Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

What’s the fuss all about with Comm block C&R (Mosins & SKSs) these days?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #31
    pro-nra
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 2270

    Boy did I open a can of worms with the Mosin/SKS/Comm block aficionados. I did not mean to attack these widely used firearms. I’m sure they have a place in someone’s safe. I just wanted to know what the fuss is all about. Is it good looks, accuracy, cheap rifle and or ammo etc.
    Originally posted by Josh Smith
    idiot-resistant
    I have to agree on a couple of points you’ve made this being one of them.
    Originally posted by Josh Smith
    the fact that US rifles, ones we might otherwise own, are simply insanely overpriced used guns, the Russian stuff starts looking very good.
    Simple economics of supply and demand. Yes an original Remington 03-A4 will fetch $4.5K and the same for an M1C because of the fact that collectors are willing to pay. I would not say overpriced as collectors are willing to pay…just expensive.
    Originally posted by Josh Smith
    I really want a Garand. I will not pay $800 to $1000 for one in the condition I'd like it in. No, I don't care what it looks like, but the bore must be good and it must shoot 2" at 100 yards.
    You can still buy a service grade M1 for $650 delivered to your door through the CMP. These rifles will have tubes averaging TE2 MW1 so the tubes are as new. As far as shooting 2 MOA, some are capable out of the box. Here is an 8 shot target on one of my HRA service grade @ 100 yards measuring 2.25” using surplus HXP. Now keep in mind I am not a master class shooter. Sounds like you are a master class shooter so you should be able to cut this group by at least half or more.

    Originally posted by Josh Smith
    Given that my $90 Mosin did this out-of-the-box and now does sub-MOA groups with handloads, a piece of friggin' cork gasket under the barrel, and a few shims under the receiver, hell man, give me the Mosin.
    Interesting. I wonder if other Mosin shooters knows about this mod? We must keep this fact a secret so Mosin shooters will not start showing up at Sac Valley’s monthly silhouette and long range matches and win each and every match. I’ve only been shooting these two matches just two years but never seen a Mosin or SKS win a match. Not saying you will not win if you shoot these matches with your Mosin, I’m just saying the past two years there was never a Mosin that won the match. Tom (silhouette) and Rob (long range) will have the raw data on this further than two years but match winners are usually shooting Swedish M96, Swiss K31 or 03-A3 and yes even M1.

    Originally posted by Josh Smith
    The Garand, as awesome as it is, is underbuilt. This is why it's limited to lighter .30-06 loads and has a strange mag capacity! Heavy loads give bent parts.
    I assume you are referring to bent op rod? You have your facts wrong and being a Garand collector I feel the duty to correct you on this fact that “heavy loads” don’t bend op rods. It is excessive port pressure from slow burning powder on some commercial rounds. I’ve loaded my M1 past red on Sierra manual with IMR 4064 with absolutely zero issues.

    Originally posted by Josh Smith
    Same for the 1903. It's a very nice rifle, probably the best Mauser variant on the planet. Prices are insane, though, due to collectors, and I'll not have one to carry around, especially since my Mosin will outshoot it!
    Although the pre WWII 1903s made by SA and RIA are beautiful rifles, I would like to agree with you as the bulk of my collection are 1903s and 03-A3s. However, IMO the 1903/03-A3 are outclassed by the Swedish Mauser in material (Swedish steel), build quality and workmanship. The Swedes just took their time to build their Mausers.

    Again supply and demand dictate prices.

    Let’s look at the National Matches held at Camp Perry annually. Unless you come up with something I missed, there has been NO Mosin that ever won the National Match ever. Again fact and data don’t support your opinion.
    Originally posted by Josh Smith
    You're more than welcome to participate here:

    Heck, I still need to get some official targets up. I'll outshoot you with irons, I promise...
    Anything further than 100 yards and I'll have to buy range time, but I'll shoot out to however far you'd like.
    Josh
    Josh, I’m not a Master Class shooter like yourself and never claimed to be one. I am a lousy shot to be honest with you. However, I know of two Mauser shooters that I bet will give you a run for your money. Vern Hays with his RA 03-A3 and Paul Wooden with his Swede M96. These two guys routinely scores in the low to mid 30s in the silhouette and in the 370s in the long range matches all with as issued rifles no mods.

    I would like to invite you and your favorite Mosin to our next silhouette match on the 19th of January at Sacramento Valley Shooting Center in Sloughhouse CA. In addition, I would like to invite you to our long range match as soon as we can get a date from the match director (Rob). In case you are not aware, the silhouettes are shot at 200M chickens, 300M pigs, 385 turkey and 500M rams. The long range and Folsom Special are shot at 300Y, 500Y, 600Y and 800Y. That would be interesting to see you win both matches.

