Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Internal Affairs Division

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    biochembruin
    Senior Member
    • Dec 2006
    • 822

    Originally posted by Bert Gamble
    Again, thank you all for the insight. It is interesting to hear the stories, and good to know that it isn't the hate/hate relationship that TV and movies make it out to be.

    I wonder if the bad IA guys that make inaccurate reports when investigating an officer made the same type of bad reports when it was civillians they were writing about.

    It is human nature to write in a way that advances your own thoughts or bias. If the person doing the report believes someone is guilty, the negatives will be highlighted and the postitves diminished, even if most or all of the facts are included.

    Like when Bio pointed out that I had asked this question in a post on another topic, he didn't include that no one really answered it, except to point out that it needed it's own thread. I don't remember for sure, but it might have ben him that suggested it.

    Since he didn't include that part, it makes it appear that I am asking the same question over and over, making me look like a troll. He was accurate in his statement, but not complete. (I say this not to disparage Bio, but only to support my point that it is natural to highlight what best advances your position).

    Again, thank you for your answers. I have enjoyed reading them. Also, this has not turned into a bash session, and no officers were offended and felt the need to lash out. That is the best part.
    I was the one that suggested you start a thread, since I knew it would be a lengthy topic, and was off the topic of the thread at the time.

    As far as making it look like you were asking the same question over and over, well... you did ask the same question twice. Does that make you look like a troll as you said? No, not to me. The first time you asked it was in an unrelated thread in the off topic section. If you have a question you wish officers to answer, the LEO section would be the place for it. That's what you did when you started the new thread.

    If you feel it makes you look like a troll to ask your question, that is you adding your own bias to my response. I merely pointed out you asked the question before, and in no way insulted you for it.
    The thing to do, my friends, is to admit to your fate with Christian resignation and live bravely until your appointed time." - Lee Marvin, "The Spikes Gang"

    Comment

    • #17
      Bert Gamble
      Veteran Member
      • Mar 2011
      • 3230

      Originally posted by biochembruin
      I was the one that suggested you start a thread, since I knew it would be a lengthy topic, and was off the topic of the thread at the time.

      As far as making it look like you were asking the same question over and over, well... you did ask the same question twice. Does that make you look like a troll as you said? No, not to me. The first time you asked it was in an unrelated thread in the off topic section. If you have a question you wish officers to answer, the LEO section would be the place for it. That's what you did when you started the new thread.

      If you feel it makes you look like a troll to ask your question, that is you adding your own bias to my response. I merely pointed out you asked the question before, and in no way insulted you for it.
      Not going to get into this with you. It didn't get us anywhere last time. I would much rather converse with the other people on the thread. It actually builds my faith in the police rather than tearing it down.

      Thank you for your thoughts.
      WARNING: This post will most likely contain statements that are offensive to those who lack wit, humor, common sense, and or maturity.

      Satire: A literary composition, in verse or prose, in which human folly and vice are held up to scorn, derision, or ridicule.
      _____________________________________________

      Comment

      • #18
        biochembruin
        Senior Member
        • Dec 2006
        • 822

        Originally posted by Bert Gamble
        Not going to get into this with you. It didn't get us anywhere last time. I would much rather converse with the other people on the thread. It actually builds my faith in the police rather than tearing it down.

        Thank you for your thoughts.
        That's fine. Like I said, you asked a good question and I answered it. I didn't insult you, and certainly don't see how the answer tore down your faith in the police.
        The thing to do, my friends, is to admit to your fate with Christian resignation and live bravely until your appointed time." - Lee Marvin, "The Spikes Gang"

        Comment

        • #19
          Notorious
          Veteran Member
          • Sep 2008
          • 4703

          I have a good buddy that's been in IAD for half his career. It's got its ups and downs. He tells me about the frivolous stuff and the righteous stuff. Then he tels me about done of the witch hunts. When IAD goes out to plant things or set up officers to see if they will do the right thing, that is going too far, imho.

          However, if a complaint comes in, they are very integral to finding the truth and giving the public, as well as us officers, some trust in the system. I've ben involved in a few IA investigations as both a witness and as the one being investigated. It depends on who is running it, I have had no problems with the way it works out as long as the investigator doss his job like he is supposed tip with everything else. Find the truth, no commentary, no preconceived notions, no predetermined outcome in mind.

          I have the same question though as tpt. Who investigates IAD? I've seen some questionable stuff that would have landed the non-IAD officer in a grilling and full personal audit but is treated as a non-issue with IAD personnel.

