Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Recommend precision dies

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #31
    ar15barrels
    I need a LIFE!!
    • Jan 2006
    • 57094

    Originally posted by JagerDog
    Bushing dies have that "extra step" as well if your brass isn't all identical. Forming the OD to induce an ID has it's pitfalls.
    Redding bushing dies leave a step.
    Forester neck/shoulder bushing dies do the neck and shoulder with no transistion as the bushings include the shoulder.

    The best setup is a properly sized full length die that's had the neck honed to the diameter you need.
    I can hone out die necks to any size.
    Last edited by ar15barrels; 12-26-2019, 12:27 PM.
    Randall Rausch

    AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
    Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
    Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
    Barrel, sight and trigger work on most pistols and shotguns.
    Most work performed while-you-wait.

    Comment

    • #32
      OpenSightsOnly
      Senior Member
      • Sep 2009
      • 1557

      Originally posted by mtenenhaus
      I will say i wish i had spent just a little more money to purchase the micrometer format of projectile seating die....i've been trying to optimize distance of the ogive to the rifle lands with a variety of different projectiles and the micrometer would have made it a little less hit and miss.
      I have the Forsters bench rest non-micrometer seater and the micrometer seater.

      Not having a micrometer seater is not a deal breaker. It does come in handy if I want to try a different bullet than what I use (non-VLD vs VLD); however, the convenience is minimal and inconsequential.

      Comment

      • #33
        kcstott
        I need a LIFE!!
        • Nov 2011
        • 11796

        Originally posted by JagerDog
        I doubt they're doing it with box stock "Ruger Precision Rifles" either.

        Again...what is OP using and what are his expectations?

        A body die, FL die and (Lee) collet die is not a bad solution for many. The body and FL dies are not used every loading (unless you're into that sort of thing).

        I presume this competition involves targets?

        Hunting I care more about utmost reliability vs. utmost accuracy. My hunting barrels aren't likely to see much gain from some of the more painstaking operations.

        Mongoose posted that he felt Lee was perfectly fine for Precision. I disagree.
        You questioned what I posted about precision and my opinion of Lee based on my reply to Mongoose not the OP's original question. A Yugo is also not a bad solution for many. It's a bad solution for me. and so is anything Lee makes. I'm sorry I'm not making a buck over minimum wage saving for two week to buy a pound of powder. I can afford better gear

        Hunting I care more about utmost reliability vs. utmost accuracy. My hunting barrels aren't likely to see much gain from some of the more painstaking operations.
        and there is the issue. What you mean by precision is not what I mean.

        I shoot 1000 Yard NRA F class. Load consistency is key. it's near benchrest type loading procedures. at least for me it is. Yes there are targets involved but it ain't target shooting.

        You can use anything you like. You can justify Lee anyway you like. The discussion was "Is Lee considered good for precision" and the consensus is NO. It may get the job done for you but we have still to hear what the OP is planing to do. Notice in my first post i mentioned Lee? I guess you missed that.

        Now Lee may be good enough for you, Lee may be good enough for a lot of people. Hell they were good enough for me at one time but not any more.

        Comment

        • #34
          bsumoba
          Veteran Member
          • Sep 2012
          • 4217

          Originally posted by ar15barrels
          The best setup is a properly sized full length die that's had the neck honed to the diameter you need.
          I can hone out die necks to any size.
          This is the answer. Forster and Whidden would be my two choices. But, I use Whidden because I have FL dies custom made with my desired neck, shoulder, and web dimension.

          In general, this does mean that one has to turn necks to get the desired neck clearance or stick with a particular brass and hope the neck thickness doesn't change from the mfg. I noticed that Lapua brass in 2014 was thicker than brass mfg in 2017. It didn't matter in my case because I just turned necks, but no neck turn guys with non-bushing FL dies will struggle with consistent "neck tensions"
          Visit- www.barrelcool.com
          The Original Chamber Flag and Barrel Cooler in 1
          Instagram: barrelcool_

          Comment

          • #35
            JagerDog
            I need a LIFE!!
            • May 2011
            • 14378

            Originally posted by kcstott
            Mongoose posted that he felt Lee was perfectly fine for Precision. I disagree.
            You questioned what I posted about precision and my opinion of Lee based on my reply to Mongoose not the OP's original question. A Yugo is also not a bad solution for many. It's a bad solution for me. and so is anything Lee makes. I'm sorry I'm not making a buck over minimum wage saving for two week to buy a pound of powder. I can afford better gear


            and there is the issue. What you mean by precision is not what I mean.

            I shoot 1000 Yard NRA F class. Load consistency is key. it's near benchrest type loading procedures. at least for me it is. Yes there are targets involved but it ain't target shooting.

            You can use anything you like. You can justify Lee anyway you like. The discussion was "Is Lee considered good for precision" and the consensus is NO. It may get the job done for you but we have still to hear what the OP is planing to do. Notice in my first post i mentioned Lee? I guess you missed that.

