Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

1911 extractor problem

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    mtenenhaus
    Veteran Member
    • Jul 2007
    • 3416

    Per the aforementioned Bunker Arms text:
    "The rim itself is also 0.025" vs 0.040" (0.035 act.) in depth. If you fit the 9mm extractor in the same manner as the 45, not only would your claw get reduced to about 0.020" to ensure clearance on variety of cases, it also has to move radially towards the center of the bore to make up for the difference of 0.050" per side case diameter... meaning bending at a greater angle AND removing more material from the fitting pad for clearance in the extractor tunnel to achieve a proper amount of deflection since the extractor tunnel is in the same location on 45 slide and a 9mm slide. As a result of this, many smiths, including myself, have decided that engaging the case with the claw in the extractor groove would allow for maximum contact with the claw on the rim, since you can maximize the entire 0.025" depth, while maintaining less of a bend in the extractor to make contact which is more difficult to tension properly and exacerbates the 90 degree claw angle itself. The 9mm case pressure is around 15,000 psi greater than 45 so the additional expansion in the chamber could use the additional claw contact.

    HOWEVER, it is still very important that neither 45 or 9mm claws contact the case bevel in the extractor groove, as again, this will prevent the case from seating square with the breechface. This can cause issues with both feeding and accuracy. I also take this one step further and add a slight bend down on the extract because just as the case is further in radially, it drops further axially as well when the barrel drops out of battery."

    Comment

    • #17
      CifaldiPrecision
      Vendor/Retailer
      • Aug 2012
      • 1806

      1911 extractor problem

      Originally posted by jimmykan
      I see the 45ACP scenario, and can now visualize the opposite scenario for 9mm.

      Why should they be opposite, though?

      I answered this above and now there is a comment from Brandan Bunker below in the same regards.

      Originally posted by CifaldiPrecision
      The reason for this is the much smaller case rim on the 9mm and the desire to get more hook contact for proper extraction.


      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
      Brett Cifaldi
      Specializing in 1911s
      Cifaldi Precision

      Comment

      • #18
        hntnnut
        Senior Member
        • Jan 2008
        • 1066

        first off thank you to mtenenhaus, those links taught me a lot mainly that extractors are at the same time both more complicated and simpler than I thought.

        tr6guns, the slide is definitely is a 9mm/38 face

        I can get tension thats not the problem, the problem lies in that I cant get a cartridge to sit flat up against the breech face, when I try the case wants to ride up on the case bevel. The only way to fix this that I can see is to decrease the width of the claw itself.
        I ordered a second Extractor by Ed Brown and it seems to Fit much better and not protrude as much and looks like I will be able to tune it without trying to reshape the claw itself.

        Richard
        "This country with it's institutions, belongs to the people who inhabit it. Whenever they shall grow weary of the existing goverment, they can excercise their constitutional right of amending it, or their revolutionary right to dismemember or overthrow it."
        Abe Lincoln

        ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ

        Comment

        • #19
          CifaldiPrecision
          Vendor/Retailer
          • Aug 2012
          • 1806

          Brett Cifaldi
          Specializing in 1911s
          Cifaldi Precision

          Comment

          • #20
            DueceMcGurk
            Senior Member
            • Jul 2016
            • 884

            Shooter and Cifaldi, excellent pics. 9mm and 45ACP extractors are different. Figure out which you have and buy a stock replacement. Run extractor test. Modify after shooting if needed.

            Comment

            Working...
            UA-8071174-1