Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Please clarify .22 capacity question-

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    NorCalDustin
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2010
    • 1463

    Originally posted by E Pluribus Unum
    That's funny.

    A Richmond, Va resident is advising a California resident of the legalities in California...
    IIRC He recently moved there...
    Originally posted by BannedinBritain
    The only dumb question is the one you don't ask...and get arrested for later.

    Comment

    • #17
      dfletcher
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Dec 2006
      • 14813

      Originally posted by Quiet
      If they are attached to a lever-action firearm, then they are exempt from the large capacity magazine laws.

      If they are not attached to a lever-action firearm, then they must comply with the large capacity magazine laws.
      I'll admit I haven't paid much attention to this, so a semi 17 M2 with a tube magazine is limited to 10 as is a bolt action 17 HMR?
      GOA Member & SAF Life Member

      Comment

      • #18
        sequoia_nomad
        Senior Member
        • Mar 2010
        • 803

        Originally posted by Quiet
        If they are attached to a lever-action firearm, then they are exempt from the large capacity magazine laws.

        If they are not attached to a lever-action firearm, then they must comply with the large capacity magazine laws.
        False. Any non-detachable tube feed magazine with a capacity over 10 is legal, regardless of the action of the firearm. Lever action, semi auto, bolt, whatever, doesn't matter.

        If you are not clear about the laws, please do not misinform others.

        Comment

        • #19
          ke6guj
          Moderator
          CGN Contributor - Lifetime
          • Nov 2003
          • 23725

          Originally posted by sequoia_nomad
          False. Any non-detachable tube feed magazine with a capacity over 10 is legal, regardless of the action of the firearm. Lever action, semi auto, bolt, whatever, doesn't matter.

          If you are not clear about the laws, please do not misinform others.
          umm, WRONG. Show us the PC with that exemption that any tube-fed 11+ round mag is legal, no matter the type. It has been posted here what the tube-fed exemptions are to the law, and they are limited.

          here is the PC for you again.


          12020(c)(25) As used in this section, "large-capacity magazine" means any ammunition feeding device with the capacity to accept more than 10 rounds,
          THis includes all tube-fed magazines.

          but shall not be construed to include any of the following:
          (A) A feeding device that has been permanently altered so that it cannot accommodate more than 10 rounds.
          (B) A .22 caliber tube ammunition feeding device.
          (C) A tubular magazine that is contained in a lever-action firearm.
          but then they exclude tubular mags for .22-caliber firearms and also tubular mags for lever actions. There is no blanket exemption for all bolt-action, pump-action, semi-autos, etc, unless they are .22 caliber.
          Last edited by ke6guj; 01-28-2011, 6:32 PM.
          Jack



          Do you want an AOW or C&R SBS/SBR in CA?

          No posts of mine are to be construed as legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

          Comment

          • #20
            sequoia_nomad
            Senior Member
            • Mar 2010
            • 803

            Originally posted by ke6guj
            but then they exclude tubular mags for .22-caliber firearms and also tubular mags for lever actions. There is no blanket exemption for all bolt-action, pump-action, semi-autos, etc, unless they are .22 caliber.
            Since this is the rimfire section, and the original post was:

            Are .22 caliber rim fire rifles and pistols exempt from California's 10 rd max capacity rule? I think I have seen posts here that talk about 20 rd and 30 rd magazines. They certainly exist but are they CA legal? Sorry if this has been asked before.
            ...I assumed it would be a given to any intelligent individual that would be reading this thread that this discussion involves rimfire arms exclusively. I was quoting Quiet to answer dfletcher's question above. Perhaps you should quote him(Quiet) as well, and point out the fact that the OP and all other posters were referring to rimfire arms.

            Perhaps you should go to the Curio & Relic page now and school them on OLL and handgun law.

            Comment

            • #21
              ke6guj
              Moderator
              CGN Contributor - Lifetime
              • Nov 2003
              • 23725

              Originally posted by sequoia_nomad
              Since this is the rimfire section, and the original post was:



              ...I assumed it would be a given to any intelligent individual that would be reading this thread that this discussion involves rimfire arms exclusively. I was quoting Quiet to answer dfletcher's question above. Perhaps you should quote him(Quiet) as well, and point out the fact that the OP and all other posters were referring to rimfire arms.
              why would I need to Quote Quiet? His posts in this thread have been accurate.

              In the post of his that you quoted, he was answering a question about .17 caliber tube-mags, which aren't .22 caliber, so 12020(c)(25)(B) does not apply to them. They can only rely on 12020(c)(25)(C) which only exempts lever-action firearms.


              Here is the sequence,
              Originally posted by dfletcher
              I'm assuming 17 M2 and 17 HMR tube magazines are also exempt, correct?
              Originally posted by Quiet
              If they are attached to a lever-action firearm, then they are exempt from the large capacity magazine laws.

              If they are not attached to a lever-action firearm, then they must comply with the large capacity magazine laws.
              Quiet was correct, and you were wrong. 12020(c)(25)(B) is not a "rimfire" exemption, it is a .22 caliber exemption. the fact that the thread is in the rimfire forum doesn't matter. The thread had drifted from a .22lr magazine question to that of a .17 caliber question.


              Perhaps you should go to the Curio & Relic page now and school them on OLL and handgun law.
              Jack



              Do you want an AOW or C&R SBS/SBR in CA?

