Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Most efficient but effective load Development?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    Metal God
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2013
    • 1839

    I did some tests awhile back seeing how much rifle hold effects velocity and SD/ES . The test were from one extreme to the other . First test was pretty much having a death grip on the rifle . This was pulling it in HARD to my shoulder while keeping a very firm grip at forend and trigger area of the stock

    The second test was having no contact with the rifle except pulling the tigger with my finger . I let the rifle freely recoil while close enough to stay in control of the firearm .

    These test were done using the same hand loads that used all the same lot powder , brass , bullets and primers . As well as handled the same from bench to range . I don't remember the components off hand but I do know I was using either 178gr A-max or 175gr smk with a stick powder ( likely IMR 4064 or 4895 ) with Win LR primers .

    I'll have to go find my notes on this but in general the death grip test had a higher average velocity and a SD in the 20"s and ES in the high 30's

    While the test where I let the rifle freely recoil had slightly less average velocity . The ES was 12 and the SD was 5

    My conclusion was how you hold the rifle can effect velocity .

    My point here ? unless you are very consistent on how you hold your rifle . Firing one shot at a given charge weight will not represent what that charge weight will actually shoot on average . It's my belief one can easily fire 3 shots with inconsistent rifle hold and it looks like your charges velocities flattened out and vise versa for that matter . You could actually be in a OCW zone but your rifle hold actually throws the velocities off enough to look like your not in that zone .

    IMHO you need to shoot at least 3 shots if all your going to do is look at velocity first . If you're going to only fire one shot I'd go with a ladder test because it ignores velocity in favor of POI which a 5 to 15 fps difference will not effect the results .

    I'll further add that generally speaking the only time my velocities consistently flatten out is when I'm at max pressure/load for a given cartridge . So keep that in mind as well . If your velocity hits a flat spot and you are at the max recommended charge area . It very well could be that's all the velocity you are safely going to get from that powder and may not actually be at your OCW for that load . I want to be clear that's a general observation to consider and is not 100% reliable as to what is your OCW or if you are at MAP .
    Last edited by Metal God; 09-01-2017, 10:21 PM.
    Tolerate
    allow the existence, occurrence, or practice of (something that one does not necessarily like or agree with) without interference.

    Anyone else find it sad that those who preach tolerance CAN'T allow the existence, occurrence, or practice of (something that they do not necessarily like or agree with) without interference.

    I write almost everything in a jovial manner regardless of content . If that's not how you took it please try again

    Comment

    • #17
      desert dog
      Senior Member
      • May 2008
      • 786

      Originally posted by kcstott
      Here's what I do. But be warned you better have your process dialed in. A good solid foundation of reloading experience to know what you are doing and have high quality control.

      As mentioned pick your projectile based on your needs. For example. I primarily shoot 1000 yard F Class matches. I need high BC bullets that will stay supper sonic and stable at 1000 yards. This example is for a .308 win, So here goes.

      1. Get your load range, you min and max powder charge. Load up ten rounds one round each from about 2-3 grains below max and load in .2-.3 gr steps one round each set seating depth .020" off lands for VLD's

      2. Go to range, 100 yard min for the first round of testing, get your chrono out fire all ten round allowing the barrel to cool between shots, we are not looking for accuracy only velocity data

      3. Go home and examine your data. You should see a velocity or two that levels off, where your increase in powder charge does very little or even reduces velocity, you'll see about 3-4 rounds with velocities within 5-10 fps of each other

      4. Pick a powder charge near center of that velocity plateau.

      5. Load up five each of that powder charge and seat the bullet closer to the lands in .005" steps.

      6. Now shoot your groups, allow barrel to cool between shots, rebuilt your position as needed to make the best shot you can each and every time.

      Within 20-25 rounds you will see one or two seating depths that really tighten up. That's your load.

      Now you can further refine that by changing one component at a time. It this will build a solid sub moa load in 20-25 rounds or you money back
      Very close to what I do. I don't even shoot for groups when looking for accuracy nodes (too much human err involved), I just fire into a hillside and read my magnetospeed.

