Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Hard to pull the "new" progressive trigger...

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ARog
    Member
    • Feb 2014
    • 259

    Hard to pull the "new" progressive trigger...

    I've been eyeing the Dillon XL 650 for about a year now. I started on a Lee Single Stage, then got a classic turret and then upgraded to the Loadmaster about two years ago. Go team red!

    The Loadmaster works 90% of the time fine (after doing about every youtube modification there is to do to make it run as smooth as possible.) The 650 seems most appealing when the Loadmaster starts acting up on me so just before I pull the trigger on the 650 today I decide to load another 100 rounds of 9mm on the loadmaster; semi-hoping for a "straw-that-breaks-the-camels-back" failure (even if it was a small one) to justify a new 650. And nothing...not one hickup...no flipped or crushed primers...no lockups...no spilt powder. Just 100 rounds of perfectly reloaded ammo. Drats. Financially can I afford a 650? Yes. I've Dave Ramsey'd my way out of debt so money is not an issue. But what eats at my soul currently is, one: I'll be a windex drinker...lol...but more seriously I'd be replacing something that is not defective or broken. We live in an age where we upgrade everything and 99% of the time the thing being upgraded is perfectly fine, it's just not "new and improved." Does anyone relate or am I just becoming delusional from powder fumes and lead exposure? #leetillidie #dillonsaveme

    end rant.
  • #2
    Divernhunter
    Calguns Addict
    • May 2010
    • 8753

    Do not know what to tell you. I love my 650 and do not own any of the lee or even a Hornady progressive.

    If you enjoy the one you have now then no real reason to change. Otherwise the 650 is an excellent choice.
    A 30cal will reach out and touch them. A 50cal will kick their butt.
    NRA Life Member, NRA certified RSO & Basic Pistol Instructor, Hunter, shooter, reloader
    SCI, Manteca Sportsmen Club, Coalinga Rifle Club, Escalon Sportsmans Club, Waterford Sportsman Club & NAHA Member, Madison Society member

    Comment

    • #3
      scotty99
      Senior Member
      • Dec 2009
      • 1184

      Buy a Hornady Lock n Load and then you can stay red. I found it much easier and cheaper to get up and running then my father's 650. To ease your guilt about the upgrade, sell the Lee and help someone get into reloading.


      Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

      Comment

      • #4
        Pauliedad
        CGN/CGSSA Contributor - Lifetime
        CGN Contributor - Lifetime
        • Dec 2012
        • 2095

        Love my 650 but then, I've never have pulled a handle on any other machine. When I'm in hobby mode I want to be efficient. I don't mind tedious tasks for the most part but when I'm relaxing and loading ammo, I want to be productive.

        Comment

        • #5
          Major Danger
          Member
          • Aug 2010
          • 110

          If you put the $600 or whatever the Dillon costs into a growth stock mutual fund, you'll have to wait till you retire to buy the Dillon.

          Not really. Pay cash, sell or give away another one of you need the space, load away.

          Comment

          • #6
            BigBronco also not a Cabinetguy
            Calguns Addict
            • Jul 2009
            • 7084

            If you are content with what you are using stay the course. Most progressives out there are fine presses. Should you decide to up grade and as you stated $$$ is not the problem. Should you load for more than one caliber then I suggest comparing the costs to add additional calibers before you make your final decision. Ultimately I am sure you will make the right decision without the input of the red or blue Koolaid drinkers.
            "Life is a long song" Jethro Tull

            Comment

            • #7
              Eljay
              Veteran Member
              • Oct 2005
              • 4985

              Originally posted by ARog
              Go team red!
              That's the part I don't really get. Horses for courses and I have at least some hardware from all the major reloading brands. I have a Lee Classic Turret and a 650 with a bulletfeeder and I'm really happy with both for what I do with them.

              Progressives are for just cranking the handle and having ammo shoot out the side. They're supposed to work. Dillon pretty much has that down although even there, there's an aftermarket with nice little upgrades (my spent primers go down a tube to a 2 liter bottle instead of into a stupid little cup, that kind of thing).

              I loaded about 2K rounds of 9mm this month (just looked it up - it was 2300) and I had no flipped primers, no real drama. I did have to tighten the shellplate - it somehow had worked a bit loose and sometimes the brass wasn't quite in place for the sizing step. I did have one piece of Berdan prime brass that slipped in and I put a pretty good dent in it but didn't break/bend the decapping pin.

