The implied consent law mandates submitting to a test after you arrest me, not before. Likewise, FST's are voluntary as well. FST's and PAST are used to establish PC for an arrest. Refusal of those tests will not result in my license being suspended, refusal after arrest will.
Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Drinking and Driving, a Quick Question
Collapse
X
-
-
Don't rely on it.... see my post farther up the thread. If the officer can properly articulate impairment, assuming that there was indeed true impairment, then the BAC being under .08 means absolutely nothing.
Your advice will cost someone thousands in attorney fees, at minimum.
-- Rifle, Pistol, Shotgun
Not a lawyer, just a former LEO proud to have served.
Americans have the right and advantage of being armed - unlike the citizens of other countries whose governments are afraid to trust the people with arms. -- James MadisonComment
-
Correct, refusal of the chemical test after will result in suspension. However refusing PAS/FSTs is a guaranteed trip to jail, where doing them isn't.
NOT true, FSTs and PAS (I assume thats what you meant) are tools used to determine the level of impairment. If there is minimal to no impairment then I wish the driver a good night and we're all on our way. I cant count the many hundreds of drivers that, in doing FSTs showed to me that they were not impaired and could safely drive a vehicle. These drivers were out 10 or 15 minutes of their time and were then on their way.
Keep in mind I will only ask you to do FSTs if I have a reason to believe impairment. Refuse FSTs, then all I have to go on is whatever led me to believe impairment in the first place and you WILL be arrested. Even if the blood test returns .000, you will still be in jail for a day or two, still be out bail, still have to pay to get your vehicle out of impound, still miss days of work, still have to pay for a lawyer, etc etc.
Or you can do the FSTs, I realize you are not impaired, and 15 minutes later you're back on your way.
Either way, I don't care, I get paid the same. Its up to you.Last edited by IrishJoe3; 09-07-2011, 3:05 PM.Urban legends are a poor basis for making public policy.Comment
-
Right.
Right again.Likewise, FST's are voluntary as well.
Those are investigative tools to backstop the officers cause to stop you for investigation in the first place and help to establish probable cause to arrest. They are not probable cause unto themselves.FST's and PAST are used to establish PC for an arrest.
But what you leave out is that your refusal to cooperate with the initial investigation is not going to win you anything. If I already have a reasonable suspicion that you are DUI and / or have a BAC above .08 based on my observations of your driving and of you during our contact, and you refuse then that's fine. You get hooked up on the spot and we take a ride. Period, end of story.Refusal of those tests will not result in my license being suspended, refusal after arrest will.
Don't want to cooperate, go straight to county.
-- Rifle, Pistol, Shotgun
Not a lawyer, just a former LEO proud to have served.
Americans have the right and advantage of being armed - unlike the citizens of other countries whose governments are afraid to trust the people with arms. -- James MadisonComment
-
I just love these guys who ignore reality and the years of experience of those of us who have actually arrested drunk drivers. But what do we know, we have only done it hundreds of times.
Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groupsComment
-
Agreed, you get more flies with honey. My concern is that I'm clumsy already. If I were to have a beer and get pulled over on the way home the officer may request I perform these tests as a way to bolster an "impairment" case and not a BAC case. Say I fall over during the FST because I'm a clumsy guy to start with, the officer may use that as proof I was "impaired". Either way I'm going to county as impaired, my way just shifts the burden back to the officer a bit more. Of course when the officer asked if I had anything to drink, I might also respectfully remain silent.Right.
But what you leave out is that your refusal to cooperate with the initial investigation is not going to win you anything. If I already have a reasonable suspicion that you are DUI and / or have a BAC above .08 based on my observations of your driving and of you during our contact, and you refuse then that's fine. You get hooked up on the spot and we take a ride. Period, end of story.
Don't want to cooperate, go straight to county.Comment
-
I'm not trying to be disrespectful at all to any of you or the DUI's you've pulled off the street. I've seen the end result of DUI in my line of work many times as well and applaud when they get hooked up. All I'm saying is if you ask me to take a voluntary test I might say "no". Then someone else said "you might go to jail anyway". So there we are....
Comment
-
Your posts just make me laugh. Flies with honey? Its got nothing to do with me, its got everything to do with you. I already told you I don't care what you do. I am telling you that your chosen course is self destructive and foolish, but hey you sleep in the bed you make.Agreed, you get more flies with honey. My concern is that I'm clumsy already. If I were to have a beer and get pulled over on the way home the officer may request I perform these tests as a way to bolster an "impairment" case and not a BAC case. Say I fall over during the FST because I'm a clumsy guy to start with, the officer may use that as proof I was "impaired". Either way I'm going to county as impaired, my way just shifts the burden back to the officer a bit more. Of course when the officer asked if I had anything to drink, I might also respectfully remain silent.
You really think in the thousands of dui investigations I've done that I've never seen a clumsy person? I've probably seen more drunk people than a bouncer in hollywood. I've also seen people who can't chew gum and walk at the same time. Alcohol consumption does not equal impairment, I've had plenty of drivers tell truthfully they had a few beers and my FSTs showed they were not impaired. I dont care if you've been drinking, I only care when you've been drinking too much.
