second handgun?

[TacticalChihuahua]

I currently own a G19 and love it (however I will be sending off to resize and texture the grip shortly because i can't hit the mag release without changing my grip). Now it is time for my second hangun. Im selling my p220 combat because i just cant get used to the first double action pull and plus i like the simplicity of the glock/m&p. Here are the 4 handguns i will be choosing from:

-G21sf
-M&P45 full size
-G17
-M&P9 full size

So do i go 45 or 9? Do i go glock or m&p?

What would be some reasons for getting another handgun if i already like my G19 (other than the fact that i really want one)?

Here are some things to note:
-i shot the m&p45 better than the i shot the 21sf
-should i consolidate and only go Glock in 9mm?
-i like 9mm because its cheap
- i hear that m&p's are better than glocks for larger calibers and vice versa. Why??

[RollingCode3]

M&P first ......then Glock.... Eventually you will buy both.. It is a lose-lose situation here.

[kahai808]

you could just put a extended mag release on your glock. help to reach the mag release better.

i have own both, i would pick up the M&P and see how it feels. the grips are alot different. if i had to choose i would go with the M&P because it feels real nice in my hand. with loads .45 acp.

[ElvenSoul]

Do you own a shotgun? Sounds like you have a good solid handgun.

[TacticalChihuahua]

Have a shotgun, ar, ak

[bsg]

if you want a second handgun and like the platform of your G19... consider sticking with Glock on your next purchase.

[evidens83]

If you really like the Glock then I'd consider a G34. Otherwise I would go M&P9 just for variety sake. I would stick with 9mm unless you start getting into 1911s that is

[CSACANNONEER]

Here is your chance to correct the mistake of buying a Glock first. You should get a .22lr next.

[DannyInSoCal]

G30SF

[DaveFJ80]

Shotgun or 1911..... but from your list above, either the G21SF or the M&P45

[EricSF]

Why get another full size? Go for Kahr PM9 as a BUG

[ElvenSoul]

No love for wheelguns?

[RollingCode3]

People are funny these days. OP asked which gun to buy next from the list he provided. You guys recommend him shotguns, revolver, subcompact, etc...

[chesterthehero]

second on the wheel gun...
m&p is a great lookin gun.. however i just cant get behind them.. randomly chambering the first round when loading a fresh mag is just not ok with me.

[FUBAR]

Go G21SF from your list for a 45. Personally, I would get a another 9mm G34 instead of the G17. The size comparison between your G19 to a G17 is not much of a difference.