Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Bullet physics question

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #46
    krwada
    Senior Member
    CGN Contributor
    • Jun 2013
    • 1457

    STP

    Originally posted by Frisco3Gun
    Good catch, but I was trying to clarify the first statement that doesn't hold in all scenarios. Didn't mean to sound like a smarty-pants, but I'm not a fan of incomplete information flying around.

    Yes, sound needs a medium to travel through. I just wanted to give an objective answer, not the easy way out. Even subsonic bullets can heat up without the supersonic shockwave.
    Now ... I did say at Standard Temperature and Pressure now did I not? There was no incomplete information in the comment I made.

    Do you know the meaning of Standard Temperature and Pressure, (STP)? It was you who added this stuff about vacuum and light ... not me.

    Also; it was you who insinuated some type of understanding of fluid mechanics and heat transfer ... and some how insinuated that I lacked some kind of understanding of these topics?

    Actually, it is relatively pointless to argue with you. Why don't you just head on over to that FLIR image of an actual .30 caliber bullet taken in mid flight ... and come up with your own conclusions?

    And please, do not post them here.

    Haw!
    Last edited by krwada; 08-08-2014, 2:50 PM.

    Comment

    • #47
      Magazineman
      Junior Member
      • May 2014
      • 98

      COMPRESSION is the cause of most of the heat, in my opinion.

      You pump up a bike tire to 70 PSI & the pump gets hot.

      A diesel engine ignites at 22/1 compression.

      A gun generates MASSIVLY MORE compression than those!! About 35,000 PSI. That's the whole point. That's how they WORK.

      Air-friction? Nope. ---A bullet has a very low surface area-to-mass ratio (again, part of the point here) & an extremely short flight time to build air-friction heat. That can't be it.

      Barrel friction? Maybe a little, but again that dense-as-hell bullet gets heated all the way through in two inches. (J frame) So that's not it.

      It's compression. I'm no physics expert, but I think this one is obvious.

      Comment

      • #48
        CSACANNONEER
        CGN/CGSSA Contributor - Lifetime
        CGN Contributor - Lifetime
        • Dec 2006
        • 44094

        Originally posted by Wicked Pete
        I had the misfortune of having a bullet come my way, about 5 feet away from my head. I could feel the heat of it as it passed. Now that's HOT!

        Did I poop my pants?
        I've had many 50cal bullets fly a few feet from my head and I've never felt heat from any of them.
        NRA Certified Pistol, Rifle, Shotgun and Metallic Cartridge Reloading Instructor
        California DOJ Certified Fingerprint Roller
        Ventura County approved CCW Instructor
        Utah CCW Instructor


        Offering low cost multi state CCW, private basic shooting and reloading classes for calgunners.

        sigpic
        CCW SAFE MEMBERSHIPS HERE

        KM6WLV

        Comment

        • #49
          krwada
          Senior Member
          CGN Contributor
          • Jun 2013
          • 1457

          Compression

          Originally posted by Magazineman
          COMPRESSION is the cause of most of the heat, in my opinion.

          You pump up a bike tire to 70 PSI & the pump gets hot.

          A diesel engine ignites at 22/1 compression.

          A gun generates MASSIVLY MORE compression than those!! About 35,000 PSI. That's the whole point. That's how they WORK.

          Air-friction? Nope. ---A bullet has a very low surface area-to-mass ratio (again, part of the point here) & an extremely short flight time to build air-friction heat. That can't be it.

          Barrel friction? Maybe a little, but again that dense-as-hell bullet gets heated all the way through in two inches. (J frame) So that's not it.

          It's compression. I'm no physics expert, but I think this one is obvious.
          Yes ... when you compress a gas ... it will get hot. The phenomenon is also known as adiabatic compression ...

          From the ideal gas equation we get:

          PV = nRT

          P = pressure
          V = volume
          n = amount of gas, (usually expressed in moles)
          R = gas constant, (a constant)
          T = Temperature

          Now; if we rearrange the equation, we get the following:

          T = PV / nR

          Which tells us that for a fixed volume, (your tire for example) ... if we increase the pressure the temperature will increase

          Now ... in the diesel engine ... Volume does not remain constant here. Actually, the volume is shrinking. However, in opposition to this the pressure is dramatically increasing ... By a lot!!! Therefore, you will get heating in that diesel cylinder ... thus getting the fuel to light up.

