Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

AR-15: budget build or budget buy? My story.....

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ErikTheRed
    Senior Member
    • Oct 2008
    • 1604

    AR-15: budget build or budget buy? My story.....

    Often times it is asked by first-time AR-15 hopefuls, "should I build an AR, or just buy a complete rifle?" Well not so long ago I was asking the same question. I decided at the time, about 2 years ago, that building my own would be a better choice. Not necessarily because it would be cheaper, but because I could afford to piece it together over time and not have to shell out such a chunk of change all at once. It probably would have been slightly less expensive to simply purchase a complete rifle, even though I set out to build a very budget weapon. I think I did just that, and my budget rifle ended up only negligibly more expensive than a comparable ready-built; and I would have added a few things to the ready-built, so the costs would have been very near the same once I rigged it with the few added accessories.

    I started with a stripped lower, which I let sit in the gun safe for over a year. This past December my folks bought me a lower parts kit for my birthday, which reignited the fire. In January I bought a stock/buffer kit. In early February I ordered my upper, and in the past month I bought a red-dot, a nicer pistol grip, and a bullet button. Heres a cost analysis, I think you'll find that I was reasonably conservative in my choices, a pretty basic no-frills rifle:

    (prices incuding sales tax average of 8%, rounded to nearest 5 dollars)

    -Aero Precision stripped lower, from TDS w/ DROS: $125
    -DPMS lower parts kit, from SOS: $65
    -LMT-clone stock and buffer tube/spring kit, from TDS: $95
    -DelTon M4 chrome-lined upper, direct from DTI w/shipping: $460
    -Primary Arms M3-clone multi-reticle red-dot, direct from PA w/ mount and shipping: $120
    -Strike Industries "Patriot Pro" pistol grip, from Rifle Gear w/ shipping: $25
    -Raddlock GenX bullet button, from Rifle Gear w/ shipping: $40
    -Rear BUIS (not yet added): approx $75-$100
    -Brownell's 10/30 GI mag: $20

    Total: $1,025 to $1,050 depending on the BUIS I choose. But for the sake of comparison to a basic complete rifle, I use only the cost of the lower, the parts kit, stock/buffer/spring, and upper assembly. My cost for these items was $745, very near the cost of a comparable complete rifle. Add in the extra goodies and you'll end up in the same ballpark once tricked out with the items of your choice. So really, if you're asking the "should I build or should I buy" question based on price, then it really doesn't matter enough to bother wasting much time on the decision. If your needs/wants are like many people (including mine), a simple yet effective AR-15 without a bunch of spendy bells and whistles, then either way will cost you approximately the same. The only real question you should be asking is, "can I afford it all now, or do I need to break it up over time?"
    Proudly nestled all snugly and warm in Hillary's basket. She even made room for my bibles and guns!


    I've committed $10 a month to the CalGuns Foundation. Have you??? Join us and donate here!
  • #2
    jbush
    Member
    • Oct 2010
    • 407

    Agreed, that really is the question. The other thing to factor in, is whether you want to learn what makes it all work by building your own. It's a good experience. I heard the warranty issues etc. agrument, but I feel building your own can have its benefits, especially if you want to upgrade later. I don't think the guy who wants one gun or it's his first build should jump into building an upper, but a lower is very simple once you figure out you are just assembling a list of parts, and it gets you familar with how the gun works. A big plus for upgrading and troubleshooting.

    I went through this starting in December when I almost bought a S&W MP sport, decided to build instead and here's what I got. Includes tax, dros, shipping

    Stripped lower on sale w/dros and tax (JD Mach) $135
    Palmetto LBK MOE $131
    PSA 14.7 upper w/pinned FH chromelined $445
    Bullet button $22
    Sights, 2 mags $80

    Total cost $813

    I didn't think this was bad for a quality AR and not much more then purchasing one, and I think I got a better rifle them the sport. Prices on parts have gone up a little, but so have the complete rifles. I spread the cost over a couple months and it didn't bite my checkbook as hard. Could have saved a few bucks by not going MOE, or using a 16" barrel instead of the pinned 14.7, but I got what I wanted in a budget build. And it was only about 60 bucks more then the sport.
    Last edited by jbush; 03-25-2012, 7:09 AM.

    Comment

    • #3
      ptgarcia
      Senior Member
      • Oct 2010
      • 744

      I'm in the process of building mine right now. Here's what I have so far. All parts have been purchased new but some have been private party:

      - JD Machine stripped lower from Turners "Off the Hook" deal - $127 out the door
      - Rock River Arms LPk from a Calgunner -$60 shopped
      - Raddlock from a Calgunner - $30 shipped
      - Stag 2H complete upper (includes sights) - $529 shipped

      So far I have invested $746 in what i feel are quality parts, and need a stock kit and a magazine to be ready to go. I expect to be complete for less than $850. Definitely could have purchased a complete rifle for less but I'm stoked with what I have.
      Last edited by ptgarcia; 04-02-2012, 10:35 AM.
      Paul

      Comment

      • #4
        Sneaky
        Member
        • Jun 2011
        • 140

        I personally think if you wish to own an AR its best build your first even though it may cost a little more. It gives you better knowledge of the rifle and worth the experience! I built my first one because I couldnt shell out 700-1200 dollars at once. But in the end I built exactly what I wanted but was in it overall in the 1300 dollar range.

        Comment

        • #5
          monk
          Veteran Member
          • Jul 2011
          • 4454

          My first AR is a build. Even building the upper. End of the day cost will end up being something like $7-800 before scope but it'll be custom.


          NRA Member
          SAF Member


          A tyrant will always find a pretext for his tyranny.

          Comment

          • #6
            peter95
            Senior Member
            • Oct 2009
            • 2488

            Lower + dross $125
            Stock and buffer kit $120
            Complete upper with iron sights $450
            Lpk $50
            Total $745

            Comment

            • #7
              bighead
              Senior Member
              • Sep 2010
              • 655

              Spikes complete mid length is 890, same exact parts as much more expensive rifles and a lifetime warranty.

              Comment

              • #8
                russ69
                Calguns Addict
                • Nov 2009
                • 9348

                First AR: buy a complete rifle.
                Second AR: build a cheap one and find out what you like and what you don't.
                Third AR: build your dream machine.

                After that you'll be an expert.
                sigpic

                Comment

                • #9
                  ErikTheRed
                  Senior Member
                  • Oct 2008
                  • 1604

                  Yeah, I'm glad I built it. The experience was good and it was fun doing it myself. As far as a "dream machine" is concerned, well, I guess I already built mine. It has everything on it I'll ever need or want, and I've satisfied the empty "this space reserved for AR-15" spot in my cabinet. On to other things now!
                  Proudly nestled all snugly and warm in Hillary's basket. She even made room for my bibles and guns!


                  I've committed $10 a month to the CalGuns Foundation. Have you??? Join us and donate here!

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    kalbos
                    Junior Member
                    • Feb 2012
                    • 82

                    Sorta built my first one.
                    New Frontier complete lower 155 w BB
                    Bull barrel 16 inch stainless flat top complete upper 470.00
                    Total for rifle 625.00

                    Need mags and optics so figure maybe another 200 or so for that.

                    Plan is to do a nicer lower if I do another one and get a cheapo barrel for the NFA lower.

                    My.new project is gonna be a RPK

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    UA-8071174-1