          P.S. That POS Bernie Parks was head of IAD... Look what he did to LAPD during his reign of terror.
          I like guns

          Comment

          • #20
            Bert Gamble
            Veteran Member
            • Mar 2011
            • 3230

            Originally posted by Notorious
            I have a good buddy that's been in IAD for half his career. It's got its ups and downs. He tells me about the frivolous stuff and the righteous stuff. Then he tels me about done of the witch hunts. When IAD goes out to plant things or set up officers to see if they will do the right thing, that is going too far, imho.

            However, if a complaint comes in, they are very integral to finding the truth and giving the public, as well as us officers, some trust in the system. I've ben involved in a few IA investigations as both a witness and as the one being investigated. It depends on who is running it, I have had no problems with the way it works out as long as the investigator doss his job like he is supposed tip with everything else. Find the truth, no commentary, no preconceived notions, no predetermined outcome in mind.

            I have the same question though as tpt. Who investigates IAD? I've seen some questionable stuff that would have landed the non-IAD officer in a grilling and full personal audit but is treated as a non-issue with IAD personnel.

            P.S. That POS Bernie Parks was head of IAD... Look what he did to LAPD during his reign of terror.
            I have to agree with you on the planting and testing thing. That is going way too far.

            It is good to hear the part about "who is investigating the investigators". For me, it puts more of a regular person face on the profession.

            Many of you are just as concerned about a fair IA investigation as some on this board are about how the officer on the street conducts his investigation.

            I hope some of them see this and come to terms with the fact that we are not that different after all.

            I will admit to having some bias', based mostly on the actions and attitudes of a few, so I am trying to broaden my span of information.

            When I asked this question, I was kind of expecting a lot of answers about hating IAD. It is good to be wrong.

            We have been conditioned to avoid painting an entire group of people with a brush meant only for a few. I apply that in most aspects of my life, but I was starting to go against the concept with you. I won't let that happen again.

            I still think some cops are jerks (even on this board), but I won't let myself judge the majority by the minority.

            Thanks again
            WARNING: This post will most likely contain statements that are offensive to those who lack wit, humor, common sense, and or maturity.

            Satire: A literary composition, in verse or prose, in which human folly and vice are held up to scorn, derision, or ridicule.
            _____________________________________________

            Comment

            • #21
              savtru
              Banned
              • May 2009
              • 92

              The problem with IA, is they tend to go out of their way to screw over fellow officers. Personal experience, has been that way and more then one time. I have seen guys go after fellow officers and take it to the extreme. Some problems need to be addressed and others dealt with more seriously. I happen to be related to a former IA, who seemed fair IMO for the most part!

              Comment

              • #22
                ckim34
                Member
                • Oct 2009
                • 408

                my old chief told me when I first got hired that if you aren't getting an IA complaint once a year you probably aren't going your job.

                Comment

                • #23
                  Notorious
                  Veteran Member
                  • Sep 2008
                  • 4703

                  The problem with any bureaucracy, including a full time IAD that has a lot of cops, is that they have to justify their existence and find work. Sometimes, the higher ups decide that they need to be proactive and look for bad cops out there even if there are no complaints.
                  I like guns

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    Gnome
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2007
                    • 1693

                    Originally posted by TrailerparkTrash
                    IA, do we need them? Sure. My only question however is, who investigates the investigators? (Taken from one department's association motto).

                    There are "some" bad apples in the mix with IA too. Afterall, they are humans as well.

                    I've seen both professionalism and incompetence amoungst some IA personnel.
                    Originally posted by TrailerparkTrash
                    Try working for a very LARGE agency that has had IA on more than numerous accounts, have not only a civil service commission, but a Superor court Judge sanction and penalize the IA investigators as well as upper management of the Dept for "crooked" investigating and out right lies against an officer!!!! Hence my earlier quote taken from one officers legal defense association's published words:

                    "Who investigates the investigators?"

                    Yup, there are many overzealous loosers that work in IA, always looking to advance their own careers with their own motives on an officer's backside! Again, there are good investigators too, but the few bad apples really put a black eye on the good guys.
                    TPT and I both work for the same department. He has much more time on and experience than I do. But in my short time on, I have had a run-in with IAB that left a bad taste in my mouth. At best, they are a neccessary evil.

                    I was notified via email, that I was the subject of an investigation. Apparently, I hurt a civilian coworker's (male) feelings. The civilian filed a POE against me (Deputies will know what this is).

                    I was respectful to the two investigators, and cooperated fully. Basically, I made a joke about myself, but it offended the civiian employee. I admitted to what I did, and explained to them why I made the joke. I even gave them evidence that it was a running joke about myself, that went back to when I first came on. The whole time they were smiling and laughing with me, and putting on a show. I knew it was all fake, but wasn't worried because I came into the meeting with the intention of telling the truth.

