Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Ctr-02

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    bwiese
    I need a LIFE!!
    • Oct 2005
    • 27622

    These concepts prob apply to some US mfgd AK receivers as well since they are not on the Harrott mandated Roster. There are some that are not on the List and are pretty cheap. Buy a couple (after permission & getting FFL cooperation) for insurance. If they get declared as AWs, build 'em up. If not, you've only lost $150.

    Bill Wiese
    San Jose

    Bill Wiese
    San Jose, CA

    CGF Board Member / NRA Benefactor Life Member / CRPA life member
    sigpic
    No postings of mine here, unless otherwise specifically noted, are
    to be construed as formal or informal positions of the Calguns.Net
    ownership, The Calguns Foundation, Inc. ("CGF"), the NRA, or my
    employer. No posts of mine on Calguns are to be construed as
    legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

    Comment

    • #17
      Richard
      Senior Member
      • Oct 2005
      • 1286

      Originally posted by 6172crew
      Best news all day! Does anyone have a list of non-named lowers? Or that funky list of the added AW's?
      here's one you won't find on that list....and you might be able to pick up an original
      Essential Arms or as you may remember " EA-J15"
      " Membership since 2003"

      Comment

      • #18
        Stanze
        Veteran Member
        • Oct 2005
        • 3301

        Originally posted by Richard
        here's one you won't find on that list....and you might be able to pick up an original
        Essential Arms or as you may remember " EA-J15"
        http://essentialarms.com/index.html
        + http://www.fulton-armory.com/
        Constitutionally, officials cannot license or register a fundamental right.

        "It is the first responsibility of every citizen to question authority." - Benjamin Franklin


        "Lifetime warranty and excellent customer service don't mean a thing when your gun fails during a zombie attack." -Stanze

        Comment

        • #19
          artherd
          Calguns Addict
          • Oct 2005
          • 5038

          Originally posted by bu-bye
          So this would be good new for my KT-10 build right. KT-10 is what KT Ordnance calls their 80% "AR-10" lower. As long as the mag is pinned and its not on the list its ok and If it does make the list I can unpin the mag.
          It's encouraging, but you'll absolutely need to get a seperate DOJ letter regarding exactly the KT-10 build. Homebuilts are tricky, it is not clear to me how the DOJ treats them as far as 'make and model' goes.

          I would *think* that in order to remain consistant in law, that the Make and Model of the KT-10 would be "Bu-bye" and "My Rifle2005" respectively, and that to BAN them under CURRENT statutes, the DOJ would have to place an injunction, hold and win a Supior Court hearing, and then promologate the make/model in a list. Yes for each and every homebuilder. But this is reaching way way way far, a court may not agree, and the DOJ themselves should be consulted.
          Last edited by artherd; 04-18-2010, 3:55 PM.
          - Ben Cannon.
          Chairman, CEO -
          CoFounder - Postings are my own, and are not formal positions of any other entity, or legal advice.

          Comment

          • #20
            artherd
            Calguns Addict
            • Oct 2005
            • 5038

            Hi Bill, thanks for the kind words, coming from you I take as quite a compliment. Forgive me for not spilling the beans untill it was all said and done, but I wanted to make sure I was not blowing smoke up anyone's skirt.
            Originally posted by bwiese
            God DAMN! Good going Ben/Artherd, good letter...
            This is the first real operational acknowledgement from DOJ/AG office that you legally acquire a non-Harrott-listed AR receiver. By extension this would apply to non-Harrott-listed AK receivers as well.
            The importance of this goes quite beyond trying to make some kinda gripless AR.
            You bet it does!
            "Near future"? This wording suggests possibly there's an upcoming administrative attempt to update the Harrott-inspired DOJ Roster of AR15 and AK Series Weapons. But these could also just be cautionary CYA weasel words too - or there could be some legislative stuff in committee we haven't heard of (but I doubt this latter case).
            I've got a FEELING this was fluf and bluf language. Ie put in to make the FFLs nervous. I went through SEVEN FFLs before I found one willing to take both the time to review the legal aspect, and to finally do the transfer.

            Here's why I think they were bluffing: One of the FFLs was all set, then they called the DOJ just to verify. The agent who answered the phone interrupted my FFL, saying "I KNOW OF THE LETTER! Thing is, once we see it DROS'd, we're going to ban it immediately*, and then come right after you for posession of an AW in inventory withought an AW permit!"

