Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Refusing LEO exemptions for firearms
Collapse
X
-
LE will always be able to get what they want, a movement like this just makes it inconvenient for them. This isn't news to anyone. Don't take it as a personal attack.
The police union is strong in CA, and could help law abiding citizens if they chose too, but they choose to stand quiet on the sidelines for political reasons. If FFL's around the state decided to make this stand, to get the attention of those who can help, I'm all for it. I applaud the guys who are willing to sacrifice profits for principle and the rights of others."To preserve liberty, it is essential that the whole body of the people always possess arms, and be taught alike, especially when young, how to use them" - Richard Henry Lee
sigpicComment
-
So would individual FFL holders also be willing to give up their special exemptions related to their acquisition of their own personal firearms ???Poke'm with a stick!
Originally posted by fiddletownWhat you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.Comment
-
This is just a strawman argument.
You mean the lack of waiting period? If so, do you think that FFLs should not honor that for LEO if they have a letter from their dept.? How about C&R FFL holders who also have a COE for C&R firearms?
FFLs are not exempt from the certified list, which is what this issue is about. Some people are allowed to buy certain firearms and others are not, based on their job, not the use of the firearm (personal use is still exempt).
Oh, so far no one who is not LE has admitted to voting "No, if the exemption exists, the FFL should honor it ". So perhaps only LE have voted that way.Last edited by kemasa; 04-22-2013, 11:53 AM.Kemasa.
False signature edited by Paul: Banned from the FFL forum due to being rude and insulting. Doing this continues his abuse.
Don't tell someone to read the rules he wrote or tell him that he is wrong.
Never try to teach a pig to sing. You waste your time and you annoy the pig. - Robert A. HeinleinComment
-
There is not really much to give up. I already have an FFL03+COE to get around handgun 1-30 day rule. If I had to wait the 10 days for the firearm it doesn't really bother me. I can still take the firearm out of the "business" safe to use. That's really the only "exemption" I get being an FFL dealer.. I'm not aware of any other laws I'm exempt from. I still can only transfer what is on the roster for handguns and I can't sell myself hi-cap mags.
What special exemptions are you referring to since I may be missing out on some of those!UG Imports - Fremont, CA FFL - Transfers, New Gun Sales
Closure Schedule: http://ugimports.com/closed
web​ / email / vendor forum
I AM THE MAJORITY!!!
Amazon Links Posted May be Paid LinksComment
-
-
Philosophically, I appreciate the idea behind polls and arguments such as this. I am an active duty California police officer, and I absolutely support RKBA, equal protection under the law, and equal rights for all.
However in reality, polls such as this one, and focus on arguments such as this, do nothing but divide the gun rights community. It alienates the law enforcement community from the larger gun rights community by using us as a target for your ire. I already work in a large, highly politicized city. I spend most of my day as a target for the ire of others - I don't appreciate being made into a target here.
I'd like to see the abolition of all special exemptions, including movie studio possession of NFA weapons that I - even as a police officer - cannot personally own in this state. Where's the poll about that exemption? Where's the outrage over that?
Instead of arguing that NO ONE should have off roster handguns, it might be more positive (and ultimately beneficial to everyone) to use the off roster guns already in California (in the hands of police officers who purchased them from dealers and private persons who bought them PPT from cops) as a way of saying, "See? There are already thousands of off roster guns lawfully in the hands of both police officers and private persons alike. The roster serves no practical purpose, so let's get rid of it. We might even save some state cash that was used in the maintenance and administration of this ridiculous program."
Is it a long shot? Sure, but so is regaining any of our already-lost gun rights in California. And it's an approach that is far more likely to unify the California firearms community. Remember that the rank and file cop is not usually the enemy. Most of us are just as ticked off about the laws in this state as you are.Comment
-
There are ways to get LEO type handguns that are not available on the roster. You could go the PPT or SSE route for non-neutered handgun. Note that just b/c it is not on the roster does not mean they are not unsafe, it meant they would not pay the CA extortion fees.Comment
-
Since LE is exempt from the certified list, do you think that they really care about it?
It is not about alienation or ire, it is making a point, not making anyone a target. Look at the comments from LE and see where the ire is. If they are treated the same as everyone else, then they will be upset.
Most dealers don't deal with the exemptions for the entertainment industry, so that is not the same.
Yes, the certified list is bogus, so why don't LE come out against it? Because it does not affect them, so they don't care. By denying the exemption, then it serves to unify the CA firearms community.Kemasa.
False signature edited by Paul: Banned from the FFL forum due to being rude and insulting. Doing this continues his abuse.
Don't tell someone to read the rules he wrote or tell him that he is wrong.
Never try to teach a pig to sing. You waste your time and you annoy the pig. - Robert A. HeinleinComment
-
Why doesn't LE come out against it? Most of us are against it, personally. However, the vast majority of us do not speak for our unions or agencies. Most association presidents are concerned with managing their association and other usual union issues to bother with 2A rights unless some specific issue occurs in their jurisdiction. Most chiefs are politicians who, even if they are 2A supporters, must toe a very narrow line or risk losing their jobs.Since LE is exempt from the certified list, do you think that they really care about it?
It is not about alienation or ire, it is making a point, not making anyone a target. Look at the comments from LE and see where the ire is. If they are treated the same as everyone else, then they will be upset.
