Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

DUI at DUI class

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • w55
    Senior Member
    • Oct 2008
    • 2438

    DUI at DUI class

    So my kid is on the DUI panel that has offenders meeting victims as part of the offenders classes.

    He is there with another officer,and the local DA.

    One of the offenders seems a bit sleepy, he goes over and the guy reeks of booze...they ask him how he got their, of course he says "I drove"

    He is asked to go and get someone to drive him home...the DA says no arrest him...the campus police notice this and provide video footage of this guy driving in and parking 3 hours earlier...

    His alcohol level is .22 at this point and off he goes to the station.

    Sure you all have plenty similar stories but they are new to me and my kid is still amazed by alchys behaviors.
  • #2
    cruising7388
    Veteran Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 2542

    Originally posted by w55
    So my kid is on the DUI panel that has offenders meeting victims as part of the offenders classes.

    He is there with another officer,and the local DA.

    One of the offenders seems a bit sleepy, he goes over and the guy reeks of booze...they ask him how he got their, of course he says "I drove"

    He is asked to go and get someone to drive him home...the DA says no arrest him...the campus police notice this and provide video footage of this guy driving in and parking 3 hours earlier...

    His alcohol level is .22 at this point and off he goes to the station.

    Sure you all have plenty similar stories but they are new to me and my kid is still amazed by alchys behaviors.
    This guy unquestionably should be keelhauled but I think there are some procedural problems getting a conviction for DUI with the evidence of him operating his vehicle three hours removed. Wouldn't the better move have been to alert the campus police, toss him from the class and have the campus cops nail him when he returned to his vehicle?

    Comment

    • #3
      Tacobandit
      Banned
      • Sep 2009
      • 914

      If he were drunk 3 hours prior he would have been well over .3 at the time so i would imagine he prbably started drinking but continued during the 3 hour lapse

      Comment

      • #4
        Jimmybacon43
        Senior Member
        • Jun 2013
        • 2000

        Haha, that is just, I mean, damn some people never learn.
        Originally posted by RookieShooter
        One of the theory is that the hormones they put in the milk. That is why there are more obesity and homosexual today then back in the 60's.

        Comment

        • #5
          jaysen
          Member
          • Apr 2011
          • 380

          Originally posted by Tacobandit
          If he were drunk 3 hours prior he would have been well over .3 at the time so i would imagine he prbably started drinking but continued during the 3 hour lapse
          ^This.

          Without knowing all the facts, and of course SPECULATING, sounds like a bum arrest. Shame on the DA. Does not excuse the fact that this idiot has not learned. - do they ever?

          Comment

          • #6
            w55
            Senior Member
            • Oct 2008
            • 2438

            Originally posted by cruising7388
            This guy unquestionably should be keelhauled but I think there are some procedural problems getting a conviction for DUI with the evidence of him operating his vehicle three hours removed. Wouldn't the better move have been to alert the campus police, toss him from the class and have the campus cops nail him when he returned to his vehicle?
            Don't know? The DA in the class told my son to go pop him...just seemed like a goofy drunk story...got a DUI at DUI class....as a recovering alcoholic I totally can understand that thinking....

            Comment

            • #7
              kermit315
              Calguns Addict
              • Sep 2007
              • 5931

              If he has a good attorney, he will probably get off. He could argue that he was sober when he got there, and got trashed during the class.

              Not saying I believe that, but it could be argued that way.

              Comment

              • #8
                nickbackouris
                Member
                • Nov 2011
                • 202

                If I cared about prosecution and convictions, I would never arrest anyone. I say arrest the guy, tow his car, make an example of him, and maybe save someone's life who he would have smashed into. You have probable cause, make it happen. Good move.

                Comment

                • #9
                  ke6guj
                  Moderator
                  CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                  • Nov 2003
                  • 23725

                  Originally posted by nickbackouris
                  If I cared about prosecution and convictions, I would never arrest anyone. I say arrest the guy, tow his car, make an example of him, and maybe save someone's life who he would have smashed into. You have probable cause, make it happen. Good move.
                  so its ok to arrest someone, make them post bail and pay towing/impoint fees for something that you don't think you can get a conviction on? Sounds like arrests are being used as a punishment all by themselves, separate from the court.