    There was a shooter last month shooting an SKS at at semi auto silhouette match and was supprised he scored a total of 3 but I was not surprised. That match winner at that match was shooting an AG42 Ljungman yes a Swedish rifle.
    Last edited by pro-nra; 12-17-2012, 10:05 AM.

    Comment

    • #32
      bruceflinch
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Jan 2006
      • 40127

      Originally posted by pro-nra
      Boy did I open a can of worms with the Mosin/SKS/Comm block aficionados. I did not mean to attack these widely used firearms.
      It's ok Juanito, We all know you like to stir poo...
      Actually I only started collecting Milsurps 3 years ago. I think I might own about 24...They're cheaper than guns that will most likely never get the opportunity to kill somebody...

      I belong to the group that uses firearms, and knows which bathroom to use.

      Tis better to have Trolled & lost, Than to never have Trolled, at all.

      Secret Club Member?.

      Comment

      • #33
        a1c
        CGSSA Coordinator
        • Oct 2009
        • 9098

        Bruce, you just like elegant women.

        Some of us like country girls too.
        WTB: French & Finnish firearms. WTS: raw honey, tumbled .45 ACP brass, stupid cat.

        Comment

        • #34
          Josh Smith
          Senior Member
          • May 2011
          • 1091

          Sir,

          I'm not sure what "master class" is. I'd love to join you in a shoot, but unfortunately it's a few thousand miles away from me. I'm just a po' Indiana boy who grew up shooting what works.

          I'll have to scare up some 100 yard targets and see what I can post. I scan most of them in and discard the paper.

          Please bear in mind that I've done many Finnish mods to my 1939 Russian 91/30, including an M39-style trigger that utilizes straight-taper roller bearings instead of static pins. The trigger pull really is near match-grade 2-stage, and extremely safe with full sear engagement until the second stage.

          The mods are no secret. They were done in one form or another by both the Finns and by the Russians, the Russians usually reserving them for the sniper models.

          I've seen this



          translated into Finnish, Russian, and English. I do not know the original language, but I would suppose it was Russian originally since they used the felt wrap on that harmonic node in their sniper's rifles. (I got to see one that had not been touched since WWII, and it did indeed have remnants of this oiled felt wrapped around the barrel at that node, with some also used to bed the receiver and even to reduce the sear engagement by a bit!)

          20/15 to 20/20 vision is fairly new to me. Been shooting targets at 60 and 80 yards or so simply because I couldn't see 'em. Got to reading about what the human eye should be able to resolve at different distances, and the printed out an eye chart.

          Come to find my 20/30 vision had turned into 20/55 or so over the years. I've since gotten glasses and am currently learning to shoot with them.

          Hey, as an aside... on the Arisaka, how do you deal with that peep sight mounted forward so far? I've shot them and don't like them for that sight, only. To me, a peep should be something you're really not aware of, and that far forward, I'm very aware of it obscuring my target a bit. Same reason I prefer my sights to Mojo sights.

          Are they more for fine, static work than for action-type shooting?

          Regards,

          Josh
          .

          Comment

          • #35
            0321jarhead
            Senior Member
            • Nov 2009
            • 2116

            Josh Smith wrote this "Same for the 1903. It's a very nice rifle, probably the best Mauser variant on the planet. Prices are insane, though, due to collectors, and I'll not have one to carry around, especially since my Mosin will outshoot it!"

            I will say this, "actions speek loader than words Josh Smith." He who laughs first will laugh last. Camp Perry anyone?
            "TRUST BUT, VERIFY"
            Ronald Reagan

            Comment

            • #36
              Josh Smith
              Senior Member
              • May 2011
              • 1091

              Originally posted by backstrap
              Hey Josh, can you post some groups at 100 yards? I noticed most of your groups are at 60-80 yards. I'm curious to see what she does at 100.
              This is the first group shot, just verifying POI out-of-the-box with surplus:



              Shooting high, but windage was on. Sorry for the three-shot-only group; never intended to publish it.

              The distance says 90 yards, but I've since re-measured it to 100 yards, with here-on-out being shot at 110 yards (about 100 meters).

              That's what I get for initially using a GPS to measure distance!

              Used trig since, but I still should grab a laser rangefinder.

              Josh
              .

              Comment

              • #37
                pro-nra
                Senior Member
                • Nov 2010
                • 2270

                Originally posted by Josh Smith
                Sir,

                I'm not sure what "master class" is. I'd love to join you in a shoot, but unfortunately it's a few thousand miles away from me. I'm just a po' Indiana boy who grew up shooting what works.

                I'll have to scare up some 100 yard targets and see what I can post. I scan most of them in and discard the paper.
                I knew this was coming.

                If you don't know what "master class" shooter is then you are not one of the elite master shooters.

                Distance is not an issue as we are in the modern world with new invention called "airplane". If you come to Sac Valley for our next match either silhouette or the long range match and win the match with your favorite Mosin, I will pay for your airline ticket, hotel and car rental. My word is golden.

