Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

What liability does an FFL have when ...

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • dbdataplus
    Junior Member
    • Dec 2015
    • 91

    What liability does an FFL have when ...

    I have two weapons in "delayed" status at a local FFL. One is a retail purchase from out of state and another is a PPT and I have reason to believe that the State is just going to run out the clock and the transfers will result in "undetermined" status.

    The dealer has told me that he won't release the weapons on an "undetermined" status - his exact quote is "If the DOJ can't figure it out, I won't accept the responsibility" but beyond that he has been proactively non-helpful. His only response to my obvious question "what to I do now?" was "You shoulda thought of that before you bought them.

    So this opens a series of questions -in my mind if nowhere else.

    First - what IS the FFL's responsibility if he releases the weapons to someone of undetermined status?

    Second - As I understand it, I OWN them, I'm just allowed to possess them? If so, do I have the right to sell them? And if I do - won't the DOJ's system freak out that an undetermined person is selling?

    Neither the out of state dealer nor the Private Party are interested in issuing refunds, so the FFL just sits and runs out his "abandoned merchandise" clause and then ends up with free goods? That seems like unlawful conversion or unjust enrichment.

    The reason I'm asking is that, while all of this is new to ME ... it has to be a well trodden path for FFLs.

    What are my options and why?
    The problem with our legislature is NOT that they hate guns. The problem is that they hate the people who don't hate guns.
  • #2
    kemasa
    I need a LIFE!!
    • Jun 2005
    • 10706

    There is really not much responsibility, but the FFL could still be sued and that costs money. It is the option of the FFL to release it or not.

    Define own. You don't really own them because it has not be transferred to you. You paid and basically have a lien on the items. You would not be the person selling them, you could not fill out a PPT, for example, since the firearm was not transferred to you.

    The problem that the FFL has is that if the firearm for the PPT can not be delivered to you, it has to be returned to the seller or turned over to the police.

    You could perhaps sue the FFL in small claims court for the value of the firearms.

    I am not sure of why the FFL seems to be blaming you for the CA DOJ not being able to determine whether you are prohibited or not. You should know if you are and they should have the records.
    Kemasa.
    False signature edited by Paul: Banned from the FFL forum due to being rude and insulting. Doing this continues his abuse.

    Don't tell someone to read the rules he wrote or tell him that he is wrong.

    Never try to teach a pig to sing. You waste your time and you annoy the pig. - Robert A. Heinlein

    Comment

    • #3
      dbdataplus
      Junior Member
      • Dec 2015
      • 91

      The best way I can describe this old guy is a cross between Sam Elliot and Gabby from Blazing Saddles. He thinks what he thinks and no hornswaggling cracker-croaker is gonna tell him nothin. As far as he is concerned the DOJ did not give me permission to possess the weapon and that's the end of it.

      I suppose I could pay him to ship the shotgun back -- and then pay the seller to ship it to another dealer.

      I guess the good news is that the PPT was from an LEO so he could probably walk in and pick it up & walk out with it - then we drive to another store ... the only thing is now, if I were a LEO and found my sale wasn't completed ... maybe I don't want anything AT ALL to do with the seller? No up side and always a chance he gets a call the the Police Chief's office.

      What a pain in the ***.
      The problem with our legislature is NOT that they hate guns. The problem is that they hate the people who don't hate guns.

      Comment

      • #4
        DEPUTYBILL
        Senior Member
        • Mar 2007
        • 875

        I hate to say it, but in this day and age, that is one of the first questions you need to ask an FFL. What is there policy on "undetermined" status Dros's.
        If it non-release, find a different FFL to do business with!

        Comment

        • #5
          Tyke8319
          CGN/CGSSA Contributor
          CGN Contributor
          • Nov 2013
          • 2105

          Further:

          American soldier by choice. Made in America by the Grace of God.

