Which one would you keep

[Sure Shot 45]

Hell if I know. Keep the one you like better.

[k1dude]

Sell your gun? WTF?

[omega]

the full sized one looks like it has some extra nice features, optical sight , upgraded trigger, nice range pistol or Home Defense use with the light

and the sub compact version for concealment / EDC / night stand duty

both are unique , probably the reason why you chose them

[Ora Serrata]

Do you carry the compact? If you have a CCW why would you get rid of a nice carry gun?

[CaliforniaCowboy]

I would keep the one I shoot better with.

[Kyle1886]

Sometime back I had to "downsize" my "arsenal". I really regret having to do it, so think twice, and maybe a third time.

As others suggest while you think on it, save a few quarters here and there, and perhaps you can save enough for that third piece.

Respectfully
Kyle

[003]

Keep the full size for sure. Sell the little one.

[Barang]

keep it if you cannot decide or flip a coin.

[Mr. Patis]

I'm thinking of replacing the subcompact for the compact p10c...I got the subcompact to add to my carry but its a little big/fat for carry. If I ever want it back later...im sure my dad will gift me another one.

[plumbum]

Keep the full size for sure. Sell the little one.

[M1NM]

The one I didn't like - the one I'd make the most profit on - the one that would be easiest to replace - the one I couldn't shoot straight with - etc

[Like2fly]

This is all fun to speculate on but seriously you have not provided enough info for definitive advice. Are these your only two hand guns? Would you ever need to conceal carry the one you keep, if so keep the compact. Would the one you keep only be used for let’s say home defense and never needs carrying or concealing? Then keep the larger one. Of course all the other input on which one do your shoot better with, grip better, shoot more often etc, is good advice but as some have said above, the best advice is to keep both and save up or sell some other (non-gun) item to fund your next purchase.

[Jess B. Guy]

Neither.
This year I made a terrible mistake by selling a pile of guns I thought I didn't need. Silly me.
That was in February. Since then I've repopulated my collection with about 20% more than I sold. Good for me.
If you are absolutely sure you need/want to sell one of the 2 - make your own decision. You'll regret it the day after you sell it. (I guess keep the big one)

[newbie1234]

I would keep BOTH , hard to replace once they are gone

+++++++ 1

[71MUSTY]

Do you carry the compact? If you have a CCW why would you get rid of a nice carry gun?

I went from Sub Compact to Compact to Micro and then back to Full size for CCW. Just me but at 7 yards I prefer 15 rounds in the heart to 8-10 center mass.