Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Issues with 223 Keyholing???

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    ocabj
    Calguns Addict
    • Oct 2005
    • 7924

    I had keyholing with a 16" 1:7 midlength CHF/CL Spikes Tactical / FN barrel a few years ago as close as 10 yards. 99% of the rounds in the gun was Federal Lake City M193 5.56.

    It developed after about 2500-3000 rounds. Couldn't figure out why. Even changed out the muzzle brake twice, then back to the A2 FH. The keyholing would start after the barrel heated up.

    I ended up changing out barrels. Replaced with a 16" 1:7 midlength CHF/CL BCM barrel. I probably have 3500 on it now. No issues.

    Distinguished Rifleman #1924
    NRA Certified Instructor (Rifle and Metallic Cartridge Reloading) and RSO
    NRL22 Match Director at WEGC

    https://www.ocabj.net

    Comment

    • #17
      bohoki
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Jan 2006
      • 20826

      are they a bunch of random sideways bullet holes or are they all vertical tears

      Comment

      • #18
        ElvenSoul
        I need a LIFE!!
        • Apr 2008
        • 17431

        Do you know maker and model of barrel.

        How does the crown look?

        Do you have a muzzle device of some kind on?
        sigpic

        Comment

        • #19
          alexisjohnson
          Senior Member
          • May 2016
          • 651

          So i went ahead and loaded another batch with less powder (mid range). I also grabbed the old batch and some factory federal ammo.

          The other two had no keyholing at all...accuracy was within spec....so i don't believe it has anything to do with the gun itself.

          What was strange was that even with the 'problem' batch, everything seemed fine and i only had one magazine where i noticed keyholing happening again. The other rounds were just fine.

          I honestly can't figure out whats going on. Something is definitely wrong with that specific batch but everything looks up to spec.

          I'm down to three possibilities right now. The first is that the batch of bullets is funky. The second is that my compensator may be somewhat off and for some reason...sometimes, it has an effect. I remember when i had first bought the gun (BCM) and i was shooting wolf, i'd get a concentric shower of sparks in the stall. In the beggining it was so startling that i stopped shooting steel from that upper. This happened only with steel and then it went away after a little bit of shooting. The third possibility is that for whatever reason, the charge is too high and sometimes, the bullets can't handle it. The lower charge batch had zero issues...

          I'll keep playing with it and try to figure out what the issue is. Thanks again for all your suggestions. It really helped me to narrow things down!

          Comment

          • #20
            baih777
            CGN/CGSSA Contributor
            CGN Contributor
            • Jul 2011
            • 5680

            Clean that compensator real good and use a flashlight to check it.
            Been gone too long. It's been 15 to 20 years since i had to shelf my guns. Those early years sucked.
            I really miss the good old Pomona Gun Shows.
            I'm Back.

            Comment

            • #21
              dwalker
              Veteran Member
              • Jul 2014
              • 2714

              If you were getting sparks from steel jacket ammo then you have an issue with the muzzle device.
              Fear is the spare change that will keep you broke

              Call him run-like-hell-when-shtf-guy or dial-911-guy but NEVER call an unarmed man "Security".

              Comment

              • #22
                alexisjohnson
                Senior Member
                • May 2016
                • 651

                Yeah i remember the first time i shot steel from it...the sparks scared me enough that i stopped. I assumed maybe it was simply unburnt powder being funneled through the compensator? But that issue went away after i had shot around 300-500 rounds. When i shot steel after that...it was fine.


                how would i know if it was a misaligned comp?

                I took a flashlight and inspected carefully and it looks just fine. Nothing abnormal that would indicate bullet strikes...

                Comment

                • #23
                  dwalker
                  Veteran Member
                  • Jul 2014
                  • 2714

                  How carboned up is the comp?
                  Fear is the spare change that will keep you broke

                  Call him run-like-hell-when-shtf-guy or dial-911-guy but NEVER call an unarmed man "Security".

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    alexisjohnson
                    Senior Member
                    • May 2016
                    • 651

                    Not much carbon at all^

                    The issues with the sparks happened very early on and have all but dissapeared

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      Oldjedi
                      Member
                      • Sep 2013
                      • 338

                      I echo devilmonkey89. I have seen this happen with soft lightweight 9mm bullets (0.355" diameter) loaded into 38 supers (0.357" diameter). The bullet is travelling too fast too early in a larger diameter. Barrel rifling does not bite into the bullet early. As the bullet wobbles down the barrel, the rifling is shaving off the plating. Bullet does not pick up angular momentum. When bullet leaves the barrel it starts random rotation. If it is rotating end-to-end when it hits the target, you will see triangle holes instead of rounds.

                      I had accuracy problems with one batch of Winchester 0.224 diameter bullets fired out of my Mini 14. The bullets were at low side of tolerance. Around half of them were below minimum tolerance. I couldn't hit the barn wall from 50 yards. Added 9/13/2017 these bullets were 55 gr. in a 1:9 barrel. Too light for the barrel twist besides other problems mentioned above. I think 1:7 is way too fast for 55 gr. I suggest you try 75, 77, 80 and 90 grain bullets. Unfortunately, with 1:7 twist there are not many choices. PM me with you email address and I'll send you my spreadsheet of stability calcs.