Most dealers don't deal with the exemptions for the entertainment industry, so that is not the same.
Yes, the certified list is bogus, so why don't LE come out against it? Because it does not affect them, so they don't care. By denying the exemption, then it serves to unify the CA firearms community.
Any dealer that refuses to honor the LE exemption for off roster guns (or agency letterhead for avoiding the 10 day waiting period) will just lose business, as there are plenty of active and retired cops who hold FFLs who will be happy to do the transfers, honoring the existing exemptions. That's just a simple business decision. Yes, there are far more non-LE gun buyers than cops, but frankly, most gun buyers don't care if a dealer honors exemptions for LE or not. They care more about price, availability, and geographic convenience. In the grand scheme of things, this is a relatively minor issue that only serves to divide the community.
I think that we, as a 2A community, can spend our time, effort, and political capital better on other issues. Plus, I don't honestly think that most cops care much about this exemption. I, personally, only own one off roster handgun, and I'd be just fine without it. If I lost this exemption, I would not be crying into my whiskey. I'd much rather campaign for CCW reform, getting the ridiculous magazine lock off my personally owned rifles, and defeating the numerous asinine bills that are currently before the California legislature. Oh, yeah, and I'd really dig not having to jump thru a million hoops for that suppressed SBR that my buddy from Arizona can buy pretty much off the shelf. And it'd be awesome if you could too, because frankly, I'm probably not going to be dealing with you in a professional capacity any time soon, unless you're talking on your cell phone or some other chicken---- nonsense. And you're probably not going to shoot me over a traffic ticket, even if I was inclined to write it. However, the gangsters I do take on don't give a damn that there's a law against suppressed SBRs with standard capacity magazines in this state.
If the goal is to get the support of law enforcement, the route is not to campaign against LE-specific exemptions, it's to find common ground and issues that we can ALL get behind, cop or not, and campaign hard for those. Like it or not, there are already plenty of retailers that cater to the LE community. Don't penalize the individual cop, penalize the agency (e.g., Franklin Armory, who purportedly restricts sales to specific anti-2A police agencies) if you can. Hit the chief/sheriff/city manager in his/her pocket book and you MIGHT make a difference.Comment
-
FFL's don't have any "waiting periods" when they DROS a hand gun from their inventory...This is just a strawman argument.
You mean the lack of waiting period? If so, do you think that FFLs should not honor that for LEO if they have a letter from their dept.? How about C&R FFL holders who also have a COE for C&R firearms?
FFLs are not exempt from the certified list, which is what this issue is about. Some people are allowed to buy certain firearms and others are not, based on their job, not the use of the firearm (personal use is still exempt).
Oh, so far no one who is not LE has admitted to voting "No, if the exemption exists, the FFL should honor it ". So perhaps only LE have voted that way.
No "letter" proving the firearm is for duty use...
FFL's don't even DROS long guns. All they do is complete the 4473 then take home any number of long guns, also without a waiting period...
So if the laws are supposed to apply to everyone then these "exemptions" written into California law should also be revoked....
No "straw man". Just pointing out other "exemptions" written into California laws which benefit a group of individuals....Poke'm with a stick!
Originally posted by fiddletownWhat you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.Comment
-
Great point! Let's boycott CA FFLs until they stop using these exemptions. Fair is fair!FFL's don't have any "waiting periods" when they DROS a hand gun from their inventory...
No "letter" proving the firearm is for duty use...
FFL's don't even DROS long guns. All they do is complete the 4473 then take home any number of long guns, also without a waiting period...
So if the laws are supposed to apply to everyone then these "exemptions" written into California law should also be revoked....
No "straw man". Just pointing out other "exemptions" written into California laws which benefit a group of individuals....www.tenpercentfirearms.com was open from 2005 until 2018. I now own Westside Arms.Comment
-
This is America. You run your business the way you see fit. I'm never going to be one of your customers because I don't live near you. However, if you did do this to me, I would tell every cop in the area to avoid your business, as is my right as a consumer. In the end, I would steer my business to the FFLs that cater to cops and would get my firearm that way. You might or might not lose business. It would not, however, keep me from getting the firearm I wanted.Comment
-
-
Ok, I would agree to all that, ignoring that a FFL is licensed and have all sorts of permits, but then it means that CCW should also be to same for everyone and all the exemptions on LE carrying would be eliminated.FFL's don't have any "waiting periods" when they DROS a hand gun from their inventory...
No "letter" proving the firearm is for duty use...
FFL's don't even DROS long guns. All they do is complete the 4473 then take home any number of long guns, also without a waiting period...
So if the laws are supposed to apply to everyone then these "exemptions" written into California law should also be revoked....
No "straw man". Just pointing out other "exemptions" written into California laws which benefit a group of individuals....
FFLs used to be subject to the waiting period.
FFLs don't need to DROS a long gun because they have to have a CA DOJ COE, which is a constant background check.
Don't forget CA DOJ inspections and BATF inspections for all, right???
So yes, it is a strawman argument.Kemasa.
False signature edited by Paul: Banned from the FFL forum due to being rude and insulting. Doing this continues his abuse.
Don't tell someone to read the rules he wrote or tell him that he is wrong.
Never try to teach a pig to sing. You waste your time and you annoy the pig. - Robert A. HeinleinComment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,755
Posts: 25,175,632
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,399
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 30731 users online. 135 members and 30596 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.

Comment