Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Ultrasonic Case Cleaning Problem

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Wrangler John
    Senior Member
    • Oct 2009
    • 1799

    Ultrasonic Case Cleaning Problem

    Here is the link to an article at Accurate Shooter regarding a peril of too much ultrasonic case cleaning: http://bulletin.accurateshooter.com/...ullet-seating/

    While I have never been a fan of ultrasonic case cleaning, some benchrest types swear by it, claiming that using the same brass repeatedly builds up a thick coating of carbon and powder residue inside the cases that can only be removed by ultrasonic means. Still, every method has advantages and disadvantages, and this appears to be a disadvantage the handloader needs to be aware of. Reading the discussion that follows the article we find outright denials and mention of steps to counter the problem such as polishing the necks with steel wool, so that cleaning things too much requires additional steps to return to consistent accuracy.

    I'm still waiting for the legendary free lunch, maybe some day I'll find one, but so far every Next Big Thing has a hidden drawback.
    Last edited by Wrangler John; 04-26-2014, 7:38 AM.
  • #2
    Jimi Jah
    I need a LIFE!!
    • Jan 2014
    • 19497

    I like ultrasonic brass cleaning. I get cleaner primer pockets. The brass may not look as pretty, but it's cleaner overall. The cartridge insides are where the cleaning makes all the difference.

    It's great for cleaning other stuff too like gun parts, jewelry, electronics, etc.

    Comment

    • #3
      SactoDoug
      CGN/CGSSA Contributor - Lifetime
      CGN Contributor - Lifetime
      • Oct 2013
      • 2884

      Where is the picture of a bullet removed from a tumbled shell for comparison? How can the author of that article claim the scrape marks and gouges are caused by ultra sonic cleaning when he has nothing to compare it to?

      The conclusion is incomplete.
      Block Google Tracking and Ads with a Raspberry Pi Hole

      Comment

      • #4
        Don Edmondson
        Member
        • May 2010
        • 377

        Neck lube

        I use graphite when I size all my cases after I clean them in tumbler or Ultra sonic maybe I am just Old Don

        Comment

        • #5
          Wrangler John
          Senior Member
          • Oct 2009
          • 1799

          I was talking about ultrasonic cleaning with my old friend last night. He was the tool and die shop superintendent for a major manufacturer of plastic tear strip bottle caps (if you ever opened a 5 gallon water jug, or plastic milk bottle, the cap probably came from one of these injection molds). He mentioned that they purchased a $49k industrial sonic cleaner for processing the raw steel billets before machining and to clean the mold parts before repairs or refurbishing. They soon learned that too much exposure of finished parts to the ultrasonic process would etch the steel rendering the parts useless. Timing of the process was critical to avoid cavitation pitting.

          The way ultrasonic cleaning works describes where the problem lies. Ultrasonic cleaners "cold boil" the liquid media with alternating waves of compression and expansion. Gas bubbles form during the expansion phase, water vapor inside the bubble condenses creating a vacuum cavity that implodes during the following compression phase. Energy from the collision of water molecules produces a stream of high-energy liquid that impacts the surface of the object being cleaned, stripping away contaminants adhering to the surface at the micron level. Sort of a microscopic liquid shape charge. This impact can and does erode the base metal as the process continues (all cleaning and polishing methods rely on removing material).

          Cavitation is a destructive process common to liquid transport systems, especially as regards pump impellers and diesel engine coolant systems, under certain operational conditions. Both can cause accelerated wear and failure.

          As long as we are aware of the problems associated with ultrasonic cleaning, we can minimize the negative effects. I tried a commercial ultrasonic cleaner only to find that it offered me no practical advantages. Indeed, its use required constant monitoring, and extra steps of rinsing the cases and drying them with compressed air. Primer pockets were no more clean than that produced by using mechanical methods followed by dry media vibratory tumbling within the same time frame. There was no accuracy gain or loss in either method. I do suspect that a micron thick layer of residual carbon inside the case may have some positive effect on brass from its insulating properties, but normal brass flow from firing pressure and mechanical stresses will render the brass unusable long before any gain would be realized.