            *= Note that this is not possible for two reasons
            1) CPC 12276.5 spells out exactly how the DOJ may 'ban' a series AW. They may issue only a temporary suspension of the sale/transfer, and then within 30 days must hold a Supior Court hearing in a populace county where the TRIAL COURT determines AW status. During that 30 day period the FFL would be able to send the weapon back out of state even if they lacked a CA AW permit.

            2) Make/Model information is not included in DROS for longguns at all, so they will never know what's happening (unless they flagged my name and looked at my next purchase. Just to fsck with them I bought a shotgun
            There is a dim-bright side to all of this, however:

            ....if AR/AK receivers that aren't declared as named/Type II AWs now (like the CTR02, a couple of other off-brand AR receivers, and some new US-made AK-style stamped receivers) get added to the list for 'functional identicality', these will become full-fledged CA AWs upon that declaration. While registration will be required after 90? days, once it's declared as an AW you can add evil features galore (detachable magwell w/pistol grip, flash hider, folder stock, etc. etc.)

            I do not believe that any retroactive 'ban' would fall in place kinda like the early '90s SKS fiasco: that is, a situation where a receiver CTR02 is allowed now, but then added to DOJ Roster list - but then also not allowed to be registered as AW. I believe once a gun/receiver is added to the list and promulgated as an AW, that triggers a registration period to come into compliance (register it, surrender it, move it/sell it out of state, etc.)
            Bill, I *THINK* historically speaking you'd be correct here in that we would open up another 90day reg period. I also *think* this *may be* WHY the DOJ has not yet updated their list at all since the last registration interval. Do you have anything we can sink our teeth into that would require a new 90day registration period for new AWs (and maybe for ALL AWs?)[/quote]
            I think a 'substantially different' receiver - like the FAB10 - will not be banned or declared as an AW.
            Another recent event, the G&B Sales "Bushmaster XM-15" (a NAMED! reciver) with welded mag-wel being declared a legal longgun seems to support the idea that the FAB-10 will fall outside whatever else happens here.
            The Vulcan receiver is in more questionable territory, but of course if Vulcan gets 'declared' as an AW, you can rip out the affixed mag

            I will have to read more deeply on how items are declared AWs, and procedures for adding to Harrott list.
            Check CPC 12276.5 for starts. Unfortunately a grace period and new registration is not mentioned.
            - Ben Cannon.
            Chairman, CEO -
            CoFounder - Postings are my own, and are not formal positions of any other entity, or legal advice.

            Comment

            • #21
              bwiese
              I need a LIFE!!
              • Oct 2005
              • 27622

              Artherd/Ben...

              Change your sigline, Tim Riegert's not at DOJ anymore. Apparently it's Alison Merilees now, perhaps just ad interim.

              Originally posted by artherd
              It's encouraging, but you'll absolutely need to get a seperate DOJ letter regarding exactly the KT-10 build. Homebuilts are tricky, it is not clear to me how the DOJ treats them as far as 'make and model' goes. It is also not clear to me how

              I would *think* that in order to remain consistant in law, that the Make and Model of the KT-10 would be "Bu-bye" and "My Rifle2005" respectively, and that to BAN them under CURRENT statutes, the DOJ would have to place an injunction, hold and win a Supior Court hearing, and then promologate the make/model in a list. Yes for each and every homebuilder. But this is reaching way way way far, the DOJ themselves should be consulted.
              As you seem to realize - and like I told buBye before - homebuilt ARs and AKs can be tricky.

              I really, really think if you were popped for AW possesion of a homebuilt AR that there's a fair chance Harrott v Kings County does not offer you protection even though your gun is 'off-list'.

              A judge could rule as a matter of law that there's no way the DOJ Roster mandated by Harrott could conceivably be practical for homebuilts, and no way it could be created to ban homebuilts due to banning criteria is make and model, and that this was an attempt to bypass legislative intent - that is, ban ARs & AKs. The fact that Harrott allows some oddball mfgrd AR receivers to exist is a side effect and not central to the fact that the List could _never_ be set up for homebuilts by name/model/etc.

              And if Harrott doesn't hold for an AR/AK, then Kasler takes over: it'd be an AR since it "walks like a duck and talks like a duck" and, since unregistered, you'd be guilty of illegal AW possession.



