Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Bullet physics question

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #31
    Victor Cachat
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2014
    • 1546

    So, is there already an SR-71 thread, or is one of you going to start it?

    I worked with guys that worked support for those birds and even saw one of the starter trailers from them in a surplus lot at McClellan.
    Two Mickey Thompson race engines, a custom transmission, and a huge flex shaft.
    Democrats>Socialists>Communists - Same goals, different speeds.

    The most effective and pervasive enemy of American freedoms today is the Legacy Media. Defeat them first.

    Comment

    • #32
      pacrat
      I need a LIFE!!
      • May 2014
      • 10287

      Originally posted by Victor Cachat
      So, is there already an SR-71 thread, or is one of you going to start it?

      I worked with guys that worked support for those birds and even saw one of the starter trailers from them in a surplus lot at McClellan.
      Two Mickey Thompson race engines, a custom transmission, and a huge flex shaft.
      Did the fuel tanks on the start carts leak too? Hey, had to ask.

      Comment

      • #33
        as_rocketman
        CGSSA Leader
        • Jan 2011
        • 3057

        Originally posted by krwada
        The heating at the tip, while overall negligible ... still appears to be significant. 100 to 150 Celsius is hot enough to boil water ... but will not have any effect on the metallurgy of the jacket or bullet.

        So ... in a manner of speaking ... the projectile does get 'hot' due to air resistance ... but in a relative fashion ... not by much.
        Yup.

        Originally posted by pacrat
        The bullets meplat has increased in temp from ambient to [+170C] in just 3 ft of flight. This evidence does show that bullets do experience heat transfer from air friction during flight. Which as previously stated must be to a maximu[m] which is below the melting point of the lead core.

        I'd still like to see a FLIR pic just before bullet strike at range.
        All right, so here's some more details.

        Counter-intuitively, for this problem we really do think about temperature instead of heat. There is a temptation to think that the ambient air either wicks away or adds more heat (the technical term is "advection") the faster it goes, but it really doesn't. What moving the air does is mixes and thins out the boundary layer around the bullet, which does increase heat transfer, but you very rapidly hit the limit where the boundary layer is negligible in terms of insulation. As you go faster, you hit this limit asymptotically.

        But instead, as you go faster the air actually is hotter. Like I said, it's temperature, not heat, that matters. Since we're heating the freestream, we effectively have a heat bath, with unlimited heat capacity so long as the velocity remains.

        Let's consider a very simple, purely conical bullet. There is an attached oblique shock cone (compression shock) at the nose, and a second oblique shock (expansion) at the tail. The shocks together define a wide conical region where the airflow has accelerated -- very abruptly -- so that it flows around the bullet. Our bullet is entirely within this cone of disturbed air.

        When the air crosses the nose shock, it suddenly changes direction, pressure, and temperature. We can compute this temperature directly if we know (a) the Mach number of the bullet; and (b) the angle of the bullet, i.e., how much the air has to "turn" to go around it.

        Supposing our bullet would keep going a particular speed, as if it was jet-propelled, then the temperature around the bullet is also a constant. It would be heated just like we tossed it in an oven set for a particular temperature.

        What is that temperature? Rule of thumb, Mach 3 is about 220 degrees C, or 415 F. It scales more-or-less linearly with the Mach number for speeds of interest (about Mach 1.5 to 3+ for rifle bullets). So in other words, if the bullet wasn't slowed down in flight, it would reach an equilibrium temperature with the accelerated air, probably in under a minute, and that temperature would be "hot" but not hot enough to actually melt the bullet.

        In reality, of course, the bullet does not maintain that speed. It actually decelerates at roughly 100 to 300 g, and time of flight is rarely more than about one or two seconds. This is not enough time to reach equilibrium temperature. Also, as it slows, the temperature of the accelerated air drops -- our "equilibrium temperature" is not a constant.

        The bullet in the FLIR image (which I still think is wicked cool) has just started. It is already being heated by the shocked air envelope, but it still retains some unmixed boundary layer around itself -- except at the nose. The point of the bullet is practically touching the shock, and it has less thermal mass to heat up as it's the skinniest part, so it has already reached a higher temperature.

        If we were to look at the bullet again a half-second downrange, we would see the bullet warming up, starting to approach the (now lower) equilibrium temperature. Except for the engraved grooves that engaged the barrel -- those would be cooling toward the equilibrium temperature.