          So, now it is ironic that the State whittles away at the right of its citizens to defend themselves from the possible oppression of their State.
          Judge Roger T. Benitez
          LCM's ruled legal 3/29/2019

          Comment

          • #6
            acespawnshop
            CGN/CGSSA Contributor
            CGN Contributor
            • Jun 2012
            • 2852

            Let's not forget the court of public opinion. I just commented about this in a different thread regarding our policy to deliver them. But, who really wants the headache of channel 2, 4, 5, 7, 11, CNN, FoxNews, MSNBC and Al Jazeera camped out in front of their shop asking why you sold a gun to somebody. I understand why some dealers don't want to risk it.
            Interstate Transfers $100 (DROS included with the price)
            Email acesjewelryandloan@hotmail.com if you need us to do a transfer!
            Or call 626-968-5900

            Follow us on Facebook @acesjewelryandloan Need Cash Fast? Get a loan on your firearms here!

            Comment

            • #7
              dbdataplus
              Junior Member
              • Dec 2015
              • 91

              I understand your position. But on the other hand I can't let you keep my property without paying for it.

              The law is horribly written in this regard. The answer, I suspect, is that if it gets that far I'll attempt to use the court system.

              Let's take you, as an example.
              I accept your reasoning.
              So I sue you for delivery of my property or the money.
              You don't even show up in court, so I get an order
              I show up with an order for you to give me my property
              You hand it over and staple the order to the back of the DROS paperwork

              I'm guess that from a legal and even moral standard you'd be covered, no?
              The problem with our legislature is NOT that they hate guns. The problem is that they hate the people who don't hate guns.

              Comment

              • #8
                kemasa
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Jun 2005
                • 10706

                Originally posted by dbdataplus
                I understand your position. But on the other hand I can't let you keep my property without paying for it.
                It is not your property until it is transferred. You also can't force a FFL to do the transfer.

                The law is horribly written in this regard. The answer, I suspect, is that if it gets that far I'll attempt to use the court system.

                Let's take you, as an example.
                I accept your reasoning.
                So I sue you for delivery of my property or the money.
                You don't even show up in court, so I get an order
                I show up with an order for you to give me my property
                You hand it over and staple the order to the back of the DROS paperwork

                I'm guess that from a legal and even moral standard you'd be covered, no?
                The court can not force a FFL to do an illegal act. There has to have been a background check within the last 30 days or it is illegal for the FFL to turn the firearm over. By the time that you go to court, it will be over 30 days. Small claims can't make such an order either.

                The FFL could say that they will ship the firearm to another FFL, if you pay them for their time and the shipping. Also don't forget that you might owe storage, all of which would have to be paid before the firearm is shipped.

                The law says that the FFL has the option. So by what law do you think that you can force the FFL to do what you think that they should?
                Kemasa.
                False signature edited by Paul: Banned from the FFL forum due to being rude and insulting. Doing this continues his abuse.

                Don't tell someone to read the rules he wrote or tell him that he is wrong.

                Never try to teach a pig to sing. You waste your time and you annoy the pig. - Robert A. Heinlein

                Comment

                • #9
                  dbdataplus
                  Junior Member
                  • Dec 2015
                  • 91

                  This is why the law sucks.

                  First I don't want to get in an argument with you - this is just discussion
                  Originally posted by kemasa
                  The court can not force a FFL to do an illegal act.
                  It's not an illegal act. The PC is clear that he CAN deliver the weapon at his discretion after 30 days and an "undetermined" status. It is very clearly NOT illegal to transfer. It is merely his choice.

                  The FFL could say that they will ship the firearm to another FFL, if you pay them for their time and the shipping.
                  I would argue that I don't owe storage on items that I want to take, have asked to take and he is authorized to give, except that he chooses not to

                  The law says that the FFL has the option. So by what law do you think that you can force the FFL to do what you think that they should?
                  Two lawyers so far - including one highly recommended here. They are in 100% agreement that civil law says that since it is solely HIS decision he cannot decide to keep the weapon without compensating me for that weapon. It's called improper conversion in the civil law and it applies to firearms as well.

                  To CHOOSE to keep a weapon simply because the law allows you to not deliver it -- does not give you a free weapon.

                  But you are right about the timing. By the time the issue reaches small claims the weapons will be long past the window and this will simply be an issue of compensation and unjust enrichment.