              Bill Wiese
              San Jose

              Bill Wiese
              San Jose, CA

              CGF Board Member / NRA Benefactor Life Member / CRPA life member
              sigpic
              No postings of mine here, unless otherwise specifically noted, are
              to be construed as formal or informal positions of the Calguns.Net
              ownership, The Calguns Foundation, Inc. ("CGF"), the NRA, or my
              employer. No posts of mine on Calguns are to be construed as
              legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

              Comment

              • #22
                blacklisted
                Veteran Member
                • Oct 2005
                • 2608

                This is great news!

                Does mean that one could theoretically get any (stripped) lower receiver not on the list (if there is a brave enough FFL in his or her area) and pin a mag in it (or have a mag pinned in it)? I do forsee DoJ trying to cover their asses here and adding pretty much every receiver to the list. In some ways that is a good thing though.

                Comment

                • #23
                  artherd
                  Calguns Addict
                  • Oct 2005
                  • 5038

                  Originally posted by Technical Ted
                  Ben,
                  I'll be damned. Congratulations.
                  Looks like I'm eating crow for lunch.
                  No hard feelings, come shoot it sometime(maybe not that interesting with 10round mag though , beer afterwords on me!

                  A footnote, this was my SECOND Certified Letter to the DOJ regarding this issue! The first time all I got in responce was a photocopy of CPC 12276, which may have been tactic admission I was correct, but not nearly enough to act on.

                  This time I recived a solid reply with a re-worded letter. This whole thing has been nearly 2 years in the making (albit off and on.)

                  Attached is my origional letter for reference. Feel free to adapt the format though I am no great author.
                  Page 1 of 2

                  Page 2 of 2
                  - Ben Cannon.
                  Chairman, CEO -
                  CoFounder - Postings are my own, and are not formal positions of any other entity, or legal advice.

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    artherd
                    Calguns Addict
                    • Oct 2005
                    • 5038

                    Originally posted by gobabygo
                    So it appears that we should be able to purchase a JP CTR-02 rifle either without the pistol grip or with a pinned mag.
                    This was overkill on my part, but to ease the nerves of my FFL I acutally did both, removed the PG *AND* affixed a 10 round magazine in place all before it was sent into CA.
                    - Ben Cannon.
                    Chairman, CEO -
                    CoFounder - Postings are my own, and are not formal positions of any other entity, or legal advice.

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      bwiese
                      I need a LIFE!!
                      • Oct 2005
                      • 27622

                      Originally posted by artherd
                      Here's why I think they were bluffing: One of the FFLs was all set, then they called the DOJ just to verify. The agent who answered the phone interrupted my FFL, saying "I KNOW OF THE LETTER! Thing is, once we see it DROS'd, we're going to ban it immediately*, and then come right after you for posession of an AW in inventory withought an AW permit!
                      That could well be agent/phone operator/idiot 'Dana' who told 6172crew here that SW5 receivers (HK94 clones) were banned "by class". Or one of the idiots that arrested folks at the Pomona gun show awhile back for illegal AW possession for having HK trigger group pistol grip lowers.

                      He may possibly have been mistakenly thinking the intent was to acquire a receiver legitmately then convert it to an AW, and that the dealer would have an AW on his shelf at moment of bust. But I think you were clear that this would never be in Type III AW form.

                      And "Banning" it will take procedural/admin/signoff work and is way beyond the skill or pay grade/authority level of that agent.

                      Bill, I *THINK* historically speaking you'd be correct here in that we would open up another 90day reg period. I also *think* this *may be* WHY the DOJ has not yet updated their list at all since the last registration interval. Do you have anything we can sink our teeth into that would require a new 90day registration period for new AWs (and maybe for ALL AWs?)
                      I'll look. Some of this is law, some of this is delegated to DOJ for sheer mechanics of administering registration program. Remember, one of the goals of AW law appears to be to avoid seizures and compensation so property-rights court challenges wouldn't use up staff/court time.

                      The DOJ may not have updated this list out of sheer bureucratic inertia. And probably not a lot of Gun List readers there.

                      Another recent event, the G&B Sales "Bushmaster XM-15" (a NAMED! reciver) with welded mag-wel being declared a legal longgun seems to support the idea that the FAB-10 will fall outside whatever else happens here.
                      Yeah, that 'time + tools' thing appears to override the name.


