Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
El Monte PD
Collapse
X
-
That's not quite how it works. . .
Again, not quite how it works. . .
Actually the high-cap "law" is unconstitutional and an informed juror should find as such at trial.
In this case, however well deserved the kick was, the officer delivering the blow was violating the perp's rights by administering roadside justice.
Sure there are few here who would defend this particular scumbag, but in reality we cannot afford to cede this power to the police. They will use it against the wrong people as well as the "right" ones. In fact, in numerous cases, they have.Erik
NRA Life Member
Sig fan.Comment
-
That's not quite how it works. . .
Again, not quite how it works. . .
Actually the high-cap "law" is unconstitutional and an informed juror should find as such at trial.
In this case, however well deserved the kick was, the officer delivering the blow was violating the perp's rights by administering roadside justice.
Sure there are few here who would defend this particular scumbag, but in reality we cannot afford to cede this power to the police. They will use it against the wrong people as well as the "right" ones. In fact, in numerous cases, they have.Comment
-
(\__/)
(='.'=)
(")_(") Copy and paste this bunny into your signature to help him gain world domination.!!!
sigpicComment
-
A bit of both.
Sure you can vote however you want on a jury but you really do need to bring reason and the rule of law into the debate.
Correct. Even if the judge tells the jury to ignore The Constitution in their deliberations.
No, because it's illegal for anyone to assault another like that. Self defense is one thing but that was not the case in this instance.
Again, I don't like gang members, don't particularly care if this gang banger or any other lives or dies and so on.
I just know that it's unlawful for someone to attack a defenseless person. In fact, it's a gross abuse of authority for a cop to do it to a detainee without provocation.Erik
NRA Life Member
Sig fan.Comment
-
look everyone, clearly the opinion of Erik S. Klein should be negated in light of the fact that this is a man who's judgment includes posting very personal info about himself online such that anyone with knowledge of Google and 2 minutes to spare can find out more about him than they probably care.Comment
-
Welcome to calguns, guy...look everyone, clearly the opinion of Erik S. Klein should be negated in light of the fact that this is a man who's judgment includes posting very personal info about himself online such that anyone with knowledge of Google and 2 minutes to spare can find out more about him than they probably care.
I, for one, have enjoyed reading this interaction. It has represented two starkly different views (neither of which i totally share, but both are fascinating), discussed the situation in a civil manner, and has not resorted to off-topic, mud-slinging comments until.....well....yours.
Please stay on topic.
Thank you.Comment
-
Fair enough.
The difference, of course, is that one option is rational - i.e. fact based.
The other is reactive - i.e. emotion based.
But like I said you can do what you want.Erik
NRA Life Member
Sig fan.Comment
-
Until you're put in the life threatening situation of a person running from you...a person of whom you have little or no knowledge other than the fact they are running and putting COUNTLESS lives in jeopardy, you cannot judge this officer by this move. It was on blow to keep this obviously deranged person from formulating and executing a plan to disarm and kill this officer and possibly others.
Any felony arrest situation that calls for a suspect to be proned looking AWAY. This keeps the suspect unaware of your location so you can effect a safe arrest. When you go hands on, this is the single most dangerous time, especially when you are dealing with an unreasonable person. This guy laid himself down, then looked back toward the officer at the last moment. What's to say he wasn't armed and waiting for the right time to strike? This blow kept him reeling so the arrest could be executed and that officer could go home to his family.
The officer didn't create the situation, the suspect did. Keep this in mind. There are many tactics one develops over the course of their career that aren't covered in a text book at the academy. I see this distraction blow as nothing different than if the officer jumped into the guys kidneys with his knees.
Had the officer delivered more than one blow, you have brutality. This was designed to bring a dangerous situation to conclusion with no loss of life.Comment
-
I would point out that the military is subject to the UCMJ, which mostly covers things they might do in the connection with their duties. So in connection with those duties, they are not entirely subject to the same laws the rest of us are, although they are often subject to both.In the US, yes, with some exception for wartime.So using your logic you believe our soldiers, sailors, air men and Marines should be subject to the same laws as other citizens???
This is explicitly constitutional, being a power granted to congress.bob
Disclaimers: I am not a lawyer, cop, soldier, gunsmith, politician, plumber, electrician, or a professional practitioner of many of the other things I comment on in this forum.Comment
-
Update
The LAC DA will not be prosecuting the two El Monte PD officers in this incident.
Excerpted from the San Gabriel Valley Tribune:
Rodriguez has filed a claim for $5 million in damages from the city.D.A. declines to file charges against El Monte cop in kicking case
By Brian Charles, Staff Writer
Posted: 12/29/2009 11:39:30 PM PST
County prosecutors won't file charges against an El Monte police officer caught on tape kicking a gang member in the head after a pursuit that ended in Pico Rivera, officials said Tuesday.
Neither El Monte police Officer George Fierro nor Officer James Singleterry face charges in the May 13 incident, which was shown on live television.
In his report declining to file charges, Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney Jason P. Lustig wrote that Fierro may have been provoked into using a distraction blow when he kicked Richard Rodriguez.
"The physical evidence of Rodriguez's injuries are significantly more consistent with a blow intended to stun or temporarily distract him than with a kick done out of anger or vindictiveness," Lustig wrote in the report, which was released Tuesday.
Singleterry can be seen on video striking Rodriguez with a flashlight. Lustig's report said Singleterry's actions were justified because Rodriguez, a known member of the El Monte Flores street gang, could have been reaching for a weapon.
Lustig described the exchange of a high five by officers after Rodriguez was arrested as a "commonplace" gesture "to signify that no one was injured and that the suspect was captured."
Fierro, who had been assigned to a desk job, will return to patrol. Singleterry was never taken off duty, El Monte police Chief Thomas Armstrong said.x
"Let those find fault whose wit's so very small,
They've need to show that they can think at all;
Errors, like straws, upon the surface flow;
He who would search for pearls, must dive below." -- John DrydenComment
-
A good decision by the DA based on the TOTALITY of the situation.Poke'm with a stick!
Originally posted by fiddletownWhat you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.Comment
-
DiaHero Foundation - helping people manage diabetes. Sending diabetes supplies to Ukraine now, any help is appreciated.
DDR AK furniture and Norinco M14 parts kit: https://www.calguns.net/calgunforum/....php?t=1756292
sigpicComment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,835
Posts: 25,176,407
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,396
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 24129 users online. 160 members and 23969 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.

Comment