Peņa v. Cid (Handgun Roster) **CERT DENIED 6-15-2020**

[gryffinwings]

March of 2017 is not two years from September of 2017. Why CGF has not updated should be addressed to them directly.

I just realized that this video is unavailable on youtube :/

[Burbur]

Perhaps they are anticipating microstamping getting tossed.

I know I'll be in line for a 357 Coonan, hopefully they'll send me a couple.

[conquestking]

Still waiting on this; all I want is a S&W 437, which as you can see, is one of the least offensive weapons out there. All it is is a black 637 but nope, apparently its too unsafe.

https://www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/product_info.php/products_id/719001061/Firearms/Handguns/Smith+%26+Wesson/S%26W+Revolvers/S%26W+437+38SPL%2BP+1.8+COMBAT+5

[TruOil]

I suspect that there have been no updates since nothing has happened. Although state courts are required to issue their decisions within 90 days of oral argument, no such rule applies in the federal court system. The Ninth is the busiest circuit in the nation, and thus decisions are rarely issued with any particular promptness. Plus, as I said above, it might be sitting on the case until the California Supreme Court decides the NSSF appeal, as a dismissal of that case as the State requests would be dispositive.

[abinsinia]

I suspect that there have been no updates since nothing has happened. Although state courts are required to issue their decisions within 90 days of oral argument, no such rule applies in the federal court system. The Ninth is the busiest circuit in the nation, and thus decisions are rarely issued with any particular promptness. Plus, as I said above, it might be sitting on the case until the California Supreme Court decides the NSSF appeal, as a dismissal of that case as the State requests would be dispositive.

I'm not sure how the NSSF case would effect this one. This case was very much argued as if that one didn't matter. Either way microstamping or no, the roster is an illegal gun ban.

[aBrowningfan]

Still waiting on this; all I want is a S&W 437, which as you can see, is one of the least offensive weapons out there. All it is is a black 637 but nope, apparently its too unsafe.

https://www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/...P+1.8+COMBAT+5

I would like to be able to purchase a Sig P225A1.... No high cap magazine, or anything that is otherwise objectionable other than that it is not on the list. Mechanical features on the P225A1 are what are on listed Sigs, but because the P225A1 is not 'listed', I can't purchase. Such a crock of s**t.

[numpty]

I would like to be able to purchase a Sig P225A1.... No high cap magazine, or anything that is otherwise objectionable other than that it is not on the list. Mechanical features on the P225A1 are what are on listed Sigs, but because the P225A1 is not 'listed', I can't purchase. Such a crock of s**t.

Duh! It's not enough, not unsafe.

[cire raeb]

Duh! It's not enough, not unsafe.

So say Gavin Newsom who might end up blowing his balls off.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[LEAD LAUNCHER]

My guess is we'll have a decision sometime between 2018 Jan 01 and Sept 01.
.............

Why the guess of this time period?


I'm honestly skeptical at this point that the roster will ever go away in my lifetime, and my 17 year old will almost certainly have got the hell out of Dodge before it's gone.

He's itchin' to escape this craphole and explore other states.


..

[Paladin]

Why the guess of this time period?

Orals were back in March. My guess is 9 months to a year and a half after that is when the 3-judge panel will most likely release its decision.

I'm honestly skeptical at this point that the roster will ever go away in my lifetime, and my 17 year old will almost certainly have got the hell out of Dodge before it's gone.

He's itchin' to escape this craphole and explore other states.

..

I know you didn't say I said we'd win, but I just want to make sure I did not give anyone that impression.

[Junkie]

Still waiting on this; all I want is a S&W 437, which as you can see, is one of the least offensive weapons out there. All it is is a black 637 but nope, apparently its too unsafe.

https://www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/...P+1.8+COMBAT+5

There's no reason that S&W couldn't get that on the roster if they thought it was worth it.

I would like to be able to purchase a Sig P225A1.... No high cap magazine, or anything that is otherwise objectionable other than that it is not on the list. Mechanical features on the P225A1 are what are on listed Sigs, but because the P225A1 is not 'listed', I can't purchase. Such a crock of s**t.

What's so special about the P225A1? I picked up a P225 a while ago, don't think I spent all that much on it but I forget the exact amount. It's a good gun, but nothing that special IMO.

[Solidsnake87]

Im surprised that there has been no activity on this in 7 months time.

[JackRydden224]

9-12mo is my guess as well

Right now I'm holding off on all off roster purchase no matter how badly I want them. If we don't get anything by March 2018 I'll buy a few things.

Orals were back in March. My guess is 9 months to a year and a half after that is when the 3-judge panel will most likely release its decision.

[JoelHugo1985]

I really can't believe how long that these cases take to flush out. If it were taxes that you owed the Fed you would be in some pretty deep doo-doo for being late to pay, but since it's your freedoms, ya know...

[kemasa]

There is no incentive for the government to rush to do anything. If the law was put on hold until it was shown to be Constitutional by ALL the courts, then you would see a much different response.