Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Home Defense Concern

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TheRain
    Junior Member
    • Apr 2013
    • 43

    Home Defense Concern

    I normally would not worry about these types of things but recent events in my neighborhood have me concerned. I live in a "good area" but I am former Marine Recon and believe is always being ready to protect my family...

    About three months ago a member of my HOA board decided to enter my home (walkway door into garage) while I was at work and proceeded to "determine" I was using my garage for storage since the only items in there at that time were several motorbikes in operational condition, a deep freezer, and my gun safe; the wife and I were at work so there was no car in my garage at that time.

    After a lengthy dispute where I feel this issue was trespass, I am letting it go only to prevent me from getting more upset.

    However, a few nights ago one of my neighbors was threatened with "I'm gonna get my 9mm if you knock on my door again" after asking a loud party to quiet down a second time around midnight. We have a bad apple that just moved in.

    Anyway, today I got a notice from the HOA complaining that I have a floor fan that is visible to the outside of my house, it is in my bedroom because it gets hot in there during the day, but the windows are closed. In the notice, the HOA wrote "The Association reserves the right to remove unsightly items". Knowing that I have had my home violated before and that I will be working at night for the next few weeks has me concerned since I typically have my Remington 870 or 1911 near the bed at night.

    I am concerned that if a person from the HOA enters my home while I am asleep and I awake and confront them with a firearm I will have a legal mess on my hands (especially if they try to enter through the bedroom window that is behind a demi-wall patio.

    What should I expect from confronting a possible daylight intruder (bad apple or HOA rep) with a firearm? I am assuming that being presented with a firearm alone will stop them, I have a grasp on what would happen if I actually engaged them with said weapon.

    Your assistance or any reference to a good source of information is appreciated. Thank You.
  • #2
    rooster85
    Senior Member
    • May 2010
    • 680

    That's one reason why I could never live anywhere with an HOA. I would suggest finding out about CAs stand your ground laws. I believe they aren't a state that believes in someone standing their ground against an intruder but I may be wrong. Keep us posted brother.
    Looking for : Savage 24 .30-30/12 Ga
    Marlin 336 .35 Rem

    Comment

    • #3
      P5Ret
      Calguns Addict
      • Oct 2010
      • 6406

      Yes Ca has a "stand your ground" law or "castle doctrine" it doesn't go as far as some states but it is there. I would seriously contact the HOA board, and determine their intention of removing the offending fan. I am fairly certain that HOA's have the ability to access the property, but not inside the home itself, especially unannounced and entering without permission of the home owner. If the intent is to enter into the home to remove your personal property or property under your care, I would consider that a burglary.

      As far as the board member entering your garage while you were not at home, I know I would have pushed the issue, and LE would have been on scene at the very least to issue a trespass warning. If that is the way your HOA board works thinking that they can just walk into someones home, the end result of that thinking may turn bad sooner or later.

      Comment

      • #4
        TheRain
        Junior Member
        • Apr 2013
        • 43

        Thanks for the input; I have been working on gathering info on Castle Doctrine, but I can find nothing about just making the perpetrator crap their pants. If I pull the trigger that is one monster. I am concerned about person entering my home and running scared then calling the for help. As a Former Marine and Presidential Support (YW) I am very familiar with the justifications and usage of deadly force. But in my home without a shot fired I have found nothing of value.

        Comment

        • #5
          TheRain
          Junior Member
          • Apr 2013
          • 43

          Originally posted by P5Ret
          As far as the board member entering your garage while you were not at home, I know I would have pushed the issue, and LE would have been on scene at the very least to issue a trespass warning. If that is the way your HOA board works thinking that they can just walk into someones home, the end result of that thinking may turn bad sooner or later.
          If they had entered while I was cleaning a weapon or packing to head out I would have had the chance to test CA Castle Doctrine... not that I want to, mainly because of the legal ramifications. And I would know the answer to brandishing a weapon in my home. I may push the point at the next board meeting.

          Comment

          • #6
            Heiko
            Senior Member
            • Jul 2008
            • 1025

            First off, I cannot believe that any member of your HOA board would think it okay to enter your home, including your attached garage. I would give your HOA board and property management company written notice that you do not give them consent to enter your property (beyond your curtilage) and any entry would constitute a trespass for which you will exercise all legal remedies including lawsuit, restraining orders, or injunctions. If you want to make it look a little more legal based, cite Penal Code section 602. (There is not a really great subsection in 602 for this circumstances as 602 was written for old agriculture and farming times but (m) might be good.) I would cite Penal Code section 459 as well since your attached garage is part of your residence. Sure they would have to have the intent to commit a crime upon entering but hey, they need know you're seriously pissed. I would not mention anything about owning firearms or your willingness to use deadly force if presented with a threat.