      As an example, I found this accuracy node by firing less than 20 rounds into a hillside. I determined the sweet spot to be 42.3gr, and now have a load that shoots in the .2s, has very low ES, and has the velocity I was looking for in a hunting bullet. This is my pronghorn hunting load, and I needed something in the 2800fps range for my Barnes LRX to perform well at longer distances. I found it quite easily, using existing load data as a starting point.


      I stole this method from some of Scott Saterlee's work.


      I basically save lots of time by finding my velocity node first (optimal barrel harmonics) without the distraction and uncertainty of human err that shooting for groups introduces. THEN, I will shoot groups and fine tune seating depth if needed. Much simpler than OCW tests.

      Just be mindful that MOST chronos are NOT accurate enough for this methgod. You must have a 35p, magnetospeed, or labradar to pull this method off reliably. Basically, results are 100% dependent on chrono accuracy.
      Last edited by desert dog; 09-01-2017, 10:32 AM.

      Comment

      • #18
        wpage
        Calguns Addict
        • Jan 2011
        • 6072

        Time and testing will always tell...

        Live and learn at the range, pops said stop thinking and try aiming.
        God so loved the world He gave His only Son... Believe in Him and have everlasting life.
        John 3:16

        NRA,,, Lifer

        United Air Epic Fail Video ...

        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u99Q7pNAjvg

        Comment

        • #19
          17+1
          Veteran Member
          • Jun 2010
          • 2847

          Originally posted by highpower790
          Use a good match bullet and a stick powder, such as varget
          This.

          Sierra bullets are excellent, they always shoot so well it's hard to try anything else...same deal with CCI primers and hodgdon powders in general.

          Comment

          • #20
            Lamski
            Member
            • Jul 2013
            • 368

            So I measured my OAL to kiss the lands with the ELD-M. It's far less then my magazine max length. I guess the throat on my barrel is short? Where should I start at? 0.020 off the lands for all the charge weights I want to measure? According to that video posted earlier in the thread they use .020 to start.

            Also, if my brass is new and not fire formed will that affect my initial velocity readings?

            Comment

            • #21
              Whiterabbit
              Calguns Addict
              • Oct 2010
              • 7602

              First question is irrelevant IMO because you will change OAL later to test for effects on SD and ATC.

              Second question I will answer tomorrow, as I have data on it. I can tell you now that the node is the node, and if you nail it with new brass (in my experience) you'll still be in the node at the same charge weight with 1x and 2x brass. But definitely possible for a velocity shift, lets see what my data says.

              Comment

              • #22
                longrange1
                Senior Member
                • Dec 2015
                • 1032

                Originally posted by Lamski
                So I measured my OAL to kiss the lands with the ELD-M. It's far less then my magazine max length. I guess the throat on my barrel is short? Where should I start at? 0.020 off the lands for all the charge weights I want to measure? According to that video posted earlier in the thread they use .020 to start.

                Also, if my brass is new and not fire formed will that affect my initial velocity readings?
                im curious what type of shooting your going to do?

                Comment

                • #23
                  Lamski
                  Member
                  • Jul 2013
                  • 368

                  Originally posted by longrange1
                  im curious what type of shooting your going to do?
                  Paper and steel at varying known distances out to 1000yds. Both prone and/or off a bench. Possibly work my way up to PRS style matches. No hunting with this rifle.

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    Whiterabbit
                    Calguns Addict
                    • Oct 2010
                    • 7602

                    Here's my data. All from "the load", which is 39 grains of powder in a 243:

                    Some of the first shots from the rifle. definitely new brass:
                    39 2897
                    39 2877
                    39 2905

                    OAL load dev, also new brass

                    long OAL:
                    2868
                    2887
                    2876
                    2865
                    2868

                    Short OAL:
                    2882
                    2874
                    2935
                    2905
                    2901

                    Next a confirmation run. This is "probably" new brass but "possibly" 1x
                    2839
                    2812
                    2848
                    2845
                    2839
                    2852
                    2864
                    2836
                    2861
                    2827

                    Two more strings, taken in March. No doubt, this is 1x brass. But taken with lab radar, not magnetospeed.
                    2878
                    2876
                    2890
                    2900
                    2886
                    2883
                    2886
                    2895
                    2883
                    2893