                The ball is in your court my friend and don't forget to bring Mr. Mosin as you will be shooting against some fine shooting M96s, 03-A3s and K31s.

                Comment

                • #38
                  0321jarhead
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 2009
                  • 2116

                  The silhouette match is the 19th of January. I plan on being there. Hope we get to meet Josh. It shows real good team spirit for us as Cal-Gunners.
                  "TRUST BUT, VERIFY"
                  Ronald Reagan

                  Comment

                  • #39
                    hakenlag
                    Senior Member
                    • May 2012
                    • 788

                    I kinda figured this thread would deteriorate into a urination match pretty quick and I really doubted the OP's stated intent.

                    Comment

                    • #40
                      Josh Smith
                      Senior Member
                      • May 2011
                      • 1091

                      I am getting married the 1st, guys, and I'm simply not spending a fortune on airfare (especially since I'm afraid to fly) simply to prove what a properly set-up Mosin-Nagant rifle can do.

                      You're welcome to fly here. I'm sure there are matches around here.

                      If you don't know what "master class" shooter is then you are not one of the elite master shooters.
                      Where did I say I was? Never shot a formal match in my life unless you count Appleseed.

                      I hate the terms "master," "expert," etc anyway, and would not be found using them to describe myself in any way, shape or form.

                      I shoot because it's fun or necessary. Fun is either blowing the hell out of expired Cambell's Tomato Soup, or seeing how close I can get little holes on paper to other little holes on paper.

                      Shooting because it's necessary includes killing critters for food for killing another person before he manages to kill me.

                      I've never shot to impress. I don't see the point and probably never will.

                      However, if you find it fun, you can spend the bucks, fly to Indiana, and we'll shoot if you'd like. I might find it fun as well. Never know until I try.

                      I will say that you're beginning to be vaguely insulting by your assumptions. I mean, "Master" class shooter? Really? If a person is a master, then he has nothing left to learn, and further pursuit of the hobby would be meaningless.

                      Maybe I'm mistaking you, and if I am, I apologize.

                      Regards,

                      Josh
                      .

                      Comment

                      • #41
                        pro-nra
                        Senior Member
                        • Nov 2010
                        • 2270

                        Originally posted by hakenlag
                        I kinda figured this thread would deteriorate into a urination match pretty quick and I really doubted the OP's stated intent.
                        My original post was for real but with comment from Mr. Josh like " I'll outshoot you with irons, I promise... " it will ruffle some feathers don't you think?

                        All I wanted to know what what the fuss is all about? Don't need any comment on how he will outshoot me as he don't even know me. Although I'm not a master class shooter, I could have been with several National medal at Perry.

                        Comment

                        • #42
                          Josh Smith
                          Senior Member
                          • May 2011
                          • 1091

                          Originally posted by hakenlag
                          I kinda figured this thread would deteriorate into a urination match pretty quick and I really doubted the OP's stated intent.
                          Hello,

                          I don't participate in pissing contests. If it becomes clear that the OP's about that, I'm bowing out.

                          It appears his ego is bruised, or getting there anyway. That was never my intent. Thought I'd show what a Mosin could do for the sake of education.

                          Maybe I was wrong in doing so. It's hard to judge company one's in on the 'net, sometimes.

                          Josh
                          .

                          Comment

                          • #43
                            johnny1290
                            Senior Member
                            • Apr 2011
                            • 1596

                            bwahahaha nice troll post. please. you didn't mean to troll LOL be honest at least

                            Comment

                            • #44
                              surplus-addict
                              Calguns Addict
                              • Jul 2011
                              • 6534

                              Well, besides this master class shooting crap, I must say that I've seen a fair share of mosins with compitent shooters beat people with K31's.
                              Most people think that the Mosin sucks primarely because almost all of the people who shoot them bought one because they are cheap, and they suck at shooting and instead of admitting that they suck, they blame it on the gun. Mind you, there are more mosins with bad barrels slimy because they were actually used in war.

                              But don't underestimate the humble Mosin. It's the sleeper car of the milsurp world...
                              Originally posted by CSACANNONEER
                              Originally posted by loophole
                              What's a PIN number? Or an ATM?
                              You don't watch much porn, do you?
                              Hammer
                              1. The weapon of Kestryll
                              Hammered:
                              1. Getting BTFO by Kestryll with the hammer

                              Comment

                              • #45
                                BroncoBob
                                Calguns Addict
                                • Mar 2008
                                • 6019

                                Wow, this thread turned into a s*** sandwich real quick.
                                sigpic
                                NRA MEMBER

                                Originally Posted by ar15barrels
                                Unscrew the lid. There is a foil seal there.
                                Pull the seal off and screw the lid back on.
                                Then you can squeeze the mustard and it will come out of the bottle..

                                Liberals are termites eating at the foundation of our constitution.
                                Michael Reagan

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1