Miller v. Bonta 9th Ckt "assault weapons": Held for Duncan result 1-26-24

[TempleKnight]

Newsome called Benitez by name and Newsome was Angry it was awesome .

Is there any video of this? I would like to him whine.

[rplaw]

Courts don't need a reason for a stay. This is why SCOTUS telling them to either state one or expedite was such an unusual move.

There are not enough hours in the day for SCOTUS to micromanage lower courts. This was the easiest thing for them to do in order to get an actual opinion on paper.

This is patently untrue.

Litigants are entitled to a rational explanation for the decisions the courts makes.

Absent that rational decision, a reversal is warranted because the absence of the explanation indicates that the decision was arbitrary and capricious on the part of the court.

Yet the SCOTUS did not do what was required.

[RoyBatty]

Hear Newsom lament Benitez

https://www.kcra.com/article/california-gov-newsom-seeks-limits-on-where-people-can-carry-concealed-guns/42735902

[homelessdude]

Look at the court now as compared to the court we had before Trump. Most court actions will never be fast enough for some people. It's their nature to complain. Why not sit back relax and watch what could be some major changes in the next few months. If they don't happen you will be all rested up to complain and I told you so some more. In the meantime some of us can enjoy the moment. JMO

[Bhobbs]

[SpudmanWP]

Heller & McDonald did not give the legal teams the tools that Bruen did. The proof is the massive amount of decisions that we are already seeing, including ones from Obama & Biden appointees.

[1911su16b870]

Hear Newsom lament Benitez

https://www.kcra.com/article/califor...-guns/42735902

[Sgt Raven]

I see what you're saying - but it took WAY TOO LONG to get Heller, McDonald, Caetano and now Bruen.

Pre Bruen I bet the pro 2A Justices were counting noses.to see who was on their side. Neither side felt they had 5 sure votes. Plus they were looking for just the right case.

[homelessdude]

And you aren't going to change that on the internet.

[Bhobbs]

Heller & McDonald did not give the legal teams the tools that Bruen did. The proof is the massive amount of decisions that we are already seeing, including ones from Obama & Biden appointees.

Well, if you listen to Mark from four boxes diner, he said that Heller already established the text as informed by history standard and did all the historical analysis. Lower courts just decided to use the two step analysis instead.

[SpudmanWP]

Heller was good, but left the door open that Bruen closed.

Pols will always try to "get around" any ruling they can. They will even directly violate a clear ruling as long as nobody catches it.
A good example of that is the spate of "safe storage" laws that directly violate Heller.

Similarly, the requirement that any lawful firearm in the home be disassembled or bound by a trigger lock makes it impossible for citizens to use arms for the core lawful purpose of self-defense and is hence unconstitutional.

[1911su16b870]

Well, if you listen to Mark from four boxes diner, he said that Heller already established the text as informed by history standard and did all the historical analysis. Lower courts just decided to use the two step analysis instead.

Mark's opinion on our goober in chief:

[Drivedabizness]

Heller was good, but left the door open that Bruen closed.

Pols will always try to "get around" any ruling they can. They will even directly violate a clear ruling as long as nobody catches it.
A good example of that is the spate of "safe storage" laws that directly violate Heller.

^^^this^^^

Just the other day, Gov. Brillcream was giving an interview and said openly that they are trying to exploit "every loophole we can" to curtail gun rights.

[Blue]

So what happens when the CaAWB goes away? Do SB23 registrations and the like get flushed?

[SpudmanWP]

Since SB23 only covers registration which is allowed, I think it stays.