Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

CA320 question

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ap3572001
    Calguns Addict
    • Jun 2007
    • 6039

    CA320 question

    I will make this as simple as possible. Lol. For a person living in California, what is the difference between buying a CA320 and converting it into a semiautomatic (by buying grip module and magazines) vs just buying a used Sig P320 via PPT ? I keep reading and hearing different stuff. Just curious.
  • #2
    fishn395
    Junior Member
    • Sep 2020
    • 34

    If I understand it correctly...You are getting a brand new Sig slide, barrel and FCU with the CA320, then purchasing a new sig frame. Depending on overal cost from your ffl. ..verses, buying a ppt used P320 and overal cost of what the seller wants to sell for and how much they have used it.

    Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

    Comment

    • #3
      ap3572001
      Calguns Addict
      • Jun 2007
      • 6039

      Originally posted by fishn395
      If I understand it correctly...You are getting a brand new Sig slide, barrel and FCU with the CA320, then purchasing a new sig frame. Depending on overal cost from your ffl. ..verses, buying a ppt used P320 and overal cost of what the seller wants to sell for and how much they have used it.

      Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk
      So basically, one ends up with the same gun.

      Comment

      • #4
        fishn395
        Junior Member
        • Sep 2020
        • 34

        I believe so...if it wasnt for the roster, the CA320 wouldn't exist...but a big thanks to Franklin for still caring about us.

        Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

        Comment

        • #5
          EsotericEpsilon
          Member
          • Aug 2019
          • 246

          Originally posted by ap3572001
          So basically, one ends up with the same gun.
          Yes and no.

          Yes it's essentially a "P320" in function.
          No because on paper it's a CA320.

          If you wanted to use it on your CCW, your paperwork would show CA320. (After checking if your IA issues with single shot or if you need to pawn return)
          If you don't care and just want to have a "P320" style firearm, then you're good to go.

          Comment

          • #6
            morrcarr67
            I need a LIFE!!
            • Jul 2010
            • 15074

            Originally posted by ap3572001
            I will make this as simple as possible. Lol. For a person living in California, what is the difference between buying a CA320 and converting it into a semiautomatic (by buying grip module and magazines) vs just buying a used Sig P320 via PPT ? I keep reading and hearing different stuff. Just curious.
            The price.

            If you just want it for the sake of having one, it's way cheaper than buying a used P320.

            The price.

            If you want one to get on your CCW it's a fair amount cheaper than buying a used P320. Granted you have to work a bit at it but you should still come out about $300-400 less than a used one.

            Sent from my LE2115 using Tapatalk
            Yes you can have 2 C&R 03 FFL's; 1 in California and 1 in a different state.

            Originally posted by Erion929

            Comment

            • #7
              sitruc
              Member
              • Nov 2016
              • 466

              I've been catching up on various conversion threads here. The simple answer is get a p320 by ppt to avoid potential issues with conversion.

              The law degree and effort one needs to be able get an FA CA 320 to semi-auto while also precluding the possibility of being arrested and charged for manufacturing an unsafe handgun (or some variant therof) might be too much for most.

              Comment

              • #8
                Nick3
                Member
                • Aug 2021
                • 135

                Originally posted by sitruc
                I've been catching up on various conversion threads here. The simple answer is get a p320 by ppt to avoid potential issues with conversion.

                The law degree and effort one needs to be able get an FA CA 320 to semi-auto while also precluding the possibility of being arrested and charged for manufacturing an unsafe handgun (or some variant therof) might be too much for most.
                Complete FUD

                OP: A CA320 is just a P320 with a bogus grip module you can swap to a regular one in under a minute. To add it to a CCW may or may not require the gun to be re DROSed as a semi auto.

                Here's some more hearsay to add to the confusion:



                I highly doubt the vast majority commenting on the legality or CCW ability of the CA320 have actually inquired with their issuing agency and are instead just parroting what others are posting. I know I'd be sour if I bought a second hand P320 private party just before this was released.

                Comment

                • #9
                  sitruc
                  Member
                  • Nov 2016
                  • 466

                  Originally posted by Nick3
                  Complete FUD

                  OP: A CA320 is just a P320 with a bogus grip module you can swap to a regular one in under a minute. To add it to a CCW may or may not require the gun to be re DROSed as a semi auto.

                  Here's some more hearsay to add to the confusion:



                  I highly doubt the vast majority commenting on the legality or CCW ability of the CA320 have actually inquired with their issuing agency and are instead just parroting what others are posting. I know I'd be sour if I bought a second hand P320 private party just before this was released.
                  This goes beyond having it listed on a CCW. I used the phrase "precluding the possibility" because the law is purposely vague regarding whether or not an unsafe handgun has been manufactured by converting it to semi-auto. I remember reading some published document by DOJ under Xavier Becerra regarding FMBUS and converting firearms essentially being interpreted as manufacturing. This is my understanding from what I have read and the research I have done by reading through things like published DOJ opinions, court filings, and the California Code of Regulations, Title 11.

