back handed insult" ?? You seriously don't get it! There was no insult there, and you are just reaching now.

                          I don't know what you do for a living, but knowing the basics of how a car works does not make me an automotive repairman. Reading a few case law citations and taking things out of context, does not qualify you on search and seizure.

                          I have tried to explain things to you, and you keep throwing up smoke and mirrors, so I'm done waiting my breath.
                          LASD Retired
                          1978-2011

                          NRA Life Member
                          CRPA Life Member
                          NRA Rifle Instructor
                          NRA Shotgun Instructor
                          NRA Range Safety Officer
                          DOJ Certified Instructor

                          Comment

                          • #73
                            5shot
                            Senior Member
                            • May 2008
                            • 1265

                            This could be another area where people end up shooting themselves in the foot. Lytle Creek and many other places in the So. Cal. National Forests use to be open to shooting, free, unsupervised, to anyone.
                            But the slobs came in, and the Forest Service got tired of bringing in dump trucks to haul away the shot up cars, refrigerators, tv's, etc. every year. Budgets got tighter, and staff got smaller, and the slobs increased. So they closed the majority of the shooting areas.
                            Instead of just closing the areas forever, they got private concessionaires to run the shooting areas in a clean orderly fashion, with safety personal on site to supervise. This took many years, and a lot of negotiation with the Forest Service. The concessionaires were given "conditional use" permits. Which means they/you can "use" these areas with certain "conditions". Some of those conditions are "no illegal" firearms, and firearms used on the range are "subject to inspection by law enforcement".
                            Now if someone doesn't want to abide by the conditions, they don't have to shoot there. Being public land/property doesn't mean it's yours to do what ever you want on it. You have a campfire in the forest, you'll be checked for a campfire permit. You launch a boat at most public lakes, it'll be inspected for safety equipment, quagga mussels, ext. You ride a dirt bike on public land, it can be inspected for spark arrestors, etc. You walk into some public buildings, you'll go thru a metal detector. etc, etc, etc.
                            Sure you can protest the gun checks at Forest Service ranges, even hire a ton of attorneys to represent your cause. But the Forest Service will take the easy way out. They won't be fighting your case all the way to the Supreme Court. Just like in the past, they'll save money and just close the shooting areas.
                            John Bishop
                            Member: NRA Life, CRPA, WEGC

                            Comment

                            • #74
                              Vacaville
                              Veteran Member
                              • Nov 2008
                              • 4360

                              Originally posted by Ron-Solo
                              "Back handed insult" ?? You seriously don't get it! There was no insult there, and you are just reaching now.

                              I don't know what you do for a living, but knowing the basics of how a car works does not make me an automotive repairman. Reading a few case law citations and taking things out of context, does not qualify you on search and seizure.

                              I have tried to explain things to you, and you keep throwing up smoke and mirrors, so I'm done waiting my breath.
                              I went back and looked at your posts, and you did state that somehow reading the law does not give him the same expertise in these matters that you and SVT-40 have due to your on-the-job experience. That was the insult.
                              Last edited by Vacaville; 08-18-2011, 1:28 PM.

                              Comment

                              • #75
                                Ron-Solo
                                In Memoriam
                                • Jan 2009
                                • 8581

                                Originally posted by Vacaville
                                I went back and looked at your posts, and you did state that somehow reading the law somehow does not give him the same expertise in these matters that you and SVT-40 have due to your on-the-job experience. That was the insult.
                                I was just stating fact, based on years of experience. If someone feels that is an insult, they are reaching in my opinion.

                                Reading a book on plumbing does not make me an expert on plumbing, but I'm not insulted by that.

                                Maybe it is just the extra thick layer of skin I had to develop to fend off the countless insults I've had to endure as a law enforcement officer.
                                LASD Retired
                                1978-2011

                                NRA Life Member
                                CRPA Life Member
                                NRA Rifle Instructor
                                NRA Shotgun Instructor
                                NRA Range Safety Officer
                                DOJ Certified Instructor

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1