                    2873
                    2883
                    2888
                    2888
                    2876
                    2888
                    2891
                    2896
                    2871
                    2883

                    I shot these last month, 95% chance this is 2x brass

                    2897
                    2885
                    2887
                    2899
                    2911
                    2902
                    2889
                    2902
                    2900
                    2894

                    AND just for fun, here are 10 shots using new brass of a different brand, shot at the same time as above

                    2873
                    2871
                    2874
                    2875
                    2877
                    2880
                    2881
                    2889
                    2889
                    2879

                    ----------------------------------------------

                    This is 8 groups of data. The question is, what does it all mean? Here are the labels i used for each group:

                    new rpr, new brass
                    new long OAL
                    new short OAL
                    Probably 1x, maybe new
                    1x (1)
                    1x (2)
                    2x
                    new starline

                    So, your question is, "does new brass make a difference vs old brass". So, I choose to use Student's T-test and compare every permutation of group above. T-test will define the confidence that any group is the same population of data. You'll have to take it with a grain of salt given sample sizes, but it's enough to give you an idea of what is going on. I then chose a confidence interval of 90%. That is to say, when I am 90% sure a group of numbers are different, I mark it in yellow.

                    more explanation of t-test with respect to guns, this guy does a good job:


                    Here is a table of t-test values



                    What you are looking for is entire rows of yellow. These indicate one brass set that is radically different than the rest.

                    I can draw the following conclusions:

                    1. The batch marked "probably 1x, maybe new" is different in population from everything. This may or may not be because the brass is 1x (or new). Maybe the rifle was cleaned, or the magnetospeed needed a new battery. I would expect ALL 1x data to be "different" if it was really due to 1x brass.

                    2. the new rifle, with new brass, did not shoot different from 1x or 2x brass. (with a sample size of 3 and a confidence of 90%)

                    3. changing brass brand changes velocity. This is not a judgement of SD, only average velocity shift.

                    4. 2x brass appears to be different than 1x, but not different from new.

                    5. The least variability measured day to day, month to month was recorded via lab radar. This may be because lab radar introduces less variability into the measurements, improving sample group data, OR, it means that magnetospeed collects better data, allowing for better resolution of each sample. Not clear.

                    6. Bottom line, if I have a very clear dataset with respect to brass age, I cannot connect it with 100% confidence to number of times fired and a velocity population shift.

                    In short, I cannot prove that new, 1x, or 2x matters a fig with this data.

                    8 samples, 63 data points in total.

                    edit: and conclusion #7, I wish my interest in statistics budded in High School, not 10+ years post-university. I would have a more advanced degree and be making more money than I am now.
                    Last edited by Whiterabbit; 01-01-2019, 10:37 PM.

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      longrange1
                      Senior Member
                      • Dec 2015
                      • 1032

                      so whiterabbit...are/were these 60 rounds shot looking for/chasing a load? or doing load development?

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        longrange1
                        Senior Member
                        • Dec 2015
                        • 1032

                        Originally posted by Lamski
                        Paper and steel at varying known distances out to 1000yds. Both prone and/or off a bench. Possibly work my way up to PRS style matches. No hunting with this rifle.
                        gotcha...i can tell you for PRS and prone(unless your talking F-class)that chasing 1 hole groups/loads is kind of a waste of time and components unless its just something you need or want to do.

                        first PRS matches can be won with a 3/4" gun...second i dont know anyone that can hold well enough off an obstacle and on the clock to know the difference between a gun that shoots 1/2" at 100yds or 1 hole at 100yds.

                        you see i use to chase these 1 hole loads...and with a little tweaking i can get my rifle to shoot one hole groups the problem is i can not go out everyday and shoot those groups and neither can most ppl plus im running back and forth testing this and that when i could actually be practicing.

                        what i can do is go out and shoot 1 MOA size targets out to about 1300yds pretty consistently.

                        i have also shot just about every load development there is and can tell you that ladder tests,graphs,charts,excel sheets ECT are for the more experienced/advanced shooters not someone new to loading...stick to the OCW method or the one i posted and save yourself a lot of time and frustration.

                        this IMHO is the simplest load development there is...

                        Find information, resources and relevant links for texasprc.club. This domain may be for sale.