                  Since nobody apparently saw the driver in the OP actually driving drunk, why is it a good arrest? three hours between the last time he drove and the gives the guy plenty of time to have gotten drunk after he got to the campus.
                  Jack



                  Do you want an AOW or C&R SBS/SBR in CA?

                  No posts of mine are to be construed as legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    tumark2
                    Member
                    • Mar 2014
                    • 144

                    Originally posted by Jimmybacon43
                    Haha, that is just, I mean, damn some people never learn.
                    it has nothing to do with "learning" addiction both physical and emotional defies logic. all we can do is demand public safety be assured. revoke his DL and seize his car.

                    he has to decide to get help for his own benefit, until then let him take the buss

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Uhhlexxxis
                      Senior Member
                      • Feb 2010
                      • 564

                      Originally posted by ke6guj
                      so its ok to arrest someone, make them post bail and pay towing/impoint fees for something that you don't think you can get a conviction on? Sounds like arrests are being used as a punishment all by themselves, separate from the court.

                      Since nobody apparently saw the driver in the OP actually driving drunk, why is it a good arrest? three hours between the last time he drove and the gives the guy plenty of time to have gotten drunk after he got to the campus.
                      Maybe a review of 40300.5 will be a refresher for you in why an arrest is warranted.

                      An arrest is a punitive action ie. it's used as a punishment. We can speculate all you want on what shoulda/coulda/woulda happened.

                      Bottom line is... the guy is an obvious danger to himself and others. By allowing him to be in public, behind the wheel, etc, poses a HUGE public safety risk.

                      I don't want a guy like that on the road when my wife is driving home from work. I don't want a guy like that on the road taking out my beat partner who's on a stop with a disabled vehicle.
                      Internetz are serious business.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Tacobandit
                        Banned
                        • Sep 2009
                        • 914

                        Umm.... 3 hours later is a little late to tell if he was over the limit when he drove....

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          border.bandito
                          Senior Member
                          • Sep 2012
                          • 770

                          what i find particularly funny about these DUI threads is that although absolutely no one will EVER admit to it...everyone here drives after having a drink(s) and some of those people will be the first to criticize whoever posts on CGN about drink&driving.

                          hypocrisy at its finest.
                          If you suck with irons you will suck with optics. The difference is the aimpoint will allow you to suck faster and a scope will give you a closer look at how much you suck.
                          AR's have finally become full blown "men's barbie dolls" now with fashion accessories.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            TRICKSTER
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • Mar 2008
                            • 12438

                            Originally posted by border.bandito
                            what i find particularly funny about these DUI threads is that although absolutely no one will EVER admit to it...everyone here drives after having a drink(s) and some of those people will be the first to criticize whoever posts on CGN about drink&driving.

                            hypocrisy at its finest.
                            Everyone? I have been carrying a gun since I came of drinking age. I don't drink when I carry and I don't drink if I'm going to drive. Don't confuse yourself with everyone.


                            Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              IrishJoe3
                              Veteran Member
                              • Feb 2009
                              • 3804

                              Originally posted by border.bandito
                              what i find particularly funny about these DUI threads is that although absolutely no one will EVER admit to it...everyone here drives after having a drink(s) and some of those people will be the first to criticize whoever posts on CGN about drink&driving.

                              hypocrisy at its finest.
                              Hardly.

                              Drinking one or two (normal sized) beverages will not impair someone to the extent that they should not operate a vehicle. It is perfectly okay to have one or two (normal sized) beverages with dinner and drive home afterwards. On patrol I have encountered dozens to hundreds of such drivers, and wished them nothing more than a good night.

                              Its also perfectly okay to get completely ****faced at home and drive one or two days later.

                              Its all about responsibility, and there is nothing wrong with calling someone out who is irresponsible, especially when that irresponsibility endangers others. Imagine the wrath if someone flagged the entire shooting line with a loaded gun, safety off and finger on the trigger. Driving DUI is no different.

                              I have seen many clearly impaired drivers (ie irresponsible and selfish drivers) rationalize and justify their stupidity. In their eyes they did no wrong, so when I arrested them, (not for "drinking and driving", rather for Driving Under the Influence), they were more than a little angry. Sadly, that anger is rarely directed at themselves, its always someone else's fault.

                              Your post strikes me as attempting to rationalize or trivialize impaired drivers (ie "everyone does it"). You haven't been arrested for DUI by chance?
                              Urban legends are a poor basis for making public policy.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1