            Now Lee may be good enough for you, Lee may be good enough for a lot of people. Hell they were good enough for me at one time but not any more.

            We seem to be missing each other. I'm only speaking to the collet die. Does the same job as a neck only bushing die, but without bushings to control OD the effect ID. It really is unique and should be experienced before being poopoo'd.

            Those, a factory crimp die in .45 ACP (because i was having issues with cast bullets in a tight Gold Cup chamber) and a universal de-capper are the only Lee dies i own.
            Palestine is a fake country

            No Mas Hamas



            #Blackolivesmatter

            Comment

            • #36
              kcstott
              I need a LIFE!!
              • Nov 2011
              • 11796

              Originally posted by JagerDog
              We seem to be missing each other. I'm only speaking to the collet die. Does the same job as a neck only bushing die, but without bushings to control OD the effect ID. It really is unique and should be experienced before being poopoo'd.

              Those, a factory crimp die in .45 ACP (because i was having issues with cast bullets in a tight Gold Cup chamber) and a universal de-capper are the only Lee dies i own.
              I've seen the die. I understand the mechanics and I choose not to trust a single thing that Lee makes. Sorry but if they wanted to make high precision gear they can. but they choose to use a lot of aluminum where it's not appropriate and o-rings to take up slop.

              See a bushing die has but one wear surface. and this collet die has three. I don't like the design. and I don't trust anything Lee makes other than maybe a bullet mold.

              So with that we can agree to disagree.

              Comment

              • #37
                vinconco
                Member
                • Jun 2015
                • 448

                I did a test on 6.5CM ammo I loaded with the Lee seater die and a Forster Straight Line competition seater die. Using a NECO runout gauge the Forster seater die produced less runout than the Lee.

                That said the Lee seater die usually produces less runout than standard seater dies.
                HANG FAST TARGETS

                THE MOST INNOVATIVE TARGET SOLUTION ON THE MARKET

                SIMPLE = AFFORDABLE


                sigpic

                10% off to Calgunners !! Use code: CALGUNS10
                www.hangfasttargets.com

                Comment

                • #38
                  JagerDog
                  I need a LIFE!!
                  • May 2011
                  • 14378

                  Originally posted by kcstott
                  I've seen the die. I understand the mechanics and I choose not to trust a single thing that Lee makes. Sorry but if they wanted to make high precision gear they can. but they choose to use a lot of aluminum where it's not appropriate and o-rings to take up slop.

                  See a bushing die has but one wear surface. and this collet die has three. I don't like the design. and I don't trust anything Lee makes other than maybe a bullet mold.

                  So with that we can agree to disagree.

                  Many replace the lock nut with Hornady or equivalent.

                  There's no aluminum where it would affect function. A disassembly knob (which also backs up the primer punch pin/mandrel) is it.

                  Any supposed wear is adjusted out. My Hardinge 5C collets have seen many millions of operations.

                  A bonus is no brass build-up at the crotch and no need to lube cases (takes a step or two away from the process).

                  I really don't understand the "blackball" bias to a name, but to each his own. <0.001 run out is good enough for me.
                  Last edited by JagerDog; 12-27-2019, 3:02 PM.
                  Palestine is a fake country

                  No Mas Hamas



                  #Blackolivesmatter

                  Comment

                  • #39
                    MrElectric03
                    Senior Member
                    • Jul 2010
                    • 1590

                    I tend to keep different sizers depending on use. I like the redding type S full length sizers for hunting rifles and have a lee collet die for most every bolt gun I have. For seaters I try to only use Forster dies. I buy the bench rest seaters on eBay individually and have the micrometer tops. They only make two sizes so one is for around 6mm and under and the other is for all other. Only thing you need to convert the becnhrest to micrometer is the micrometer and in some cases a longer seating stem. Also I load on a CoAx so typically the redding seaters are too long and get in the way of the handle.
                    Originally posted by ar15barrels
                    So you are throwing out 95% of reality to select the 5% of reality where you are actually right?
                    We must be on calguns...

                    Comment

                    • #40
                      MongooseV8
                      Veteran Member
                      • Apr 2010
                      • 4426

                      One of my Lee collet dies has at least 20k pieces of brass through it. Not sure about all these wear surfaces but it still makes precise ammunitions. Seems like one should have some experience with a tool before driving a new reloader away from the entry brand.

                      Comment

                      • #41
                        ExtremeX
                        Calguns Addict
                        • Sep 2010
                        • 7160

                        I am pretty happy with my competition seating die from Forester. I have had great results with them.

                        It was worth spending the extra for a micrometer adjustment knob, it is very convenient.

                        I also use a mix of other dies depending on the step. Lee dies are actually pretty good for things like neck sizing, I use the collect ones often.
                        ExtremeX

                        Comment

                        • #42
                          kriller134
                          Senior Member
                          • Jan 2011
                          • 1302

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          UA-8071174-1