                  Fear, uncertainty, and doubt are appropriate nouns to use when the DOJ has bent over backwards trying to justify the UHA/handgun roster in both Boland and Renna. Newsom is in office for another 4 years and thus control over the executive and DOJ is still not in gun owners' favor.

                  My assessment stands; it is easier, safer, and precludes the possibility of being arrested for manufacturing an unsafe handgun to PPT an actual p320 instead of converting. If the potential risk to your freedom is worth the $300 or so in savings, by all means, do so.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    bwiese
                    I need a LIFE!!
                    • Oct 2005
                    • 27622

                    Originally posted by sitruc
                    ...because the law is purposely vague regarding whether or not an unsafe handgun
                    has been manufactured by converting it to semi-auto.
                    I, with an embellishment or two by others, was developer of the "SSE" workflow such that off-Roster handguns
                    could be acquired via the 12133PC single-shot exemption (as long as they were dimensionally compliant per that s
                    section).
                    • From late 2007 til 2014, off-Roster handguns were "SSE'd" using the single-shot exemption to
                      allow them to be purchased at CA FFLs. In fact, CA FFLs were given repeated explicit guidance
                      by multiple CA DOJ staff across the state (captured on security video, to boot) on "how to do it
                      properly".


                      This included customers walking out of FFL dealer w/their SSE'd off-Roster handguns after 10 day wait+
                      pickup - then walking back in the door for "gunsmithing services" to remove/return SSE conversion kit
                      parts to the FFL so as to recover depoit, and the FFL re-rendering such guns back into their normal native
                      form (albeit with 10rd or less magazines, some of which were permanently-converted downsized hicaps).

                      Notably, FBI & other Fed agents acquired personal handguns (incl ones duplicative of their duty guns)
                      using this method until there was a fixup in the exemptions around 2012(?)-ish. ATF was contacted (ATF
                      actually has good expertise in CA law and knows what's good & bad often more than line CA DOJ agent
                      staff; I believe other Fed agency relevant legal leads were also consulted before Fed agents got go-ahead
                      to get 'personal duplicate' off-Roster duty firearms (i.e, they often wanted extra gun(s) duplicating their
                      likely-not-Rostered service sidearm but had to buy it on their own & was not gov't-supplied).

                    • An, um, "noted" CA DOJ Deputy AG in ~2007 acknowledged, in writing, that while 'lefty Glocks' were
                      not Rostered nor available in California, a one-armed man desiring a lefthanded Glock could indeed send
                      his Glock to factory for such modifications and get it returned to him. (She was prob not aware of ease of
                      such conversion and that it did not require mfgr or gunsmith work, but that is irrelevant to this matter: you
                      can mod your Glock into off-Roster status.) [IIRC, this particular woman in fact was involved as a legislative
                      aide for antigun state Sen Jack Scott.]

                    • ANYTIME even a trivial part changes (other than perhaps sights/grip finish) on a Rostered firearm from a
                      part that was used on the submitted/tested exemplars (for test lab + DOJ storage), the gun then becomes
                      non-Rostered!! This includes use of aftermarket magazines - the gun is tested as a system with matching
                      mag, not just as a mag-less pistol.

                      This also includes any warranty or repair work done on the gun using parts that differ from the exemplar (in fact
                      CA DOJ uses this stance regarding minor production changes to avoid Rostering guns having trivial production
                      changes and which then required microstamping for re-Rostering, leading to many models disappearing from
                      the market.)

                      There are no statutes listing 'authorized' vs 'unauthorized' transition to off-Roster status (i.e, changing feature
                      vs warranty replacement part vs aftermarket magazine).

                      It would be wonderful for our litigation - esp since some specific gun parts' vendors/suppliers may've disappeared
                      - for CA DOJ to prevent/criminalize warranty repair nor normal maintenance of handguns!!

                      { Hell, DOJ BoF does not examine Rostered used handguns [bought back/traded in to CA FFLs for resale] deeply
                      for mods. They most likely can't even tell on some of these changes unless they used non-BoF forensic labs/
                      toolmark examiners, perhaps from ATF. If the FFL can't tell, they can't! }

                    • There's no legal differentiation btwn an owner changing generic spring or rivet or pin or lever, etc on a Rostered
                      pistol - changing it to non-Rostered status - vs changing a Roster-exempt firearm to non-Rostered status via some
                      other means/style/configuation.... or the gun falling off Roster thru no action of his, just because of non-renewal!

                      There simply is no 'priority list' of "what's allowed to be changed or repaired". Period. And it'd be delicious for
                      us for them to deny warranty repairs and corral warranty parts to sole suppliers (hey, lotsa Fed warranty law there
                      to interfere - Magnusson-Moss, etc.) But we'd rather win on 2A grounds than just interference with Fed warranty
                      laws.

