I did some tests awhile back seeing how much rifle hold effects velocity and SD/ES . The test were from one extreme to the other . First test was pretty much having a death grip on the rifle . This was pulling it in HARD to my shoulder while keeping a very firm grip at forend and trigger area of the stock
The second test was having no contact with the rifle except pulling the tigger with my finger . I let the rifle freely recoil while close enough to stay in control of the firearm .
These test were done using the same hand loads that used all the same lot powder , brass , bullets and primers . As well as handled the same from bench to range . I don't remember the components off hand but I do know I was using either 178gr A-max or 175gr smk with a stick powder ( likely IMR 4064 or 4895 ) with Win LR primers .
I'll have to go find my notes on this but in general the death grip test had a higher average velocity and a SD in the 20"s and ES in the high 30's
While the test where I let the rifle freely recoil had slightly less average velocity . The ES was 12 and the SD was 5
My conclusion was how you hold the rifle can effect velocity .
My point here ? unless you are very consistent on how you hold your rifle . Firing one shot at a given charge weight will not represent what that charge weight will actually shoot on average . It's my belief one can easily fire 3 shots with inconsistent rifle hold and it looks like your charges velocities flattened out and vise versa for that matter . You could actually be in a OCW zone but your rifle hold actually throws the velocities off enough to look like your not in that zone .
IMHO you need to shoot at least 3 shots if all your going to do is look at velocity first . If you're going to only fire one shot I'd go with a ladder test because it ignores velocity in favor of POI which a 5 to 15 fps difference will not effect the results .
I'll further add that generally speaking the only time my velocities consistently flatten out is when I'm at max pressure/load for a given cartridge . So keep that in mind as well . If your velocity hits a flat spot and you are at the max recommended charge area . It very well could be that's all the velocity you are safely going to get from that powder and may not actually be at your OCW for that load . I want to be clear that's a general observation to consider and is not 100% reliable as to what is your OCW or if you are at MAP .
The second test was having no contact with the rifle except pulling the tigger with my finger . I let the rifle freely recoil while close enough to stay in control of the firearm .
These test were done using the same hand loads that used all the same lot powder , brass , bullets and primers . As well as handled the same from bench to range . I don't remember the components off hand but I do know I was using either 178gr A-max or 175gr smk with a stick powder ( likely IMR 4064 or 4895 ) with Win LR primers .
I'll have to go find my notes on this but in general the death grip test had a higher average velocity and a SD in the 20"s and ES in the high 30's
While the test where I let the rifle freely recoil had slightly less average velocity . The ES was 12 and the SD was 5
My conclusion was how you hold the rifle can effect velocity .
My point here ? unless you are very consistent on how you hold your rifle . Firing one shot at a given charge weight will not represent what that charge weight will actually shoot on average . It's my belief one can easily fire 3 shots with inconsistent rifle hold and it looks like your charges velocities flattened out and vise versa for that matter . You could actually be in a OCW zone but your rifle hold actually throws the velocities off enough to look like your not in that zone .
IMHO you need to shoot at least 3 shots if all your going to do is look at velocity first . If you're going to only fire one shot I'd go with a ladder test because it ignores velocity in favor of POI which a 5 to 15 fps difference will not effect the results .
I'll further add that generally speaking the only time my velocities consistently flatten out is when I'm at max pressure/load for a given cartridge . So keep that in mind as well . If your velocity hits a flat spot and you are at the max recommended charge area . It very well could be that's all the velocity you are safely going to get from that powder and may not actually be at your OCW for that load . I want to be clear that's a general observation to consider and is not 100% reliable as to what is your OCW or if you are at MAP .




Comment