                      The remedy may come from one, a few, or all of these options:

                      Change barrel to a slower twist if using lightweight bullets
                      Use jacketed bullets instead of plated
                      Use slower burning powder
                      Check for erosion at the start of rifling in your barrel. I use pin gages for this.
                      Get a micrometer and measure bullet diameters. They have to be within tolerance
                      If replacing the barrel, get an American made one. I like Shilen barrels. They last a lot longer than some of these imports.

                      As usual, any advice should be taken as advice only. It comes from personal experience or private conversations or opinions not necessarily backed by facts or figures. It is not a guarantee that it will work for you. Whatever you choose to do will be at your own risk. Good luck. Safe shooting.
                      Last edited by Oldjedi; 09-13-2017, 5:26 PM.

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        arrowshooter
                        Senior Member
                        • Aug 2013
                        • 724

                        Have you shot it without the break?

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          alexisjohnson
                          Senior Member
                          • May 2016
                          • 651

                          Nope...never shot it without the Comp. ^

                          I'll keep playing until i figure it out. My strongest guess is that its the ammo. Either the bullets are problematic or the powder is too much for them.

                          If it was the comp, the same thing shoudl be happening with other ammo but it only has taken place with this specific batch.

                          The Sparks from the comp might simply have been unburnt powder...

                          I'll keep tinkering until i pinpoint the issue.

                          Thanks again to everyone for the help.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            Capt.Dunsel
                            Senior Member
                            • May 2011
                            • 1199

                            Originally posted by Devilmonkey89
                            Barry's plated? You might be pushing them too fast causing the copper plating to come off the lead core causing said issue. My best guess.

                            Edit: seems like barry's is a FMJ bullet. Did you check bullet diameter? Could be out of spec bullets wobbling down the barrel.
                            Not all of Berry's are FMJ , they do have plated listed . if it is the plated , slow them down a bit or get them over sized , say .225 .

                            Had the problem with a little 22 ( 218 Bee) went larger and slower and problem went away. And yes my loads for the bee , hard cast / gas checked can speed along faster than the .223 , a lot faster !
                            Bweise says "I have to say the situation was not at all helped by 22 yr old former Airsoft douches who kept touting here, "But possession is not illegal!" "

                            Fighting on the internet is like being in the special Olympics , everybody wins but your still retarded.

                            Librarian " Calguns is not a 'general discussion board".

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              ElvenSoul
                              I need a LIFE!!
                              • Apr 2008
                              • 17431

                              Originally posted by Oldjedi
                              I echo devilmonkey89. I have seen this happen with soft lightweight 9mm bullets (0.355" diameter) loaded into 38 supers (0.357" diameter). The bullet is travelling too fast too early in a larger diameter. Barrel rifling does not bite into the bullet early. As the bullet wobbles down the barrel, the rifling is shaving off the plating. Bullet does not pick up angular momentum. When bullet leaves the barrel it starts random rotation. If it is rotating end-to-end when it hits the target, you will see triangle holes instead of rounds.

                              I had accuracy problems with one batch of Winchester 0.224 diameter bullets fired out of my Mini 14. The bullets were at low side of tolerance. Around half of them were below minimum tolerance. I couldn't hit the barn wall from 50 yards.

                              The remedy may come from one, a few, or all of these options:

                              Change barrel to a slower twist if using lightweight bullets
                              Use jacketed bullets instead of plated
                              Use slower burning powder
                              Check for erosion at the start of rifling in your barrel. I use pin gages for this.
                              Get a micrometer and measure bullet diameters. They have to be within tolerance
                              If replacing the barrel, get an American made one. I like Shilen barrels. They last a lot longer than some of these imports.

                              As usual, any advice should be taken as advice only. It comes from personal experience or private conversations or opinions not necessarily backed by facts or figures. It is not a guarantee that it will work for you. Whatever you choose to do will be at your own risk. Good luck. Safe shooting.
                              In other words

                              OP you shot out the barrel or have a bad throat.
                              sigpic

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                alexisjohnson
                                Senior Member
                                • May 2016
                                • 651

                                So i played with things a bit more. I loaded different batches (with varying amounts of TAC powder).

                                I then started to shoot the batch i know has issues. It only begins keyholing once it warms up and not before. I have to shoot around 30-40 rounds and then bam...it starts keyholing big time... Meaning bullets are not even hitting paper (a standard size piece of paper). One or two will hit just fine and the other 3-4 will keyhole. But...before the barrel warms up...they're fine...

                                So anyways...i lowered the charge amount and the ones that had less powder worked just fine...no keyholing except for one bullet which did keyhole. The other 70 rounds did not keyhole and shot fine.

                                This doesn't happen at all with other types of factory ammo.

                                I'm really stumped. I've decided to send in the upper and have the company take a good look at it. It is a new upper which may have some sort of issue.

                                It could also be the berrys bullets which are problematic for whatever reason.

                                For now, the upper is going on a journey and my next step will be to test whats left of this batch with another ar.

                                Wish me luck....the journey continues

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1