        However, at no time is the bullet expected to reach crazy high temperatures. That's not likely unless we fire a stupid fast round -- if over Mach 4, we might see blue smoke.

        One factor I haven't considered is the fact that the bullet is spinning. This will serve to thin the boundary layer, but given an ideal and perfectly concentric bullet it won't have any other significant effect. With a real bullet, however, non-concentric, yawing, etc., it could lead to instability and uneven heating, and in really bad cases would actually destabilize or shatter...

        So, to reconsider the OP: The correct answer is "both." Provided the round is supersonic, the bullet is both heated and cooled by the freestream -- parts that were heated by the powder charge or barrel friction will cool, and parts that weren't will heat up. But we do not expect the bullet to exceed a moderate temperature. You should be able to handle it with gloves at worst, and it will not reach the working temperature of its constituent metals.

        I too would like to see FLIR of the round way downrange, but that's a tough experiment to set up!
        Riflemen Needed.

        Ask me about Appleseed! Send a PM or see me in the Appleseed subforum.

        Comment

        • #34
          ja308
          I need a LIFE!!
          • Nov 2009
          • 12660

          Originally posted by as_rocketman
          Yup.



          All right, so here's some more details.

          Counter-intuitively, for this problem we really do think about temperature instead of heat. There is a temptation to think that the ambient air either wicks away or adds more heat (the technical term is "advection") the faster it goes, but it really doesn't. What moving the air does is mixes and thins out the boundary layer around the bullet, which does increase heat transfer, but you very rapidly hit the limit where the boundary layer is negligible in terms of insulation. As you go faster, you hit this limit asymptotically.

          But instead, as you go faster the air actually is hotter. Like I said, it's temperature, not heat, that matters. Since we're heating the freestream, we effectively have a heat bath, with unlimited heat capacity so long as the velocity remains.

          Let's consider a very simple, purely conical bullet. There is an attached oblique shock cone (compression shock) at the nose, and a second oblique shock (expansion) at the tail. The shocks together define a wide conical region where the airflow has accelerated -- very abruptly -- so that it flows around the bullet. Our bullet is entirely within this cone of disturbed air.

          When the air crosses the nose shock, it suddenly changes direction, pressure, and temperature. We can compute this temperature directly if we know (a) the Mach number of the bullet; and (b) the angle of the bullet, i.e., how much the air has to "turn" to go around it.

          Supposing our bullet would keep going a particular speed, as if it was jet-propelled, then the temperature around the bullet is also a constant. It would be heated just like we tossed it in an oven set for a particular temperature.

          What is that temperature? Rule of thumb, Mach 3 is about 220 degrees C, or 415 F. It scales more-or-less linearly with the Mach number for speeds of interest (about Mach 1.5 to 3+ for rifle bullets). So in other words, if the bullet wasn't slowed down in flight, it would reach an equilibrium temperature with the accelerated air, probably in under a minute, and that temperature would be "hot" but not hot enough to actually melt the bullet.

          In reality, of course, the bullet does not maintain that speed. It actually decelerates at roughly 100 to 300 g, and time of flight is rarely more than about one or two seconds. This is not enough time to reach equilibrium temperature. Also, as it slows, the temperature of the accelerated air drops -- our "equilibrium temperature" is not a constant.

          The bullet in the FLIR image (which I still think is wicked cool) has just started. It is already being heated by the shocked air envelope, but it still retains some unmixed boundary layer around itself -- except at the nose. The point of the bullet is practically touching the shock, and it has less thermal mass to heat up as it's the skinniest part, so it has already reached a higher temperature.

          If we were to look at the bullet again a half-second downrange, we would see the bullet warming up, starting to approach the (now lower) equilibrium temperature. Except for the engraved grooves that engaged the barrel -- those would be cooling toward the equilibrium temperature.

          However, at no time is the bullet expected to reach crazy high temperatures. That's not likely unless we fire a stupid fast round -- if over Mach 4, we might see blue smoke.

          One factor I haven't considered is the fact that the bullet is spinning. This will serve to thin the boundary layer, but given an ideal and perfectly concentric bullet it won't have any other significant effect. With a real bullet, however, non-concentric, yawing, etc., it could lead to instability and uneven heating, and in really bad cases would actually destabilize or shatter...

