Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

dumb question

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • chinaserf1
    Member
    • Aug 2012
    • 235

    dumb question

    Disclaimer: I do not reload and don't know much about it.

    I was doing the transfer for a Bulgarian Mak yesterday and a guy at the gun store asked if I would be interested in 600 rounds of brass Makarov mistaken reloads.

    The story was that a friend was reloading 9x19 and got into his reloading groove...while not noticing that he was actually loading the 115gr 9mm (.355) slug (and I can only assume the 9x19 powder load) into 18mm makarov casings. He then gave it to his friend in exasperation to see if he could find any Makarov owners who would take it.

    The man said he knew nothing about whether or not that was safe, and I have a feeling that he'd let the ammo go for a song...

    BUT I also have a feeling it is a bad idea. The slug diameter is less, so that will not add to the 115gr and extra pressure of the powder. In fact, there are 115gr Makarov rounds out there, and something labelled +P.



    BUT that is what I am basically coming to ask: Is there any reasonable expectation of safety, here? The guy could have been throwing 9x19 +P powder loads into those casings, that seems unsafe to me.
    Last edited by chinaserf1; 10-05-2014, 12:03 PM.
    MOSINS MOSins Mosins . snisoM sniSOM SNISOM
  • #2
    classicbronco
    Junior Member
    • May 2011
    • 66

    NO ! He needs to discard that ammo, immediately, before someone gets seriously injured or killed

    Comment

    • #3
      chinaserf1
      Member
      • Aug 2012
      • 235

      Common sense seems like it.
      MOSINS MOSins Mosins . snisoM sniSOM SNISOM

      Comment

      • #4
        stilly
        I need a LIFE!!
        • Jul 2009
        • 10685

        Originally posted by chinaserf1
        Disclaimer: I do not reload and don't know much about it.

        I was doing the transfer for a Bulgarian Mak yesterday and a guy at the gun store asked if I would be interested in 600 rounds of brass Makarov mistaken reloads.

        The story was that a friend was reloading 9x19 and got into his reloading groove...while not noticing that he was actually loading the 115gr 9mm (.355) slug (and I can only assume the 9x19 powder load) into 18mm makarov casings. He then gave it to his friend in exasperation to see if he could find any Makarov owners who would take it.

        The man said he knew nothing about whether or not that was safe, and I have a feeling that he'd let the ammo go for a song...

        BUT I also have a feeling it is a bad idea. The slug diameter is less, so that will not add to the 115gr and extra pressure of the powder. In fact, there are 115gr Makarov rounds out there, and something labelled +P.



        BUT that is what I am basically coming to ask: Is there any reasonable expectation of safety, here? The guy could have been throwing 9x19 +P powder loads into those casings, that seems unsafe to me.
        Sure, they are safe, As long as you pull the pills off and use them in a regular 9x19 load and toss the powder that came with them as well. But 600 pills and primed brass that you can get rid of aint so bad if you can get it all for around $50-$150... (those WERE regular 9x19 pills right?)

        I thought that makarov was really only 9x18 so the only REAL issue would be possible HOT loads/max/+P FO SHO...If you wanna pull 600 pills go for it... For a song though.

        Then go sell the extras in the MARKETPLACE (NOT IN THIS DISCUSSION FORUM!)
        7 Billion people on the planet. They aint ALL gonna astronauts. Some will get hit by trains...

        Need GOOD SS pins to clean your brass? Try the new and improved model...



        And remember- 99.9% of the lawyers ruin it for the other .1%...

        Comment

        • #5
          chinaserf1
          Member
          • Aug 2012
          • 235

          Heh apparently people selling stuff here is a sore spot for yall.

          You can fire 9x19 pills out of a Makarov (but not the other way around), but with 300FPS difference between the two standard powder loads, I'm not going to chance that the powder load is safe.

          I'm not a staunch enough capitalist to try and turn these things.
          MOSINS MOSins Mosins . snisoM sniSOM SNISOM

          Comment

          • #6
            Noonanda
            Veteran Member
            • Oct 2005
            • 3404

            if you broke down the ammo for components, the brass makarov casings would sell for a good price if you dont reload for it. If the .355 9mm bullets dont have a crazy crimp they could easily be reused.

            Really only thing you couldnt/dont want to reuse would be the powder.
            "You see in this world theres two kinds of people my friend. Those with loaded guns, and those who dig... You Dig" Blondie from TGBU

            Comment

            Working...
            UA-8071174-1