                  The problem is, small claims, unlike Superior Court, can be unpredictable
                  The problem with our legislature is NOT that they hate guns. The problem is that they hate the people who don't hate guns.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    dbdataplus
                    Junior Member
                    • Dec 2015
                    • 91

                    That all said ... we'll see what we see.
                    Maybe the state will clear the records and decide I didn't kill the Lindberg baby after all.
                    The problem with our legislature is NOT that they hate guns. The problem is that they hate the people who don't hate guns.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      71MUSTY
                      Calguns Addict
                      • Mar 2014
                      • 7029

                      If I were in your shoes I would be more concerned with why the DOJ didn't clear me then in how I was going to punish the FFL.
                      Only slaves don't need guns

                      Originally posted by epilepticninja
                      Americans vs. Democrats
                      We stand for the Anthem, we kneel for the cross


                      We already have the only reasonable Gun Control we need, It's called the Second Amendment and it's the government it controls.


                      What doesn't kill me, better run

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        kemasa
                        I need a LIFE!!
                        • Jun 2005
                        • 10706

                        It would be illegal by the time you get a court order and small claims would not get you a court order.

                        One problem is that the FFL refusing to do the transfer is not the same as keeping it. The FFL can give you an option as to what to do, other than the transfer. It could be shipped back, it could be consigned, etc. It is the same as when the person is prohibited. The firearm is not yours until the transfer is complete. You have a lien on it, but there is also the issue of the expenses related to the FFL.

                        You would owe storage if you delay deciding what to do. You could pay to have it shipped elsewhere right away, or delay hoping that a court finds in your favor, but that could take a year and in the meantime do you think that the FFL should store it for your for free?
                        Kemasa.
                        False signature edited by Paul: Banned from the FFL forum due to being rude and insulting. Doing this continues his abuse.

                        Don't tell someone to read the rules he wrote or tell him that he is wrong.

                        Never try to teach a pig to sing. You waste your time and you annoy the pig. - Robert A. Heinlein

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          dbdataplus
                          Junior Member
                          • Dec 2015
                          • 91

                          Originally posted by 71MUSTY
                          If I were in your shoes I would be more concerned with why the DOJ didn't clear me then in how I was going to punish the FFL.
                          Well first - I'm not looking to "punish" him. He elects to keep my $1100 handgun all he has to do is reimburse me the $1100. Why in the world would me asking him to pay for what he has received be looked at as punishment?

                          Or are you saying that he gets to keep it as a prize for not exercising his legal right to hand it over if he chooses?

                          As far as the DOJ - here's the issue: 30 days is not enough TIME to get the 45 year old paper records out of the crate next to the Ark of the Covenant and get them sent across country. My DOJ contact explained that if the records don't appear within 28 calendar days from the date of my original application the application is automatically changed to "undetermined" and the case is now officially off of the analyst's desk. But then she was unclear about what happens (or can happen) in the next 30 day window when a new number is issued ...

                          like I said, stupid law.
                          The problem with our legislature is NOT that they hate guns. The problem is that they hate the people who don't hate guns.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            kemasa
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • Jun 2005
                            • 10706

                            Have the FFL ship it to another FFL, then you can do the transfer there.
                            Kemasa.
                            False signature edited by Paul: Banned from the FFL forum due to being rude and insulting. Doing this continues his abuse.

                            Don't tell someone to read the rules he wrote or tell him that he is wrong.

                            Never try to teach a pig to sing. You waste your time and you annoy the pig. - Robert A. Heinlein

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              dbdataplus
                              Junior Member
                              • Dec 2015
                              • 91

                              Originally posted by kemasa
                              It would be illegal by the time you get a court order and small claims would not get you a court order.
                              You are correct - but probably a judgement to get my $1100 back, which is fine with me.

                              There is no universe in which, at his sole discretion, he gets to keep an $1100 weapon just because he wants to. If the law forbade him, that would be different.

                              But then I've seen small claims cases decided based on someone's shoe size .. so who the heck knows.

                              It's probably time we end this?

                              After all - we each know the other's position and none of us are likely to change our minds at this point.
                              The problem with our legislature is NOT that they hate guns. The problem is that they hate the people who don't hate guns.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1