          There are other phenomena to consider ....
          1. Friction, (yes friction does exist)
          2. Shock wave, (only applicable if we are going supersonic ... which the rifle bullet is)
          3. Changes in the medium, (in this case air ... and the viscosity of air)

          So ... all of these will have an effect ... including the adiabatic heating you point out in your post.

          The question is how much effect each one has.

          So far ... from what I can see, the Rocket Guy has the best explanation of what is going on. Plus, his explanation appears to match the FLIR evidence I posted.

          Friction is not to be ignored. I can vigorously rub two sticks together and start a fire. All of this ... and I do not even need to rub the two sticks in a super sonic fashion.

          Comment

          • #50
            krwada
            Senior Member
            CGN Contributor
            • Jun 2013
            • 1457

            Feelings

            Originally posted by CSACANNONEER
            I've had many 50cal bullets fly a few feet from my head and I've never felt heat from any of them.
            You should not feel any heat from any of them.

            Air at Standard Temperature and Pressure, (STP), is a darn good insulator! Plus, the temperature is not nearly high enough for radiative heat transfer.

            The only transfer would be via convection or conduction. Convection would be pretty negligible since at these high Reynolds numbers ... the boundary layer would be miniscule.

            And as I have said ... conduction is out of the question because air is such a good insulator.

            Now ... I can tell you this ... If someone were shooting at me ... and I hear that buzzing sound. My head and extremities would definitely get flush from increased blood flow due to more adrenalin going through my system....

            I would definitely get that warm feeling as a result!

            Also ... elevated adrenalin levels have known to cause a laxative or diuretic effect to people ... (tendency to poo or pee the pants) ... I think this tendency is quite normal. I think ... I would have difficulty controlling my sphincter or bladder if I were getting shot at!
            Last edited by krwada; 08-08-2014, 3:10 PM.

            Comment

            • #51
              Magazineman
              Junior Member
              • May 2014
              • 98

              I'll stick with compression as BY FAR the biggest contributor to bullet heat.

              I fired the J Frame I spoke of into a sand bucket, Then dug out the bullet. It was hot as hell. Had to drop it.

              The FMJ bullet was not deformed much, so we can discount the heat generated by squishing metal.

              The distance was standing-to-bucket. Two feet? At 850 FPS it's flight time is 1/425th of a second. You could not get a bullet that hot in 1/425th of a second if you chucked it into a volcano. So much for air-friction.

              Barrel friction? Two inches of it? SAND friction? Smooth copper sliding against sand for 10 inches?

              It's the heat of the propellant (slightly) & the heat of the compression generated. (mostly) again, in my uneducated opinion nothing else makes much sense.

              Comment

              • #52
                krwada
                Senior Member
                CGN Contributor
                • Jun 2013
                • 1457

                An excellent test

                Originally posted by Magazineman
                I'll stick with compression as BY FAR the biggest contributor to bullet heat.

                I fired the J Frame I spoke of into a sand bucket, Then dug out the bullet. It was hot as hell. Had to drop it.

                The FMJ bullet was not deformed much, so we can discount the heat generated by squishing metal.

                The distance was standing-to-bucket. Two feet? At 850 FPS it's flight time is 1/425th of a second. You could not get a bullet that hot in 1/425th of a second if you chucked it into a volcano. So much for air-friction.

                Barrel friction? Two inches of it? SAND friction? Smooth copper sliding against sand for 10 inches?

                It's the heat of the propellant (slightly) & the heat of the compression generated. (mostly) again, in my uneducated opinion nothing else makes much sense.
                You neglected the heating due to the powder burning.... That has to get the bullet pretty hot.

                You stopped the bullet almost as it came out of the muzzle.

                How much of that heat you felt was due to the burning gas?

                Doing these kind of experiments are difficult because everytime you do do something... You inadvertently affect the result!

                Do this test for me.

                Get a pistol round, and if you reload, use something light ... like Trailboss. Then shoot a bucket of water from about 50 to 100 yards away.

