All said in original post I have to agree on. It puzzles me when people spend all day arguing over brand like its a sports team or even a religion. We should be counting our lucky stars that we are spoiled with enough high quality firearms that we actually have so many solid choices. Also notice people getting way too caught up on the quality of a gun within the first 200 rounds.
Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reliability observation.
Collapse
X
-
Yes...
++1000 ^^^^good points.!Reliability has been a debate on here for some time (and will remain to be)with different handguns. I just wanted to give my take on it or more so what I have observed as of late. After really getting out there and shooting the S*** out of a lot of mine and buddies guns lately I have really not found one the end all pistol that does not have issues (I never thought there was one anyways).
Lately I have been shooting IDPA and practicing quite a bit. I have noticed a few things that kind of debunks some of the BS I see/hear on a daily basis.While this is far from a scientific experiment just a observation so take it FWIW.
1. You would be surprised at how many issues you see at some matches with glocks ( you see them with other guns too, just mentioning this because glocks are thought of to be the holy grail of reliability)
2. No matter the make or model of the gun you should clean/maintain your gun often. I don't care if it's a glock,hk,sig,beretta,1911,s&w,ruger whatever. Maintenance is what keeps the gun chugging a long the best it can. Dirty guns and lack of maintenance contributes to a lot of the issues I have seen in matches,not all but a lot.
3. I have seen matches won in overall accuracy by stock glocks and seen cheap and expensive 1911's run without hiccups. (so there goes the glocks are not accurate and 1911's are not reliable unless expensive bs)
4. You really don't know your gear until you get out and really run it through it's paces. (I remember one guy in particular that kept having issues with a sig p226. He had mentioned to me that he was glad he came out and started shooting because he had that sig laying next to his bed for the last year and he was getting malfunctions every damn mag during the match.) Just imagine if he relied on the gun for self defense. On top of the fact that he never practiced or really shot the thing.
I have ran thousands upon thousands of rounds through my glock 17 and a few thousand already through my ria tactical and none of them have had much of a issue at all. I get frustrated when I hear other people bashing platforms on here with lack of experience and just commenting because they drink the M&P,GLOCK,RUGER whatever koolaid. Any quality firearm should run if you take care of it, mechanical devices are all prone to fail at some point in their life. The best thing to do is to get out there shoot and learn how to deal with it if the problem happens and not think that your gun will never have a failure and never practice clearing failures/malfunctions because when your glock or sig has a double feed and surprises the hell out of you, How are you going to react?May the Bridges I burn light the way.
Life Is Not About Waiting For The Storm To Pass - Its About Learning To Dance In The Rain.
Fewer people are killed with all rifles each year (323 in 2011) than with shotguns (356), hammers and clubs (496), and hands and feet (728).Comment
-
It seems to me from what I have seen a lot of the people that shoot modded guns and reload are not new to the sport and a lot of times are working out kinks with certain loads and upgrades,so failures are pretty common and a lot of times they even expect it. IDPA is a good place to find out if the gun runs with a certain ammo and or modification. Especially if one cant afford to go to a ton of classes.
Like I said this is far from a experiment and just a general observation I have made. I never claimed to be a guru or anything, I have been shooting for the majority of my life and this doesn't just come from shooting IDPA this comes experience from trying different platforms and watching others. I run my guns and I run them hard, I know what guns I trust my life to and what guns I don't. I think it is in everyone's best interest to run ANY gun through it's paces before trusting you or your family's lives to it whether it be a glock or whatever brand. My intent in this thread was not to bash any firearm as most quality made handguns in most common service rounds will serve you well as long as you take care of them and learn how to run your system effectively.Last edited by ChrisO; 04-19-2011, 5:43 PM.Comment
-
I wonder how reliable revolvers are compared to most auto pistols?Reliability has been a debate on here for some time (and will remain to be)with different handguns. I just wanted to give my take on it or more so what I have observed as of late. After really getting out there and shooting the S*** out of a lot of mine and buddies guns lately I have really not found one the end all pistol that does not have issues (I never thought there was one anyways).
Lately I have been shooting IDPA and practicing quite a bit. I have noticed a few things that kind of debunks some of the BS I see/hear on a daily basis.While this is far from a scientific experiment just a observation so take it FWIW.
1. You would be surprised at how many issues you see at some matches with glocks ( you see them with other guns too, just mentioning this because glocks are thought of to be the holy grail of reliability)
2. No matter the make or model of the gun you should clean/maintain your gun often. I don't care if it's a glock,hk,sig,beretta,1911,s&w,ruger whatever. Maintenance is what keeps the gun chugging a long the best it can. Dirty guns and lack of maintenance contributes to a lot of the issues I have seen in matches,not all but a lot.