                    They ignored the evidence, and took the investigation in a completely different direction. Their findings were disgusting. They nailed me to the cross, for the sake of making an example out of me. They labeled me a hate monger. As a result of IAB's "findings", I received five days off without pay.

                    I went into the investigation a happy-go-lucky person, and came out jaded and distrustful of IAB and the executives on my department.

                    I beefed the discipline through my union. Three years later, my department executives conceeded, removed the POE, and refunded most (not all) of my days off.

                    SCREW IAB! They're a bunch of wannabe detectives that make their money by taking money away from other cops! There, I said it! Flame on.


                    Originally posted by E Pluribus Unum
                    During Y2K my neighbor and I were talking and he said he had a basement full of water and canned food. He asked if I had stocked up and I said that I had. I told him I bought a 12 guage shotgun, a .308 rifle and several bricks of .22 ammo.

                    He is an anti-gun guy and he said. "Well, you can't eat ammunition". I replied with "When I'm starving to death with a case of ammunition, who's door do you think I am going to knock on?"

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      Notorious
                      Veteran Member
                      • Sep 2008
                      • 4703

                      Wait... The one group worse than IAD investigators are the background investigators. Both are not ranked positions usually, but plainclothes assignments for officers. The BI guys, in my experience, are the ones on a worse power trip and exercise personal vendettas against people they don't know.

                      Unless you are the one making the decision, you gather facts and present them to the personnel LT or whoever and let them review the facts to make their recommendation.
                      I like guns

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        biochembruin
                        Senior Member
                        • Dec 2006
                        • 822

                        Originally posted by Notorious
                        Wait... The one group worse than IAD investigators are the background investigators. Both are not ranked positions usually, but plainclothes assignments for officers. The BI guys, in my experience, are the ones on a worse power trip and exercise personal vendettas against people they don't know.

                        Unless you are the one making the decision, you gather facts and present them to the personnel LT or whoever and let them review the facts to make their recommendation.
                        I've never really heard any horror stories about our background investigators. But then, we only deal with them very rarely.
                        The thing to do, my friends, is to admit to your fate with Christian resignation and live bravely until your appointed time." - Lee Marvin, "The Spikes Gang"

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          yzErnie
                          CGN/CGSSA Contributor - Lifetime
                          CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                          • Mar 2007
                          • 6310

                          My department is large and the IA assignments are all ranked at Sgt and above. Are there some assigned there who believe they are better than their peer Sgts throughout the dept?...sure there is because that is human nature. I did a stint at IA while I was recovering from a broken leg and without details, I can tell you first hand that I was a little disappointed in the outcome (in both directions) of some of the investigations. IA is in fact a necessary evil for any department and I personally believe they need to be in place to address some of the goofy things that occur. Overall though, our IA division is fair yet has a very steep ladder of discipline for repeat offenders.
                          The satisfaction of a job well done is to be the one who has done it

                          Originally posted by RazoE
                          I don't feel a thing when some cop gets ghosted.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            solanoshooter
                            Member
                            • Oct 2008
                            • 252

                            I'm at a fairly small department and our IAs are handled by a Sgt. No one hates him but being IA'd isn't fun. We have had a couple large IA's that the PD contracted out to a law firm to handle.

                            I have quite a few friends who work for Oakland PD and they talk about IAD with the stereotypical TV loathing.

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              Tacobandit
                              Banned
                              • Sep 2009
                              • 914

                              Small department the IAD is generally awesome, they are fair, dont try to screw over officers and will do a full investigation, get into a larger department such as LASO, LAPD etc and you get cops who want to burn others because they think it will help them promote, hell in LAPD they wont promote you to LT if you havent done a loan to IAD/PSB. You get a lot of half assed investigations that will simply get there side across and the officer is holding the short end of the stick, alot of one sided questions that meets there needs and the more officers they can get canned or suspended the better they look to brass. Not to mention the many stupid audits they will do, such as in west bureau of LAPD they would set up mock accidents and have one of the "drivers" smell like alcohol yet they will ace the FST, so the officers were doing a FI card on the drivers and writing on the back, "Passed FST in field" Well there is a small policy that states that when you do an FST you have to do DUI face sheet. When a DUI face sheet was not turned in they would hit the officers with write ups or suspension days.

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                tyrist
                                Veteran Member
                                • Jun 2007
                                • 4564

                                I would never fault somebody who does their job correctly.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1