                Put a thermometer in the bucket of water, (before you shoot into the bucket) and look for the rise in the temperature of the thermometer.

                Sand ... water ... You will see some compression no?

                The rise in temperature should tell you something no?

                Again ... these things are very difficult to measure. Every time you measure something ... you will invariably introduce a new variable or alter the result in some way.

                Another good one....

                Get yourself one of those PCP air rifles that can push a 200 grain projectile at the same speed as a .45 ACP.

                Compare the result of your sand test with the .45 ACP along with the PCP rifle.

                You can then eliminate the powder burning as a variable.

                I really look forward to more tests!


                This kind of stuff is what made our Country... the USA great! We argue ... but the proof is in the doing no?
                Last edited by krwada; 08-08-2014, 9:09 PM.

                Comment

                • #53
                  as_rocketman
                  CGSSA Leader
                  • Jan 2011
                  • 3057

                  Originally posted by krwada
                  Yes ... when you compress a gas ... it will get hot. The phenomenon is also known as adiabatic compression ...
                  This is correct, "adiabatic" because there is no heat entering or leaving the flow. However the Ideal Gas Law doesn't give you the solution, because you need an equation of state. If we assume the gas passes through a single shock, however, it can be solved very quickly. The shock either compresses or expands the gas.

                  If subsonic, the gas will not be compressed to any significant degree, and thus there is virtually no heat exchange. At transonic speeds (specifically, above the Critical Mach Number) the bullet is subsonic but in order to flow around it, the flow somewhere must accelerate to sonic speeds -- the situation gets more interesting, but it's still less heating than we see at supersonic speeds.

                  Originally posted by krwada
                  There are other phenomena to consider ....
                  1. Friction, (yes friction does exist)
                  Negligible. Heating from friction only occurs when the boundary layer sheds and rolls up into turbulence. While this does happen, it happens at a length scale longer than virtually any bullet, and thus contributes to heating of the wake, not the bullet.

                  Originally posted by krwada
                  2. Shock wave, (only applicable if we are going supersonic ... which the rifle bullet is)
                  Yup.

                  Originally posted by krwada
                  3. Changes in the medium, (in this case air ... and the viscosity of air)
                  Possible but in our model, we assume the freestream is isotropic. If you shot a bullet into a supercooled suspension of ideally mixed flammables, all bets are off.

                  Originally posted by krwada
                  Friction is not to be ignored. I can vigorously rub two sticks together and start a fire. All of this ... and I do not even need to rub the two sticks in a super sonic fashion.
                  Mechanical friction of solids is very different than gas dynamics. In that situation you are causing plastic deformation of the solid surfaces through abrasion and erosion, dissipating kinetic energy into heat through strain. This is not too far removed from the ablative mechanism experienced at very high Mach by blunt objects. None of that happens for a properly designed bullet.
                  Riflemen Needed.

                  Ask me about Appleseed! Send a PM or see me in the Appleseed subforum.

                  Comment

                  • #54
                    Magazineman
                    Junior Member
                    • May 2014
                    • 98

                    krwada---You said I ignored the heat from the powder burning. I did not. Read my last sentence.

                    But overall, energy transferred to the bullet has to go somewhere. It's expended as both heat & motion.

                    Comment

                    • #55
                      krwada
                      Senior Member
                      CGN Contributor
                      • Jun 2013
                      • 1457

                      Pretty much the picture!

                      Originally posted by as_rocketman
                      This is correct, "adiabatic" because there is no heat entering or leaving the flow. However the Ideal Gas Law doesn't give you the solution, because you need an equation of state. If we assume the gas passes through a single shock, however, it can be solved very quickly. The shock either compresses or expands the gas.

                      If subsonic, the gas will not be compressed to any significant degree, and thus there is virtually no heat exchange. At transonic speeds (specifically, above the Critical Mach Number) the bullet is subsonic but in order to flow around it, the flow somewhere must accelerate to sonic speeds -- the situation gets more interesting, but it's still less heating than we see at supersonic speeds.



                      Negligible. Heating from friction only occurs when the boundary layer sheds and rolls up into turbulence. While this does happen, it happens at a length scale longer than virtually any bullet, and thus contributes to heating of the wake, not the bullet.


                      Yup.