          My conclusion is that such a degree of cleanliness is unneeded to produce accurate ammunition. The choice of cleaning methods is a personal preference and no further justification is required. I did find that the ultrasonic cleaner is an ideal method for removing carbon buildup from muzzle brakes. I toss them in for a few minutes and they come out nice and clean, a quick rinse and trip to the air compressor and they are ready to go again.

          Comment

          • #6
            ryan0320
            Senior Member
            • Sep 2010
            • 765

            I am using both actually. The brass will be much cleaner with ultrasonic cleaner. The prime pocket and inside will be clean. However, you can't process large amount of brass. In addition, there are more details to be considered such as, solution type, disposal of solution, dry time. On the other hand, tumbler can process large amount of brass but you can manually clean prime pocket. So it's up to you.
            01001001011001100010000001111001011011110111010100 10000001100011011000010110111000100000011101010110 11100110010001100101011100100010000001110100011010 00011001010111001101100101001000000111010001100101 01111000011101000010110000100000011110010110111101 11010100100000011010000110000101110110011001010010 00000110100001101001011001110110100000100000010010 01010100010010000001100001011100110010000001101101 01100101001011100010000001010000011001010110000101 100011011001010010000000100001

            Comment

            • #7
              Ferrum
              Janitors Mop
              CGN Contributor - Lifetime
              • Aug 2011
              • 4431

              Originally posted by SactoDoug
              Where is the picture of a bullet removed from a tumbled shell for comparison? How can the author of that article claim the scrape marks and gouges are caused by ultra sonic cleaning when he has nothing to compare it to?

              The conclusion is incomplete.
              Agreed, failed experiment. Where's the comparison with new brass? Where's the bullets for comparison? Could the authors dies contribute to excessive neck tension?

              Comment

              • #8
                stilly
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Jul 2009
                • 10685

                Originally posted by Wrangler John
                Here is the link to an article at Accurate Shooter regarding a peril of too much ultrasonic case cleaning: http://bulletin.accurateshooter.com/...ullet-seating/

                While I have never been a fan of ultrasonic case cleaning, some benchrest types swear by it, claiming that using the same brass repeatedly builds up a thick coating of carbon and powder residue inside the cases that can only be removed by ultrasonic means. Still, every method has advantages and disadvantages, and this appears to be a disadvantage the handloader needs to be aware of. Reading the discussion that follows the article we find outright denials and mention of steps to counter the problem such as polishing the necks with steel wool, so that cleaning things too much requires additional steps to return to consistent accuracy.

                I'm still waiting for the legendary free lunch, maybe some day I'll find one, but so far every Next Big Thing has a hidden drawback.
                One day you and I shall meet.

                And I will buy you a free lunch...
                7 Billion people on the planet. They aint ALL gonna astronauts. Some will get hit by trains...

                Need GOOD SS pins to clean your brass? Try the new and improved model...



                And remember- 99.9% of the lawyers ruin it for the other .1%...

                Comment

                • #9
                  krwada
                  Senior Member
                  CGN Contributor
                  • Jun 2013
                  • 1457

                  Yet another thread

                  Yes ...

                  Yet another thread posted by some dude who has never used a technology ... then soundly criticizing it as if he is some kind of expert.

                  The Internets ... is ALL kinds!

                  Sheesh!

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Carcassonne
                    Veteran Member
                    • Jul 2012
                    • 4897

                    .




                    Ultrasonic cleaners will remove zinc from the brass and leave the copper exposed. You can see this when there are "pink" spots on your brass. This happens with all brass, and not just brass cartridges.

                    I use to clean brass electrical conductors in an ultrasonic cleaner where I worked. The conductors didn't see any excessive force like a gun cartridge would see, so having surface zinc depletion didn't hurt anything.

                    The cleaning solution also made a difference. I think Dawn dish soap worked good without exposing too much copper. Lime-a-way cleaned good, but the parts came out solid pink.




                    .
                    Be sure to ask your doctor if depression, rectal bleeding, and suicide are right for you.