              Comment

              • #8
                BAWunder
                Junior Member
                • Mar 2015
                • 10

                Comment

                • #9
                  rcslotcar
                  Senior Member
                  • Jul 2014
                  • 1100

                  I used a RCBS Rock Chucker for 40 year before I bought the Dillon xl 650. The Dillon is the best investment I could have made for reloading. The only set back is the cost of caliber change set ups. I still use the RCBS unit to do some sizing/bullet pulling/load testing,etc. At this time the Dillon set up to do 9mm, 45acp and .223 with a couple more to follow.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    1859sharps
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2008
                    • 2261

                    Originally posted by ARog
                    The Loadmaster works 90% of the time fine (after doing about every youtube modification there is to do to make it run as smooth as possible.)
                    to me this right here justifies the Dillon.

                    if you have to do every youtube modification to make it work smooth....what did you gain by buying the loadmaster? why stay with something that is only 90%... buy a dillon and be 99.99999% uptime.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      stilly
                      I need a LIFE!!
                      • Jul 2009
                      • 10685

                      Originally posted by ARog
                      I've been eyeing the Dillon XL 650 for about a year now. I started on a Lee Single Stage, then got a classic turret and then upgraded to the Loadmaster about two years ago. Go team red!

                      The Loadmaster works 90% of the time fine (after doing about every youtube modification there is to do to make it run as smooth as possible.) The 650 seems most appealing when the Loadmaster starts acting up on me so just before I pull the trigger on the 650 today I decide to load another 100 rounds of 9mm on the loadmaster; semi-hoping for a "straw-that-breaks-the-camels-back" failure (even if it was a small one) to justify a new 650. And nothing...not one hickup...no flipped or crushed primers...no lockups...no spilt powder. Just 100 rounds of perfectly reloaded ammo. Drats. Financially can I afford a 650? Yes. I've Dave Ramsey'd my way out of debt so money is not an issue. But what eats at my soul currently is, one: I'll be a windex drinker...lol...but more seriously I'd be replacing something that is not defective or broken. We live in an age where we upgrade everything and 99% of the time the thing being upgraded is perfectly fine, it's just not "new and improved." Does anyone relate or am I just becoming delusional from powder fumes and lead exposure? #leetillidie #dillonsaveme

                      end rant.
                      Wow... Brother?

                      So I started on a Lee Classic Turret based on advice here and after 3 years I saw someone offer up a Loadmaster with "Indexing issues" for $150 setup for 40/9mm in the marketplace here so I bought it. Hey, $150 for a progressive aint all that bad and after I see that the Lee Classic Turret works as excellent as it does, I figured that Lee had another winner with the Loadmaster. When it was requested that I had to make 10k rds of 9mm I was like, oh HELL NO I aint gonna do that on my turret. So I busted out the Loadmaster that had been sitting in a box for the past 1.5 years and I started to tinker with it. I was not happy because Lee has taken their typical "simple" and squared it. The problem is that by being simple squared, they had made a machine that has been designed to be simple and efficient, but not bulletproof. As soon as one thing gets out of whack, the new user might tend to go check EVERYTHING and thus, get more things out of alignment so that now the simplicity is gone and you have to start from the top and adjust it all to make certain it is working properly. I think the weakest point is the priming. If you can get the priming fixed and working solid then you should have NO issues with the Loadmaster. The next thing is the indexing. But once I recalibrated the indexing flipper and rod, it all seemed to work FINE. Every now and then it might start to not index, but that means I need to check and possibly tighten the locknut in the middle of the shell carrier. Simple things like that, but MAN it can certainly crank out the ammo if you need it to in comparison to the turret anyways. But that is expected.

                      Here is my take, I have heard it from many folks, Dillon makes a good machine that is for the most part, a decent and performing machine. I have never seriously knocked their machines for failing to work. Dillon might have a solid rep for having a nearly bulletproof machine. I know the Loadmaster is NOT bulletproof. It works, but like a house of cards. RCBS has a good reputation and I have never heard anything mean about their machines. I like that they came out with the Pro Chucker progressive line and I was seriously thinking of trying one of them out.