              No posts of mine are to be construed as legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

              Comment

              • #22
                sequoia_nomad
                Senior Member
                • Mar 2010
                • 803

                Well, if you can find a current-production tube feed .17 caliber rifle that isn't a lever action and holds more than 10 rounds in said tube, you have my apologies.

                Comment

                • #23
                  killmime1234
                  Senior Member
                  • Mar 2009
                  • 1536

                  To clarify, because I can see how it might be confusing to sift through the above posts and the bickering:

                  .22lr 10+ magazines (tube or otherwise) are legal to use in any .22lr rifle regardless of the action as long as the magazines were owned before 2000.

                  .17 only have the tube exemption, and therefore the only .17 calibre rifles that can have 10+ magazines are those fitted with tubular mags.

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    Mssr. Eleganté
                    Blue Blaze Irregular
                    CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                    • Oct 2005
                    • 10401

                    Originally posted by killmime1234
                    To clarify, because I can see how it might be confusing to sift through the above posts and the bickering:

                    .22lr 10+ magazines (tube or otherwise) are legal to use in any .22lr rifle regardless of the action as long as the magazines were owned before 2000.

                    .17 only have the tube exemption, and therefore the only .17 calibre rifles that can have 10+ magazines are those fitted with tubular mags.
                    Nope. You got it wrong.

                    The .22 caliber tube mags (rimfire or centerfire) are exempt from the magazine ban completely. You do not need to have owned them before 2000.

                    .17 caliber doesn't have the exemption for all tube mags like .22 caliber does. For a .17 caliber tube mag to be exempt from the magazine ban it has to be on a lever-action firearm. It is also perfectly legal to use any large capacity .17 caliber magazines that you legally own in any firearm (as long as you don't create an "assault weapon" in doing so).
                    __________________

                    "Knowledge is power... For REAL!" - Jack Austin

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      ke6guj
                      Moderator
                      CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                      • Nov 2003
                      • 23725

                      Originally posted by sequoia_nomad
                      Well, if you can find a current-production tube feed .17 caliber rifle that isn't a lever action and holds more than 10 rounds in said tube, you have my apologies.
                      really, my apology is dependant on finding a currently-made tube-fed .17 caliber rifle that isn't exempt from the large-capacity magazine ban? So, since there may not a current production gun out there that would be an illegal sale of a large-cap mag, Quiet shouldn't have completely explained how the exemption works?

                      What if dfletcher was thinking about rebarreling a tube-fed .22lr semi-auto or bolt-action to shoot .17Mach2? Wouldn't it be nice that he had the correct info that there wasn't an exemption to the large-cap magazine regs for his new .17-caliber rifle?
                      Jack



                      Do you want an AOW or C&R SBS/SBR in CA?

                      No posts of mine are to be construed as legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        killmime1234
                        Senior Member
                        • Mar 2009
                        • 1536

                        Nope. You got it wrong.

                        The .22 caliber tube mags (rimfire or centerfire) are exempt from the magazine ban completely. You do not need to have owned them before 2000.

                        .17 caliber doesn't have the exemption for all tube mags like .22 caliber does. For a .17 caliber tube mag to be exempt from the magazine ban it has to be on a lever-action firearm. It is also perfectly legal to use any large capacity .17 caliber magazines that you legally own in any firearm (as long as you don't create an "assault weapon" in doing so).
                        Darn. You got me there. I know my .22 pretty well and I forgot to put that the tubular exemption is 2000-ban exempt. Good catch.

                        As for the .17 info. I was just regurgitating what I had thought I had read above. Glad to be corrected, though.

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          sequoia_nomad
                          Senior Member
                          • Mar 2010
                          • 803

                          Originally posted by ke6guj
                          really, my apology is dependant on finding a currently-made tube-fed .17 caliber rifle that isn't exempt from the large-capacity magazine ban? So, since there may not a current production gun out there that would be an illegal sale of a large-cap mag, Quiet shouldn't have completely explained how the exemption works?

                          What if dfletcher was thinking about rebarreling a tube-fed .22lr semi-auto or bolt-action to shoot .17Mach2? Wouldn't it be nice that he had the correct info that there wasn't an exemption to the large-cap magazine regs for his new .17-caliber rifle?
                          Ok, then find an out of production one then. You have successfully explained how California law applies to a firearm that doesn't exist. Kudos.

                          As for fletcher, you are simply making up a hypothetical situation. No one mentioned modifying an existing firearm except you. That's a whole 'nother can o' worms.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            Mssr. Eleganté
                            Blue Blaze Irregular
                            CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                            • Oct 2005
                            • 10401

                            Originally posted by sequoia_nomad
                            Ok, then find an out of production one then. You have successfully explained how California law applies to a firearm that doesn't exist. Kudos.

                            As for fletcher, you are simply making up a hypothetical situation. No one mentioned modifying an existing firearm except you. That's a whole 'nother can o' worms.
                            It's pretty simple really...

                            Dfletcher asked a question.

                            Quiet answered it 100% correctly.

                            You (rudely) accused Quiet of being incorrect even though he was 100% correct. Trying to justify your wrong answers and rude behavior by saying dfletcher should never have asked the question to begin with if pretty funny. You were wrong. You made a mistake. We all do it occasionally.
                            __________________

                            "Knowledge is power... For REAL!" - Jack Austin

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              jackandblood
                              Senior Member
                              • Oct 2010
                              • 1125

                              Originally posted by lewisracing
                              I found my Umarex 20 rounders in a gutter outside of my house. They were just laying there. Amazing huh?
                              hey what?
                              Dont go against the grain if you cant handle it - Wu Tang

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1