          So, to reconsider the OP: The correct answer is "both." Provided the round is supersonic, the bullet is both heated and cooled by the freestream -- parts that were heated by the powder charge or barrel friction will cool, and parts that weren't will heat up. But we do not expect the bullet to exceed a moderate temperature. You should be able to handle it with gloves at worst, and it will not reach the working temperature of its constituent metals.

          I too would like to see FLIR of the round way downrange, but that's a tough experiment to set up!
          I'm guessing the person who said. " one lifetime is not long enough to learn the gun culture " had it right .

          Just noticed your sig line ! If your any indication of the Appleseed program. It's even better than I heard .

          Comment

          • #35
            tbc
            Calguns Addict
            • Jun 2011
            • 5955

            The bullet is cool.

            At the range, a bullet ricochet and hit me on the head and I didn't feel any heat from it. The period between the gun went bang and the brass hit me was less than a second. The heat from the lead bullet couldn't dissipate that fast.

            When brass hit me on the head from my Glock 19 gen 4, the thing was freakin hot.

            Comment

            • #36
              pacrat
              I need a LIFE!!
              • May 2014
              • 10287

              When brass hit me on the head from my Glock 19 gen 4, the thing was freakin hot.
              But not because it heated up due to air friction after flying out of the breech. BTDT

              Brass cases are thin and just got spit out of an enviroment where they had a belly full of 3,400 deg. F gas. The thicker a given medium is the longer it takes to transfer a given temperature. For several yrs I had a scar on my right temple. 45acp case bounced off the dividing barrier at a range and landed between my glasses earpiece and my temple. You could smell hair burning.

              rocketman is correct in the uses of the terms "temperature v heat". Temp. is a measurable factor and "heat" is a subjective.

              I would also like to see some high speed FLIR pics of cases being ejected from an arm and the bullet having cleared the muzzle. Chances are the case would be hotter than the bullet for a short period of time. Then the case would cool significantly as the bullet heats.

              Cool Stuff

              Comment

              • #37
                LCU1670
                Veteran Member
                • Mar 2010
                • 2865

                I was told you had to wear a plate because the heat of the rifle round would melt the Kevlar. Is it a hot bullet, or the heat generated on impact?

                I have been spalled by FMJ rounds, they ARE hot. Some stuck to my skin, burnt, then fell off me.
                sigpic Waterborne!

                Former: Knight of Front Sight &
                Gold Star Member

                Comment

                • #38
                  LCU1670
                  Veteran Member
                  • Mar 2010
                  • 2865

                  I was told you had to wear a plate because the heat of the rifle round would melt the Kevlar. Is it a hot bullet, or the heat generated on impact?

                  I have been spalled by FMJ rounds, they ARE hot. Some stuck to my skin, burnt, then fell off me.
                  sigpic Waterborne!

                  Former: Knight of Front Sight &
                  Gold Star Member

                  Comment

                  • #39
                    tjg
                    Member
                    • Sep 2010
                    • 180

                    Wow great response guys. We've all handled hot ejected casings and we're familiar with how long it takes them to cool (yes a bullet will be different but you catch my drift) and obviously those casings suffered no introduced temp from air friction.

                    It's interesting to know that some parts of the bullet do get hotter as it travels through the air.

                    Comment

                    • #40
                      Victor Cachat
                      Senior Member
                      • Apr 2014
                      • 1546

                      Originally posted by pacrat
                      Did the fuel tanks on the start carts leak too? Hey, had to ask.
                      LOL!
                      I never saw it running or with fuel in the tanks, but I am pretty sure they didn't let gasoline leak as it was flammable, not just combustible.

                      Here is one:
                      Democrats>Socialists>Communists - Same goals, different speeds.

                      The most effective and pervasive enemy of American freedoms today is the Legacy Media. Defeat them first.

                      Comment

                      • #41
                        RobertMW
                        Senior Member
                        • Jul 2013
                        • 2117

                        Originally posted by pacrat
                        But not because it heated up due to air friction after flying out of the breech. BTDT

                        Brass cases are thin and just got spit out of an enviroment where they had a belly full of 3,400 deg. F gas.
                        Also, remember that all brass is stretched out inside the chamber upon firing, the strain will generate heat. Try taking a paperclip, bend the outside and inside loops around until they snap apart and feel the break point, it will be hot.

