Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Reloading Press UPDATE post 114

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #91
    beetle
    The Clip guy
    CGN Contributor
    • May 2009
    • 1677

    Originally posted by Ducky's Dad
    And how, exactly, will you "test" this load? Planning to tie your gun to an old tire and pull the trigger with a string from behind a big tree? You seem to be violating a basic principle of safe reloading.
    yes that's exactly what I'm concerned about. How is the OP going to "test" -- it sounds like he will try them out by shooting them.

    fecalguns, what i'm trying to say is that with shotshell reloading you should not just start swapping stuff around. For example, loading a fiocchi hull is competely different than a remington. Using a wad designed for tapered hulls and putting them into straight wall would likely yield poor performance. However using a straight walled wad in a tapered hull will likely cause overpressure and a potential kaboom. Use a recipe that specifies a win 209 primer and then swapping with a Fed 209A will also likely cause overpressure.

    what you did (lower the powder charge) is probably ok -- although I think the performance will be poor (blooper most likely). but the point is don't get into a habit of "making up" recipes or swapping components. respect the published recipes and be safe.

    P.S. are you weighing your charges? I just read that you stated you are moving from bushing #29 to bushing #23 "which is 13.1 grains" -- that is straight off the MEC bushing chart. another piece of advice, bushing charts are just a "starting place". Don't rely on them for the actual charge -- you need to weigh. advice for your future reloading adventures.
    Last edited by beetle; 06-28-2018, 11:03 PM.

    Comment

    • #92
      fecalguns
      CGN/CGSSA Contributor
      • Jul 2015
      • 1341

      Originally posted by beetle
      yes that's exactly what I'm concerned about. How is the OP going to "test" -- it sounds like he will try them out by shooting them.

      fecalguns, what i'm trying to say is that with shotshell reloading you should not just start swapping stuff around. For example, loading a fiocchi hull is competely different than a remington. Using a wad designed for tapered hulls and putting them into straight wall would likely yield poor performance. However using a straight walled wad in a tapered hull will likely cause overpressure and a potential kaboom. Use a recipe that specifies a win 209 primer and then swapping with a Fed 209A will also likely cause overpressure.
      I appreciate that, however I already tried this exact load yesterday except for the difference in grains. I am now trying a lower amount of grains so I am confused as to how the pressure would be more when I am using less powder.

      Originally posted by beetle
      what you did (lower the powder charge) is probably ok -- although I think the performance will be poor (blooper most likely). but the point is don't get into a habit of "making up" recipes or swapping components. respect the published recipes and be safe.
      You are absolutely correct. Also in that I won't experiment without some guidance with people who I trust. The person who has been recommending these difference powder charges has been reloading for more than 30 years. He is in his 70s and I shoot with him every week. I am not going at this completely alone. Since I am new to this, he has taken me in and he has been helping me every step of the way especially with reloading.

      Comment

      • #93
        fecalguns
        CGN/CGSSA Contributor
        • Jul 2015
        • 1341

        Originally posted by beetle
        P.S. are you weighing your charges? I just read that you stated you are moving from bushing #29 to bushing #23 "which is 13.1 grains" -- that is straight off the MEC bushing chart. another piece of advice, bushing charts are just a "starting place". Don't rely on them for the actual charge -- you need to weigh. advice for your future reloading adventures.
        Yes I am weighing one for every box. With that load of 13.1 grains it came in with 13.0 with the one shell.

        Comment

        • #94
          BOBGBA
          CGN/CGSSA Contributor
          CGN Contributor
          • Sep 2010
          • 2405

          I would recommend that you get this manual.


          And use these online tools.




          I would only load published data.

          Try telling the guys in you squad that you are using a recipe that is not from published data (even though it's using less powder) and see if they still want to shoot with you.
          God Bless America - My iTrader rating - https://www.calguns.net/forum/market...2-transactions

          Comment

          • #95
            fecalguns
            CGN/CGSSA Contributor
            • Jul 2015
            • 1341

            I finished that load with 13.1 grains. It was actually very comfortable. And it still busted the birds. I still have both almonds.

            Sent from my SM-G950U1 using Tapatalk

            Comment

            • #96
              beetle
              The Clip guy
              CGN Contributor
              • May 2009
              • 1677

              bloopers will still bust birds, but the question is how consistent will it be. In one of your earlier posts on shotgunning it stressed how important it is to develop the right technique. With these questionable loads when you miss is it because of your technique or because of the load? i would eliminate ammo being a factor so that you can practice your technique. if 13g was a good load it would be a published recipe. my $0.02

              Comment

              • #97
                fecalguns
                CGN/CGSSA Contributor
                • Jul 2015
                • 1341

                Originally posted by beetle
                bloopers will still bust birds, but the question is how consistent will it be. In one of your earlier posts on shotgunning it stressed how important it is to develop the right technique. With these questionable loads when you miss is it because of your technique or because of the load? i would eliminate ammo being a factor so that you can practice your technique. if 13g was a good load it would be a published recipe. my $0.02
                Beetle. You are correct! Today was a test on that load and from what I could tell, I didn't have to adjust my leads on stations 2-6 and stations 1,7, and 8 were the same also. That being said they most likely won't cycle through my autoloader. This load will be only for O/U and for skeet only. I will be loading 17 grains for trap and sporting clays using my autoloader. For really far targets with sporting clays I will use high velocity factory loads that go 1350fps.

                Comment

                • #98
                  whutsup40
                  CGN/CGSSA Contributor
                  CGN Contributor
                  • Mar 2009
                  • 2727

                  Im with beetle, I am pretty anal ( or it could be my ocd ) lol, But I am a true believer in being consistent, and my loads need to be consistent, that takes one less thing off my list of wtf happened! and puts it on my performance!!

                  Comment

                  • #99
                    fecalguns
                    CGN/CGSSA Contributor
                    • Jul 2015
                    • 1341

                    Originally posted by whutsup40
                    Im with beetle, I am pretty anal ( or it could be my ocd ) lol, But I am a true believer in being consistent, and my loads need to be consistent, that takes one less thing off my list of wtf happened! and puts it on my performance!!
                    I agree. I will continue to test this load vs other published loads. If they are consistent for at least a month, and my performance stays consistent or improves, this may be my load for skeet and skeet only.
                    Last edited by fecalguns; 06-30-2018, 12:56 AM.

                    Comment

                    • whutsup40
                      CGN/CGSSA Contributor
                      CGN Contributor
                      • Mar 2009
                      • 2727

                      fecal I don't know what you pay for shot, but im making a phillips run tomorrow for shot, 40 a bag I will pick some up for you if you want, let me know, can give it to you on sunday!! size? whutsup40@gmail.com or 3107499557

                      Comment

                      • Tom-ADC
                        Veteran Member
                        • Apr 2010
                        • 3614

                        Originally posted by beetle
                        bloopers will still bust birds, but the question is how consistent will it be. In one of your earlier posts on shotgunning it stressed how important it is to develop the right technique. With these questionable loads when you miss is it because of your technique or because of the load? i would eliminate ammo being a factor so that you can practice your technique. if 13g was a good load it would be a published recipe. my $0.02
                        US Navy Retired, NRA Lifetime member. Member CRPA

                        Comment

                        • Ducky's Dad
                          Senior Member
                          • Dec 2012
                          • 737

                          Conventional wisdom is to establish a velocity that you like, say 1200fps, and then shoot that velocity in all your guns and in all your gauges. You can vary the gauge or the shot size or the powder or the wad or the hull or the primer or the shot charge with hundreds of different recipes, but your pellets always arrive at the target at the same speed. It will make you a better shooter. There are lots of soft 12ga loads at 1200fps that will cycle an autoloader, and they are published and tested. You are new to reloading shotshells, having done it for what, two weeks? And you are already developing bad loading habits. Maybe I'm just a crusty old fart, but your approach makes me uncomfortable.

                          Comment

                          • JagerDog
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • May 2011
                            • 15885

                            I'm with Beetle. Getting that low in pressure tends to create a round which is not consistent in performance. That low of velocity can pattern odd. Safe? most likely so. I doubt you'd get such a blooper that you risk hanging a wad. A primer alone will propel the wad past the barrel half the time or so.

                            I used to load a lot of 1 oz loads with 800X which was very low pressure (6-7 kpsi). It was listed at the time (not any longer) and faster powder at the same velocity wouldn't operate my B80 until I got a 2-3/4" barrel. I had one shotgun at the time and 1oz was considered "light" at the time and I was very money conscious.

                            What's the goal? If it's to reduce recoil, you're better off with reducing the shot charge and going to #9. There'a lot of #9's in 3/4 or 7/8 oz of shot. Shot is also much more expensive than a powder if it's driven by economy.
                            Palestine is a fake country

                            No Mas Hamas



                            #Blackolivesmatter

                            Comment

                            • fecalguns
                              CGN/CGSSA Contributor
                              • Jul 2015
                              • 1341

                              Originally posted by JagerDog
                              I'm with Beetle. Getting that low in pressure tends to create a round which is not consistent in performance. That low of velocity can pattern odd. Safe? most likely so. I doubt you'd get such a blooper that you risk hanging a wad. A primer alone will propel the wad past the barrel half the time or so.

                              I used to load a lot of 1 oz loads with 800X which was very low pressure (6-7 kpsi). It was listed at the time (not any longer) and faster powder at the same velocity wouldn't operate my B80 until I got a 2-3/4" barrel. I had one shotgun at the time and 1oz was considered "light" at the time and I was very money conscious.

                              What's the goal? If it's to reduce recoil, you're better off with reducing the shot charge and going to #9. There'a lot of #9's in 3/4 or 7/8 oz of shot. Shot is also much more expensive than a powder if it's driven by economy.
                              Recoil is the main objective and I appreciate you mentioning about less shot as I was planning on that. The next load I was going to try is a 3/4 ounce 9shot with 17 grains red dot.

                              Sent from my SM-G950U1 using Tapatalk

                              Comment

                              • Ducky's Dad
                                Senior Member
                                • Dec 2012
                                • 737

                                You don't need 17 grains of Red Dot with 3/4oz of shot. What's the velocity and pressure of that load? Published?

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1