if you could only have one?

[calif 15-22]

Xd9
Glock 22
Sa 1911 mil spec

Which would you choose?

I only see one gun on that list for self defense . . . XD9! (I have 3 of them)

Of the other two, one is good range gun and the other might explode!

(the above comments are meant in fun and good ribbing)

[12voltguy]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Glock 22, nothing wrong with the other two two choices though.

[whipkiller]

1911

[Jimi Jah]

Sig. Much more class.

[Nick Justice]

It's a trap! The antis will see the winner of the list and ban every other gun!

[iluvmycolt]

1911

[tamalpias]

they are all good guns. Since you are narrowing it down to one can I have the other 2?

[Squidward]

Xd9
Glock 22
Sa 1911 mil spec

Which would you choose?

Probably the XD9. I like Glocks but I'm not a fan of .40 caliber. IMO, if you're going to pick the 40, you might as well get a .45. I don't shoot a 1911 very well but the low round count isn't a deal breaker.

[gwgn02]

G22

[polo.45]

1911...glock ? I don't need stinky glocks,

[maylebox]

If I could only have one gun period and had to choose from the list I would choose the XD9 because of the caliber. Adding to my collection from the list I would chose the Glock.

[curtru]

For capacity the glock but over all i shoot better with my 1911

Sent from my SCH-S735C using Tapatalk

[stix213]

Glock 22, with the 1911 a close second. If it is more for a range gun, or if you prefer the 1911 controls, I might choose the 1911 instead.

[Southwest Chuck]

1911 all the way.

[Zorgnot]

It depends on if you have standard capacity mags for the g22. If so I'd go with the glock. If not I'd go with the 1911. My philosophy, if you can only punch 10 holes, make them the biggest holes possible. I do love my 1911 for the record.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk