Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Benelli M4 vs. Benelli M2

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Calilove1
    Member
    • Jan 2009
    • 286

    Benelli M4 vs. Benelli M2

    Looking at getting a semi-auto shotgun for home defense and training through Front Sight. I have a built up 870 pump but wanted a Semi-Auto as well as an option.

    I've looked at the Benelli M4 and the M2 and wondered if any of you had any experience between the two to make a good comparison.

    Pros & Cons?
    Likes & Dislikes?
    I believe in our rights under the 2nd Amendment and believe that all gun owners need training. Training not only makes gun ownership safe it also creates strong defenders of our rights. Are you interested in a lifetime of top notch firearms training from the very basics to the most advanced force on force tactical courses available for pennies on the dollar?

    Please PM me about a Diamond, Legacy, Challenge, or Self Reliance Lifetime Memberships at Front Sight in Nevada.
  • #2
    Prowler
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2006
    • 2099

    Go with the M2, or an M1S90. Less money and more practical
    sigpic

    Comment

    • #3
      pl408
      Senior Member
      • Apr 2008
      • 640

      Originally posted by Prowler
      Go with the M2, or an M1S90. Less money and more practical
      and when you roll up on someone with an m4 at the range with your m1 or m2 and they say you should have got one of these , you will wish you did
      we dumped 50 rounds through my m4 as fast as we could and with the barrel blistering hot the bolt was room temp

      Comment

      • #4
        Calilove1
        Member
        • Jan 2009
        • 286

        Benelli's

        It's not really about the money... Both are coming to me Brand New as a trade for an extra membership I had and I have to decide which to keep and which to sell or trade.

        Obviosly I would get more for selling the M4 but I'm always partial to the "higher end".

        Looking for pratical Pro's and Con's.... not mine is bigger than yours...
        Last edited by Calilove1; 02-03-2009, 11:23 PM. Reason: Spelling... Clarification
        I believe in our rights under the 2nd Amendment and believe that all gun owners need training. Training not only makes gun ownership safe it also creates strong defenders of our rights. Are you interested in a lifetime of top notch firearms training from the very basics to the most advanced force on force tactical courses available for pennies on the dollar?

        Please PM me about a Diamond, Legacy, Challenge, or Self Reliance Lifetime Memberships at Front Sight in Nevada.

        Comment

        • #5
          rosiekai
          Junior Member
          • Mar 2008
          • 98

          I LOVE my M4!! Never regretted buying it for a second.
          Residential Construction Management and Consulting
          http://www.spectre8.com

          Comment

          • #6
            Hitman
            Senior Member
            • Oct 2005
            • 927

            Go with the latest and greatest.

            My M4 shoots low powered birdshot to Slugs with ease.
            PISTOLS:
            Colt 1911 9mm Govt Model, Colt 1911 Commander 9mm, Intratec Tec22 Scorpion, Glock 17/17C RTF2 "Fish Gill", Sig P365 for EDC, AR 9mm (uses Colt SMG Mags), NFA C-5 9mm with Fostech Binary Trigger(uses HK MP5 Mags), Ruger 10/22 Charger TakeDown, Spike's Zombie 5.56 w/ Fostech Binary Trigger
            SHOTGUNS:
            AWS SPETS-12
            RIFLES:
            Colt Sporter LMT MRP Piston, Eagle Arms LMT MRP Piston, HK94/MP5 A3 Clone
            NFA:SBR/Suppressors:
            Colt LE6933 M4 Commando, MP5 PDW Clone

            Comment

            • #7
              eric90503
              Senior Member
              • Dec 2008
              • 825

              Originally posted by Calilove1
              It's not really about the money... Both are coming to me Brand New as a trade for an extra membership I had and I have to decide which to keep and which to sell or trade.

              Obviosly I would get more for selling the M4 but I'm always partial to the "higher end".

              Looking for pratical Pro's and Con's.... not mine is bigger than yours...
              Please let me know which one you decide to sell. I'd like to get the M4 but for my purposes, the M2 would be the most ideal. Which M2 is it btw?

              Also the M2 is like the M1 (inertia driven) and the M4 is (gas) which a lot of members say is softer on the recoil. LAPD has been given the green light to use the M4, the only thing is you have to buy it yourself

              Comment

              • #8
                cseabass
                Senior Member
                • Mar 2006
                • 969

                my only gripe with my M4 is it seems to cycle slower than the M1.

                Comment

                • #9
                  TenSeven
                  Senior Member
                  • Dec 2007
                  • 1272

                  Originally posted by Calilove1

                  ...I'm always partial to the "higher end".

                  I'm like that also. When I bought my M2 there was an M4 right next to it on the rack for a "mere" $600 more. The very high extra cost and the fact that I think the M2 looks better made the decision a no-brainer.

                  I added a DMW 7-shot mag tube and have been totally happy with the gun. It has run perfectly with every load I have put in it from the weakest and cheapest birdshot to slugs. It is a terrific shotgun!
                  Last edited by TenSeven; 02-04-2009, 2:17 AM.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    TenSeven
                    Senior Member
                    • Dec 2007
                    • 1272

                    Originally posted by Calilove1

                    ...Both are coming to me Brand New as a trade for...

                    Argh! I missed that you are getting them as part of a trade and were deciding which to keep and which to sell. I misread it in thinking you were looking for opinions on which to buy.

                    Aww heck... in that case, I'd keep the M4 and move the M2.

                    Ideally, I'd keep them both of course! Fun for you and a friend.
                    Last edited by TenSeven; 02-04-2009, 2:19 AM.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      randy
                      In Memoriam
                      • Nov 2006
                      • 4642

                      Both are great guns. I own both of them and an M1. You can't go wrong with any.

                      If you want to shoot 3 gun matches none of the tactical Benellis are as good as their field models.

                      Keep the M2, use the money from selling the M4 to trick out an M2 field for 3 gun.
                      I move slow but I make up for it by shooting poorly.

                      When I hit the lotto I'm only shooting factory.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        TenSeven
                        Senior Member
                        • Dec 2007
                        • 1272

                        Originally posted by randy
                        ...none of the tactical Benellis are as good as their field models.
                        Could you please expand on this statement? I honestly do not know what you mean. The M2/M4's are not as good as "X" Benellli??

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          esskay
                          Senior Member
                          • Oct 2005
                          • 2304

                          Originally posted by TenSeven
                          Could you please expand on this statement? I honestly do not know what you mean. The M2/M4's are not as good as "X" Benellli??
                          If you notice randy was referring to use for 3-gun matches. For that purpose, generally speaking the "Field" models are more suited than the "tactical" models, i.e.:
                          * 21"+ vent rib barrels w/ fiber bead sight vs. 18.5" barrel with ghost ring or rifle sights
                          * straight stock vs pistol grip stock

                          I didn't see OP defining an intended use for this shotgun, which is really needed to provide specific feedback. OP, what are you going to use the shotgun for?

                          Also, which models of the M2 and M4 are you going to be getting?
                          WTS: Ewbank AKM & NDS-4 AK receivers, Custom Chief AJ Ruger Mini-14

                          WTS: Oakley SI Shoes

                          WTS KAC rail panels

                          WTS: MGI Hydra Modular AR Lower

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            Calilove1
                            Member
                            • Jan 2009
                            • 286

                            M2 Vs. M4

                            Well nothing is set in stone yet but it looks like I will be getting these two:
                            M-4 Tactical w/ Pistol Grip- Camo- Pictured Below


                            And the M2 Tactical w/ Comfortech Stock and Ghost Ring Sights (rifle sights are pictured)- http://cdn.benelliusa.com/assets/sil...ct_defense.jpg

                            Hey I may keep both based on what I am hearing but some extra cash for some ammo never hurts either.

                            INTENDED USE: Primarily Tactical Shotgun Training through Front Sight in Nevada... Secondary use... Home Defense
                            Last edited by Calilove1; 02-04-2009, 2:11 PM. Reason: Added info... on Intended Use
                            I believe in our rights under the 2nd Amendment and believe that all gun owners need training. Training not only makes gun ownership safe it also creates strong defenders of our rights. Are you interested in a lifetime of top notch firearms training from the very basics to the most advanced force on force tactical courses available for pennies on the dollar?

                            Please PM me about a Diamond, Legacy, Challenge, or Self Reliance Lifetime Memberships at Front Sight in Nevada.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              TenSeven
                              Senior Member
                              • Dec 2007
                              • 1272

                              Originally posted by esskay
                              If you notice randy was referring to use for 3-gun matches...

                              Ahhh, gotcha. Thanks...

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1