                    In the United States a person's expertise on a subject is inversely proportional to their knowledge of the subject: The less they know about something, the more they become an expert on it.

                    I am being held hostage in a giant insane asylum called Earth.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Mike402
                      Senior Member
                      • Nov 2012
                      • 555

                      Actually I can attest that this is true. I've been reloading for my .308 no problems using a lee collet neck die to size the necks and seating AMAX bullets. All along I've been using a Dillon tumbler with dry media.

                      Then I got the new Frankford Arsenal Wet SS media tumbler. Night and day difference with how much cleaner/shinier the brass comes out. However, I immediately starting having problems seating my bullets. They were tough to go in, and would shave the bullets.

                      I did compare cases and noticed the SS Wet tumbled cases were much cleaner in the neck area, whereas the dry tumbled still had a coating of powder residue. I have to agree with the author of the article.

                      I started out trying imperial wax on the bullets, which only helped slightly. I ultimately solved it by getting a moly neck lubing kit from Neco. I actually dip the bottom half of the bullet in there, and wipe off the excess before seating it. Not too onerous, but it did add an extra step to my process. I still say its worth it though for what amounts to brand new looking brass after I'm done tumbling.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Jimi Jah
                        I need a LIFE!!
                        • Jan 2014
                        • 19497

                        If the case necks are trimed and camfered properly, the bullets go it nice and smooth. If you have any rough edges you will see copper get pealed off the bullet sides.

                        I don't need lube to seat bullets in ultrasonic cleaned cases. I usually will give each neck a couple of twists on a Scotchpad to remove any sharp edges on brass that is not trimmed.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          Mike402
                          Senior Member
                          • Nov 2012
                          • 555

                          Originally posted by Jimi Jah
                          If the case necks are trimed and camfered properly, the bullets go it nice and smooth. If you have any rough edges you will see copper get pealed off the bullet sides.

                          I don't need lube to seat bullets in ultrasonic cleaned cases. I usually will give each neck a couple of twists on a Scotchpad to remove any sharp edges on brass that is not trimmed.
                          I guess we should make the distinction between ultrasonically cleaned & wet tumbled with ss media. I've also cleaned cases in my Hornady ultrasonic cleaner (which i've now relegated to cleaning gun parts only). I had no problems seating bullets. It was only when I switched to ss wet tumbling that I had the issues.

                          The case necks are trimmed true w/ a wilson case trimmer & deburred/chamfered w/ a Hornady case prep center. The seating problems only came about AFTER using the rotary tumbler

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            Wrangler John
                            Senior Member
                            • Oct 2009
                            • 1799

                            Let's Go Jump in the Deep End.

                            As we can see there is a great variation in opinion and experiences with ultrasonic cleaning, and other methods to boot. The discussion demonstrates, in a minor way, how expectations of the individual effects the observational outcome of the process. Then there are the questions that remains: To what degree does brass cleanliness effect accuracy? Are absolutely pristine primer pockets more accurate than those that are mechanically cleaned and tumble polished? The answer is unclear, and may never be reduced to an objective quantity with any degree of certainty.

                            One aspect that we can not discuss is the effect psychology has on the outcome. The shooter has no control over the chemical reaction occurring within the cartridge, or either interior or exterior ballistic factors. He or she may take steps designed to improve consistency, but each shot is a separate entity, with a chemical reaction that runs to its own end point, and each bullet flight is subject to a separate set of dynamic environmental variables. This is where the skill and experience of reading conditions and shooting technique become deciding.

                            That leaves us with the perception and expectations of the shooter. In this regard, the individual's confidence in his or her ammunition, firearm, and ability or skill set, may be the deciding factor. If a shooter has confidence that his or her ammunition is as perfect as possible, the net effect may be that his or her concentration on the biological functions of shooting are undisturbed, while the individual that lacks such confidence makes mistakes that become a self-fulfilling prophesy. So my recommendation is to do that which instills the greatest confidence, realizing that the mind is more important than the brass.

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            UA-8071174-1