                        Originally posted by pacrat
                        I have been spalled by FMJ rounds, they ARE hot. Some stuck to my skin, burnt, then fell off me.
                        Same answer as above, except to a greater degree than the case.

                        Originally posted by LCU1670
                        I was told you had to wear a plate because the heat of the rifle round would melt the Kevlar. Is it a hot bullet, or the heat generated on impact?
                        Sort of, but not true. The Kevlar fails against rifle rounds because of their velocity. Against pistol rounds it is effective at catching them because the first couple layers absorb a lot of the rounds energy by being destroyed, like a car's crash zones, and then the rest is able to spread the last of the energy out over a larger area. As you go up in velocity, the impact begins to be so fast that those first layers aren't able to absorb as much energy before they are sheared through by mechanical energy. It also doesn't help that rifle rounds have Spitzer tips, further concentrating the mechanical energy to a point of the kevlar. In either case, the bullet may be hot enough to melt the kevlar, but the rate of heat transference is much slower than what is necessary to affect the impact from a round.

                        The plate is going to either be ceramic or steel. Steel works by shattering the bullet by being so much harder. Ceramic plates work by absorbing energy through abrasion and destruction.
                        Originally posted by kcbrown
                        I'm most famous for my positive mental attitude.

                        Comment

                        • #42
                          GW
                          I need a LIFE!!
                          • May 2004
                          • 16078

                          Originally posted by tjg
                          When the bullet leaves the bore, it's hot from powder charge and bore friction. It travels through the air at a high speed.

                          So, is it traveling fast enough for the air friction to keep the bullet hot, or does the air dissipate the heat and cool the bullet?
                          Friction from air will heat it up
                          Think of the astronauts returning from space.
                          As they enter the atmosphere, moving at God's own speed, they need heat shielding because friction from the atmosphere heats them up massively despite being in sub-zero temperatures.
                          sigpicNRA Benefactor Member

                          Comment

                          • #43
                            as_rocketman
                            CGSSA Leader
                            • Jan 2011
                            • 3057

                            Actually in the case of the bullet "air friction" is almost zero. The heating is from the shockwave.

                            Capsule re-entry from space is different. In that case, the shock is so strong, and temperature so high, that a different mechanism sets in: Ablation. That transfers a lot more heat to our projectile.

                            It also burns up much more energy, which is why we use it as part of re-entry systems.
                            Riflemen Needed.

                            Ask me about Appleseed! Send a PM or see me in the Appleseed subforum.

                            Comment

                            • #44
                              RobertMW
                              Senior Member
                              • Jul 2013
                              • 2117

                              Originally posted by as_rocketman
                              Capsule re-entry from space is different. In that case, the shock is so strong, and temperature so high, that a different mechanism sets in: Ablation.
                              Ablation is HOW we deal with the heat, not what causes it. By using ablative shielding you literally shed the hot particles from the craft, exposing cooler ones to absorb energy.

                              What causes it is a multi-ton metal capsule falling through the air at Mach 20, lets see YOU compress air at that rate and keep it cool.

                              Originally posted by kcbrown
                              I'm most famous for my positive mental attitude.

                              Comment

                              • #45
                                Frisco3Gun
                                Senior Member
                                • Jan 2014
                                • 709

                                Originally posted by krwada
                                In a vacuum ... there is NO speed of sound. Heck ... there is NO sound. Sound requires a medium in order to have any presence!

                                I suppose you are an expert at fluid mechanics and heat transfer? Given your comments about speed of sound in a vacuum ... well ... let us leave it at that.

                                Or perhaps you have already found the closed form solution for the Navier Stokes equation ... If you have ... then a very big prize is awaiting you!

                                Heh!
                                Good catch, but I was trying to clarify the first statement that doesn't hold in all scenarios. Didn't mean to sound like a smarty-pants, but I'm not a fan of incomplete information flying around.

                                Yes, sound needs a medium to travel through. I just wanted to give an objective answer, not the easy way out. Even subsonic bullets can heat up without the supersonic shockwave.
                                God may have made men, but Samuel Colt made them equal.

                                Send me pics of your: Colt Detective Special, AMT Hardballer, pre-64 Winchester Model 70. I'm looking for them.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1