                      Possible but in our model, we assume the freestream is isotropic. If you shot a bullet into a supercooled suspension of ideally mixed flammables, all bets are off.



                      Mechanical friction of solids is very different than gas dynamics. In that situation you are causing plastic deformation of the solid surfaces through abrasion and erosion, dissipating kinetic energy into heat through strain. This is not too far removed from the ablative mechanism experienced at very high Mach by blunt objects. None of that happens for a properly designed bullet.
                      Dang ... and I thought I was the only one here that had some modicum of understanding of thermodynamics and fluid mechanics at very high Reynolds numbers!

                      You ... obviously have a quite a good grasp of this!

                      Say ... Do you know what the Reynolds number of the gas around the space shuttle is when it is coming in from orbit?

                      I have difficulty grasping such large physical numbers.

                      It must be huge.

                      By the way ... Your last statement ... I did not know this. I now know ... from what you have said that it takes a very high velocity for this to occur.

                      The compression from the shock wave ... well I do know a little bit about this ... Those professors made sure that it got beat into me when I was a graduate student.

                      Heh!
                      Last edited by krwada; 08-08-2014, 11:40 PM.

                      Comment

                      • #56
                        as_rocketman
                        CGSSA Leader
                        • Jan 2011
                        • 3057

                        I don't but I can compute it:

                        Re = U L / nu

                        where U is a characteristic speed -- in this case, call it 7.5 km/s

                        L is a characteristic length, let's use a nice round 35 m (comparable to the length of the Orbiter)

                        and nu is the kinematic viscosity of the fluid, which takes some figuring...

                        The value we really want, nu, is mu divided by the density. The dynamic viscosity mu is temperature dependent, and the temperature behaves strangely in the upper atmosphere (referred to as the "thermosphere" for a reason). If we pick an altitude of 100 km (the Karman Line), T is at a local minimum of about 200 K, and we get a value for mu = 13.3 mg / m sec.

                        Next we need the air density, which is falling off logarithmically at this high altitude. Again at 100 km we have a density of approximately 21 mg / cubic meter, thus nu is 0.63 m^2 / sec.

                        This is an extremely high value of kinematic viscosity compared to air down here near the ground. This means that visually, because the air is so thin, moving through it is more like moving through sand than through air or water with respect to turbulence etc. -- except that "sand" is incredibly light, so the actual drag forces are quite low...

                        Anyway, the answer is Re = (7500 m / s) (35 m) / (0.63 m^2 / s) = about 410,000. Very turbulent.

                        But much lower Re than something like a hurricane. Denser air sets up turbulent structures much more easily than the near-vacuum of the upper atmosphere.

                        By comparison, our bullet example, using a speed of 800 m/s and a length (bullet length) of 2 cm, at sea level, would have:

                        Re = (800 m / s)(0.02 m) / (0.000016 m^2 / s) = 1 million

                        Thus its flow would be considered slightly more turbulent than the Space Shuttle Orbiter at re-entry.
                        Riflemen Needed.

                        Ask me about Appleseed! Send a PM or see me in the Appleseed subforum.

                        Comment

                        • #57
                          I Swan
                          Calguns Addict
                          • Sep 2010
                          • 8770

                          Not scientific but I've been hit by bullet fragments and they are hot. I've been shot at but I guess didn't come close enough to me to register warmth on my body. A friend of mine has been shot I think he mentioned it feeling hot.

                          Comment

                          • #58
                            Magazineman
                            Junior Member
                            • May 2014
                            • 98

                            Air rifles also generate heat by their compression. I have heard that some will "diesel" their lubricants. Gasoline engines will after-run on fumes at half the comp ratio of a diesel.

                            There also are indigenous tribesmen who have a wooden piston-&-pipe setup that they use for starting fires.

                            How much pressure you think they get out of one of those? Not the 35,000 psi of a .38 Special! But they still ignite their tinder.

                            My money is on compression w/ the combustion in second position.

                            Comment

                            • #59
                              Magazineman
                              Junior Member
                              • May 2014
                              • 98

                              Also, The Olin rounds in my J Frame, doing about 850 FPS, are quite a bit slower than sound. I don't think that there is much "air friction" at that leisurely pace.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1