Also, if it ever did go to jury, juries tend to see FSTs as very reasonable requests, and refusal to cooperate and refusal to answer questions generally is looked on as guilty behavior. Fair or not, I dunno, its just the way it is.
I gotta say, you're setting yourself up for one heck-of-a fantastic story for off topic! They'll eat it up over there if you do end up getting hooked....Urban legends are a poor basis for making public policy.Comment
-
I am sorry, that's about the dumbest statement I've seen this week. I'll give you an example that isn't even extreme. Bicyclist decides to hop on his bike after leaving the bar. Guy is plastered. he makes it half way down the block and ends up scratching and gouging the hell out of 3 cars before he tries to leave again. I'll leave you to ponder all the implications of that along with the other statements.Since this is related, I will semi-thread jack.
Who here has given a DUI to someone on a bicycle? I routinely ride my bicycle home after a night out because I don't want to kill someone and am too cheap for a cab (not to mention I hate waiting 40 minutes for a ride).
seems dumb that I can get a DUI, just like idiots that don't remember they drove home.
I think the diciest DUI I ever gave was to a guy who blew a .02. He wrecked into 6 parked cars going uphill. I found him heaving his guts out about 6 blocks away. I do remember that case was charged and the guy plead.
So to summarize, a BAC is only a tool to gauge how imparied someone is.Comment
-
Do stupid things, win stupid prizes. I got convictions on every refusal to submit to FSTs or chemical test that I arrested. Conversly, I didn't arrest many of the people o gave FSTs to. It's their chance to showe they're not impaired. There are also many tests you can do for "clumsy" or disabled people too. That excuse won't fly.LASD Retired
1978-2011
NRA Life Member
CRPA Life Member
NRA Rifle Instructor
NRA Shotgun Instructor
NRA Range Safety Officer
DOJ Certified InstructorComment
-
+1... and well stated.Do stupid things, win stupid prizes. I got convictions on every refusal to submit to FSTs or chemical test that I arrested. Conversly, I didn't arrest many of the people o gave FSTs to. It's their chance to showe they're not impaired. There are also many tests you can do for "clumsy" or disabled people too. That excuse won't fly.
-- Rifle, Pistol, Shotgun
Not a lawyer, just a former LEO proud to have served.
Americans have the right and advantage of being armed - unlike the citizens of other countries whose governments are afraid to trust the people with arms. -- James MadisonComment
-
I am just speaking from what I see my local DA do you are absolutely right my advice will cost someone big attorney fees but this is what is almost routine with our DADon't rely on it.... see my post farther up the thread. If the officer can properly articulate impairment, assuming that there was indeed true impairment, then the BAC being under .08 means absolutely nothing.
Your advice will cost someone thousands in attorney fees, at minimum.Last edited by mille806; 09-08-2011, 12:23 AM.Comment
-
Interesting. I'm guessing the refusals were people who were obviously impaired but "smart enough" to know their rights. I would guess that all the refusals, if they had complied, would have still gotten arrested and convicted?Do stupid things, win stupid prizes. I got convictions on every refusal to submit to FSTs or chemical test that I arrested. Conversly, I didn't arrest many of the people o gave FSTs to. It's their chance to showe they're not impaired. There are also many tests you can do for "clumsy" or disabled people too. That excuse won't fly.Comment
-
Go back and re-read Ron's post..... the FST is the opportunity for the driver to demonstrate that they are not impaired. He stated clearly that he didn't take people who could demonstrate lack of impairment through FST.
Stands to reason that some percentage of that sub-set of refusals would have been able to get past an FST and not be taken into custody. There are a whole range of factors that go into making a DUI arrest, you are focusing on a narrow sub-set. And while I certainly respect your opinion to stand on your rights and be uncooperative, I'm simply saying (as are others) that doing so is more than likely going to end up becoming a fool's errand farther down the road.Last edited by BigDogatPlay; 09-08-2011, 11:35 AM.
-- Rifle, Pistol, Shotgun
Not a lawyer, just a former LEO proud to have served.
Americans have the right and advantage of being armed - unlike the citizens of other countries whose governments are afraid to trust the people with arms. -- James MadisonComment
-
I've been out of DUI enforcement for a few years but am still hooked up with guys working them now....If I'm not mistaken, many of the PAST devices are, in fact, a DOJ connected chemical testing device. So, although you might refuse FSTs, refusing the blow may result in the same consequences as on the big machine back at the Cop Shop....The implied consent law mandates submitting to a test after you arrest me, not before. Likewise, FST's are voluntary as well. FST's and PAST are used to establish PC for an arrest. Refusal of those tests will not result in my license being suspended, refusal after arrest will.
But, I always got a chuckle when a Duece refused the tests, forced blood draws under the "best evidence" rule tended to be quite humerous.sigpicCertainly there is no hunting like the hunting of man and those who have hunted armed men long enough and liked it, never really care for anything else thereafter.
Ernest Hemingway, "On the Blue Water," Esquire, April 1936
Comment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,676
Posts: 25,174,877
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,389
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 26769 users online. 46 members and 26723 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.

Comment