                    • While the single-shot (SSE) exemption re: pistols was the usual exploit, many folks worked with FFLs to
                      also perform "Single Action Revolver"-exempt transfers by deleting and then re-adding DA sears on their
                      dimensionally compliant off-Roster S&W and Colt (and perhaps Ruger) DA revolvers. These such mods &
                      transfers on revolvers continue to this day.


                    • Due to the great Sacramento Cop Roster Flipping fiasco ("Omigod they're making sharks with nuclear
                      lasers on their guns!") AB1964 was passed in legislature and changed ONLY the SSE exemption - wording was
                      merely tweaked slightly to say that (in essence) "... if the gun has ever been semiauto it can't be Single-shot
                      exempt." (This history presumably even includes mfg testing as such.) It did not address revolver changes,
                      only "single shotting". AB1964 only touched a corner of the original single shot exemption and did not touch
                      the single-action revolver exemption whatsoever.)

                    • For years the DOJ had information this was going on, from inside the AFS system/DROS. They could easily
                      see which nonexempt people were getting *new* (non-PPT/non-consignment/non-OpLaw) off-Roster, say,
                      Gen4 Glocks or new Ruger 1911s or new Sphinx 9mms, etc. These were transferred via "Roster override" on
                      DROS system and were done In Plain View of DOJ for years.

                      DOJ staff across the state observed conversions from SSE'd pistols back to 'normal form' for significant period
                      of time.

                    • The FA 320s etc are NOT SSE. They are Rostered/approved guns. Changing the plastic frame around
                      the serialized FCU is of equal legal status to any of the changes done pre-2014 and given full (perhaps
                      grudging) DOJ BoF sanction from 2007 - 2013.



                    1. For the DOJ to try to (for misdemeanor at best) go after a FA320 'restoration' person - given all the
                    above history (and in high volume with DOJ staff guidance/witnessing) would be legally unsupportable -
                    and would make them look even sillier in their Roster defense.

                    2. DOJ had the opportunity - with complete documentation, witnessing etc - to even TRY to go after
                    the SSE process for YEARS.

                    DOJ also knows that the Single Action Revolver mods are going on right now (just usu in lower volume
                    since pistols outsell, generally, revolvers.)
                    Last edited by bwiese; 05-01-2023, 3:23 AM.

                    Bill Wiese
                    San Jose, CA

                    CGF Board Member / NRA Benefactor Life Member / CRPA life member
                    sigpic
                    No postings of mine here, unless otherwise specifically noted, are
                    to be construed as formal or informal positions of the Calguns.Net
                    ownership, The Calguns Foundation, Inc. ("CGF"), the NRA, or my
                    employer. No posts of mine on Calguns are to be construed as
                    legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Nick3
                      Member
                      • Aug 2021
                      • 135

                      Originally posted by sitruc
                      freedom

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        sitruc
                        Member
                        • Nov 2016
                        • 466

                        Originally posted by bwiese
                        ...[*] The FA 320s etc are NOT SSE. They are Rostered/approved guns. Changing the plastic frame around the serialized FCU is of equal legal status to any of the changes done pre-2014 and given full (perhaps grudging) DOJ BoF sanction from 2007 - 2013.


                        1. For the DOJ to try to (for misdemeanor at best) go after a FA320 'restoration' person - given all the
                        above history (and in high volume with DOJ staff guidance/witnessing) would be legally unsupportable -
                        and would make them look even sillier in their Roster defense.

                        2. DOJ had the opportunity - with complete documentation, witnessing etc - to even TRY to go after
                        the SSE process for YEARS...
                        I appreciate your detailed thoughts and input. I also acknowledge the work you put into this process in the past. I have come across multiple posts of yours conveying similarly thoughtful and detailed information in the various threads I have explored.

                        I am sure you can appreciate that I do not want to be the test case for DOJ and don't recommend anyone be the test case for DOJ by pushing the more lax interpretation of current firearm laws in CA to the point of litigation. To say that people have not been charged/prosecuted with this in the past is current grounds for a legal justification for my actions is not enough for me. We all have heard of when an overzealous DA (or in this case, the AG) tries to over-charge someone to make an example. I agree simple possession of said firearm may result in a misdemeanor, but there are more serious felony charges that are at the discretion of the prosecuting body. If you use this firearm in a defensive shooting, enjoy being poor, in jail, or most likely both.

                        As you acknowledge, the Roster nonsense points at an executive branch that is unwilling to adopt a position that could conceivably be interpreted as pro 2A. Although I appreciate the work CRPA and Michel & Associates is doing for us, I would rather not rely on their services as a direct client. If Boland ends up nullifying the Roster, my fear of being prosecuted for manufacturing an unsafe handgun from a 2A Zone P320 or FA CA 320 goes away.

                        If one has the means to PPT a used bona-fide semi-auto P320 right now it still remains the only means to prevent oneself from the additional effort (doing the pawn shop trick, double ppt, registering in CFARS, etc.) and the associated potential legal risks of manufacturing (new grip module and magazines).
                        Last edited by sitruc; 05-02-2023, 7:04 PM.

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        UA-8071174-1