Which to keep?

[Dvrjon]

I'm in the process of a career change and funds are tight currently. I'm also trying to consolidate down to only 9mm and one other cartridge.

Spot on. I carry open (where legal) and have been wanting a 4 or 6" 357 or 44. I don't have much desire to CC, so the snubby is really only an asthetic luxury at the moment.

Sell both. Neither has sentimental value for you, and unless the other caliber is either .45 or .38/.357, neither meets the goal of getting to 9mm plus one other caliber. (And neither is 4" or 6" .357 or a .44).

The Citadel is a decent entry .45 and potential project gun, so has some market appeal. The Ruger has great appeal as a CCW weapon. Sell both, stabilize career issues; buy what you truly want. Never look back.

Best.