                        ive used it with the last 5-6 barrels and every time ive walked away with a load in 38 rounds...i dont chase the lands..my seating depth stays the same for the life of the barrel...when the barrel starts to slow down i add .2-.3g of powder to keep in the speed node.

                        i do not shoot BR but i do shoot long range prone,PRS,short range tactical and F-class matches with the same gun and load.

                        IMHO load development is the most over thought part of shooting there is(ive been there myself)and most ppl would be better served if they shot more and worried less about the perfect load.
                        Last edited by longrange1; 09-08-2017, 2:05 PM.

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          kcstott
                          I need a LIFE!!
                          • Nov 2011
                          • 11796

                          Originally posted by longrange1
                          IMHO load development is the most over thought part of shooting there is(ive been there myself)and most ppl would be better served if they shot more and worried less about the perfect load.
                          Been saying that for many years
                          What's funny is guys shooting Steel and trying to load to BR groups... why??

                          I have better things to do with my time.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            Whiterabbit
                            Calguns Addict
                            • Oct 2010
                            • 7602

                            Originally posted by kcstott
                            Been saying that for many years
                            What's funny is guys shooting Steel and trying to load to BR groups... why??

                            I have better things to do with my time.
                            Cause I like statistics and loading ammo (and casting bullets) basically as much as, if not better than shooting.

                            Tho I don't go nuts with the annealing, neck tuning on custom rifles, weight sorting crap, etc. At least, not till I measure a difference

                            Oh, and to address longrange1's response which you had quoted, I agree. The fun part of modelling load performance (for me) is I get to take all these highfalutin' claims people make on the internet and see if they actually apply in my case. Here's an example: people say they weight sort their brass. I've measured it. Doesn't make a darn bit of difference in my rifle. Maybe you guys don't consider that load development but rather statistical mythbusting, but it does make for a fun range day that keeps bringing me fun hours after I get home from the range

                            edit: I'm going back out for load development over the next few months as I can (or get help with) for a new test: David Tubb says hBN coated bullets eliminate first shot flyers. Well, I'm not gonna just start using his product, I'm gonna test it. And there's something thta COULD theoretically benefit me if I were a steel shooter, since I have data (love data!) that shows I have a massive first round issue, and a minor second round issue. Doesn't mean I cna't go long range shooting tomorrow with what I got, but it's sure fun to collect a bunch of first round cold bore data and model it
                            Last edited by Whiterabbit; 09-08-2017, 3:36 PM.

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              Whiterabbit
                              Calguns Addict
                              • Oct 2010
                              • 7602

                              Originally posted by longrange1
                              so whiterabbit...are/were these 60 rounds shot looking for/chasing a load? or doing load development?
                              First four were a part of load development. First was a part of a velocity screening. From there, I Identified 3 nodes i wanted to explore, I tried long and short OAL with each node to see what I liked best. At that time I also shot more screening and found a 4th node, but didn't do anything with that. Then the last group I mentioned was a 10 round group to confirm where I was at.

                              Actually, I probably have even more data around from primer load development, so I'll have even more there.

                              But let's be clear. from a "let's take it out and shoot it and have fun" perspective, I was done by the first three groups. That doesn't mean I stopped load developing, just for me, it's a fun exercise.

                              But if I wanted to go do something, like shoot groups at 300, or take it to SLOSA and shoot their 700 yard steels, etc, I just take whatever is the latest greatest load and go shoot.

                              so the next groups there are incidentals when I was tracking velocity for whatever reason.
                              Last edited by Whiterabbit; 09-08-2017, 3:37 PM.

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                longrange1
                                Senior Member
                                • Dec 2015
                                • 1032

                                Originally posted by kcstott
                                Been saying that for many years
                                What's funny is guys shooting Steel and trying to load to BR groups... why??

                                I have better things to do with my time.
                                like i say i did it for several years but i did it more for the loading experience.
                                i got tired of hearing and reading all the contradicting info about loading when i first started so i went out and did all my own testing in the field to see first hand the effects of case/bullet prep,primers,powders ect.

                                ive done all the case/bullet prep there is and now i do none of it...i SST tumble,FL size and trim/chamfer every time and anneal every 2nd firing and thats a part time job LOL.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1