                      If you gotta make that ammo, and you are tired of having to mess with that Loadmaster, then by all means, it might be time to upgrade to a more bulletproof machine. I am a hardcore Lee fan as well since I believe in being able to perform the job by spending as little money as possible and buying a progressive for $300 or less is VERY nice in thought. I only wish that their Loadmaster and their Pro-1000 worked as well as their classic turret. If they did, we would not be talking about it here.

                      So think it over. Personally though, I would not consider a Dillon unless you have at least $2000 ready to dump on it. The 650 may start at around $400 or $500 or whatever but if you want it to work like they show it and everyone else has it, you will be spending at least twice that and more. $2000 should have you covered for a 650XL.

                      Lee is certainly an underdog but we all know that they crank out some good dies and some excellent 6 cavity molds. Hey my boolits do not care WHAT mold they drop out of or that there is 6 of them at a time so I am happy to have seen them perform. For $40, a 6 cavity mold is AWESOME and I doubt there is a difference between an Arsenal aluminum mold and a Lee aluminum mold. Oh yeah, Lee has the better CAM lever action plate thingamabobber...

                      Well, your decision to migrate should be easier than this so think it over and enjoy whatever you decide.

                      Oh yeah and here is something else I learned. I ALSO started watching the you-tube videos on the Loadmaster. You know what I learned from them? Most of those people are asshats who do not know what they are talking about. And some of them do have an idea and they are trying to be helpful, but in the end, me bringing my Loadmaster BACK to factory specs with new parts that Lee kept sending me (free of charge let me add) while working with me via e-mail got my Loadmaster BACK to working properly. The ONLY mod that I am running is the hole with the primer LED indicator mod. I might move to a shake brake just to see if it helps anymore as well, but so far that is only for priming. Mods are weird, if they do not ban you for something stupid they all get together and **** up your Loadmaster so beware of that...
                      Last edited by stilly; 09-29-2015, 1:23 PM.
                      7 Billion people on the planet. They aint ALL gonna astronauts. Some will get hit by trains...

                      Need GOOD SS pins to clean your brass? Try the new and improved model...



                      And remember- 99.9% of the lawyers ruin it for the other .1%...

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        ARog
                        Member
                        • Feb 2014
                        • 259

                        Originally posted by 1859sharps
                        to me this right here justifies the Dillon.

                        if you have to do every youtube modification to make it work smooth....what did you gain by buying the loadmaster? why stay with something that is only 90%... buy a dillon and be 99.99999% uptime.
                        I saved about $1000. lol Now the kicker is I reloaded 500 rounds this morning and still not one hickup...lol...eventually I will upgrade to the Dillon but it's almost like my Loadmaster knew it was about to be replaced so it starting working flawlessly to avoid it...lol

                        Cheers everyone and thanks for the input!

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          milotrain
                          Veteran Member
                          • Apr 2011
                          • 4301

                          My dillon has never been 100% uptime. In fact I'd consider it a 90% or 95% uptime device. I would absolutely try someone else's Dillon first. I love mine but if you have gotten a loadmaster to run 90% of the time then maybe you are out of the woods.
                          weg: That device is obsolete now. They replaced it with wizards.
                          frank: Wait a minute. There are more than one wizard? Is [are?] the wizard calibrated?

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            Eljay
                            Veteran Member
                            • Oct 2005
                            • 4985

                            Fear can be a powerful motivator. Poor little thing.

                            If it works only you can decide how much money it's worth to move up. Personally I was fine with the turret press until I got semi-serious about USPSA and I started going to more matches, practicing, signing up for classes with high round counts and it would have just killed me to load those the way it was going.
                            Last edited by Eljay; 09-29-2015, 1:44 PM.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              1859sharps
                              Senior Member
                              • Jun 2008
                              • 2261

                              Originally posted by ARog
                              I saved about $1000. lol Now the kicker is I reloaded 500 rounds this morning and still not one hickup...lol...eventually I will upgrade to the Dillon but it's almost like my Loadmaster knew it was about to be replaced so it starting working flawlessly to avoid it...lol

                              Cheers everyone and thanks for the input!
                              there is always the Dillon 550b. if volume or money is an issue.

                              I have the 550b and have no intention of upgrading.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1