            Secondly, confronting anybody in your home is a judgement call. You know from your military experience how to assess a threat and you've probably got a good gut feeling. The simple rule is that you cannot use deadly force unless you are in reasonable fear of death or great bodily injury. There is a legal presumption in CA that if a person unknown to you is in your house, that he or she is intending to do you harm but I wouldn't push things based on that. I'm not guaranteeing anything but I think that if you did happen to draw down on a HOA rep nosing inside your garage or beyond, having given them prior notice could help you. The inevitable 417(a)(2) brandishing [or even a 245(a)(2)] investigation would be clearer if you can demonstrate that you had a legitimate fear that a burglar was in your home because it couldn't have been your friendly HOA rep who you gave prior written notice not to enter your home. To me, you can't 417 someone in your own home if that person was an unwelcome "intruder", if you will. You kind of give up your "victim of 417" status if you're somewhere you're not allowed to be.

            Finally, perhaps you should lock your garage access door. Just a suggestion....
            Last edited by Heiko; 06-13-2013, 10:45 PM.

            Comment

            • #7
              TheRain
              Junior Member
              • Apr 2013
              • 43

              WOW great response!
              Just to be clear, my garage access was locked, but can be shimmed open as most of those doors and I have no intent of EVER pulling the trigger in my house.

              I did send some nasty letters about trespass and yadda yadda yadda but had not mentioned firearms for the fear it would be considered a threat, I will go in with those civic codes at the next board meeting and scare the ever living crap out of them. The HOA Bylaws are very clear that they cannot scale a wall, or enter my home under ANY circumstances other than a life threatning emergency.

              Thanks to everyone!

              Comment

              • #8
                DemocracyEnaction
                Senior Member
                • Jan 2011
                • 1270

                rain sounds like you have a hall monitor. having somewhat similar issue no hoa just scandalous neighbor. set up cameras gather evidence. take action. remember guerrilla tactics retreat when engaged, pick your battle ground and only fight when victory is assured and Somthing is to be gained.
                "Capitalism is the unequal distribution of wealth; Socialism is the equal distribution of poverty ... Communism is socialism with a gun at your back." - Sir Winston Churchill

                Comment

                • #9
                  Ron-Solo
                  In Memoriam
                  • Jan 2009
                  • 8581

                  Get better locks. No one from an HOA has any right to enter your residence without your permission.

                  If he jimmied your lock to get in, he committed a trespass. Call the police on him next time.

                  As far as how you furnish the INSIDE of your home, including floor fans, that is none of their business. The cc&r's only apply to the outside with regard to that.

                  Good curtains also help.
                  LASD Retired
                  1978-2011

                  NRA Life Member
                  CRPA Life Member
                  NRA Rifle Instructor
                  NRA Shotgun Instructor
                  NRA Range Safety Officer
                  DOJ Certified Instructor

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    jdben92883
                    Veteran Member
                    • Dec 2012
                    • 3635

                    That kind of B.S. would have me put a floor fan in every room.
                    NRA Benefactor Member

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Petro6golf
                      Senior Member
                      • Dec 2010
                      • 1309

                      Your initial post is concerning. I would call your local PD to make a report regarding the incident. They will contact the HOA person who entered your home and hopefully he will get the idea not to do that again.

                      If you want to minimize further conflict I would close my blinds; it will help cool your home as well as keep prying eyes from your stuff. Or you could just carry on as you are and if he does it again demand a citizens arrest for PC 602. No one, and I mean no one has the right to enter your home without your permission, HOA or not. I dont care if your the Pope, if you enter my home against my permission your not going to like it. You said your prior force recon; that tells me your of above average intelligence and training. Use discretion in your actions but if you "detain" an intruder in your home I don't see how the police would rule against you. Its your home, HOA or not.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        fullrearview
                        Calguns Addict
                        • Jan 2008
                        • 9371

                        Save that letter. It proves intent to commit burglary and is a GREAT piece of evidence. Thanks for your service.
                        "Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest."~M.Twain~

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          cindynles
                          Veteran Member
                          • Dec 2008
                          • 2806

                          HOA stories are great. Some of these people really have no clue. 10 -12 years ago I lived in an HOA community in Temecula and we had our board morph into a bunch of crazed control freaks. One board member decided it would be a good idea to enter fenced and locked back yards to makes sure everyone was following the rules about landscaping.

                          His MAJOR problem was that he decided to poke around my neighbors yard. My neighbor was a San Diego Deputy Sheriff who worked nights (and was home and sleeping during the day).

                          I don't know exactly what happened but I do know that said board member wound up being "detained" by a Deputy in his tighty whities. We laughed about that over beers the entire summer (Deputy "tighty whitie" was rewarded with lots of 6-packs by most of the street).
                          "Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch. Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote." B.Franklin,1759

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            TheRain
                            Junior Member
                            • Apr 2013
                            • 43

                            Originally posted by fullrearview
                            Thanks for your service.
                            Your welcome, but don't need to thank me bro, the Law enforcement community deserve all the thanks they can get. Those guys get crapped on day in and day out, even by those they are helping. I couldn't do it I am certain I could not be in their shoes; I believe stupid should hurt, alot.

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            UA-8071174-1