3. I have seen matches won in overall accuracy by stock glocks and seen cheap and expensive 1911's run without hiccups. (so there goes the glocks are not accurate and 1911's are not reliable unless expensive bs)
4. You really don't know your gear until you get out and really run it through it's paces. (I remember one guy in particular that kept having issues with a sig p226. He had mentioned to me that he was glad he came out and started shooting because he had that sig laying next to his bed for the last year and he was getting malfunctions every damn mag during the match.) Just imagine if he relied on the gun for self defense. On top of the fact that he never practiced or really shot the thing.
I have ran thousands upon thousands of rounds through my glock 17 and a few thousand already through my ria tactical and none of them have had much of a issue at all. I get frustrated when I hear other people bashing platforms on here with lack of experience and just commenting because they drink the M&P,GLOCK,RUGER whatever koolaid. Any quality firearm should run if you take care of it, mechanical devices are all prone to fail at some point in their life. The best thing to do is to get out there shoot and learn how to deal with it if the problem happens and not think that your gun will never have a failure and never practice clearing failures/malfunctions because when your glock or sig has a double feed and surprises the hell out of you, How are you going to react?
-Freq

Comment
-
In all honesty I do not see THAT many people using revolvers (a lot of people start using revolvers when they get bored and master all the other classes lol), In the bigger matches like state matches yeah you see them but on a club level not as much. I have seen a few hiccups with revolvers. A cylinder lock up with a taurus, seen the timing be off on a colt lawman but these are the only problems I have seen in person at a match.Comment
-
Glocks are incredibly reliable. That's why you see them at range rentals. They can't afford to have something that's not reliable. Do Glocks fail sometimes? Sure. A man-made object will fail at one point in time.
Don't need a competition to see how reliable your gun is. Just go to the range and keep shooting. Especially your bedside gun. Keep shooting it.
I would have belived that untill I started shooting action pistol.
Things change a lot when you stop shooting from "ideal" static range settings and go into improvised shooting positions.Sandstorm Custom Rifle Slings : Custom Paracord slings
10% off slings for calguns members. PM for details. Like us on facebook!Comment
-
I really didn't pay that much attention to that comment because until you really start running your gun in less than ideal situations you don't know how it will act. Some will run fine some wont, but I can tell you right now that shooting a gun sideways can induce a lot of issues in the feeding department. I can also say that the gun may run fine in different positions but none will run as good in improvised shooting position as it will in a ideal shooting position no matter what way you want to slice it and it is more prone to failures in certain positions.Comment
-
thats basicaly what i was saying.......in more words : )Sandstorm Custom Rifle Slings : Custom Paracord slings
10% off slings for calguns members. PM for details. Like us on facebook!Comment
-
So a reliable gun in ideal shooting position is still more reliable than an unreliable gun in ideal shooting position, when both are placed in improvised shooting position?I really didn't pay that much attention to that comment because until you really start running your gun in less than ideal situations you don't know how it will act. Some will run fine some wont, but I can tell you right now that shooting a gun sideways can induce a lot of issues in the feeding department. I can also say that the gun may run fine in different positions but none will run as good in improvised shooting position as it will in a ideal shooting position no matter what way you want to slice it and it is more prone to failures in certain positions.
Is it possible that an otherwise reliable gun becomes as bad as an otherwise unreliable gun, when both are placed in improvised shooting position?
Further, can an unreliable gun under normal conditions, become more reliable than a reliable gun under normal conditions, when both are shooting from improvised position?Comment
-
I shot IDPA for many years and alot of training. Was shooting about 20k at one point, and seeing 30 or so student go through classes a month. Point is, I got to see hundreds of thousands of round discharged, in all fashions, from just about every make and model of handgun out there. My conclusion, boiled down: The more the handgun was stock, the less it malfunctioned. The more factory mags were used, the less it malfunctioned. The more factory ammo was used, the less it malfunctioned. Make and model were pretty far down the list of variables in determining if a handgun was reliable.Comment
-
A ideal shooting position is with the gun straight up and shooting on a square range or even off a rest. Any other position besides this is technically a improvised shooting position, Improvised shooting positions are more prone to cause failures in guns. Any gun doesn't matter how reliable or not they all act differently in different positions/situations thats why I'm saying to run the gun so you can know how gun acts.So a reliable gun in ideal shooting position is still more reliable than an unreliable gun in ideal shooting position, when both are placed in improvised shooting position?
Is it possible that an otherwise reliable gun becomes as bad as an otherwise unreliable gun, when both are placed in improvised shooting position?
Further, can an unreliable gun under normal conditions, become more reliable than a reliable gun under normal conditions, when both are shooting from improvised position?Comment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,971
Posts: 25,178,131
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,382
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 36276 users online. 27 members and 36249 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.



.
Comment