                      Check CPC 12276.5 for starts. Unfortunately a grace period and new registration is not mentioned.
                      Yes. That may be allowed to be set by agency to something reasonable for admin purposes. If they made it 10 years or 1 day, those'd both be unreasonable to differing parties and challenged on that basis.


                      Bill Wiese
                      San Jose

                      Bill Wiese
                      San Jose, CA

                      CGF Board Member / NRA Benefactor Life Member / CRPA life member
                      sigpic
                      No postings of mine here, unless otherwise specifically noted, are
                      to be construed as formal or informal positions of the Calguns.Net
                      ownership, The Calguns Foundation, Inc. ("CGF"), the NRA, or my
                      employer. No posts of mine on Calguns are to be construed as
                      legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        artherd
                        Calguns Addict
                        • Oct 2005
                        • 5038

                        As far as other lower options; The high quality 'mil spec' Lewis Machine and Tool springs to mind. I hesitate a little to print an easy to digest 'list' of non-named AR/AK lowers, but I CAN list the ones that ARE banned, and by definition the ones you find should be legal (subject to DOJ approval, I would get a letter of your own and not rely totally on mine.)

                        Category 1 & 2 both in an easy-to-digest list: http://ag.ca.gov/firearms/regs/aw.htm

                        This includes the usual CPC 12276(a)-(c) AND the elusive yet law; CPC 12276(e)
                        If it's not on there, it's worthy of a DOJ letter at the least.
                        - Ben Cannon.
                        Chairman, CEO -
                        CoFounder - Postings are my own, and are not formal positions of any other entity, or legal advice.

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          artherd
                          Calguns Addict
                          • Oct 2005
                          • 5038

                          Originally posted by bwiese
                          Artherd/Ben...
                          Change your sigline, Tim Riegert's not at DOJ anymore. Apparently it's Alison Merilees now, perhaps just ad interim.
                          Done, thanks. I've noticed Alison seems to be Tim's permant replacement. (also if you know how to make my font smaller on both windows/mac computers, I'd like to shrink it a little in the interest of space

                          Yes, I really have no idea how a trial court might apply Harrott to homebuilts. I woudn't touch one with a 10-round pole with-ought a STRONG letter from an Attorney like Allison within the DOJ.
                          - Ben Cannon.
                          Chairman, CEO -
                          CoFounder - Postings are my own, and are not formal positions of any other entity, or legal advice.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            C.G.
                            Calguns Addict
                            • Oct 2005
                            • 8259

                            Originally posted by artherd

                            This time I recived a solid reply with a re-worded letter. This whole thing has been nearly 2 years in the making (albit off and on.)
                            I don't feel so bad now, I've only been at it 7 months now. Maybe in another year I will have my toy.
                            sigpic

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              artherd
                              Calguns Addict
                              • Oct 2005
                              • 5038

                              Originally posted by bwiese
                              That could well be agent/phone operator/idiot 'Dana' who told 6172crew here that SW5 receivers (HK94 clones) were banned "by class". Or one of the idiots that arrested folks at the Pomona gun show awhile back for illegal AW possession for having HK trigger group pistol grip lowers.
                              Funny side note; The phone clerk was familiar with my letter off the top of his head over 2 weeks after I recived it, and thought the author of the letter (myself) was a Doctor. (heh. Formatting is awesome.)
                              And "Banning" it will take procedural/admin/signoff work and is way beyond the skill or pay grade/authority level of that agent.
                              Not to mention a trial court purusuant to CPC 12276.5: http://ag.ca.gov/firearms/dwcl/12275.htm
                              I'll look. Some of this is law, some of this is delegated to DOJ for sheer mechanics of administering registration program. Remember, one of the goals of AW law appears to be to avoid seizures and compensation so property-rights court challenges wouldn't use up staff/court time.
                              Yep, I'm in about the same place, based on regulatory history it should happen the way we think (another 90day period in which to register... possibly any new AW of any type.)
                              The DOJ may not have updated this list out of sheer bureucratic inertia. And probably not a lot of Gun List readers there.
                              Also a distinct possibility!
                              - Ben Cannon.
                              Chairman, CEO -
                              CoFounder - Postings are my own, and are not formal positions of any other entity, or legal advice.

                              Comment

                              • #30

                                I have not read the recent posts you and bwiese have written, but give them hell guys!

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1